Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Religion, the Church of England and State Ceremonies

354 replies

cakeorwine · 13/11/2022 11:25

I know we have an established church. I get that. And that's probably the answer to this question.

I do feel uncomfortable with the role that religion - specifically the Church of England - plays in State Ceremonies.

Watching the Cenotaph events on Remembrance Sunday. A moving event - but it does have a lot of religious elements. Prayers, hymns and The Lord's Prayer.

I think that anything religious should stick to events that are just for people of that religion. Or if it is multi-faith, then involve other faiths.

Remembrance Sunday is a national event. Keep religion out of it and just stick to remembering the people who died.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WombatChocolate · 15/11/2022 21:31

Yes, that is what I said. Over time things might change….but we are not at that point at the moment.

cakeorwine · 15/11/2022 20:47

Over time, that group might grow and the influence of the Church might decline, but currently, the Church is still a huge institution in the same way the monarchy is and so it will be there at these key events

Over time, maybe it will become less so.

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 15/11/2022 20:23

I think you’re right - the CofE does have a ‘hold’ or role within society still. It is still a key institution and as such, has an influence and role in key state occasions like this. Or the coronation, or Queen’s funeral etc.

Lots of people are not religious. This might mean that in time we don’t have a state Church or its role dwindles. However, we haven’t got to that position. Like it or not, the Church is more entwined in the nations history and also in its present than many people realise. That’s why it’s there.

And actually, many of these events do include other religions too now. One of the official remembrance videos produced for use in schools was about the role of Empire Muslims in WW2 and the unknown role many played.

Some people would like there to never be a prayer or Bible reading, or mention of God anywhere public. Some people feel like this, but lots don’t. Bigger numbers than you think remain strongly religious and others might not call themselves religious but value the Church heritage and see it as part of their culture. It is true that some are uncomfortable with it. Over time, that group might grow and the influence of the Church might decline, but currently, the Church is still a huge institution in the same way the monarchy is and so it will be there at these key events.

cakeorwine · 15/11/2022 20:10

As has been explained to you (and I don't know why I'm rising to the bait, but still...) Head of State and Head of CoE are intertwined for state and public occasions and you don't have one without the other. The service we have on the second Sunday of November has been in pretty much that format for 103 years, only you seem to have an issue with it; if anyone else does they find something else to do once a year

It's a matter of hats.

He would be there as the Monarch. The Head of State. When I see the Monarch on the State Occasions such as Opening Parliament, I see the Head of State. Not the Head of the Church of England.

And yes, it's the same format. But guess what, formats can change. I mean they let a Humanist lay a wreath recently on behalf of Humanists.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 15/11/2022 20:06

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/11/2022 17:23

He could lead it. Talk about the sacrifices of war, thank the veterans on behalf of a grateful nation

Remembering the sacrifices of war and thanking the veterans is what Remembrance Sunday IS FOR AND HAS BEEN SINCE 1919

You're trolling now. You have to be, no-one's this (struggles for word that won't get me banned) incapable of understanding.

You don't seem to understand yourself.

It would be the same ceremony as now.
EXCEPT there would be no Lord's Prayer.

The Church of England would be on an equal footing with other faith groups. Free to put down a wreath along with the other faith groups on behalf of their communities.

It would be the Monarch leading it. In their role as Monarch. He would be taking the lead.

No need to have the Lord's Prayer. It would be a secular service but almost the same as it is now. Except the bit by the Bishop of London.

OP posts:
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/11/2022 17:23

He could lead it. Talk about the sacrifices of war, thank the veterans on behalf of a grateful nation

Remembering the sacrifices of war and thanking the veterans is what Remembrance Sunday IS FOR AND HAS BEEN SINCE 1919

You're trolling now. You have to be, no-one's this (struggles for word that won't get me banned) incapable of understanding.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/11/2022 17:01

(Yes, he is Head of the Church of England) but he would be there in his role as Head of State

As has been explained to you (and I don't know why I'm rising to the bait, but still...) Head of State and Head of CoE are intertwined for state and public occasions and you don't have one without the other. The service we have on the second Sunday of November has been in pretty much that format for 103 years, only you seem to have an issue with it; if anyone else does they find something else to do once a year.

Get another hobby, FFS. Or help.

mpsw · 14/11/2022 22:28

cakeorwine · 14/11/2022 20:49

I think a good ceremony would be:

Charles, as Monarch, leading it. (Yes, he is Head of the Church of England) but he would be there in his role as Head of State.

He could lead it. Talk about the sacrifices of war, thank the veterans on behalf of a grateful nation. There could be the Last Post, They shall not grow old, and then representatives could lay wreaths.

No Lord Prayers. Maybe the National Anthem.

Just the Head of State (as Head of State) thanking the veterans and remembering the dead.

You'll need to sell that model to your local branch of RBL, and if a secular version catches on, then it'll spread round the regions, and will percolate up (remembrance is grassroots led)

That's what I meant by starting local

The Cenotaph ceremony would of course continue to be annual, and Whitehall would be no more difficult to close than it is now.

Remember there are thousands of other ceremonies, of same format, going on at the same time. Starting local means getting those to change. It means talking to the veterans and volunteers and persuading them to change. And changes that are welcome will spread

I don't think a speech would be a particularly good replacement for the traditional words of remembrance that have be spoken through the years. But perhaps, when you start taking your online idea into the RL veterans and wider community that people would prefer that

cakeorwine · 14/11/2022 20:49

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 14/11/2022 17:06

You know Charles is head of the Church of England as King don't you?

Dunno if you have RTFT but if not I'll precis briefly for you - there are 14 pages of various people explaining why state and public occasions have a religious component and OP is STILL posting vague, waffly posts along the lines of 'The Church of England, but whyyyyyyyyy isn't this all secular? can't we do it another way, I've got ideas?'

Spare yourself and don't engage. It's now either deliberate goading or beyond ignorant.

I think a good ceremony would be:

Charles, as Monarch, leading it. (Yes, he is Head of the Church of England) but he would be there in his role as Head of State.

He could lead it. Talk about the sacrifices of war, thank the veterans on behalf of a grateful nation. There could be the Last Post, They shall not grow old, and then representatives could lay wreaths.

No Lord Prayers. Maybe the National Anthem.

Just the Head of State (as Head of State) thanking the veterans and remembering the dead.

OP posts:
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 14/11/2022 17:06

You know Charles is head of the Church of England as King don't you?

Dunno if you have RTFT but if not I'll precis briefly for you - there are 14 pages of various people explaining why state and public occasions have a religious component and OP is STILL posting vague, waffly posts along the lines of 'The Church of England, but whyyyyyyyyy isn't this all secular? can't we do it another way, I've got ideas?'

Spare yourself and don't engage. It's now either deliberate goading or beyond ignorant.

JusteanBiscuits · 14/11/2022 15:18

cakeorwine · 13/11/2022 21:00

I know that it's the most common prayer. I had to say it every day at school. Twice

I think that a national ceremony with a secular nature would be good. Faith leaders could be present and lay wreaths.

Maybe Charles could lead it. As the figurehead of our nation.

You know Charles is head of the Church of England as King don't you?

JusteanBiscuits · 14/11/2022 15:16

We have a state religion. That's how it is.

Where as the US has separation of church and state - look how great that does.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/11/2022 15:14

I don’t think there’s much historical fact on miracles.

I believe a guy called Jesus existed. But he was just a normal guy. No walking on water or any such nonsense.

VestaTilley · 14/11/2022 12:35

YABVU, OP.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/11/2022 12:28

I’m commenting generally not on Remembrance Day specifically. I think the ceremony should stay.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/11/2022 12:27

I really don’t agree with countries having a state religion. Religion should be a personal thing, and not woven into the fabric of the state.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/11/2022 12:26

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow , then why did you say the man didn’t exist? Whether he was the Messiah is a completely different question.

You were implying that he was a made-up entity, , like Rumpelstiltskin or something.
It’s best not to confuse historical fact with what you prefer to think.

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 13/11/2022 21:35

So if the religious aspect is dropped and those who appreciate it complain, what then? More division in a society already divided. The ceremony of remembrance has had a religious aspect since it's inception. The people attending seem fine with the status quo - and let's face it, the people in the parade should have a much greater say on the mechanics than those watching from afar.

So much tradition being thrown out with the bathwater. OK, things move on, but change for change sake? Not always the best way to move things forward.

As I said upthread, I have no religious faith, but that doesn't mean I don't appreciate the tradition, history, art, music, literature that stems from all faiths and I think the world would be poorer without it. And yes, I do perceive the damage that can be done by individuals in the name of faith. We all need something to believe in, but it's up to us as individuals to not use faith, or let's face it, lack of faith, to push a personal agenda.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/11/2022 21:30

But l think the cerony needs to stay! Just without the religion.

WW2 and 2 were seismic terrible events. They shouldn’t be forgotten.

cakeorwine · 13/11/2022 21:20

mpsw · 13/11/2022 21:16

None of it is needed.

What is done is what the veteran community (who run the event) wants to happen.

If you want different events, organise them. The level of support for alternatives will be formative of any future changes. Start locally (there are events up and down the country) and if there is support, then the movement will grow and change will happen

Might be a bit hard to close Whitehall and ask politicians to attend.

But I am sure as the UK population changes over the years, the ceremony will change too.

OP posts:
mpsw · 13/11/2022 21:16

None of it is needed.

What is done is what the veteran community (who run the event) wants to happen.

If you want different events, organise them. The level of support for alternatives will be formative of any future changes. Start locally (there are events up and down the country) and if there is support, then the movement will grow and change will happen

cakeorwine · 13/11/2022 21:00

jackstini · 13/11/2022 20:49

The Lord's Prayer is said because it would have been the most common prayer for service men and women, and is probably still the most well known today

I know that it's the most common prayer. I had to say it every day at school. Twice

I think that a national ceremony with a secular nature would be good. Faith leaders could be present and lay wreaths.

Maybe Charles could lead it. As the figurehead of our nation.

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/11/2022 20:52

Why did the Lord's Prayer need to be said?
Would it have been a lesser ceremony if it had not been said?

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

jackstini · 13/11/2022 20:49

The Lord's Prayer is said because it would have been the most common prayer for service men and women, and is probably still the most well known today

cakeorwine · 13/11/2022 20:45

JudgeJ · 13/11/2022 20:41

That's the case in many ceremonies on a grand scale, eg HM's funeral, but it's only the Christians who get bashed, the easy tsrget because these days we don't fight back.

It was the Lord's Prayer that was said by the Bishop of London.

And it's not bashing Christians.

Why did the Lord's Prayer need to be said?
Would it have been a lesser ceremony if it had not been said?

OP posts: