Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this incredibly annoying-son kissing baby

114 replies

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:07

I've posted before under a different username and I know a lot of you will think I'm being silly.

I have a lovely, sweet, kind 7 year old son and a 9 month old baby. My son seems to have an irresistible urge to kiss the baby and its driving me around the bend. I mean, it's seriously starting to impact me mentally. First World problems, whatever.

For several months he has been kissing her over and over, either on the hand on the face. It's started off as being the loudest, slurpiest, smacking sound. He was deliberately kissing her in a way that made the most noise. The noise more than drove me mad: it actually distressed me at the time, especially if he did it when I was breastfeeding her. I don't want to start using very dramatic language, but sometimes I wanted to cry as the noise kept happening over and over, sometimes very much in my space.

Now, he kisses her in a much more quiet way but in an open mouthed sort of way that often leaves saliva on her face or hand. This does my head in too. If I'm picking her up off the ground when they are playing together, he will automatically grab her hand to kiss it goodbye, which means sometimes her arm gets pulled back as I'm lifting her. I've explained the dangers of this over and over. Since she has started crawling, he will also lift her hand to kiss it and it destabilises her as she is on all fours. I've spoken to him about that too, but the urge seems to be too strong to resist. Baby generally starts whinging when he does it and we have explained how he needs to respect her space and back off when he hears the whinging noise.

My baby has been sleeping absolutely terribly the past few weeks. I mean waking up every 90 minutes all night and hardly napping in the day. I was becoming a zombie. For the past three nights, she has been sleeping in good long stretches of 4 hours or so and I feel like a new woman. Last night was a good night and this morning I was having a dream where I was listening to music and the music gradually turned into the sound of a baby whinging, that dreaded sound. Soon, I woke up and realised the baby whinging was mine. My son was lying beside me looking very worried. The first thing he said was 'it's my fault, I kissed her hand and she woke up'.

It was 7.30, so a 'lie in' anyway but I had been in a deep sleep, the baby was asleep and I felt so upset that this very rare occasion was interrupted by his kissing.

I adore my son, I really do. He gets a huge amount of love, affection and attention from me and my husband. We make a lot of time for his emotional well being and I know he is a very happy child with a huge amount of love in his heart. We have talked about the kissing and he says its because he just loves the baby so much. My husband says I need to get over the kissing thing as our boy just loves his sister and we shouldn't stand in the way of that relationship.

However I cannot help this visceral reaction and a few times I have physically batted my sons hand away when he has gone to to kiss the baby today. I've lost count of how many times it has happened since this morning. I'm actually a bit of a Ned Flanders goodie two-shoes type who never swears and there have been a few times I've felt like screaming 'f* off!' at my 7 year old child! I haven't and wouldn't but this isn't normal surely!

Other than this issue, I'm very happy, no PND, we are a happy family, all is going well, and I generally love motherhood and have a very high threshold for the ups and downs of a mum's life. I normally take everything in my stride but this is driving me so crazy that I asked my husband to take my son out with the baby for a walk as I seriously need some space.

Any advice!

OP posts:
SheWoreARaspberryBeret123 · 13/11/2022 11:49

Also, give yourself a break. You must be knackered. Even my lovely cat annoyed the crap out of me when I was breast feeding. It'll pass op x

SheWoreARaspberryBeret123 · 13/11/2022 11:47

I think he needs more attention. Can his dad take him out for special daddy /DS time?

CarolineHelston · 13/11/2022 11:46

It all sounds a bit cloying to me. I think it's great that you're an affectionate, attentive parent - and that kisses and hugs and saying loving things are part of that. But if you're implicitly saying that this is what people in families should do as much as possible, is it hardly surprising that he is - for whatever reason -choosing to imitate this/pass on this behaviour to the new arrival.

Does your son have friendships and hobbies? Does he enjoy school? It's great if he feels positive about his baby sibling - though perhaps there may be some ambivalence as people suggest. But it would be healthier if he regarded this new member of the family as occasionally lovely, sometimes irritating - but basically irrelevant to his own, much more grownup world. I think that some of the time his attention should be directed elsewhere.

DarkKarmaIlama · 13/11/2022 11:44

It sounds like you’ve made a mountain out of a molehill.

Your son needs to stop kissing her so frequently as it’s annoying you. Why can’t you instil some boundaries there and indeed some consequences if he continues to do it. I have a 7 year old boy and he would never do this repeatedly if I told him not too. To want to cry about it is a bit much. Just get him to stop,
problem solved.

Ozgirl75 · 13/11/2022 11:44

When you talk about how physically affectionate you are as a family (which is lovely by the way!), maybe your son is just mirroring how you show love to him, with how he shows love to his sister?

I actually think learning boundaries and consent is important and siblings are a brilliant way of showing this long before anything sexual comes into the picture. From very young I would say “look, he doesn’t look super happy with you laying on top of him, so jump off and let’s find a new thing to do”, and talking about reading siblings expressions, don’t wait for them to say no or stop Mine are now 10 and 12 and although they have their moments, they are actually very respectful of each other’s personal space.

So redirecting with a “when the baby whinges like that, it’s her way of showing she doesn’t like what you’re doing, even though she loves you. But we know she loves it when you do X (stroke her cheek, read her a story, play with a toy) so let’s do that instead.

beastlyslumber · 13/11/2022 11:43

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:27

Thanks everyone for being so kind. I was expecting a bit of a lashing and I feel guilty for even saying these things about my lovely boy.

I like the idea of redirecting the kissing to a stroke and I agree that something primal seems to happen to me which is related to breastfeeding.

I really am a very, very affectionate person myself. I snuggle my son constantly. I tell him I love him several times a day and factor in very frequent mum and son times, where we snuggle and watch his favourite show, go through his Pokemon book, play games together and justbthe other night I lay beside him and stroked his back as he went to sleep and told him all the things I love about him over and over. Me and my husband make a big, big effort with all our kids to know how special they are and how much we adore them. We have a secret handhold where I squeeze 3 times as code for 'I love you' and we do that all the time. We write him notes telling him how much we love him. I honestly cannot think of any other ways that I can make him feel seen, loved and heard. And the evidence really is in his nature. Everyone comments on what a happy, loving child he is.

Thanks again for listening everyone, I felt a bit cra,y when I wrote this!

I think this is the key to it all. You express your love to your son in what I would consider quite an overwhelming/overbearing way. He is copying what you've modelled to him, in how he shows love to his sister.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:42

Can i just say that I feel a million times better having reached out. All of the responses are really valid and helpful and yes, I do feel sensory overloads very easily, and coupled with breastfeeding and lack of sleep, things have been magnified.

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 13/11/2022 11:41

*unconsciously even

AloysiusBear · 13/11/2022 11:41

Im sort of sympathetic to this situation because I (and DD who is 3) both love kissing babies!

There's just something irresistible about those soft little cheeks. DD is basically desperate for a baby sibling because sge wants a baby to kiss (she isn't going to get one, alas).
Blush

DD will also kiss me a lot and its often quite sloppy but i love it Grin

I wouldnt discourage the affection I'd just focus on him not destabilising her and try to tell him to close his mouth

Sceptre86 · 13/11/2022 11:41

When you have a baby your older children look bigger and sometimes inconciously you can perceive them as a threat to your precious newborn. its instivtinvr to want to prorxt the baby but your son isn't doing any harm, apart from being a bit annoying. My baby is 1 now and her brother is 5, he annoys her sometimes and I have to remind him that if she is whining it's a sign yo back off and leave her alone.

I'd do constant reassurance to your sometimes that he is loved as ever but also reminders that kissing baby over and over can be annoying to her.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:40

Good question @NoSquirrels . He developed a tic a few years ago which I think was down to some anxiety at the time. I researched it and got some advice and had a two pronged approach of ignoring the tic while ramping up all the positive stuff. He still gets it from time to time but we ignore it.

I think I should maybe just ignore the kissing and redirect his attention while keeping up with the attention stuff.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 13/11/2022 11:36

I do think he had a nature which can be a bit compulsive and unfortunately I recognise myself in that, which is maybe why I get so triggered!

Are there any other things he does compulsively? And how do you deal with those?

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:36

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/11/2022 11:33

Ask him what he’d like to do with you? It might be he actually wants to be taken to the park or play whatever game? It’s always worth asking people what attention they want. And this will help him feel noticed.

Also it’s evident from this you are a very physical family, so his physicality with his sister is in this context. It doesn’t change how you have to manage it, obviously, but it might help to know it when you are taking to him about it.

Yes I definitely ask him what he wants to do. Drawing together, watch a movie with sweets and a blanket, sticking stickers in his football book, taking silly selfies etc. I ask for his input a lot.

OP posts:
7eleven · 13/11/2022 11:35

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:20

Yes it does make sense. My son is average maturity for his age, I would say but I do think he had a nature which can be a bit compulsive and unfortunately I recognise myself in that, which is maybe why I get so triggered!

You could be right. A psychologist told me that things that annoy us about other people are often like holding a mirror to ourselves. It’s something we don’t like about ourselves.

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/11/2022 11:33

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:27

Thanks everyone for being so kind. I was expecting a bit of a lashing and I feel guilty for even saying these things about my lovely boy.

I like the idea of redirecting the kissing to a stroke and I agree that something primal seems to happen to me which is related to breastfeeding.

I really am a very, very affectionate person myself. I snuggle my son constantly. I tell him I love him several times a day and factor in very frequent mum and son times, where we snuggle and watch his favourite show, go through his Pokemon book, play games together and justbthe other night I lay beside him and stroked his back as he went to sleep and told him all the things I love about him over and over. Me and my husband make a big, big effort with all our kids to know how special they are and how much we adore them. We have a secret handhold where I squeeze 3 times as code for 'I love you' and we do that all the time. We write him notes telling him how much we love him. I honestly cannot think of any other ways that I can make him feel seen, loved and heard. And the evidence really is in his nature. Everyone comments on what a happy, loving child he is.

Thanks again for listening everyone, I felt a bit cra,y when I wrote this!

Ask him what he’d like to do with you? It might be he actually wants to be taken to the park or play whatever game? It’s always worth asking people what attention they want. And this will help him feel noticed.

Also it’s evident from this you are a very physical family, so his physicality with his sister is in this context. It doesn’t change how you have to manage it, obviously, but it might help to know it when you are taking to him about it.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:32

I also agree about the personal space thing and we have spoken at length about respecting space and listening for cues as to whether the other person likes what you are doing or not. This is important to me as a mother to instill this.

OP posts:
SheCameRoundAMountain · 13/11/2022 11:29

CatherinedeBourgh · 13/11/2022 11:23

I'm going to get jumped on by this but this is a great time to start to drum in notions of consent.

You need to gently but consistently stop him doing it. Explain that the baby doesn't like that expression of affection, and that 'I can't help it because I love her' is really, really not an acceptable answer.

Sadly the normalisation of such behaviour like your husband is doing is a cause of many, many problems in society today. It's (sadly) never too early to start teaching the respect for others' personal space.

I agree with this angle, babies are able to express their needs and that includes personal space, and that should be respected to a point (safety, etc excluded).

It's good practice for your son to learn to respect the needs of his much-loved baby sibling, and to build a two way relationship, not one where the baby is merely acted upon.

Other points raised are good as well, with considerations around the 7yo's attention seeking and your own overwhelm. A lot is going on, so it makes sense you're struggling.

Cinnabomb · 13/11/2022 11:29

Just wanted to say @Shandyinthejarro that I completely understand your rage at eldest waking the baby. Rightly or wrongly, I would have been absolutely raging too. I’ve currently got a breastfed newborn (and toddler) and I think you forget just how desperate one can feel regarding sleep in the early days. Totally normal.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:29

Pumpkinpatchlookinggood · 13/11/2022 11:22

Read up on misaphonia op... Do other noises drive you bonkers?
Wish I had realised I so obviously have it years ago. I can literally feel my blood pounding round my body when dc used to play with toy cars noisily..

Yes many!

OP posts:
DrivingHomeForChristmaaargh · 13/11/2022 11:28

This seems like a good example of the theory that all behaviour is communication. It sounds to me as if he’s feeling a bit unsure and that he’s looking for ways to check whether he still has the same close bond with you as he did as a younger child- both by looking for attention and by inserting himself into the mother-baby bond you have with your baby (which I imagine is what is producing such a strong reaction in you).

As children get older, they often need to take a step back in maturity every now and then for comfort and reassurance. I’d try maybe extra cuddles, suggest you read him a story one night if he’s no longer having that habitually etc. I’d also try to redirect his kisses into something more helpful- can he help do things for the baby eg bring the bits you need for a nappy change, help you prepping food, or whatever it is, and praise him for doing them. Try to find ways to show him that your bond with the baby is no challenge to your bond with him and that he can still be your little boy. 7 seems huge when you also have a baby and younger child but it’s still just a little one really.

olympicsrock · 13/11/2022 11:28

I think you are exhausted and hypersensitive. I remember those days.

asking for DH to take him out was the right thing to do. Don’t make DS feel too guilty for loving the baby , gently ask him not to disturb when she is awake or crawling.

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/11/2022 11:28

CatherinedeBourgh · 13/11/2022 11:23

I'm going to get jumped on by this but this is a great time to start to drum in notions of consent.

You need to gently but consistently stop him doing it. Explain that the baby doesn't like that expression of affection, and that 'I can't help it because I love her' is really, really not an acceptable answer.

Sadly the normalisation of such behaviour like your husband is doing is a cause of many, many problems in society today. It's (sadly) never too early to start teaching the respect for others' personal space.

Do you actually have any experience with kids?! I don’t think anyone is going to jump on you, consent is important - it’s just that this isn’t going to help the OP - because her actual problems are 1) her son is feeling a bit neglected and thus attention seeking and 2) she is knackered and thus irritable

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:27

Thanks everyone for being so kind. I was expecting a bit of a lashing and I feel guilty for even saying these things about my lovely boy.

I like the idea of redirecting the kissing to a stroke and I agree that something primal seems to happen to me which is related to breastfeeding.

I really am a very, very affectionate person myself. I snuggle my son constantly. I tell him I love him several times a day and factor in very frequent mum and son times, where we snuggle and watch his favourite show, go through his Pokemon book, play games together and justbthe other night I lay beside him and stroked his back as he went to sleep and told him all the things I love about him over and over. Me and my husband make a big, big effort with all our kids to know how special they are and how much we adore them. We have a secret handhold where I squeeze 3 times as code for 'I love you' and we do that all the time. We write him notes telling him how much we love him. I honestly cannot think of any other ways that I can make him feel seen, loved and heard. And the evidence really is in his nature. Everyone comments on what a happy, loving child he is.

Thanks again for listening everyone, I felt a bit cra,y when I wrote this!

OP posts:
CatherinedeBourgh · 13/11/2022 11:23

I'm going to get jumped on by this but this is a great time to start to drum in notions of consent.

You need to gently but consistently stop him doing it. Explain that the baby doesn't like that expression of affection, and that 'I can't help it because I love her' is really, really not an acceptable answer.

Sadly the normalisation of such behaviour like your husband is doing is a cause of many, many problems in society today. It's (sadly) never too early to start teaching the respect for others' personal space.

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/11/2022 11:23

I think you have got a bit of sensory overload and irritability due to hormones/tiredness, because you are overreacting - in the nicest possible way you mainly need to manage yourself not your son.

I think as a PP says there’s probably a bit of attention seeking - a new baby inevitably sucks attention and this is a great way of putting it back on him. It’s also probably a genuine expression of affection.

Give him a bit of 1 on 1 time, remove him from the baby every time he leaves saliva, pulls her arm, or climbs on you when you are feeding. He needs to keep having those boundaries reinforced. Learn to tune out the lip smacking. Try and get more rest. Remember this will pass.