Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ban my bullying sister from seeing my kids?

341 replies

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 10:34

I’ve got 2 teenagers just a year apart, a DS15 with ASD and DD14 with anxiety and depression. Both are school refusers, I am trying my best and working with relevant authorities. DD often spends all day in bed (DS wakes up but will play video games) and I have to WFH but I make sure they come out at least once a day. As soon as I finish work at 2pm (I start early) both DC will come on a long dog walk at a country park and we’ll go to a cafe for cake/coffee afterwards.

My sister has a holier than thou attitude and is always giving me shit about my kids. Her adult DD and DS are ‘perfect’, both went to top RG uni’s, never had any kind of issue and now both live abroad with great jobs and she is constantly comparing them to my DC.

On Friday, I had to call in sick due to a cold. Around 1pm whilst feeling like shit, with DC still in bed, I get a text from Dsis announcing she was 2 minutes away. She does this often, I was fuming as house was a tip. When she arrived I told her I wasn’t well, and she just sort of pushed passed me and said “Oh well I’ll make you a cup of tea!!!!!”. She set off my 2 Alsatians who were barking for England and I had to settle them.

Then, as expected, the arsey comments about my kids started. “Little madam is in bed I take it? My daughter was always up by 6 on a weekend for her part-time job!” “What’s he doing? For goodness sake, you need to get him a proper hobby. He’ll wither away, no wonder he’s skin and bones!”. Her DH has ‘aspergers’ (yes I know it’s not called that but that’s the term she uses) and she thinks she’s the autism expert because of it, and implies my DS in non-verbal due to my failings. DS wears headphones when out for sensory reasons and once in a coffee shop she tried to bully him into removing them saying it was rude. Her husband who has a great job in finance is a completely different kettle of fish to my son FFS.

Her kids always had a very regimented routine, both with a long list of chores and several hobbies each, they never had ‘chill’ time. This is simply impossible for my kids due to their additional needs, they would not cope with me forcing things on them. As I say, we’ve come up with our own plans with authorities. DS is getting a grant so I can take him to places for enrichment (and is also slowing building a relationship with a key worker who will take him out) and DD may potentially be able to start a college course early at 15 at a small local animal care college, which is an environment I think she’ll thrive in as the rough, large local comp nearly killed her (horrific bullying). So it’s not like I’ve got nothing in place for them.

She just went on and on. Bla bla bla fucking bla. My kids cannot stand her as she always makes them uncomfortable, goes into DD’s room whilst she’s sleeping and lectures her. Dsis works part-time so is here a lot. Last Monday it was just before DD was going into the shower to get ready (and she was doing well that day, up at 12pm and expressing an interest in doing some baking), Dsis arrived, went up to her room and went on for half an hour about how DD should be up and ready before noon. DD was in tears afterwards and went back to bed for the rest of the day, it set her back.

Anyway, back to Friday, she gave me my drink then took herself upstairs. I could hear her. She tried to talk to non-verbal DS so I went up, and as usual, she looked shocked and appalled when he blanked her. She went into DD’s room with DD fast asleep started loudly clapping her hands (As usual. It’s also a huge sensory trigger for DS and in the midst of everything I heard him slamming his bedroom door repeatedly) shouting “Right you! Up now! You can’t live like this!!!! Your poor mum is ill and you need to pull your weight!!!! Come and make her some soup!!!”. In the end it was humiliating for DD as she had slept just in bottom underwear (her thermostat is broken and her room is boiling) so when Dsis pulled her duvet off she was exposed. DD then started crying and begging me to intervene. This is notable behaviour for DD as she usually doesn’t break down until Dsis leaves (Dsis is a huge anxiety trigger for her) but this time she started crying and having a panic attack in front of Dsis, DD finally ‘snapped’.

I lost my shit, this has been happening consistently for years and I was done. I grabbed her arm, pulled her into the hallway, told her she was a fucking disgrace for bullying my vulnerable kids and basically said “Fuck off and don’t ever talk to me again.” She continued lecturing me about my parenting so I threatened to call the police to get rid of her then she sheepishly left. I then sent her a message saying if she turns up again, she’s not being let in, and forceful attempts WILL result in me calling the police as I feel I have to safeguard my children from her. I also sent a text to my parents to inform them I am done with her. My parents are angry with me but I can’t have her around my kids anymore.

OP posts:
ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 15:09

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 14:59

My DS doesn’t have a concept of ‘easy or hard’ or boundaries.

OP i know you're getting some support here but maybe you should leave the thread or start another one in the SEN section. The amount of ignorant and vicious posters ,changing the narrative, blaming you and setting up unrealistic goal posts for your children,while reminding you constantly what they'll never be able to do (particularly you DS) can't be good for your own mental health.

Some cake for you too, and a big hug.(screw it)

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 15:06

ChristmasisRuined I won’t be facing fucking fines because the council know and are supporting me. Don’t attempt to lecture me on something you don’t know about

OP posts:
ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 15:05

mashh · 13/11/2022 15:01

Honestly the life your kids have now is setting them up for failure in the future. Your sister does not sound kind either. But it's a shit situation for them and I would be concerned for the children in your sister's position

A severely disabled autistic child is never going to become a paragon of success is he? Probably the hardest thing OP had to get her head around and eventually accept. No amount of teaching or effort on OP's part will make his brain function in an age related way if it isn't wired that way.

ChristmasisRuined · 13/11/2022 15:03

They're BOTH refusing to go to school and you're allowing them to sleep all day and rewarding them with cake everyday? I'm sorry but whilst your sister has been rude in how she's said things, she's absolutely not wrong. You'll be facing massive fines if you're not careful

Jedsnewstar · 13/11/2022 15:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This. The scenario that you have allowed to happen is literally a teenagers dream. School refusers should be home educated using the vast resources available not be allowed to sleep half the day away and then play video games all day, before being rewarded with cake and coke.

mashh · 13/11/2022 15:01

Honestly the life your kids have now is setting them up for failure in the future. Your sister does not sound kind either. But it's a shit situation for them and I would be concerned for the children in your sister's position

Onlyforcake · 13/11/2022 15:00

And absolutely. Your sister is a disgrace waltzing into a house uninvited and invading the personal space of children, including whisking of blankets she's either abusive (maybe that's why her kids left the country) or dumb as fuck. Either way, definitely don't open the door to her again.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 13/11/2022 15:00

@User135792468 - reading the OP’s posts, I don’t think she is doing nothing to help her kids. It sounds as if it is not going to be a quick process, but if that is what these children need, there’s nothing wrong with it.

It may not look like big improvements, but it is relative, and the progress may well be good for the OP’s children, and that is all that matters. Her sister is measuring the OP’s children against hers, and is judging them harshly as a result, when it would be better is she looked for the little steps forward they are making, and applauded them for it.

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 14:59

My DS doesn’t have a concept of ‘easy or hard’ or boundaries.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 13/11/2022 14:58

I am a mother of school refusing DC on the spectrum and I think you're making things far to easy for them.

If they're not going school so they're not playing video games.

How will they function as adults.

If anything they need stricter boundaries than the average teenager.

Onlyforcake · 13/11/2022 14:57

Wow. Some judgy mners. There is NO magic support for families dealing with children with ASD. What support do you actually think there is?

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 14:56

Ex doesn’t give a shit. He openly admitted he finds DS ‘unloveable’. He also couldn’t be arsed with DD. 5 years ago when me and DD saw him in public (after a lack of communication from him) he had the nerve to tell my 9yo DD “The phone works both ways” and we haven’t seen him since.

OP posts:
LaGioconda · 13/11/2022 14:54

It's not generally called school refusal nowadays, it's called emotionally based school avoidance. It might be helpful to use that term because it's a much more accurate description of what is going on with your children.

potter5 · 13/11/2022 14:53

Well done! You did the right thing to protect your kids. Your sister needs telling to back off.

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 14:51

@ldontWanna.

Thank you! I can’t believe what people are expecting of my son. 2 minutes with him and they’d know how ridiculous they sound expecting him to attend school and even get a job. I let him play children games and the Animal Crossing games on his computer because it keeps him settled and prevents outbursts and screeching. Then my sister triggers outbursts during visits. He doesn’t benefit from school, it is unnecessary stress for all of us and he was having toiletry accidents at school from the stress of it.

OP posts:
ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 14:50

If they lose, they lose, but at least they went down fighting.

And if that means death? Just collateral damage? Great comfort to the bereaved parents, "at least they went down fighting ".

Fuck me.

Nimo12 · 13/11/2022 14:50

This 100%

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 14:49

@JoonT how the fuck do you fight /educate yourself from your brain working at the capacity of a 5 yo child?

Or being non verbal because once again your brain is lacking the capacity for speech?

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 14:45

On the sleep thing.

At my worst that particular period of depression and anxiety was caused by a deeply (for me,other people might think it was ridiculous) traumatic event. I relieved that moment(and various scenarios of the aftermath) several times a night through very vivid dreams. When I woke I was right back in that place,with those feelings,the panic. It took ages to come back from it and fall asleep again. It was fucking pointless and I was exhausted. It made my anxiety even worse because I knew they were coming. Oh I got the tough love you must be in school,you must be awake,you can't laze about bullshit. All this did was add even more to my anxiety/depression and only ended up with me so exhausted I was unable to function. How much learning,socialising and healing do you think took place when walking was difficult, standing upright was difficult, motor skills were difficult, even talking was so difficult I developed a stutter? I was barely eating. Walks,chores,routines,being awake ,doing x,y,z was physically painful and exhausting.I self harmed in various ways ,took overdoses and had carious suicidal ideations. Luckily I was too exhausted to implement the ones that would've been successful.

Things only started to get better when I was actually allowed to sleep, yes even until 1 pm. It removed some of the pressure and anxiety around sleeping and the nightmares. I got enough rest that simple functioning was possible and I saw every single thing I was able to do as an achievement and a positive rather than yet another failure. I was functioning and aware enough that I could learn good coping mechanisms and actually put them in place. I could access and engage with the help on offer.It was a long slog but I came out of it and I'm a fully functional adult now with a job,a family,a home. Not particularly successful or a high flyer,but I'm doing ok.If I'd kept doing the awake for the sake of being awake thing so many posters seem to be fond of,I'd be dead.

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 14:44

@GreenFingersWouldBeHandy

This is the most ridiculous thing I have ever read, I was full of a cold on Friday with the shivers so left the houswork for a day. What, shall I just teach myself how to fix my own central heating? The council are on it but taking a while, I can’t fucking afford to have it done privately. And no, my non-verbal son who has never uttered a word in his life and communicates through clapping and screeching isn’t ever going to be independent so get over it, I had to.

Also, she’s 15 for fucks sake and it’s a special course for kids who’ve had mental health problems where they learn an English and Maths qualification at their own place and then do animal care. Lectures? Jesus christ, there won’t be lectures. I’d hate to live in your simple, black and white world where everybody has to be a robot.

OP posts:
JoonT · 13/11/2022 14:43

Realistnotpessimist · 13/11/2022 10:39

She's not gone about it in the right way but she's absolutely right that the kids can't live like that.

I kind of agree. I am completely against bullying, but we have swung too far in the other direction. If you are too soft and soppy with people (not just children, but anyone who is struggling), it can backfire. Sometimes, people need kind, gentle but firm guidance. They need to be told to put their chin up and face the world (in a gentle and compassionate way, let me stress). If they lose, they lose, but at least they went down fighting. We are moving to a society in which everyone is a victim, and in which people seem almost proud to be weak or ill or anxious. They shouldn’t be. And we shouldn’t teach the young to look for excuses, or to exaggerate and focus on their weaknesses. Instead, we should be teaching them to fight their handicaps and to be proud of doing so. No matter what your problems, there is usually something you can do. And fiercely proud, determined people can achieve miracles. They learn to walk again when the doctors told them it was impossible, or they write a great novel after their teachers told them they were talentless, or whatever.

I’m not naive. I know that some kids have a massive advantage. A handsome, clever, insensitive extrovert has a massive head start in life. An anxious, introverted, socially awkward child (like me) is at a disadvantage. But life isn’t fair. Telling the weaker child that he’s a victim, and allowing him to hide under the duvet, seems kind. In reality, it’s cruel. Life is a challenge. And you can either face it or hide away. I would never say to a child “you’ve got to win,” but I would say “you’ve got to try.” Forget competing with others. I’m not talking about keeping up with the Joneses. I’m simply talking about how you approach life. Do you fight or do you wallow? Do you focus on your weaknesses or strengths?

Luellie · 13/11/2022 14:37

I'm honestly shocked by how nasty, smug, and ignorant a lot of the responses on here are. Maybe I shouldn't be.

YANBU OP, your sister is awful

User135792468 · 13/11/2022 14:35

You are failing your children by allowing them to live like this. I don’t mean, forcing them back to school but not doing anything at all is not good for them. I’m not surprised your sister is frustrated with you.

custardbear · 13/11/2022 14:31

@NotMyFinestMoment - very apt name!

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 14:31

@UnshakenNeedsStirring I don't know.

What future do you think a non verbal, autistic kid with other significant needs is going to have?

What could OP actually do to make him into a fully functioning member of society, with a job and everything else?

Swipe left for the next trending thread