Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this incredibly annoying-son kissing baby

114 replies

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:07

I've posted before under a different username and I know a lot of you will think I'm being silly.

I have a lovely, sweet, kind 7 year old son and a 9 month old baby. My son seems to have an irresistible urge to kiss the baby and its driving me around the bend. I mean, it's seriously starting to impact me mentally. First World problems, whatever.

For several months he has been kissing her over and over, either on the hand on the face. It's started off as being the loudest, slurpiest, smacking sound. He was deliberately kissing her in a way that made the most noise. The noise more than drove me mad: it actually distressed me at the time, especially if he did it when I was breastfeeding her. I don't want to start using very dramatic language, but sometimes I wanted to cry as the noise kept happening over and over, sometimes very much in my space.

Now, he kisses her in a much more quiet way but in an open mouthed sort of way that often leaves saliva on her face or hand. This does my head in too. If I'm picking her up off the ground when they are playing together, he will automatically grab her hand to kiss it goodbye, which means sometimes her arm gets pulled back as I'm lifting her. I've explained the dangers of this over and over. Since she has started crawling, he will also lift her hand to kiss it and it destabilises her as she is on all fours. I've spoken to him about that too, but the urge seems to be too strong to resist. Baby generally starts whinging when he does it and we have explained how he needs to respect her space and back off when he hears the whinging noise.

My baby has been sleeping absolutely terribly the past few weeks. I mean waking up every 90 minutes all night and hardly napping in the day. I was becoming a zombie. For the past three nights, she has been sleeping in good long stretches of 4 hours or so and I feel like a new woman. Last night was a good night and this morning I was having a dream where I was listening to music and the music gradually turned into the sound of a baby whinging, that dreaded sound. Soon, I woke up and realised the baby whinging was mine. My son was lying beside me looking very worried. The first thing he said was 'it's my fault, I kissed her hand and she woke up'.

It was 7.30, so a 'lie in' anyway but I had been in a deep sleep, the baby was asleep and I felt so upset that this very rare occasion was interrupted by his kissing.

I adore my son, I really do. He gets a huge amount of love, affection and attention from me and my husband. We make a lot of time for his emotional well being and I know he is a very happy child with a huge amount of love in his heart. We have talked about the kissing and he says its because he just loves the baby so much. My husband says I need to get over the kissing thing as our boy just loves his sister and we shouldn't stand in the way of that relationship.

However I cannot help this visceral reaction and a few times I have physically batted my sons hand away when he has gone to to kiss the baby today. I've lost count of how many times it has happened since this morning. I'm actually a bit of a Ned Flanders goodie two-shoes type who never swears and there have been a few times I've felt like screaming 'f* off!' at my 7 year old child! I haven't and wouldn't but this isn't normal surely!

Other than this issue, I'm very happy, no PND, we are a happy family, all is going well, and I generally love motherhood and have a very high threshold for the ups and downs of a mum's life. I normally take everything in my stride but this is driving me so crazy that I asked my husband to take my son out with the baby for a walk as I seriously need some space.

Any advice!

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 13/11/2022 12:15

CatherinedeBourgh · 13/11/2022 11:23

I'm going to get jumped on by this but this is a great time to start to drum in notions of consent.

You need to gently but consistently stop him doing it. Explain that the baby doesn't like that expression of affection, and that 'I can't help it because I love her' is really, really not an acceptable answer.

Sadly the normalisation of such behaviour like your husband is doing is a cause of many, many problems in society today. It's (sadly) never too early to start teaching the respect for others' personal space.

This is how I felt when reading.

It's great that your ds loves his sibling.

But he's 7. Old enough to understand your boundaries of personal space and babies.

He doesn't need to kiss her when she's attached to you feeding. He knows it gets in your space and you don't like it. He needs to understand that.

Have you thought of silently walking away to another room when he does it and then really praising every little time he respects boundaries and space? It's very likely an attention seeking thing but crossing personal boundaries for attention can lead to bigger problems in the future.

A child I knew had no personal space boundaries and her and her mum always used "but she wants ....." "she's only....." without ever considering her feelings didn't matter more than the other persons.
She had a sever breakdown at 15yo because after years of people pushing her away and literally refusing to be near her for years after joining secondary school her MH was shot.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 12:15

'And remember that many siblings absolutely hate their new siblings so try and see it as a positive thing.'

This is so true👍

OP posts:
Deemarie11 · 13/11/2022 12:14

I don't think an older boy should be leaving saliva all over a girl baby's face. That must feel disgusting for the baby.

It is very important to establish boundaries when it is an older male younger female sibling.

As I said, I remember being very young, aged 3, and I I remember my older brother who was 6, making me feel extremely uncomfortable.

Tell him not to do it at all. And punish him if he does. Instill lessons about boundaries. That you can't just kiss who you want all the time. Especially if that person is much smaller than you are.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 12:13

FictionalCharacter · 13/11/2022 12:09

It isn’t that you aren’t giving him enough attention. It’s that you are giving some of your attention to the baby. I had this conversation with a HV when my son was attention seeking and I said the same thing, that he gets plenty of attention, and she said “it’s never enough”!
The fact that he does it while you’re breastfeeding is a clue to this. Also that he pulls her hand up while she’s crawling, destabilising her. And that he “accidentally” woke her up in the morning and appeared next to you in bed.

This makes sense as he gets so much attention. But you're right, he doesn't get all of it, though he is used to sharing it with his 5 year old sibling.

As I said before, I had a very sickly younger sibling as a child and while I wouldn't say that I didn't get attention (I don't remember feeling sidelined as such), nobody made as much of an effort to make extra sure I got enough attention as my husband and I do with our older two kids. Hope that makes sense!

OP posts:
Deemarie11 · 13/11/2022 12:12

Ah my spell check keeps changing what I am saying .
It should read

*Looming over her and leaving saliva over her face

Deemarie11 · 13/11/2022 12:11

close family
*Looking over and leaving saliva over her face

CarefreeMe · 13/11/2022 12:11

It sounds like you are quite over the top with affection and so he is just mirroring you, like DCs will do.

He loves his sister so he is going to show her affection.

If he receives over the top affection then he is obviously going to show over the top affection.

DH or the baby doesn’t have an issue with it and so you are the problem.
Tiredness isn’t helping the situation.

Talk to him about personal space but you need to also show this by giving him his personal space and asking if it’s ok to give affection.
I would have definitely put a stop to him kidding her when you’re breastfeeding or asleep as that’s not fair on the baby.

Maybe you could word it as now the baby is getting older.

You just need to remember that he is going to mirror your behaviour, so I would be aware of how you treat the baby and him.

And remember that many siblings absolutely hate their new siblings so try and see it as a positive thing.

Deemarie11 · 13/11/2022 12:10

I've never ever kissed a baby. Even babies of close familt. I don't think the baby would like it, me leaving saliva over her face.

I'm sure a small baby wouldn't like a seven year old boy looking over and leaving saliva over her face. It is important to establish boundaries. Especially in an older male younger female scenario.

Im female, I grew up with one older brother (no sisters), and my brother often made me feel uncomfortable when I was very young. I had to tell him not to do things to me, then I had to tell my mother what he was doing. It is hard having an older brother. I wish I'd had sisters only.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 12:10

@reachforthebloodymary yes the noise drives me crazy. The quieter kisses that leave pool's of saliva don't drive me as crazy but aren't pleasant. It's definitely the noise.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 13/11/2022 12:09

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:15

OK we are getting somewhere. Thank you. I've considered this but I literally don't know how much more attention we could give him. Also, I remember having a very sick baby sibling and everyone telling me I was jealous of them, and I wasn't! It infuriated me, so I didn't want to go down this road without being very thoughtful about it. Thanks.

It isn’t that you aren’t giving him enough attention. It’s that you are giving some of your attention to the baby. I had this conversation with a HV when my son was attention seeking and I said the same thing, that he gets plenty of attention, and she said “it’s never enough”!
The fact that he does it while you’re breastfeeding is a clue to this. Also that he pulls her hand up while she’s crawling, destabilising her. And that he “accidentally” woke her up in the morning and appeared next to you in bed.

reachforthebloodymary · 13/11/2022 12:06

I was also going to suggest its the noise that annoys you, not the action, I found when DS was little it was so much worse, noises that I had coped with before, made me want to punch doors or scream shut the fuck up, it did calm down, but it was really hard

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 12:04

jolies · 13/11/2022 12:03

I was thinking misophonia too. I can relate to the feeling as MILs dog is constantly licking herself and the noise makes me want to pull my eyeballs out, I have to leave the room or just avoid her.

Yes I get irrationally distressed at certain sounds. My son gets irrationally distressed at certain clothing. I think we are maybe just too similar in some respects!

OP posts:
jolies · 13/11/2022 12:03

Pumpkinpatchlookinggood · 13/11/2022 11:22

Read up on misaphonia op... Do other noises drive you bonkers?
Wish I had realised I so obviously have it years ago. I can literally feel my blood pounding round my body when dc used to play with toy cars noisily..

I was thinking misophonia too. I can relate to the feeling as MILs dog is constantly licking herself and the noise makes me want to pull my eyeballs out, I have to leave the room or just avoid her.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 12:02

Mariposista · 13/11/2022 12:00

The kissing is not annoying or upsetting the baby - it is upsetting YOU. You ate therefore the problem.
your poor boy who loves his sibling gets his hand smacked just because his mother can’t cope. I’ve heard it all now. Take yourself into another room and calm the heck down.

Hand smacked 🙄

OP posts:
Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 13/11/2022 12:02

I would just say that you can kiss the baby in x place once per day but it's her body and she needs some space. And reinforce with sanctions. There is no irresistible urge to kiss and it's clearly pestering her. Never too early to learn to respect another's personal space and boundaries.

Not on.

Topsyturvy78 · 13/11/2022 12:02

Looks like he's doing it in purpose knowing he will get a reaction from you. If you had ignored him it would have fizzled out by now.

Doingmybest12 · 13/11/2022 12:01

I am sure he has struggled with new baby coming along and doing this is getting attention from you. But he is hurting the baby and that's not ok, pulling her arm back, destabilising her when crawling all dressed up in a kiss. I think this should be the focus, not kissing .

Mariposista · 13/11/2022 12:00

The kissing is not annoying or upsetting the baby - it is upsetting YOU. You ate therefore the problem.
your poor boy who loves his sibling gets his hand smacked just because his mother can’t cope. I’ve heard it all now. Take yourself into another room and calm the heck down.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 13/11/2022 12:00

I'm reading my reply back and some other posts and realising we're all telling you to carve out some time, either for son, yourself, baby - like you have a magical time clock that can give you another couple of hours in the day, and when you're exhausted too. God love you, mothering is hard! Flowers

Jibo · 13/11/2022 11:59

Decorhate · 13/11/2022 11:13

I wonder if (subconsciously or otherwise) the kissing has actually become an attention seeking thing rather than a display of affection?

Could you try to ignore the kissing (unless it’s hurting or upsetting the baby) but give your son extra attention or praise when he is doing something else?

Agree. Regardless of whether he is kissing her or shoving her, his is bad behaviour for the purpose of seeking attention, and needs to be managed accordingly. What would you do if he behaved like this with a friend's baby?

The problem will probably resolve once your DD can speak/run away/bite him, but you shouldn't wait that long. Tell DS not to touch the baby and make sure there are natural consequences e.g. if you see it's too hard for him to leave her be, then he'll have to be in a different room; if he wakes her (and therefore you), then you are too tired to take him to do something nice he was looking forward to.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 13/11/2022 11:58

Honestly, I think part of the problem is that you're touched out - and because your very strong instincts are driving you towards the baby, you're projecting your touched-out-ed-ness at your eldest DS. Which is fine. And actually one of the reasons that I only have one child, because I really struggled with that when DS was born and knew it would be ten-fold if we had a second.

Are you getting any time alone? I know how hard that is with a BF baby, but even a 15 minute walk around the block where no-one is responsible for you at all. Might that help?

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:51

@SheWoreARaspberryBeret123 yes dh does a lot with him and they have a hobby they do together as well. Dad also very affectionate haha! The thing is I literally don't know how much more attention we could give our son. I already do what everyone suggests and probably more, in that respect. Some people here even described it as overbearing and cloying (value these responses too BTW!)

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 13/11/2022 11:51

I feel really sorry for your poor son. He adores his sibling, kisses present no danger but lots of positivity. You are being really unreasonable.

KettrickenSmiled · 13/11/2022 11:51

CatherinedeBourgh · 13/11/2022 11:23

I'm going to get jumped on by this but this is a great time to start to drum in notions of consent.

You need to gently but consistently stop him doing it. Explain that the baby doesn't like that expression of affection, and that 'I can't help it because I love her' is really, really not an acceptable answer.

Sadly the normalisation of such behaviour like your husband is doing is a cause of many, many problems in society today. It's (sadly) never too early to start teaching the respect for others' personal space.

Well said @CatherinedeBourgh

Especially given the DH in this scenario, who tells OP to put up with it -
he says its because he just loves the baby so much.

Ghastly.
Modelling male entitlement on a 7 year old boy - "it's ok because he loves her" -
not too far a jump from - "he's only mean cos he likes you" or "he can't help pinching your bum cos he fancies you so much."

btw I'm NOT saying that DS will grow up to say those things to his own sister! - but the mindset is what leads to boys thinking that their feelings about girls surpersede those girls' rights to personal autonomy.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:49

Definitely taking on board that I have maybe created an extremely affectionate child! Again our middle child isn't over affectionate at all, and we respect that and don't push it, but the problem might just be that me and my son are the most alike in the family and maybe that's why I get so irate. A lot to think about.

Yes son loves school, has lots of friends and hobbies outside of school too.

OP posts: