Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Role of grandparents in a family

186 replies

Stickmansmum · 13/11/2022 16:53

There’s a few dynamics at play here that requires respect and control of entitlement on both sides. BUT (having come from and married into) a loving and supportive family I never understand the double standard of ‘you decided to have kids so need to not be anyway entitled about help with them from their grandparents’ vs what I believe to be a lifelong commitment to help and love and support your children. Your grandchildren are maybe not your responsibility but by default they are. You decided to have children and that doesn’t end when they are 18. I think it’s ok to expect your mum and dad to still be supportive.

Of course as the adult child of someone you also have a responsibility to not make your parents unwell or take so much from them that it damages their quality of life. And to also support them with help and love and consideration.

I guess some people don’t make the jump to grandparent who still feels love and responsibility for their grown up child, and grown up child who doesn’t realise they now have a responsibility to care for their parents.

But my AIBU is, if you have a child I think you are taking on the responsibility of being both a parent and a grandparent (probably) as part of that. And don’t get to just wash your hands of the role any more than you get to wash your hands of being a parent. (Assuming you haven’t raised entitled dickheads for children).

OP posts:
Riverlee · 13/11/2022 21:33

My parents and my in-laws are/were great grandparents. Neither did regular childcare (nor did I expect them too). All of them ‘had/have a lifelong commitment to help and support their children” to quote from the op. This doesn’t have to equate to childcare, but to taking an interest, birthday/Christmas presents, visiting grandchildren etc.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 21:29

Ted27 · 13/11/2022 21:26

@ApplePieFry

You do realise that it's very privileged position to be able to retire over 10 years before state pension age, and to be mortgage free in your early 50s.

I'm a civil servant, most of my friends are civil servants ( solid careers) or teachers (heads of dept of deputy heads). We are all approaching 60. ie good jobs, with pensions.
None of us can afford to take our pensions now. I am 'retiring' from the civil service next year however I will still need to earn a living until I am 68. Same goes for most of my friends.

Even if I wanted to I could not afford to give up work to look after grandchildren.
I will be a fantastic grandmother - I will babysit, take them out, help in the holidays, spoil them on their birthdays. But childcare I cannot do - that does not mean I love my son or his future children any less than you do, and it does not make me a lesser grandparents

No one has retired 10 years before state pension age in my situation though, so again not sure why you seem to be going down that road but hey ho.

And the thing here is, my mum is able to go part time at 52 because she had help from her mum and MIL when my siblings and I were born.

She gets to do this for me because she had the same help, do you really not see that’s what is driving her decision?

Did you have childcare from your parents? If not do you not think you’d be in a better financial position now if you had?

Ted27 · 13/11/2022 21:26

@ApplePieFry

You do realise that it's very privileged position to be able to retire over 10 years before state pension age, and to be mortgage free in your early 50s.

I'm a civil servant, most of my friends are civil servants ( solid careers) or teachers (heads of dept of deputy heads). We are all approaching 60. ie good jobs, with pensions.
None of us can afford to take our pensions now. I am 'retiring' from the civil service next year however I will still need to earn a living until I am 68. Same goes for most of my friends.

Even if I wanted to I could not afford to give up work to look after grandchildren.
I will be a fantastic grandmother - I will babysit, take them out, help in the holidays, spoil them on their birthdays. But childcare I cannot do - that does not mean I love my son or his future children any less than you do, and it does not make me a lesser grandparents

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 21:22

Changechangychange · 13/11/2022 21:16

I didn’t miss the fact your dad still pays your bills in your mid thirties, which implies a fair amount of wealth.

Who said he pays my bills

are you ok?

You might need an appt at spec savers

Changechangychange · 13/11/2022 21:16

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 21:15

Not wealthy

did you miss the fact mum went part time?

I didn’t miss the fact your dad still pays your bills in your mid thirties, which implies a fair amount of wealth.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 21:15

Changechangychange · 13/11/2022 21:11

If your family are so wealthy that none of you need to work for a living, and you all just have little hobby jobs, good for you.

Most people either need to work to pay their bills, live on their pension after retirement age, or live on benefits.

Not wealthy

did you miss the fact mum went part time?

SallyWD · 13/11/2022 21:14

I've never thought about grandparents having a specific role. Family dynamic and relationships vary greatly from family to family so it will be different for each family. For us, my parents and in laws live far away. It's enough that we love and care about them and vice versa. That's it - we're family and we love each other.

Changechangychange · 13/11/2022 21:11

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 21:05

Who is living on benefits?

I sure won’t be at 52, neither is mum

If your family are so wealthy that none of you need to work for a living, and you all just have little hobby jobs, good for you.

Most people either need to work to pay their bills, live on their pension after retirement age, or live on benefits.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 21:05

Changechangychange · 13/11/2022 20:41

Most women aged 52 don’t want to give up their career and live on benefits (because retirement age is 68) in order to provide full time free childcare for somebody else’s kids, no. I somehow doubt you will either.

Who is living on benefits?

I sure won’t be at 52, neither is mum

Aisling28 · 13/11/2022 20:45

I agree every situation is different. We only had one grandparent alive when my kids were younger. They were elderly and I wouldn't have expected them to look after my kids. I still made sure they had a good relationship though.
One thing I often see on here is though grandparents being expected to help out , however when it comes to times like Christmas or weekends grandparents are kept at a distance as its " our own little family" time.

I would hope to be in a position to help out my kids maybe not full time but as much as I could. I would feel upset if it was just for childminding and not included in other things. I always think it's nice to see grandparents at matchs, concerts etc.

Changechangychange · 13/11/2022 20:41

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 19:02

Just look at this thread, you’re mistaken to think most parents don’t want to support their children.

I’ve never said it was a grandmothers job, I have repeatedly said I don’t expect it, I earn enough to pay for childcare many times over, my mum wants to support, as does my father. So it’s not just a ‘grandmothers’ job either

Most women aged 52 don’t want to give up their career and live on benefits (because retirement age is 68) in order to provide full time free childcare for somebody else’s kids, no. I somehow doubt you will either.

Musicaltheatremum · 13/11/2022 20:39

I will support my children when they have children but not regular care. I lost my husband when my children were teen-agers and have recently remarried. I want to spend time with my husband and do all the things I thought I would do in retirement.

whatthejuice · 13/11/2022 20:36

Being a good grandparent doesn't mean endless free childcare.
My parents are fantastic, loving grandparents - kind, generous, fun - who help us out when we're stuck. But they wouldn't want to provide weekly childcare for my children - and more importantly I wouldn't ask them to!

DarkShade · 13/11/2022 20:30

encantorerun · 13/11/2022 19:33

I'm my Mum's first priority, always have been, always will be. I know that down in my core and it's so deeply reassuring.

If I just expected free childcare because I was entitled and a brat - she'd tell me to go do one. If I ask her to babysit she would if she didn't have plans. If I asked her to do regular childcare she'd want paying and/or tell me 'no', she's got a life.

If I was struggling financially, desperate to get to work, leaving a bad marriage, unwell, needed her - then yes she would drop everything and be there.

That's how I was raised, and that's how my kids will be raised. A deep sense of security that Mamma always has your back, but don't be a cheeky fucker or you'll get your arse handed to you. After your arse has been handed to you, you'll know that you're still loved, still wanted, still supported, just, you know - don't be a dick about it.

This is absolutely lovely. I think this describes exactly how I think an ideal relationship with adult children should be, and what I would like with mine when they're older. I really relate to how you've described the support system a good mum provides you, its how I feel about my own relationship with my mum - except she is liable to be taken advantage of. I never would, my siblings are not so scrupulous.

Beeboppy · 13/11/2022 20:30

I agree being a grandparent is a responsibility - but how they wish to grandparent is up to them not to you. Accept they may have very different views to you on this. Also accept being a grandparent doesn’t necessarily mean proving you with childcare. I’m sure you don’t necessarily mean this but many seem to think it!

DarkShade · 13/11/2022 20:24

Do you think this applies to grandfathers too or is it just grandmothers? To me this seems more misogynistic rubbish. The role of women is to look after children - hers, her kids kids, etc. You never see people complaining that their dad or father in law isn't pulling their weight childcare wise.

In general I think grandparents should support you if they love you and are able to, but that doesn't mean childcare. It might mean listening to your problems, encouraging you, lending you money, come round and play with children, invite you round Sunday dinner or to stay at theirs for the weekend - it will depend on what they are able to give, your relationship up to that point, their working and financial position, and loads of other things. One thing that does irk me is folk who don't bother with their parents at all until they have their own kids and want support. A good loving relationship works both ways and is in place before kids arrive.

Also, life stage does matter. If my eldest has kids the same age I had them, then I would be 54 and I plan to be in full time work at that age, so obviously would not be able to be my kids childcare. I don't believe that I "committed" to that when they were born though.

Ragwort · 13/11/2022 20:07

I have a number of friends who are DGPs and some of them are totally taken advantage of by their adult DC in terms of childminding .. they are too 'afraid' to say 'no' because they are fearful of their DD's (& sadly it is usually a DD not a DS) reaction and frightened of being banned from seeing the DGC.

I am mid 60s, happily still working, caring for my own elderly DM, volunteering with rough sleepers and a Food Bank ... fortunately I am not yet a DGM but would I want to give all that up to childmind - no thank you.

BadNomad · 13/11/2022 19:53

"Grandparent" isn't a role. It's just a title. When you have a child, you are not signing up to a life of servitude to them from that point on until the day you drop dead. How is that even supposed to work if you have three children, then each of those three children has three children? No human can give nine grandchildren equal care and attention.

FinnysTail · 13/11/2022 19:51

@encantorerun

That is a healthy mother/daughter/grandchild relationship. Everyone knows where they stand 👏👏👏

Lavenderflower · 13/11/2022 19:49

It is subjective. I think the main role of grandparent is be a support system to their grandchild.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 13/11/2022 19:47

encantorerun · 13/11/2022 19:33

I'm my Mum's first priority, always have been, always will be. I know that down in my core and it's so deeply reassuring.

If I just expected free childcare because I was entitled and a brat - she'd tell me to go do one. If I ask her to babysit she would if she didn't have plans. If I asked her to do regular childcare she'd want paying and/or tell me 'no', she's got a life.

If I was struggling financially, desperate to get to work, leaving a bad marriage, unwell, needed her - then yes she would drop everything and be there.

That's how I was raised, and that's how my kids will be raised. A deep sense of security that Mamma always has your back, but don't be a cheeky fucker or you'll get your arse handed to you. After your arse has been handed to you, you'll know that you're still loved, still wanted, still supported, just, you know - don't be a dick about it.

Great post!

ZeroFuchsGiven · 13/11/2022 19:46

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 19:14

There are many who say they’ll be glad to help their DC out with grandchildren when the time comes.

You seem awfully caught up on this, bitter almost.

Not sure if you’re a parent who is bitter their parents didn’t support them, or a grandparent wanting to feel validated for not helping their DC.

My mother and father benefitted from grandparent support, why wouldn’t they offer the same to their DC. It’s frankly a little sad you have the opinions you do on the matter.

I bet you’d keel over hearing that my father still sends me ‘pocket money’

You are seriously young, entitled and or deluded if you think most people would do as your parents are doing. Your mum giving up work to look after your kids for your high flying career whilst daddy still pays you pocket money? Get a grip and a fucking paid help while you are at it and let your mum have a break. I've never read anything so princessy in all my life. We see you and what kind of person you are.

Kite22 · 13/11/2022 19:44

What @encantorerun said.
Very well put.

encantorerun · 13/11/2022 19:44

@Roomytrouser haha! I was thinking - eh, err, what? 😂

Roomytrouser · 13/11/2022 19:37

That was not to you encantorerun!