Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ban my bullying sister from seeing my kids?

341 replies

PontinsBeach · 13/11/2022 10:34

I’ve got 2 teenagers just a year apart, a DS15 with ASD and DD14 with anxiety and depression. Both are school refusers, I am trying my best and working with relevant authorities. DD often spends all day in bed (DS wakes up but will play video games) and I have to WFH but I make sure they come out at least once a day. As soon as I finish work at 2pm (I start early) both DC will come on a long dog walk at a country park and we’ll go to a cafe for cake/coffee afterwards.

My sister has a holier than thou attitude and is always giving me shit about my kids. Her adult DD and DS are ‘perfect’, both went to top RG uni’s, never had any kind of issue and now both live abroad with great jobs and she is constantly comparing them to my DC.

On Friday, I had to call in sick due to a cold. Around 1pm whilst feeling like shit, with DC still in bed, I get a text from Dsis announcing she was 2 minutes away. She does this often, I was fuming as house was a tip. When she arrived I told her I wasn’t well, and she just sort of pushed passed me and said “Oh well I’ll make you a cup of tea!!!!!”. She set off my 2 Alsatians who were barking for England and I had to settle them.

Then, as expected, the arsey comments about my kids started. “Little madam is in bed I take it? My daughter was always up by 6 on a weekend for her part-time job!” “What’s he doing? For goodness sake, you need to get him a proper hobby. He’ll wither away, no wonder he’s skin and bones!”. Her DH has ‘aspergers’ (yes I know it’s not called that but that’s the term she uses) and she thinks she’s the autism expert because of it, and implies my DS in non-verbal due to my failings. DS wears headphones when out for sensory reasons and once in a coffee shop she tried to bully him into removing them saying it was rude. Her husband who has a great job in finance is a completely different kettle of fish to my son FFS.

Her kids always had a very regimented routine, both with a long list of chores and several hobbies each, they never had ‘chill’ time. This is simply impossible for my kids due to their additional needs, they would not cope with me forcing things on them. As I say, we’ve come up with our own plans with authorities. DS is getting a grant so I can take him to places for enrichment (and is also slowing building a relationship with a key worker who will take him out) and DD may potentially be able to start a college course early at 15 at a small local animal care college, which is an environment I think she’ll thrive in as the rough, large local comp nearly killed her (horrific bullying). So it’s not like I’ve got nothing in place for them.

She just went on and on. Bla bla bla fucking bla. My kids cannot stand her as she always makes them uncomfortable, goes into DD’s room whilst she’s sleeping and lectures her. Dsis works part-time so is here a lot. Last Monday it was just before DD was going into the shower to get ready (and she was doing well that day, up at 12pm and expressing an interest in doing some baking), Dsis arrived, went up to her room and went on for half an hour about how DD should be up and ready before noon. DD was in tears afterwards and went back to bed for the rest of the day, it set her back.

Anyway, back to Friday, she gave me my drink then took herself upstairs. I could hear her. She tried to talk to non-verbal DS so I went up, and as usual, she looked shocked and appalled when he blanked her. She went into DD’s room with DD fast asleep started loudly clapping her hands (As usual. It’s also a huge sensory trigger for DS and in the midst of everything I heard him slamming his bedroom door repeatedly) shouting “Right you! Up now! You can’t live like this!!!! Your poor mum is ill and you need to pull your weight!!!! Come and make her some soup!!!”. In the end it was humiliating for DD as she had slept just in bottom underwear (her thermostat is broken and her room is boiling) so when Dsis pulled her duvet off she was exposed. DD then started crying and begging me to intervene. This is notable behaviour for DD as she usually doesn’t break down until Dsis leaves (Dsis is a huge anxiety trigger for her) but this time she started crying and having a panic attack in front of Dsis, DD finally ‘snapped’.

I lost my shit, this has been happening consistently for years and I was done. I grabbed her arm, pulled her into the hallway, told her she was a fucking disgrace for bullying my vulnerable kids and basically said “Fuck off and don’t ever talk to me again.” She continued lecturing me about my parenting so I threatened to call the police to get rid of her then she sheepishly left. I then sent her a message saying if she turns up again, she’s not being let in, and forceful attempts WILL result in me calling the police as I feel I have to safeguard my children from her. I also sent a text to my parents to inform them I am done with her. My parents are angry with me but I can’t have her around my kids anymore.

OP posts:
MintyGreenDreams · 13/11/2022 14:30

@Chailatteplease I'm entitled to my opinion

Branleuse · 13/11/2022 14:30

You are right to ban her. Its overdue. Your children are startled and frightened by her intimidating them in their own home. In their own rooms. Even removing the cover ad exposing your daughter half naked while she was sleeping.
They are not her children. Its not her house, and you are managing a very difficult situation while holding down a job. Her strategy will make it worse.

As proved on this thread, lots of arseholes have opinions on how to deal with mentally unwell autistic children using tough love, but usually these are from people whove never actually had to live with it.
Fuck her. Shes crossed the line too many times now.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 13/11/2022 14:25

Realistnotpessimist · 13/11/2022 10:39

She's not gone about it in the right way but she's absolutely right that the kids can't live like that.

I agree. Kids should not be living like this. What future are they going to have? The sisters delivery was wrong but shes obv concerned

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 13/11/2022 14:21

@PontinsBeach - you sound like a great mum, and I just wish your sister was giving you and your children the support you need, in the same way your ex’s sister does.

You have done the right thing in standing up to your sister. She sounds very insensitive and rude, and her treatment of you and your kids was cruel.

NotMyFinestMoment · 13/11/2022 14:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

^ This.

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 14:13

Even if what some PP's are saying was true (it's not, it's just ignorant bullshit) I'd rather have a "failing" child than a dead child.

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 14:02

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 13/11/2022 13:56

So your kids don't get up, don't go to school and you're ok with that? Do they ever do anything like have a shower or change their bed linen? Good luck getting your DD into college with that attitude. How will she cope with coursework etc? Let alone turning up on time for lectures.

How long had this been going on before you sought proper support/medical/psychological intervention?

Your house, family and attitude all sound like a nightmare to be honest. The thermostat in your DD's room is broken? Well fix it then!

I was fuming as house was a tip well, tidy it up! Or ask your kids to help and set them chores. Might help them get out of bed if they have something to do, rather than, 'It's ok to skip school, we'll go for some cake instead'.

Are you expecting your children to live with you forever because you can't be bothered to teach them how to be independent? Being ND has nothing to do with this. Really lazy parenting. Sorry. Where is their Dad in all of this?

The dad can't be bothered with his kids and has a new family. How's that for lazy parenting?

Boomboom22 · 13/11/2022 14:02

People are creating their own stories here.
The boy is severely autistic, non verbal and will never be independent whatever she does.
The girl has mh issues including attempted suicide due to bullying, the pressure of her brother and likelihood she will have to care for him in future, and it is quite likely she is also autistic given genetics and the late diagnosis of girls.
The ex husband is absent but his family eg sister is supportive.
Provision for both is being provided through the relevant authorities.
Yes an earlier routine phased in over 6 weeks would be useful for college readiness. The girl seems to be OK academically it was the school environment so this should be fine.

Orangepolentacake · 13/11/2022 14:02

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 13/11/2022 10:55

Are you struggling mentally? How did you let her upstairs? If you don't want her in DD's room whilst she sleeps why do you let her? Do you secretly want her help?

Oh do find something better to do than turn it around and blame the op for something that is not her fault.
there’s always one!

BigglyBee · 13/11/2022 13:56

The thing that strikes me most, OP, is how huge the pressure on you must be. You have one profoundly autistic child, one with MH issues, you need to earn a living and also arrange/fight for every little thing your children need (and it's clear that they need a lot). That's huge when you have no partner and precious little other support, and the last thing you need is someone swanning in and essentially telling you that if you were just like her, everything would be fine.

Your sister didn't ask what you need, or offer to spend time with your kids, or even listen to how you feel. She berated you and your kids, and caused a lot of extra stress for you. It's easy to blame the one adult who has tried to support these children, is she as disparaging of their absent father?

Obviously, you know that your daughter needs to gradually move towards a sleep routine which is appropriate for college, but I'm sure you are working towards that. I hope that you get a bit of breathing space from January and that things start to look up for you. Nobody does their best when they are totally drained and unsupported, and I can't see any way that you wouldn't feel utterly washed out.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 13/11/2022 13:56

So your kids don't get up, don't go to school and you're ok with that? Do they ever do anything like have a shower or change their bed linen? Good luck getting your DD into college with that attitude. How will she cope with coursework etc? Let alone turning up on time for lectures.

How long had this been going on before you sought proper support/medical/psychological intervention?

Your house, family and attitude all sound like a nightmare to be honest. The thermostat in your DD's room is broken? Well fix it then!

I was fuming as house was a tip well, tidy it up! Or ask your kids to help and set them chores. Might help them get out of bed if they have something to do, rather than, 'It's ok to skip school, we'll go for some cake instead'.

Are you expecting your children to live with you forever because you can't be bothered to teach them how to be independent? Being ND has nothing to do with this. Really lazy parenting. Sorry. Where is their Dad in all of this?

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 13/11/2022 13:53

I'm surprised you've lasted this long without losing your shit with her

Don't let her in again, your dc need their home to be a safe space. Especially while you work towards them going to collage etc in a few months

JubileeTrifle · 13/11/2022 13:46

I found with school refusing ND teen I almost had to let it all go for a while and now she’s at the point she is wanting to back to school, we are now being reintroduced slowly.
unless you’ve been through it you have been through it, you have no idea.
Pushing a ND child will usually have the opposite effect.

Getting into a good routine for college would be a good idea, but I find once child is on board they are good at doing these things anyway.

BatsAtDawn · 13/11/2022 13:39

You are right to ban your sister, regardless of her reasons her behaviour is awful.

My friends daughter is non verbal and has ASD and she has similar struggles with her brother. He's a teacher in a mainstream school so will work with ND children who are not so limited they can attend a mainstream school. He truly has no concept of the needs of profoundly autistic children - he's full of opinions and ignorance. They are now LC.

It sounds incredibly tough for you all, hopefully going to college results in a massive improvement for your daughter. It might be worth investigating if the college has MH services your daughter can access there too.

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 13:36

JustAnotherHappyFatty · 13/11/2022 13:26

I don't think anyone means the OP has created the situation, just that leaving them in bed gaming or doing a bit of drawing during the day is not preparing them for the future.
If you are honest with yourself OP, is it easier to let them keep unsociable hours so you can work from home uninterrupted? It strikes me that they seem to be getting up just as you finish work.
Also, I would be gradually getting your daughter up earlier as she won't cope with the early starts at college if her body clock is so distorted.
Your sister went about it the wrong way but I can you see what worried her? Your kids are asleep at lunchtime and your house was a mess by your own admission, wouldn't you worry if you saw someone's kids living like that?
As for people saying no wonder the sisters kids live abroad and insinuating it's to get away from her.....give your heads a wobble! They are maybe just successful and had good opportunities in life!

You know what would've been easier for OP? To send them off to unsuitable schools ,insist they keep attending and let the chips fall where they may. Out of the house ,work in peace etc.

What she is doing is not taking the easy way out. It's giving her kids tome and space to recover from past trauma, try and get in a better place while waiting for better suited provision to start.

custardbear · 13/11/2022 13:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

custardbear · 13/11/2022 13:29

JustAnotherHappyFatty · 13/11/2022 13:26

I don't think anyone means the OP has created the situation, just that leaving them in bed gaming or doing a bit of drawing during the day is not preparing them for the future.
If you are honest with yourself OP, is it easier to let them keep unsociable hours so you can work from home uninterrupted? It strikes me that they seem to be getting up just as you finish work.
Also, I would be gradually getting your daughter up earlier as she won't cope with the early starts at college if her body clock is so distorted.
Your sister went about it the wrong way but I can you see what worried her? Your kids are asleep at lunchtime and your house was a mess by your own admission, wouldn't you worry if you saw someone's kids living like that?
As for people saying no wonder the sisters kids live abroad and insinuating it's to get away from her.....give your heads a wobble! They are maybe just successful and had good opportunities in life!

Pure ignorance

kweeble · 13/11/2022 13:28

Your children do need to get up and out of bed - they also need to be off screens. If they don’t go to school you need to home school then but you don’t seem able to do that.
i can see why your sister wants to intervene but she does need to get you on board too. I can’t see much future for children that are supported by an inadequate parent to stay in bed. You talk about safeguarding but you’re not doing them any favours by having no discipline or routine.

JustAnotherHappyFatty · 13/11/2022 13:26

I don't think anyone means the OP has created the situation, just that leaving them in bed gaming or doing a bit of drawing during the day is not preparing them for the future.
If you are honest with yourself OP, is it easier to let them keep unsociable hours so you can work from home uninterrupted? It strikes me that they seem to be getting up just as you finish work.
Also, I would be gradually getting your daughter up earlier as she won't cope with the early starts at college if her body clock is so distorted.
Your sister went about it the wrong way but I can you see what worried her? Your kids are asleep at lunchtime and your house was a mess by your own admission, wouldn't you worry if you saw someone's kids living like that?
As for people saying no wonder the sisters kids live abroad and insinuating it's to get away from her.....give your heads a wobble! They are maybe just successful and had good opportunities in life!

Chailatteplease · 13/11/2022 13:24

fUNNYfACE36 · 13/11/2022 11:23

I imagine your parents and siblings are very concerned. I would be extremely worried if youngsters in my extended family were being parented like this.
Your dc should be in education.i am not sure why you think your dds anxiety will magically melt away come January after 6 months of hiding away.That will make her anxiety worse not better

You’ve clearly never had a child who’s suffered so badly from bullying that they’ve self-harmed. Lucky you. I can assure you, when it affects them that badly mentally, you no longer priorities education.

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 13:24

@redbigbananafeet

I'm assuming you believe staying in bed until 1pm is good for a child suffering from depression?

It depends on the child and the circumstances doesn't it? And if not necessarily good,then a reasonable adjustment.

You seem to think in general and blanket terms about struggling children and trying to fit them into neat little boxes. Life doesn't work that way. I wonder how many children have been failed or lost because of your attitude of "kids with x must do y".

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 13:21

fUNNYfACE36 · 13/11/2022 13:12

I dontbsee anything about the daughter being ND? Are the education authorities happy with the current situation? I can't believe they are just ignoring the fact that a 14 year old will be out of education for 6 months

Then you're not paying attention. If they can get away with it and can wash their hands of such children that is their go to.

AnotherEmma · 13/11/2022 13:19

YANBU, but AIBU is not the place for this thread. I haven't read all the replies as I found many of them too annoying. Lots of people with a similar attitude to your sister. The only thing you've done wrong is allowing her access to your home and your children for so long. You definitely shouldn't let her in.

It seems to be the sad reality of parenting SEND children that so many others - from your own family to strangers on mumsnet - judge you and think they know better than you how to parent your own children. It's bullshit.

Please don't feel you have to justify yourself or defend your children to anyone on here. You and they are doing great.

Do you claim DLA for them? If not maybe look into whether they'd be eligible.

Chailatteplease · 13/11/2022 13:19

MintyGreenDreams · 13/11/2022 11:02

anxiety and depression are not additional needs imo

Actually, they are. There are parents who have been able to access EHCP’s because they are medical conditions. Maybe do some research before making ignorant comments.

WinterLobelia · 13/11/2022 13:17

It usually is easier to blame the parents IME as a mother of a child with asd, adhd, tourettes, dyspraxia and very low functioning IQ.

Certainly I have been called a fantasist and a person whose crap parenting has created these issues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread