Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ban my bullying sister from seeing my kids?

341 replies

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 10:34

I’ve got 2 teenagers just a year apart, a DS15 with ASD and DD14 with anxiety and depression. Both are school refusers, I am trying my best and working with relevant authorities. DD often spends all day in bed (DS wakes up but will play video games) and I have to WFH but I make sure they come out at least once a day. As soon as I finish work at 2pm (I start early) both DC will come on a long dog walk at a country park and we’ll go to a cafe for cake/coffee afterwards.

My sister has a holier than thou attitude and is always giving me shit about my kids. Her adult DD and DS are ‘perfect’, both went to top RG uni’s, never had any kind of issue and now both live abroad with great jobs and she is constantly comparing them to my DC.

On Friday, I had to call in sick due to a cold. Around 1pm whilst feeling like shit, with DC still in bed, I get a text from Dsis announcing she was 2 minutes away. She does this often, I was fuming as house was a tip. When she arrived I told her I wasn’t well, and she just sort of pushed passed me and said “Oh well I’ll make you a cup of tea!!!!!”. She set off my 2 Alsatians who were barking for England and I had to settle them.

Then, as expected, the arsey comments about my kids started. “Little madam is in bed I take it? My daughter was always up by 6 on a weekend for her part-time job!” “What’s he doing? For goodness sake, you need to get him a proper hobby. He’ll wither away, no wonder he’s skin and bones!”. Her DH has ‘aspergers’ (yes I know it’s not called that but that’s the term she uses) and she thinks she’s the autism expert because of it, and implies my DS in non-verbal due to my failings. DS wears headphones when out for sensory reasons and once in a coffee shop she tried to bully him into removing them saying it was rude. Her husband who has a great job in finance is a completely different kettle of fish to my son FFS.

Her kids always had a very regimented routine, both with a long list of chores and several hobbies each, they never had ‘chill’ time. This is simply impossible for my kids due to their additional needs, they would not cope with me forcing things on them. As I say, we’ve come up with our own plans with authorities. DS is getting a grant so I can take him to places for enrichment (and is also slowing building a relationship with a key worker who will take him out) and DD may potentially be able to start a college course early at 15 at a small local animal care college, which is an environment I think she’ll thrive in as the rough, large local comp nearly killed her (horrific bullying). So it’s not like I’ve got nothing in place for them.

She just went on and on. Bla bla bla fucking bla. My kids cannot stand her as she always makes them uncomfortable, goes into DD’s room whilst she’s sleeping and lectures her. Dsis works part-time so is here a lot. Last Monday it was just before DD was going into the shower to get ready (and she was doing well that day, up at 12pm and expressing an interest in doing some baking), Dsis arrived, went up to her room and went on for half an hour about how DD should be up and ready before noon. DD was in tears afterwards and went back to bed for the rest of the day, it set her back.

Anyway, back to Friday, she gave me my drink then took herself upstairs. I could hear her. She tried to talk to non-verbal DS so I went up, and as usual, she looked shocked and appalled when he blanked her. She went into DD’s room with DD fast asleep started loudly clapping her hands (As usual. It’s also a huge sensory trigger for DS and in the midst of everything I heard him slamming his bedroom door repeatedly) shouting “Right you! Up now! You can’t live like this!!!! Your poor mum is ill and you need to pull your weight!!!! Come and make her some soup!!!”. In the end it was humiliating for DD as she had slept just in bottom underwear (her thermostat is broken and her room is boiling) so when Dsis pulled her duvet off she was exposed. DD then started crying and begging me to intervene. This is notable behaviour for DD as she usually doesn’t break down until Dsis leaves (Dsis is a huge anxiety trigger for her) but this time she started crying and having a panic attack in front of Dsis, DD finally ‘snapped’.

I lost my shit, this has been happening consistently for years and I was done. I grabbed her arm, pulled her into the hallway, told her she was a fucking disgrace for bullying my vulnerable kids and basically said “Fuck off and don’t ever talk to me again.” She continued lecturing me about my parenting so I threatened to call the police to get rid of her then she sheepishly left. I then sent her a message saying if she turns up again, she’s not being let in, and forceful attempts WILL result in me calling the police as I feel I have to safeguard my children from her. I also sent a text to my parents to inform them I am done with her. My parents are angry with me but I can’t have her around my kids anymore.

OP posts:
ChristmasisRuined · 13/11/2022 18:32

@JennyNotFromTheBlock But what about before next year? There are other options besides school and hanging around in bed all day.
In our area at least (unsure if area dependant) the county council will provide a tutor to come to the house provided there is an adult over 18 in the house at all times - OP says she works from home. They don't need to be in the room, just present in the house. There are also referral units the teens can attend on more flexible schedule than that of school. As they're teens, they could be doing some work themselves, provided by school....

Thereisnolight · 13/11/2022 18:31

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 13/11/2022 18:26

As the OP has already said, she has applied for help and will be getting that next year.

But what’s being done this year? Nothing at all by the sounds of it. Not even basic home education or basic home cleaning.

Thatsnotmycar · 13/11/2022 18:30

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 13/11/2022 18:12

YANBU I would never allow her to darken your daughter ever again, what a vile, entitled bullying bitch she is! How dare she!

Btw, as someone who has Aspergers, just politely, you are wrong, the term is still used and in very wide medical and societal usage; many of us "Aspies" (as we call ourselves), prefer Aspie or Aspergers to Autistic or ASD, because to us High Functioning Autists, Autism has connotations of non-verbal, severely disabled etc. Where as Aspergers means High Functioning, so there is a difference between Aspergers and severe Autism, and we prefer the distinction known. We feel more comfortable with the term Aspergers. Just so you know.

You can’t speak for all. Functioning labels are harmful, the spectrum isn’t a linear continuum from mild to severe. ‘High functioning’ autism doesn’t mean it isn’t severe and is mild, and doesn’t mean the person isn’t non-verbal. All high functioning means is someone’s IQ is above 70. There’s also a difference between what used to be diagnosed as AS (which isn’t diagnosed anymore) and HFA.

ChristmasisRuined · 13/11/2022 18:28

Noonesperfect · 13/11/2022 17:52

unless you have an autistic child you haven’t got a b***y clue. This sister is in no way supportive she just makes Op’s life even harder. Austism is a disability and very hard for both the children and the parents. If the sister doesn’t go by Ops rules and treat her and her kids with respect she shouldn’t be allowed in. You mums slagging off Op do not realise how incredibly hard and isolating being an autistic parent can be, and the constant judging from family, and even professionals is sole destroying. I’m totally in your corner OP. We have to care for our kids because we know them best, and very few other people care. They just want to force them to be like NT’s and they’re not!

I DO have an Autistic child and as per my post above, I disagree that OP is handling this correctly. As I said in my previous post, children with Autism/any other Neurodivergence still need guidance etc. Just shrugging your shoulders and allowing them to do nothing and then reaffirm this allowance by rewarding them with cake every day, is simply making matters worse. I don't however agree with how the sister has said all this of course

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 13/11/2022 18:26

ChristmasisRuined · 13/11/2022 18:24

@JennyNotFromTheBlock I too have a neurodivergent child and I can tell you it's not an excuse to allow them to do nothing! They still need guidance, support and direction. They are children, not adults. Allowing them to do nothing on a long term basis, is not good for their mental health which is already fragile. Tbh my DD actually needs extra guidance, emotional support & direction

As the OP has already said, she has applied for help and will be getting that next year.

ChristmasisRuined · 13/11/2022 18:24

@JennyNotFromTheBlock I too have a neurodivergent child and I can tell you it's not an excuse to allow them to do nothing! They still need guidance, support and direction. They are children, not adults. Allowing them to do nothing on a long term basis, is not good for their mental health which is already fragile. Tbh my DD actually needs extra guidance, emotional support & direction

Tigertigertigertiger · 13/11/2022 18:20

So anyone whose children live abroad have done so to escape overbearing parents ?

what bollocks

krustykittens · 13/11/2022 18:19

You are not being unreasonable, OP. She might have good intentions but she is making your life a lot harder and you and your DC don't need that. Everyone who has kids who didn't have severe problems is a fucking expert on parenting. I pretty much thought I had it sussed with my eldest - with my youngest and her personality disorder, not a fucking clue! I hope things get better for you DD soon.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 13/11/2022 18:16

WilsonMilson · 13/11/2022 18:10

You’re targeting your energy at the wrong person. Your sister went about this badly, but what the hell is going on with your kids?
No wonder your daughter is depressed and anxious if she’s allowed to wither away in bed all day and not go to school. DS allowed to play video games all day? Where’s the parenting?

I’m afraid that you need to wake up and see that something is seriously amiss at home if these issues have arisen and address that first. Who cares about your sister, you need to sort your kids out!

Could you possibly be more uneducated, ignorant and disablist!?

How dare you! This is not 'bad parenting', the children have disabilities! You should be ashamed of your ignorance.

shiningstar2 · 13/11/2022 18:16

Once kids get to a certain age and size it's impossible to physically make them get up and out. Mental Health and other issues are real and parents can be at their wits end trying to find solutions.
If things are in place for January that is a good start op. I wonder if you could my I've the long walk a half hour earlier. Have some reason/ excuse so it doesn't seem to them a sudden arbitrary change. If you could get that established you could then maybe move it another half hour forward. I would leave the 'reward' coffee and cake in place. Sometimes struggling teens need a motivator and it's a good time to talk. You could maybe incorporate an afternoon at the gym eventually. Do they need/like own spending money Op? If so using it as a carrot for small steps forward can work ...until hopefully gradual new routines are made You do need to keep your sister away from them. However motivated she is to help her intervention is clearly doing the opposite. Try to keep her away without falling out with her or your parents though. You don't need the extra stress.💐

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 13/11/2022 18:13

#darken your door that should be, not daughter.

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 18:13

WilsonMilson · 13/11/2022 18:10

You’re targeting your energy at the wrong person. Your sister went about this badly, but what the hell is going on with your kids?
No wonder your daughter is depressed and anxious if she’s allowed to wither away in bed all day and not go to school. DS allowed to play video games all day? Where’s the parenting?

I’m afraid that you need to wake up and see that something is seriously amiss at home if these issues have arisen and address that first. Who cares about your sister, you need to sort your kids out!

Have you even bothered to read all OP's posts?

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 13/11/2022 18:12

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 10:34

I’ve got 2 teenagers just a year apart, a DS15 with ASD and DD14 with anxiety and depression. Both are school refusers, I am trying my best and working with relevant authorities. DD often spends all day in bed (DS wakes up but will play video games) and I have to WFH but I make sure they come out at least once a day. As soon as I finish work at 2pm (I start early) both DC will come on a long dog walk at a country park and we’ll go to a cafe for cake/coffee afterwards.

My sister has a holier than thou attitude and is always giving me shit about my kids. Her adult DD and DS are ‘perfect’, both went to top RG uni’s, never had any kind of issue and now both live abroad with great jobs and she is constantly comparing them to my DC.

On Friday, I had to call in sick due to a cold. Around 1pm whilst feeling like shit, with DC still in bed, I get a text from Dsis announcing she was 2 minutes away. She does this often, I was fuming as house was a tip. When she arrived I told her I wasn’t well, and she just sort of pushed passed me and said “Oh well I’ll make you a cup of tea!!!!!”. She set off my 2 Alsatians who were barking for England and I had to settle them.

Then, as expected, the arsey comments about my kids started. “Little madam is in bed I take it? My daughter was always up by 6 on a weekend for her part-time job!” “What’s he doing? For goodness sake, you need to get him a proper hobby. He’ll wither away, no wonder he’s skin and bones!”. Her DH has ‘aspergers’ (yes I know it’s not called that but that’s the term she uses) and she thinks she’s the autism expert because of it, and implies my DS in non-verbal due to my failings. DS wears headphones when out for sensory reasons and once in a coffee shop she tried to bully him into removing them saying it was rude. Her husband who has a great job in finance is a completely different kettle of fish to my son FFS.

Her kids always had a very regimented routine, both with a long list of chores and several hobbies each, they never had ‘chill’ time. This is simply impossible for my kids due to their additional needs, they would not cope with me forcing things on them. As I say, we’ve come up with our own plans with authorities. DS is getting a grant so I can take him to places for enrichment (and is also slowing building a relationship with a key worker who will take him out) and DD may potentially be able to start a college course early at 15 at a small local animal care college, which is an environment I think she’ll thrive in as the rough, large local comp nearly killed her (horrific bullying). So it’s not like I’ve got nothing in place for them.

She just went on and on. Bla bla bla fucking bla. My kids cannot stand her as she always makes them uncomfortable, goes into DD’s room whilst she’s sleeping and lectures her. Dsis works part-time so is here a lot. Last Monday it was just before DD was going into the shower to get ready (and she was doing well that day, up at 12pm and expressing an interest in doing some baking), Dsis arrived, went up to her room and went on for half an hour about how DD should be up and ready before noon. DD was in tears afterwards and went back to bed for the rest of the day, it set her back.

Anyway, back to Friday, she gave me my drink then took herself upstairs. I could hear her. She tried to talk to non-verbal DS so I went up, and as usual, she looked shocked and appalled when he blanked her. She went into DD’s room with DD fast asleep started loudly clapping her hands (As usual. It’s also a huge sensory trigger for DS and in the midst of everything I heard him slamming his bedroom door repeatedly) shouting “Right you! Up now! You can’t live like this!!!! Your poor mum is ill and you need to pull your weight!!!! Come and make her some soup!!!”. In the end it was humiliating for DD as she had slept just in bottom underwear (her thermostat is broken and her room is boiling) so when Dsis pulled her duvet off she was exposed. DD then started crying and begging me to intervene. This is notable behaviour for DD as she usually doesn’t break down until Dsis leaves (Dsis is a huge anxiety trigger for her) but this time she started crying and having a panic attack in front of Dsis, DD finally ‘snapped’.

I lost my shit, this has been happening consistently for years and I was done. I grabbed her arm, pulled her into the hallway, told her she was a fucking disgrace for bullying my vulnerable kids and basically said “Fuck off and don’t ever talk to me again.” She continued lecturing me about my parenting so I threatened to call the police to get rid of her then she sheepishly left. I then sent her a message saying if she turns up again, she’s not being let in, and forceful attempts WILL result in me calling the police as I feel I have to safeguard my children from her. I also sent a text to my parents to inform them I am done with her. My parents are angry with me but I can’t have her around my kids anymore.

YANBU I would never allow her to darken your daughter ever again, what a vile, entitled bullying bitch she is! How dare she!

Btw, as someone who has Aspergers, just politely, you are wrong, the term is still used and in very wide medical and societal usage; many of us "Aspies" (as we call ourselves), prefer Aspie or Aspergers to Autistic or ASD, because to us High Functioning Autists, Autism has connotations of non-verbal, severely disabled etc. Where as Aspergers means High Functioning, so there is a difference between Aspergers and severe Autism, and we prefer the distinction known. We feel more comfortable with the term Aspergers. Just so you know.

WilsonMilson · 13/11/2022 18:10

You’re targeting your energy at the wrong person. Your sister went about this badly, but what the hell is going on with your kids?
No wonder your daughter is depressed and anxious if she’s allowed to wither away in bed all day and not go to school. DS allowed to play video games all day? Where’s the parenting?

I’m afraid that you need to wake up and see that something is seriously amiss at home if these issues have arisen and address that first. Who cares about your sister, you need to sort your kids out!

Daisychainsx · 13/11/2022 17:53

Your sister was a bit overbearing in what she did and obviously crossed a line, but I think she was coming from a good place.
It sounds like you've got a plan for your DS, which is good, but if your DD is suffering from poor mental health due to bullying I don't see how sleeping until 1pm is going to make her feel better.

Ive worked with teens with such severe asd that they were able to eat, point and tap their hands on a desk. They didn't like music, TV, games, anything. Just sitting alone and tapping was what they wanted to do for hours on end. So I totally understand, the mainstream idea of what you should be doing with your asd ds is not going to work. Keep doing what works for you and him.

I'm not there, don't know the situation or your kids, but based purely on what I've read I'd say DD should be being pushed to have more of a routine at home. Up early, shower, dressed, help making breakfast, help with chores, bit of free time, your usual walk, help cook dinner... fill the day with things that are enjoyable, ever so slightly challenging and therefore rewarding.

Loneliness and boredom feed depression, routine and responsibility might help and set her up for success at her college placement.

If need be why not go to the docs and sign off with stress for a while to get these routines set up and spend some time together? If anyone sounds like they deserve a break from work, it's you!

Noonesperfect · 13/11/2022 17:52

unless you have an autistic child you haven’t got a b***y clue. This sister is in no way supportive she just makes Op’s life even harder. Austism is a disability and very hard for both the children and the parents. If the sister doesn’t go by Ops rules and treat her and her kids with respect she shouldn’t be allowed in. You mums slagging off Op do not realise how incredibly hard and isolating being an autistic parent can be, and the constant judging from family, and even professionals is sole destroying. I’m totally in your corner OP. We have to care for our kids because we know them best, and very few other people care. They just want to force them to be like NT’s and they’re not!

pinheadlarry · 13/11/2022 17:51

My dd has autism so I get where you are coming from BUT I do think your sisters heart is in the right pace, she's definitely stepping on everyone's toes but still...

VillageCottageEmo · 13/11/2022 17:50

I’m not quite sure why you’ve allowed your sister to terrorise your disabled and mentally unwell children for this long tbh.

If any of my siblings did any of this even once to my ASD child or the one with MH issues, it would last all of however long it took me to fly upstairs and the bitches feet wouldn’t touch the floor.

In fact, I wouldn’t even tolerate any adult walking into my teenagers rooms without knocking and waiting for a response - even with out NDs/MH issues, it’s their private, personal space.

Panickstop · 13/11/2022 17:48

What a bitch!! I have two ASD children with very similar issues. You are 100% right to never let her hear your children again. I am SO angry for you. Your poor children. She has not got a fucking clue. Her arrogance is unbelievable.

You sound like a brilliant mum going through a very tough time. Your way is the right way though. I was where you were a year ago and we're slowly coming out the other side. Good luck Flowers

mam0918 · 13/11/2022 17:41

She was completely out of line in her behavior, No one should ever act like that in someone elses home.

But shes right about your DD refusing to go to school and sleeping all day... all teens WANT to do that if you let them, its not remotely unique or unusual we simply don't let them.

I have anxiety, depresion + complex brain disabilities and still got my ass dragged into school everyday even though I spent every other moment of the day and night in bed. Non of it mean't I got to just choose to opt out of life, responsability and the law though. Its the easy route to just let her stay in bed all day and it won't do her any favors, in fact it actually makes it harder as you fall deeper into withdrawl from the real world and struggle far worse to readjust when you HAVE too.

I know that because I spent a whole year in hospital and recovering at home for mobility issue (due to my disability) and I did exactly what you discribed your daughter is doing and it was horrific having to try and readjust to reality afterward.

Coatdegroan · 13/11/2022 17:37

Just wanted to say good luck with everything and I hope your kids are OK. I think a lot of people do not know the reality of having teenagers with SEN and mental health issues (usually stemming from inadequate provision and bullying in school).

I think the long walk and cake in the afternoon sounds really positive and will help them recover.

PS I don't have experience of kids with SEN but have a sister with autism who wasn't diagnosed till her 30s and know how very hard it can be to set expectations which would seem appropriate for people who aren't facing such huge challenges.

Also I'm a secondary maths teacher teaching resits and see just how little help there can be sadly

thingumybob · 13/11/2022 17:36

SweetPeaGirl · 13/11/2022 16:43

OP you're solo parenting two teens with SN and mental health issues, holding down a job, feeling ill, and contending with a sister who makes it all worse. Fucking hell.

Sending loads of love and support your way because it must be so, so hard.

It's so easy for people here to judge and say you should be doing this or that, but it's a whole other thing for this to be your daily reality, on your own, when the various 'services' are usually shit/take ages to help.

Absolutely this. We've been dealing with some serious health and ND issues in our house and I've lost count of the number of times I have said to DH I'm so glad I'm not doing it on my own!

OP anyone who has dealt with trying to get the right support for their children will know that the things that you will have had to work really hard to get to where you are with that. All while trying to hold down a job and keep a roof over your heads too. I have nothing but sympathy and admiration for how you are dealing with it all.

Facing up to the reality that your child's future is not going to be one where they can live independently is so hard. The last thing you need is idiots telling you that you just aren't trying hard enough. I worked with a non-verbal autistic child for 6 years. I was always so frustrated by how little understanding people had of what realistic expectations were for them.

You keep doing you and yes, keep your sister away. Exposing your DD like that by pulling the bedclothes off when she wasn't dressed is beyond shocking. She needs to know you will keep her safe from that kind of abuse.

mrstreacle · 13/11/2022 17:21

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 15:57

@Scottsy100

No one can be arsed? Hahahaaa. The fact that that’s your first assumption screams not only projection of your own personality, but a lack of basic understanding about ASD and anxiety.

Pontins Beach I understand and think you are an amazing mum. Ignore the people who think that ASD will fit neatly into tidy little boxes and stay with what you're doing. If I had to do half of what you're managing so well to do I'd be a complete wreck. You have my admiration but for heaven's sake don't ever let her in the house again

WhereYouLeftIt · 13/11/2022 17:18

To get back to your question @PontinsBeach, would you BU to ban your sister from seeing your kids. No. YANBU to protect your children from her overbearing and frankly abusive behaviour. As for your children, it sounds to me that they have real and substantial difficulties, and that you are handling these difficulties well, enlisting what appropriate help you can, and have a workable plan for your children's future. I'm honestly impressed.

So, let's talk about your sister and your parents.

Reading your OP, I was a bit gobsmacked that she would go up to the bedrooms at all. Or that you would put up with it. Entering someone else's bedroom (other than that of your own child) without being invited in - I'd struggle to do that. Thinking back to my own childhood, my aunts were in and out of our home all the time; and given it was a flat they actually walked past my bedroom door to reach the living room. But not once did they enter my room. Not once. And maybe that's why I find your sister's behaviour so - intrusive. So lacking in healthy boundaries.

And that got me thinking about how you said in your OP "I also sent a text to my parents to inform them I am done with her. My parents are angry with me". And about how she's been "taking herself upstairs" and into the private rooms (for years, I assume) and how "Dsis works part-time so is here a lot". And I am wondering about the whole dynamic of your family, where your sister rides roughshod over you without any apparent pushback from you (until today) and your parents are angry at you rather than upset with her because you've said 'no more'.

I guess I'm asking - do your parents treat your sister as The Golden Child, and you as The Scapegoat? Where she can do no wrong and you can do no right and get nothing but blame from all three of them? And that is why, despite knowing how wrong her behaviour was, you've put up with it? Not stopped her going to their bedrooms, not told her to STFU before, not stopped her from walking in? I'm not blaming you for not putting a stop to her until now. I'm raising the possibility that this is WHY you've been unable to challenge her before. And that this is your real problem, not your children's needs. Your sister (and your parents) are the problem to be addressed. And since this is a problem of long-standing - since your childhood - you're going to need to be kind to yourself and not become disheartened when your sister and parents continue to push themselves on you. It isn't going to be easy, standing fast against them. But, for your children's sake as well as your own sanity, you are going to have to draw a line and say 'NO MORE'. For starters - your sister doesn't get over the door ever again. She is not welcome in your home and is never to enter it again. Your home is your sanctuary. Your children's rooms are their sanctuary. She doesn't get into your sanctuary ever again. Ever. And if your parents are angry about that, tough shit, they can stay out as well. I think it would be very reassuring to your children to KNOW that she will never come in to their rooms again. And you won't have the dread of her turning up. Of course, she will try. Do not open the door to her. You'll feel like a fool the first few times, but do it anyway. Never let this bully into your home again. And yes, I would call the police on her if she didn't go away when asked.

MumOfOne55 · 13/11/2022 17:15

awaynboilyurheid · 13/11/2022 16:40

It could be you need to get your daughter “ college ready” though, and by that I mean not sleeping in till lunch time, having tasks and chores to do. also trying to have more of a structured routine that doesn’t just involve going for coffee and cake.
I think your sister means well but just went about it all wrong.

Yes agree

Swipe left for the next trending thread