Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"People have their own lives"

406 replies

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 09:18

We lived abroad for many years but moved back to the U.K. recently so our children could spend time with grandparents and extended family. DH in particular was really concerned that our DC were missing out from not having those family connections.

Since moving back we have found family on both sides to be a massive disappointment and one of the phrases I constantly hear when speaking to people about the situation is “yes but people have their own lives”

I have lots of friends who’s parents/aunts/cousins etc seem very interested in spending time with them and their children and this is just integrated into “their own lives”

I am well aware that everyone has different priorities in life, however AIBU to think that really that phrase just means “people can’t be fucked” and would rather just continue on as they always have without making any effort for anyone else?

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 13/11/2022 17:53

I always find it crazy that there is so much vitriol on MN for people who move abroad. That the OP 'deserves' her family to be uninterested because she moved abroad, and the assumption that anyone who moeyre just saingves abroad doesn't care about their family.

I haven't seen any vitriol here, just honesty.

Also, nobody has said that OP deserves an uninterested family - just that if you move abroad and choose to live your life thousands of miles away, you can't come home and expect things to just pick up where you left off.

planesandtrains · 13/11/2022 17:25

I always find it crazy that there is so much vitriol on MN for people who move abroad. That the OP 'deserves' her family to be uninterested because she moved abroad, and the assumption that anyone who moves abroad doesn't care about their family.

OP, I think more recent PPs have been most helpful in saying these things take a while. I've also seen advice that moving back home takes just as long to 'settle into' as moving somewhere new.

My two penny worth on this matter (as an expat myself) is that if your family were close when you were abroad then you can expect similar when you move home. But essentially the relationship will mirror what it did before.

DH and I are very close with our parents. Our parents visit twice a year, we go home once or twice too. We speak on the phone every day or nearly every day. The kids' relationship with their grandparents is different but they are still close (zoom and the extended visits). Our parents would obviously rather we lived in the U.K., but can see we can give our DC a much better life where we are. My dad often tells me we'd be mad to move back.

If that closeness wasn't present when you were abroad and you want it, then it will take time to build up

MrsLargeEmbodied · 13/11/2022 17:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

exactly
i cannot believe these posters are actual parents!

AllNightDiner · 13/11/2022 17:14

LondonJax · 13/11/2022 15:28

I'm not a grandparent yet but I do have a sibling who moved away for a time (over five years) and then came back so I can speak from that perspective.

My DSis moved back five years ago and couldn't understand why I didn't drop meeting up with my friends in favour of being there, on tap, for her. The reason was because, by that time, I was involved in play dates, coffee with other mums, setting up a new business etc. The friends were part of a circle that had formed in the time she was away. My DSis wasn't, to be blunt. I was pleased to see her back but she had to fit into my world - just like you said you had a wide circle of friends you saw frequently in the country you moved from OP. My life hadn't been on hold and it was different (by five years) compared to what it had been when she left. Five years later and we meet up regularly as our lives have begun to merge more. Now I appreciate that's not grandparents/grandchildren and I'd have made more effort if it had been but it's just for a bit of perspective. You said a lot of your friends in your old town see their family more. But they've been there...all the time. So no 'gaps in the week' have occurred with them not being around that then get filled with friends, work, volunteering or whatever. It's habit.

You mentioned @alfreddo82 that one of the grandparents dropped into see you for a quick cuppa a while ago but that's the last you've seen of anyone for almost a year. Which is sad. Yet you say they live 20 minutes away. What's wrong with you dropping into theirs once a month during that time? Or is it that having two children and, as you say, a demanding job, makes that commitment hard? But you expect them to make a commitment to come to you. As my DH says about his family who live a few hundred miles away 'the motorway runs in both directions'.

It's fine inviting them to you, that's lovely. But what about inviting yourself to them? Just for a 30 minute sit down with them? Inviting them over for Christmas or a BBQ is great. But how can you say they haven't made the effort this year when you've not made an effort to drive 20 minutes for a quick cup of tea? Or do they say they're busy all the time? Seeing family doesn't mean spending a whole day together, especially if you live close. It's the 'just dropped by for a quick coffee - oh and I brought that cake you like' or 'I'm taking the kids to the park around the corner from you, OK if I drop by for half an hour afterwards?' that makes family or friends bond.

I think there is a lot of wisdom in this post, @alfreddo82. If you really were, and still are, serious about wanting your children to grow up within a close extended family, then I think you need to pay heed to how much time and effort it took @LondonJax and her sister to get on to that footing. You may feel you've given it plenty of time, but two years isn't a huge amount taken in the context of their entire childhood to come. It would be a shame to look back when they're teenagers and realise that two years was nothing, and that things could be very different if you'd stuck with it. That is, if you were ever that close in the first place and genuinely have something to rebuild, which you haven't really said. I still find it odd tbh that you don't really seem to be talking to your parents about any of this.

I think it's really unhelpful that some posters are making this into some kind of moral issue btw, as though OP's parents are monsters instead of just normal people who happen not to be quite on the same page as their daughter (especially when she doesn't seem to have talked to them about it).

Endofmyteatherr · 13/11/2022 16:57

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 09:34

We moved away as a childless couple. Moved back when the DC were very young. We have been back for two years and lucky if we see GP or siblings once twice per month now. Extended family we have seen maybe two or three times in two years. Friends we don't see a lot but again they are busy with their own extended families.

I don't have any expectation of help with childcare, I pay a fortune for nursery however I've always done that so I'm used to it. Most weekends we spend on our own with the DC, I used to try and organise things but now I've given up.

Just makes me sad that we uprooted our lives and gave up so much so the DC could know their family and they barely see them

Can you go back? Do you really uproot your lives though? This sounds like a cultural issue to me and some are more family oriented than others. I don't think anyone means it in a bad way but life in UK is very busy it's all work tbh it's just the way it works here! Unless your well off.

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 16:57

@BadGranny

I would say you have probably hit the nail on the head there.

OP posts:
Valeriekat · 13/11/2022 16:45

You moved overseas, people got on with their lives without you.
You now expect them to make you a priority.
YABU

BadGranny · 13/11/2022 15:49

I think there’s a risk that when one moves away from family for a long-ish time, one expects the world at home to freeze-frame, and then to pick up where one left off on your return. Unfortunately, it doesn’t work like that.

In fact, people at home have reconfigured their lives without you in them. They have routines and interests and commitments that you have not been part of for years because of your absence. It’s not reasonable to expect people to rearrange their lives just because you have decided that you want them to be part of your life again. If you want to build relationships, you have to start from scratch, and you can’t expect others to make the running. You chose to move away, and so they weren’t involved with your children from birth. No doubt you and your husband are also a very different people from the childless couple who set off to live overseas. They don’t know you now - the continuity of your family relationships has been broken.

if you want to have cosy family relationships, you’ll need to invest time, effort and patience to build them, and you will need to make it worth while for your family to reciprocate. All I can see in your posts is resentment that they don’t fit into your idea of how a family ought to operate.

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:44

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 13/11/2022 15:27

They sound like cold fish to me. Luckily she doesn't need to rely on them any longer to be happy. I wish her the best

Perhaps you could offer to be surrogate nan to OP's children - as you're so much more warm and caring than her parents.

Do you know I would be delighted to be anyone's adopted granny if anyone needs one, I love babies and kiddies and I can't understand the cold indifference.

MrsDooDaa · 13/11/2022 15:43

Ironic that it is the 'warm hearted' posters advising OP reduced contact with her family.

billy1966 · 13/11/2022 15:39

I can well understand your disappointment if you see your father for 30 minutes a month.

Your siblings don't have children and wont have, so the dynamic may indeed be different as their lives would be different to yours, and always will be.

I think the decision to return where you were happy and felt you had community is very wise.

That they are the only grandchildren on both sides with so little involvement is surprising, but you can at least move back with a clear mind.

Moving back before primary starts is best and hopefully you will assimilate back in easily .

thelobsterquadrille · 13/11/2022 15:28

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:23

I am out of this thread, you can't even follow what has happened lobster. The children were BABIES! She didn't go off and have kids elsewhere and bring back teenagers, they came back when the baby was just a few months old!!!!!!!!

JH Christ. You are literally making up stuff.

Most parents would be over the moon to have their children and baby grandchildren home. It is not normal to be indifferent to your own grandchildren when they are so tiny. I think the problems with op's parents are far deeper than she has said on here. They sound like cold fish to me. Luckily she doesn't need to rely on them any longer to be happy. I wish her the best.

I'm well aware of that Hmm But the grandparents still missed out on the early months and years of their lives, through no fault of their own. They also missed out on several years of their daughters' life. Like it or not, that has an impact.

Also - OP never said her parents are indifferent to the children, just that they don't see each other as much as they wanted/expected.

Lots of people only see their grandparents/in-laws every few weeks, that's a very normal level of contact for me. That doesn't say "cold fish" - it says "normal grandparents who have other things going on in their lives too".

I only see my mum every few weeks - we still have an excellent relationship. But we both have lives outside each other - I work, I have animals and hobbies - she volunteers and has her own hobbies and friends to spend time with. I don't expect to see her all the time, and vice versa.

LondonJax · 13/11/2022 15:28

I'm not a grandparent yet but I do have a sibling who moved away for a time (over five years) and then came back so I can speak from that perspective.

My DSis moved back five years ago and couldn't understand why I didn't drop meeting up with my friends in favour of being there, on tap, for her. The reason was because, by that time, I was involved in play dates, coffee with other mums, setting up a new business etc. The friends were part of a circle that had formed in the time she was away. My DSis wasn't, to be blunt. I was pleased to see her back but she had to fit into my world - just like you said you had a wide circle of friends you saw frequently in the country you moved from OP. My life hadn't been on hold and it was different (by five years) compared to what it had been when she left. Five years later and we meet up regularly as our lives have begun to merge more. Now I appreciate that's not grandparents/grandchildren and I'd have made more effort if it had been but it's just for a bit of perspective. You said a lot of your friends in your old town see their family more. But they've been there...all the time. So no 'gaps in the week' have occurred with them not being around that then get filled with friends, work, volunteering or whatever. It's habit.

You mentioned @alfreddo82 that one of the grandparents dropped into see you for a quick cuppa a while ago but that's the last you've seen of anyone for almost a year. Which is sad. Yet you say they live 20 minutes away. What's wrong with you dropping into theirs once a month during that time? Or is it that having two children and, as you say, a demanding job, makes that commitment hard? But you expect them to make a commitment to come to you. As my DH says about his family who live a few hundred miles away 'the motorway runs in both directions'.

It's fine inviting them to you, that's lovely. But what about inviting yourself to them? Just for a 30 minute sit down with them? Inviting them over for Christmas or a BBQ is great. But how can you say they haven't made the effort this year when you've not made an effort to drive 20 minutes for a quick cup of tea? Or do they say they're busy all the time? Seeing family doesn't mean spending a whole day together, especially if you live close. It's the 'just dropped by for a quick coffee - oh and I brought that cake you like' or 'I'm taking the kids to the park around the corner from you, OK if I drop by for half an hour afterwards?' that makes family or friends bond.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 13/11/2022 15:27

They sound like cold fish to me. Luckily she doesn't need to rely on them any longer to be happy. I wish her the best

Perhaps you could offer to be surrogate nan to OP's children - as you're so much more warm and caring than her parents.

Qwayserdeyas · 13/11/2022 15:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 15:27

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:23

I am out of this thread, you can't even follow what has happened lobster. The children were BABIES! She didn't go off and have kids elsewhere and bring back teenagers, they came back when the baby was just a few months old!!!!!!!!

JH Christ. You are literally making up stuff.

Most parents would be over the moon to have their children and baby grandchildren home. It is not normal to be indifferent to your own grandchildren when they are so tiny. I think the problems with op's parents are far deeper than she has said on here. They sound like cold fish to me. Luckily she doesn't need to rely on them any longer to be happy. I wish her the best.

Thanks @Venetiaparties.

OP posts:
BosaNova · 13/11/2022 15:26

Ha. Who is projecting eh

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:25

BosaNova · 13/11/2022 15:21

It's not about me, and I am not making it about me. You talk way more about your family on here than op proba di so who is doing who.

If you have no experience of families moving far from each other your opinion has same weight like if I were to talk to builder about how I would totally build the house better... Yet people with that experience are being called cold and uncaring by someone who is doing romantic hypotheticals in their head 🤷🏻

Op had too big expectations for her family to change their life. It stings, but it is very common occurrence because things change.

Err I have lived experience yes, I lived overseas for six years. My over dramatic mother called it a bereavement! Ridiculous. I am very close to my kids, and support whatever direction they wish to take now they are reaching adulthood. This is not about me, my love for my dc are unconditional, I will always be here for mine. Clearly not everyone feels the same, and that is a matter for them.

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:23

I am out of this thread, you can't even follow what has happened lobster. The children were BABIES! She didn't go off and have kids elsewhere and bring back teenagers, they came back when the baby was just a few months old!!!!!!!!

JH Christ. You are literally making up stuff.

Most parents would be over the moon to have their children and baby grandchildren home. It is not normal to be indifferent to your own grandchildren when they are so tiny. I think the problems with op's parents are far deeper than she has said on here. They sound like cold fish to me. Luckily she doesn't need to rely on them any longer to be happy. I wish her the best.

BosaNova · 13/11/2022 15:21

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:17

You can do you bosa and justify it to yourself. I am not interested in your issues. We are here to talk to op. Don't derail, and make this all about you. It is not about you, or your set up or your issues around your kids. Okay.

This is about op feeling very hurt, and I for one am glad she will have a future overseas that sounds much happier than the life she currently has here with her so called family. My best advice op is to tell them if you can, give them a chance to change, but if they don't - well it is most definitely their loss Flowers

It's not about me, and I am not making it about me. You talk way more about your family on here than op proba di so who is doing who.

If you have no experience of families moving far from each other your opinion has same weight like if I were to talk to builder about how I would totally build the house better... Yet people with that experience are being called cold and uncaring by someone who is doing romantic hypotheticals in their head 🤷🏻

Op had too big expectations for her family to change their life. It stings, but it is very common occurrence because things change.

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:20

I know OP's DC are only young but their grandparents are still virtual strangers to them

Are you reading a different thread?

thelobsterquadrille · 13/11/2022 15:19

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:17

You can do you bosa and justify it to yourself. I am not interested in your issues. We are here to talk to op. Don't derail, and make this all about you. It is not about you, or your set up or your issues around your kids. Okay.

This is about op feeling very hurt, and I for one am glad she will have a future overseas that sounds much happier than the life she currently has here with her so called family. My best advice op is to tell them if you can, give them a chance to change, but if they don't - well it is most definitely their loss Flowers

What about her parents feelings, though?

I imagine it really bloody hurt to see their daughter settle down and have children abroad. Unfortunately that decision had consequences.

thelobsterquadrille · 13/11/2022 15:17

Oh, and to add, my grandparents did make an effort - but in the nicest way, I didn't know them because I never had the chance to get to know them.

As an example - I vividly remember not wanting to talk to them on the phone, because my grandma would get emotional and upset and I never understood why. I know OP's DC are only young but their grandparents are still virtual strangers to them. It's difficult.

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:17

You can do you bosa and justify it to yourself. I am not interested in your issues. We are here to talk to op. Don't derail, and make this all about you. It is not about you, or your set up or your issues around your kids. Okay.

This is about op feeling very hurt, and I for one am glad she will have a future overseas that sounds much happier than the life she currently has here with her so called family. My best advice op is to tell them if you can, give them a chance to change, but if they don't - well it is most definitely their loss Flowers

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 15:15

BosaNova · 13/11/2022 15:10

Stop with this "people don't care that much" @Venetiaparties . It's fucking insulting pretending how you would drop everything and everyone else is a monster for not doing exactly that🙄

Wow. Raw nerve?