Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this incredibly annoying-son kissing baby

114 replies

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:07

I've posted before under a different username and I know a lot of you will think I'm being silly.

I have a lovely, sweet, kind 7 year old son and a 9 month old baby. My son seems to have an irresistible urge to kiss the baby and its driving me around the bend. I mean, it's seriously starting to impact me mentally. First World problems, whatever.

For several months he has been kissing her over and over, either on the hand on the face. It's started off as being the loudest, slurpiest, smacking sound. He was deliberately kissing her in a way that made the most noise. The noise more than drove me mad: it actually distressed me at the time, especially if he did it when I was breastfeeding her. I don't want to start using very dramatic language, but sometimes I wanted to cry as the noise kept happening over and over, sometimes very much in my space.

Now, he kisses her in a much more quiet way but in an open mouthed sort of way that often leaves saliva on her face or hand. This does my head in too. If I'm picking her up off the ground when they are playing together, he will automatically grab her hand to kiss it goodbye, which means sometimes her arm gets pulled back as I'm lifting her. I've explained the dangers of this over and over. Since she has started crawling, he will also lift her hand to kiss it and it destabilises her as she is on all fours. I've spoken to him about that too, but the urge seems to be too strong to resist. Baby generally starts whinging when he does it and we have explained how he needs to respect her space and back off when he hears the whinging noise.

My baby has been sleeping absolutely terribly the past few weeks. I mean waking up every 90 minutes all night and hardly napping in the day. I was becoming a zombie. For the past three nights, she has been sleeping in good long stretches of 4 hours or so and I feel like a new woman. Last night was a good night and this morning I was having a dream where I was listening to music and the music gradually turned into the sound of a baby whinging, that dreaded sound. Soon, I woke up and realised the baby whinging was mine. My son was lying beside me looking very worried. The first thing he said was 'it's my fault, I kissed her hand and she woke up'.

It was 7.30, so a 'lie in' anyway but I had been in a deep sleep, the baby was asleep and I felt so upset that this very rare occasion was interrupted by his kissing.

I adore my son, I really do. He gets a huge amount of love, affection and attention from me and my husband. We make a lot of time for his emotional well being and I know he is a very happy child with a huge amount of love in his heart. We have talked about the kissing and he says its because he just loves the baby so much. My husband says I need to get over the kissing thing as our boy just loves his sister and we shouldn't stand in the way of that relationship.

However I cannot help this visceral reaction and a few times I have physically batted my sons hand away when he has gone to to kiss the baby today. I've lost count of how many times it has happened since this morning. I'm actually a bit of a Ned Flanders goodie two-shoes type who never swears and there have been a few times I've felt like screaming 'f* off!' at my 7 year old child! I haven't and wouldn't but this isn't normal surely!

Other than this issue, I'm very happy, no PND, we are a happy family, all is going well, and I generally love motherhood and have a very high threshold for the ups and downs of a mum's life. I normally take everything in my stride but this is driving me so crazy that I asked my husband to take my son out with the baby for a walk as I seriously need some space.

Any advice!

OP posts:
Topgub · 13/11/2022 13:24

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 13:16

The reason is literally because I didn't know if it was unfair for me to make him stop. As some of the responses on this situation are clearly so divided, its hard to know whether I am the problem or my son actually is doing something wrong. If I was more sure of where I stand I would enforce it, whether putting limits on myself or my son (or both)

His behaviour is distressing you. You dont want him to do it.

You dont need any more reason than that or to over think it

It doesn't really matter what the behaviour is. You've repeatedly asked him to stop doing something and he is ignoring you.

What will you do when your dd becomes distressed by it? Keep letting him away with it anyway?

Doingmybest12 · 13/11/2022 13:23

If he is hurting your baby and doing things you've asked him not to he is doing something wrong. That doesn't mean there isn't a reason for that that you can work with and channel more appropriately or that you don't need to look if your responses aren't helping.

Branleuse · 13/11/2022 13:21

Have you tried ignoring the kissing or not reacting to it, but giving lots of positive attention when he interacts without kissing (but not mentioning anything about kissing).
Might take a while. If he kisses her, just ignore it and ignore him.
Its going to be a self limiting problem. Hes still really little himself, despite probably seeming really big to you, and little kids do do weird stuff.

Thelnebriati · 13/11/2022 13:20

Can you redirect his behaviour? Get him to make a card for the baby, give him a teddy to kiss?

smooththecat · 13/11/2022 13:20

He’s being aggressive and concealing it with a usually sweet and socially acceptable act. He needs to learn that it’s still aggression and unacceptable. He’s old enough to understand this kind of manipulation.

Brigante9 · 13/11/2022 13:20

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 11:27

Thanks everyone for being so kind. I was expecting a bit of a lashing and I feel guilty for even saying these things about my lovely boy.

I like the idea of redirecting the kissing to a stroke and I agree that something primal seems to happen to me which is related to breastfeeding.

I really am a very, very affectionate person myself. I snuggle my son constantly. I tell him I love him several times a day and factor in very frequent mum and son times, where we snuggle and watch his favourite show, go through his Pokemon book, play games together and justbthe other night I lay beside him and stroked his back as he went to sleep and told him all the things I love about him over and over. Me and my husband make a big, big effort with all our kids to know how special they are and how much we adore them. We have a secret handhold where I squeeze 3 times as code for 'I love you' and we do that all the time. We write him notes telling him how much we love him. I honestly cannot think of any other ways that I can make him feel seen, loved and heard. And the evidence really is in his nature. Everyone comments on what a happy, loving child he is.

Thanks again for listening everyone, I felt a bit cra,y when I wrote this!

That sounds very over the top, telling him over and over why you love him. I can see why he’s doing the attention seeking kissing, he is directing your attention away from the baby with his actions. Notes telling him you love him? You’re modelling for him that you constantly tell/show him how much you love him. He’s reflecting your behaviour.

I would stop him doing the constant kissing, it’s probably thoroughly annoying the baby, especially if he’s yanking her as you go to pick her up, that’s dangerous. He’s 7, he is old enough to be told never to pull her and to stop the endless kissing. I’m amazed you haven’t snapped yet, you must have endless patience!

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 13:16

The reason is literally because I didn't know if it was unfair for me to make him stop. As some of the responses on this situation are clearly so divided, its hard to know whether I am the problem or my son actually is doing something wrong. If I was more sure of where I stand I would enforce it, whether putting limits on myself or my son (or both)

OP posts:
Topgub · 13/11/2022 13:12

Is there a reason why you haven't disciplined your son for repeatedly ignoring you and for not respecting your dds personal space?

Secretusername3 · 13/11/2022 13:10

Give him a time that he can do it, such as evenings and some restrictions, he’s old enough to handle that. But also reconnect with him, if it’s driving you crazy it sounds like you have disconnected with him somewhat. Its’ natural as you are busy with the baby, but it’s very common to feel insecure as an older sibling with the shock of a new baby - can you treat him, make him feel good and special?

Ohyeahbabe · 13/11/2022 13:06

Your son sounds lovely but I can understand why it can be annoying!

The breastfeeding hormone prolactin can apparently cause maternal aggression, so this could also be a factor??

MissMaple82 · 13/11/2022 13:01

I'm with your husband!! Non of what your saying sounds normal. Poor lad just wants to love his sister

Janbohonut · 13/11/2022 12:54

I remember when breastfeeding newborn my other child would deliberately fly his plane very close to his head and in my face - the older child knows this is a moment they have quite a lot of power and they will use it!

He seems to have latched onto kissing as a way of making some noise and getting attention. Not sure what the answer is, except to give it minimal attention, just explain to him calmly to give her some space. And give him extra attention, one on one at other times. It would drive me mad too.

aSofaNearYou · 13/11/2022 12:45

I totally get where you're coming from. This sounds like a more constant and extreme version of what my four year old DD is like with DD2 (7 weeks).

You're burnt out, it's stressful when another child casually wakes your baby as they (naturally) have no real concept of how hard it was to settle them and how much you needed that rest, and actually it's frustrating that they're not listening to you. That winds me up and my DD is only 4, it would definitely annoy me from a 7 year old.

It's a difficult balance to strike as you don't want to spoil their growing bond, but I don't think how you're feeling is unnatural.

I think you perhaps need to try and stress that he needs to listen to you about things like not grabbing her when you're standing etc, whilst heaping lots of praise on for how much he loves his little sister generally. This is what I do with my DD.

ShellyBelley · 13/11/2022 12:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

nobird · 13/11/2022 12:36

Sorry to have not RTFT and if this is repetition, but it sounds like if sensory stuff like this is grating on you you might have a touch of PND or just be exhausted and overwhelmed. It sounds like you’re trying your best to just tolerate it even though it bugs you. It may be a phase that passes soon. In the meantime could you find something to distract your son from the slurpy lipsmacking kisses? Get him to show his love in other ways?

I have you say though that you all sound like a very affectionate family, which is lovely.

Doingmybest12 · 13/11/2022 12:30

I would absolutely mention the safety aspect to him . Affection is lovely, hurting your sibling , leaving saliva over them and interrupting feeding is not. He is understandably struggling with the change in his life and jealous and he might need help identifying that this is what he is doing and why.

NCFT0922 · 13/11/2022 12:30

Op, you sound a lovely mum ❤️

Mumoffairy · 13/11/2022 12:29

My son used to smack the baby. And later when she started to walk he would push her over all the time..
So i think your problem seems like no problem at all 🤷🏻‍♀️

He will eventually stop it. My DS did too. They are best friends now and have been since DD turned 2. I think when baby is a bit bigger and your DS can play with her, he will do less kissing. Maybe show him some ways he can interact with her. Read her a book etc.

OneFrenchEgg · 13/11/2022 12:26

I think this is the key to it all. You express your love to your son in what I would consider quite an overwhelming/overbearing way. He is copying what you've modelled to him, in how he shows love to his sister.

Yes - I wonder if he is trying to model to you how much he loves the new baby (you've mentioned an anxious tic in the past) because he thinks it's important to you. Can you be very clear on no kissing when she's crawling or feeding and also give him helpful stuff to do - help prep her meals, help with running a bath, things you can do together for the baby?

FictionalCharacter · 13/11/2022 12:26

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 12:10

@reachforthebloodymary yes the noise drives me crazy. The quieter kisses that leave pool's of saliva don't drive me as crazy but aren't pleasant. It's definitely the noise.

He’s seven though- old enough to know that you don’t kiss someone with an open mouth and leave saliva on their face. He isn’t a two year old. Surely he doesn’t kiss his dad or grandparents like this? If he keeps doing it she’ll soon get annoyed by it when she’s a bit older. He’s old enough to know that pulling a baby’s hand up while she’s crawling isn’t right either.
Sorry but this doesn’t sound like genuine affection from him. It sounds more like performative “affection” and a way to push your buttons.

SunshineLoving · 13/11/2022 12:25

I understand OP. Sometimes certain sounds annoy me and whenever you hear it, it's really frustrating. For example, I hate hearing people whistle.

I don't think you're being mean. Tbh it does seem a bit strange to me for your son to want to kiss his sister this much. I think either he's just very affectionate or he is trying to get the attention. It's a way of making himself known maybe.

I would definitely try and increase the one on one time that your son has both with you and his dad. Maybe your son is craving something more.

reachforthebloodymary · 13/11/2022 12:25

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 12:10

@reachforthebloodymary yes the noise drives me crazy. The quieter kisses that leave pool's of saliva don't drive me as crazy but aren't pleasant. It's definitely the noise.

I did some googling at the time and misaphonia seemed to fit better than most, so it might be worth having a google. But it did calm down in the end, so that bit never fitted, I do remember thinking if the hormones made my hearing better

SquirrelFan · 13/11/2022 12:24

What @Sceptre86 said about older children really rings a bell - they do start annoying you more when you have a baby - not because their behaviour has necessarily changed, but because you you perceive them differently - which is perfectly natural! I think you're on the right track with ignore /limit /redirect. Also you sound like a great parent!

thepurplewhisperer · 13/11/2022 12:22

I would keep an eye on the safety aspect of what you've described. But not make mention, or comment to your 7 year old. Ignore the behaviour when he does it. No verbal response at all.

If it is attention seeking, and it may well be a form of this, it will die back when he's not getting the reward he's subconsciously seeking.

There will be a few small bumps along the way. But he's not setting out to hurt her.

Easier to ignore and reevaluate in a month.

Shandyinthejarro · 13/11/2022 12:19

OK thank you everyone for your input. I got a lot of responses, some very different and I'm going to go off for a while and try to think of a balance of all of the suggestions, going forward.

For the record, I mist definitely did not smack my son. I intercepted his hand as he went to take the baby's for the tenth time in a row. Where I come from, that could be considered 'batting away but maybe that's a colloquial saying that others might misconstrue as me actually hitting my child, which I actually oppose and never do.

Thanks everyone for all of your views and for the kindness most of you showed me.__

OP posts: