Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Role of grandparents in a family

186 replies

Stickmansmum · 13/11/2022 16:53

There’s a few dynamics at play here that requires respect and control of entitlement on both sides. BUT (having come from and married into) a loving and supportive family I never understand the double standard of ‘you decided to have kids so need to not be anyway entitled about help with them from their grandparents’ vs what I believe to be a lifelong commitment to help and love and support your children. Your grandchildren are maybe not your responsibility but by default they are. You decided to have children and that doesn’t end when they are 18. I think it’s ok to expect your mum and dad to still be supportive.

Of course as the adult child of someone you also have a responsibility to not make your parents unwell or take so much from them that it damages their quality of life. And to also support them with help and love and consideration.

I guess some people don’t make the jump to grandparent who still feels love and responsibility for their grown up child, and grown up child who doesn’t realise they now have a responsibility to care for their parents.

But my AIBU is, if you have a child I think you are taking on the responsibility of being both a parent and a grandparent (probably) as part of that. And don’t get to just wash your hands of the role any more than you get to wash your hands of being a parent. (Assuming you haven’t raised entitled dickheads for children).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JockTamsonsBairns · 15/11/2022 13:50

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:37

If you care about your child you generally want to help them.

I will be glad to do the same for my kids when they’re old enough to start their own families.

It sounds like both your parents are very comfortably off financially, as well as enjoying good health - both of which allows them to be "good grandparents".

Not everyone is so fortunate. My mother became physically disabled at the age of 56, and was in a care home by the age of 72 with dementia. My father died in 1989 when I was 15.
You never know what life has in store.

Dappy1212 · 15/11/2022 13:47

housemaus · 14/11/2022 16:08

It's always women, this, isn't it? It's always whether it's somehow unnatural for women to not want to be defined by caring responsibilities for their entire life. We say 'grandparents' but we usually mean 'grandmothers'.

People find it odd when a woman who's raised children doesn't want to be hands on in their grandchild's life, because - you're a woman, your job is caring. Your job is raising kids. We don't allow for women to ever be free of the expectation of caring, and it's a load of bullshit.

Yes, if a grandmother wants to be very involved in their grandchildren's lives then that is absolutely lovely and I'm sure the family bond is all the richer for it. But it's not wrong or weird for someone to want to have their own life and not to be at the sole disposal of their children forever. I think I see a thread a week about whether someone's mum is unreasonable for not wanting to do X Y Z childcare and I don't think I've ever, ever seen one about someone's dad. That just isn't expected in the same way.

Very true. But I don't think anyone wants their kids to stay with their granddad's! ... I've learnt the hard way with DS returning having eaten nothing but banoffee pie with mud all over his clothes and a new phobia of heights (I wonder why?)😂

Definitely agree though, my mum gave us everything and I sense she wishes she saved a part of her for herself as she is incredibly talented and academic. We've done nothing but encourage her to live her life now as she has some free time (finally!) and more money for herself.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 15/11/2022 13:43

Wiccan · 15/11/2022 11:08

I agree every part is true . My DM didn't help with our DDs childcare I would never asked her she had her own life.
I really didn't expect that type of attitude from my own DD though , that shit cuts deep.

That must have really stung! My adult kids still live at home and I will do anything to help them out but I have been very clear when they decide to have children I will not be doing regular childcare.

Huntswomanonthemove · 15/11/2022 13:38

Yes it's all about grandmothers. Very well put @housemaus .

Wiccan · 15/11/2022 11:08

ZeroFuchsGiven · 15/11/2022 07:58

Best comment of the thread!

I agree every part is true . My DM didn't help with our DDs childcare I would never asked her she had her own life.
I really didn't expect that type of attitude from my own DD though , that shit cuts deep.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 15/11/2022 07:58

housemaus · 14/11/2022 16:08

It's always women, this, isn't it? It's always whether it's somehow unnatural for women to not want to be defined by caring responsibilities for their entire life. We say 'grandparents' but we usually mean 'grandmothers'.

People find it odd when a woman who's raised children doesn't want to be hands on in their grandchild's life, because - you're a woman, your job is caring. Your job is raising kids. We don't allow for women to ever be free of the expectation of caring, and it's a load of bullshit.

Yes, if a grandmother wants to be very involved in their grandchildren's lives then that is absolutely lovely and I'm sure the family bond is all the richer for it. But it's not wrong or weird for someone to want to have their own life and not to be at the sole disposal of their children forever. I think I see a thread a week about whether someone's mum is unreasonable for not wanting to do X Y Z childcare and I don't think I've ever, ever seen one about someone's dad. That just isn't expected in the same way.

Best comment of the thread!

PhilomenaPringle · 14/11/2022 21:19

Grandparents should help with their families because their grandchildren are their future going forward in life

Well I don't know that grandchildren are their future, given women are having babies much older than they used to, gps are much older too. And their future is what they're thinking about! Approaching 70, trust me, one is keenly aware that time is flashing by at a rate of knots. I'd rather at that age, as much future as I have left is not committed to providing regular daily childcare for grandchildren.
Grandmothers don't live forever.

hiredandsqueak · 14/11/2022 16:28

Blossomtoes · 14/11/2022 16:24

I hate looking after children. Loathe it. It’s been made clear that I’ll willingly clean your house, do your shopping, washing or ironing, drive you anywhere, lend or give you money, scrub your loo if you’ve got a stomach upset but I absolutely won’t do childcare. Not happening.

Me too @Blossomtoes I'm much happier offering to do dd's ironing or cleaning than I am being asked to care for dgs.

Blossomtoes · 14/11/2022 16:24

I hate looking after children. Loathe it. It’s been made clear that I’ll willingly clean your house, do your shopping, washing or ironing, drive you anywhere, lend or give you money, scrub your loo if you’ve got a stomach upset but I absolutely won’t do childcare. Not happening.

hiredandsqueak · 14/11/2022 16:15

I see my role as a parent is to raise children to be capable and independent adults so that they fly the nest. Whilst I love my adult dc I don't see me as responsible for their happiness and wellbeing although will offer them any support I am able to if needed.
My grandchildren are my children's responsibility and whilst I am happy to spend time with them and enjoy their visits I don't see them as my responsibility and as such don't feel the need to provide care for them. I will though look after them occasionally if needed. I did provide childcare for one dgs until he started pre school, I didn't enjoy it, it reminded me how tedious young children are tbh and I won't be repeating it

Wiccan · 14/11/2022 16:15

Housemaus , this is it . My DD constantly stated that she didn't want her own choices as a women restricted & her DDs but at the same time trying to stifle my own . My DH said " like she doesn't see the irony !" .

housemaus · 14/11/2022 16:08

It's always women, this, isn't it? It's always whether it's somehow unnatural for women to not want to be defined by caring responsibilities for their entire life. We say 'grandparents' but we usually mean 'grandmothers'.

People find it odd when a woman who's raised children doesn't want to be hands on in their grandchild's life, because - you're a woman, your job is caring. Your job is raising kids. We don't allow for women to ever be free of the expectation of caring, and it's a load of bullshit.

Yes, if a grandmother wants to be very involved in their grandchildren's lives then that is absolutely lovely and I'm sure the family bond is all the richer for it. But it's not wrong or weird for someone to want to have their own life and not to be at the sole disposal of their children forever. I think I see a thread a week about whether someone's mum is unreasonable for not wanting to do X Y Z childcare and I don't think I've ever, ever seen one about someone's dad. That just isn't expected in the same way.

Wiccan · 14/11/2022 15:58

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:59

@Kabalagala

The issue is what does “support” mean? Does support mean family dinner, flog one calls, babysitting sometimes and dropping by to see the grandkids or having them over - or does “support” mean free childcare while mum works full time?

Because often I get the impression on here grandparents keeping a distance actually have a good read on their kids and realise that if they give a hand then a arm will be expected and their daughters will want full time childcare and get stroppy if it doesn’t happy how and when they want it.

Someone said that good parents made good grandparents - well it could also be said that selfish daughters grow into selfish mothers who expect grandparents to do their job.

I agree. We had 2 DD in our early to mid 20s. DD 2 does not want kids . DD 2 has a DD aged 4. We explained from the start that no full time child care would be done DH is a night worker and us changing our working lives was simply not an option We never wanted to be over pushy but will always be there if really needed and of course do visiting / family events etc and spending time with GD all seemed well . But DD 1 wasn't happy with this and expected pretty much everything to be on her terms . Long story short DD 1 has gone NC and we have not seen our GD for nearly a year . It's all very upsetting but me & my DH have to be ok with this we have no choice. If our DD thinks that not allowing us to see our GD is fair punishment for having our own commitments then it speaks volumes that our role was simply for child care .

Suedomin · 14/11/2022 15:50

Surely the role is whatever you make of it. Every family is different so the role will be different.
But it is wrong go to suggest that parents have an ongoing duty to support their children's children. Some may want to but it's not an obligation.
A parents duty to their children is to nuture and care for them when they are children and give them all the tools and support to enable them to become independent adults.

ButterCrackers · 14/11/2022 15:44

Grandparents should help with their families because their grandchildren are their future going forward in life. I look forward to being whatever help and support my kids might need when I might be a Gran. Being a parent is a privilege as you are the parent to a child with the responsibilities of this role. Being a gran will be a responsibility that I hope to have.

Roomytrouser · 14/11/2022 15:42

ChillysWaterBottle · 14/11/2022 10:56

This has been my experience too. People who don't want to help their children and grandchildren often didn't get proper help themselves and found child rearing tough, all-consuming and thankless. Without family support having children affected their careers and social lives. Then they couldn't wait to sack it off and 'start their own life' again, as they see their children/family as an imposition on their life and not part of it. I get why they're unhappy but I don't get why they A) would want their children to go through what they went through and not want to break that miserable cycle, and B) spend their time attacking people who got proper support from their parents, calling them entitled and selfish and all that. Its not going to make them happy, and it's not going to help them build the kind of warm, happy, supportive families other people have and are benefiting from.

Awww, I’ve really enjoyed being a parent even though my DCs went to nursery. DH and I split the childcare equally and they have a lovely relationship with their grandparents. How sad you know so many miserable people.

SparkyBlue · 14/11/2022 15:10

Also remember for many women especially many of my own mothers generation especially those from more working class backgrounds as they get older they get their first sense of freedom. Many went from being under their parents roof to being busy wives and mothers and finally they have children reared and they are more comfortable financially and want to relax and enjoy themselves and they are entitled to that. My own mother was just told she wasn't returning to school after Christmas one year as her cousin got her a job at a local factory. And she worked in factories all her working life as my dad was laid off in the 80s so she went back fulltime. My poor mother wasn't even 14 when she started work. So now in her early seventies while fit and healthy if she wants to spend her days watching soaps on telly who am I to criticise her.

Legallypinkish · 14/11/2022 13:10

I have adult children but no grandchildren. I also have teenagers. None of them are showing any signs of wanting children. I’m happy with that . If they do have children I’ll be supportive and help where I can but in absolutely do not want to take on regular childcare. I’ll babysit and look after them when I can but after bringing up two children and then having two more I want some peace and freedom! I’ve never expected my parents to take on childcare.

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 14/11/2022 13:05

I couldn't disagree more and I cannot bear this level of entitlement. Your choice to produce kids is just that, your choice.

Mimi1313 · 14/11/2022 13:01

My grandmother has around 100 grandchildren and great grandchildren! No way in heaven could she be a parent to us all. She was however a fantastic grandmother. I would massage her feet and she would get up to date with all my life details. She had an impecible memory and knew everything about us all! We never expected anything in return and felt so loved despite her not being more of a "parent" to us. Love and support is different for everyone. If I was the only grandchild things would probably have been different but I never felt less loved or supported.

SparkyBlue · 14/11/2022 12:55

My mother spent her life helping with siblings before having her own children and always said that she wasn't spending her senior years minding children and she stuck to her word. She will step in in an emergency or for the occasional hour in the afternoon but that's it and that's fine as it what i expected. I don't think her own mother was at all nurturing despite having a massive family so my mother is only copying her. I definitely don't want to turn out like my own mother as she just doesn't seem happy in herself and never really has been happy. Also just in relation to the original OP a lot depends on health as well.

Huntswomanonthemove · 14/11/2022 11:43

This has been my experience too. People who don't want to help their children and grandchildren often didn't get proper help themselves and found child rearing tough, all-consuming and thankless. Without family support having children affected their careers and social lives. Then they couldn't wait to sack it off and 'start their own life' again, as they see their children/family as an imposition on their life and not part of it.

This is a massive generalisation and in my experience utterly untrue.

ChillysWaterBottle · 14/11/2022 10:56

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 18:06

Good loving parents tend to grow into good loving grandparents, health issues allowing. They will enjoy helping their adult children, nurture their grandchildren and welcome the joy of new children in the family. Keen to help and bond with their young GC, they will contribute and help as much as possible, and be much loved in return.

Those that didn't want children/had too many/struggled in some or many ways tend to think their job is done and dusted at the first opportunity, often at very young ages such as 15/16/17/18 and are not interested in doing anything else child related - including interest or support of grandchildren. Their job is 'done' mentality. They are the same bunch that seem to then expect to be 'paid back' for their exceptionally average parenting efforts. There is a transactional element to parenting.

In a perfect world we would have loving gps and families that help and support each other. In reality it is not a given.

This has been my experience too. People who don't want to help their children and grandchildren often didn't get proper help themselves and found child rearing tough, all-consuming and thankless. Without family support having children affected their careers and social lives. Then they couldn't wait to sack it off and 'start their own life' again, as they see their children/family as an imposition on their life and not part of it. I get why they're unhappy but I don't get why they A) would want their children to go through what they went through and not want to break that miserable cycle, and B) spend their time attacking people who got proper support from their parents, calling them entitled and selfish and all that. Its not going to make them happy, and it's not going to help them build the kind of warm, happy, supportive families other people have and are benefiting from.

Theydoyaknow · 14/11/2022 10:55

ChubbyMorticia · 14/11/2022 09:46

My kids range from adult to teens to under 10. It’s highly likely that I’ll have at least one GC before the last kid leaves home. I’m also working on getting a new career off the ground, as a workplace incident resulted in disability.

I’ve been a parent all my adult life. Once the kids are grown and flown, my DH and I will be able to be a priority in how we spend our time/money vs coming in last. Some may call it selfish, but after decades of putting the kids first, being able to go away for a week just because we want to sounds like bliss.

Of course we’ll help the kids as we can, especially if there’s an emergency. Occasional babysitting? Okay.

But full time child care? I’d rather set my hair on fire.

There’s more to my identity than being a parent or one day, a grandparent. I’m allowed to be a person, to value myself, for more than how I serve others.

Absolutely well said.

ChubbyMorticia · 14/11/2022 09:46

My kids range from adult to teens to under 10. It’s highly likely that I’ll have at least one GC before the last kid leaves home. I’m also working on getting a new career off the ground, as a workplace incident resulted in disability.

I’ve been a parent all my adult life. Once the kids are grown and flown, my DH and I will be able to be a priority in how we spend our time/money vs coming in last. Some may call it selfish, but after decades of putting the kids first, being able to go away for a week just because we want to sounds like bliss.

Of course we’ll help the kids as we can, especially if there’s an emergency. Occasional babysitting? Okay.

But full time child care? I’d rather set my hair on fire.

There’s more to my identity than being a parent or one day, a grandparent. I’m allowed to be a person, to value myself, for more than how I serve others.