Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"People have their own lives"

406 replies

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 09:18

We lived abroad for many years but moved back to the U.K. recently so our children could spend time with grandparents and extended family. DH in particular was really concerned that our DC were missing out from not having those family connections.

Since moving back we have found family on both sides to be a massive disappointment and one of the phrases I constantly hear when speaking to people about the situation is “yes but people have their own lives”

I have lots of friends who’s parents/aunts/cousins etc seem very interested in spending time with them and their children and this is just integrated into “their own lives”

I am well aware that everyone has different priorities in life, however AIBU to think that really that phrase just means “people can’t be fucked” and would rather just continue on as they always have without making any effort for anyone else?

OP posts:
TedMullins · 15/11/2022 09:29

You’re right Venetia, there is a lot of weird bitterness towards people who emigrate. Imagine stunting your own life and ambitions because “faaaaaamily”. What a sad and narrow minded approach to life. Surely any loving and supportive family would be happy for each other fulfilling dreams and having adventures. Parents who emotionally blackmail their adult children by being “devastated” if they move away are toxic imo. If moving abroad can ruin a relationship it can’t have been that strong in the first place! If the relationship is there, it should be able to survive distance. Moving away or abroad doesn’t mean you don’t value or love your family ffs! It just seems like OP’s family wasn’t very close in the first place. Or as I said in my previous post, maybe as she’s the only one to have kids, her siblings just aren’t kid people. I wouldn’t choose to hang out with children even if they did belong to family members or close friends.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 07:50

AloysiusBear · 15/11/2022 06:16

Is it really too much to expect for your own mother to be happy you are back (with baby grandchildren) and wish to spend some time with you?

My sil emigrated a long way away. Mil was devastated, she's very hurt that her beloved daughter has happily run off to the other side of the world. Many people wouldn't do it, me included, because family mean too much to them. I do think it damages a bond when someone goes.

A mother and child relationship should not be damaged by an adventurous child. I fundamentally disagree with the insistence that this all important bond is so fragile that it can be so easily damaged by something so bienign.

My dd is going to Australia to study in 13 months time, I am thrilled for her. I plan to visit and hear all about her wonderful opportunities. It is beyond me how I can possibly love her less, think less of her and lose interest in her simply because she will be living somewhere else.

It seems to me that lots of people really do have very conditional relationships.

What a shame for them, and for their children.

AloysiusBear · 15/11/2022 06:16

Is it really too much to expect for your own mother to be happy you are back (with baby grandchildren) and wish to spend some time with you?

My sil emigrated a long way away. Mil was devastated, she's very hurt that her beloved daughter has happily run off to the other side of the world. Many people wouldn't do it, me included, because family mean too much to them. I do think it damages a bond when someone goes.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 06:05

Those that say well everyone moved on, and what do you expect etc

We are talking about a parent- child relationship here. Not some random relative.

The bond between parent and child, dare I say it mother and child by its very definition should be deep and loving, and in many cases unconditional. Is it really too much to expect for your own mother to be happy you are back (with baby grandchildren) and wish to spend some time with you?

LemonBounce · 15/11/2022 04:54

I hear you OP I would have expected them to be more involved too! They can have their own lives and also make time, you have also made a sacrifice to spend more time with them. Family isn't just a social activity to be fitted into the calendar! If your families don't get it sadly the only option is to adjust your expectations to help you cope - you will know you did everything you could and they will be missing out!

WindyHedges · 15/11/2022 03:23

Since moving back we have found family on both sides to be a massive disappointment and one of the phrases I constantly hear when speaking to people about the situation is “yes but people have their own lives

Indeed they do. As did you. You lived abroad for many years - living your own lives.

IME this happens when you emigrate. Life in your original country goes on. If you return, you have to accept this and find ways to reintegrate. You can’t expect everyone to drop everything just because you’ve re-emigrated.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 15/11/2022 02:59

As someone who lived in Asia for years, I think I know what you feel like you’re missing. Friends out there became family, and our lives were intertwined, seeing each other all the time. Ex-pat communities can often be like this.

It just isn’t like that here though. You’ve mentioned family being not around as much as you’d like, but have you made friends? Maybe join some groups etc, you can’t just rely on family.

Friday123 · 15/11/2022 02:41

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 09:51

My children are 2.5 and 4 so yes it does hurt my feelings that family aren't interested in them also.

The once per month I'm referring to could be that in a timespan of 30 days I see my DF when he pops in for a cup of tea for 30 mins. I've stopped inviting DH family to see us as I am sick of always being the one to do all the running around.

I posted before I read it was just a 30 minute visit. That's odd. If you're local I'd have thought you'd see them more regularly for shorter periods. If they have to travel, less often but for longer

Friday123 · 15/11/2022 02:34

How much would you see them when you lived abroad Vs now? When my sister lived abroad I saw them once a year for two weeks at most. Now they are back it's a couple of weeks a year plus the odd weekend. It would be more but "I have my own life" (mainly work).

How often do you go to them/take annual leave to fit their schedule?

Firethehorse · 15/11/2022 02:23

I’m sorry things haven’t worked out how you hoped OP. I was going to post about persevering and accepting being the one to keep working on building relationships. I see you’ve decided to go back to where your established friendship groups are.
It’s really hard trying to reintegrate, I don’t think friends and relatives fully understand how emotionally hard it is if they’ve always lived in one area. That said, when we move others carry on with their ‘new’ lives without us, and rightly so.

AloysiusBear · 15/11/2022 01:01

lucky if we see GP or siblings once twice per month now. Extended family we have seen maybe two or three times in two years.

How much were you expecting to see them?!

Were you expecting to spend every weekend with them? Don't you have anything else on? Most people have various different things on at weekends - kids activities, hobbies, errands to run but also down time at home. They then fit in a rotation of seeing family, friends etc, but tbh you can't fit in seeing the same people every weekend/every other.

DoYouWantDecking · 15/11/2022 00:26

I am really sorry it turned out this way. You must be so sad.
Also there are a lot of snotty vipers on this thread who don't seem to have actually read what you are writing.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/11/2022 00:18

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 09:57

Only on MN are people unreasonable for expecting thier parents and siblings to show an interest in their children 🙄

Not unreasonable but mostly unrealistic. You said these are the only GC, so you are upset that people who have never had your children or any children in their lives aren’t clamoring to fill their day with you kids.

This will probably sound harsh and I don’t mean it to be, but your kids aren’t as important to others as they are to you. I think you were unrealistic In expectations with regard to your families and your part in their lives. This doesn’t mean they don’t love you but it does mean that while you were gone they built friends and activities that don’t include you and your family.

I’ve been that person who moved away and I had to accept that meant I wasn’t part of the day to day lives of the friends and family as I once was. In your mind your picking up where you left off but in reality you now have to integrate into the established.

hate to break this to you, but you might face the same thing relocating back to your previous life.

My advice is to be realistic with the next move or you might be chasing that same same unrealistic expectation.

saraclara · 15/11/2022 00:03

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 10:05

@weinerdog

It always surprises me the lack of value that posters on this forum place on family.

Most of my friends have such close family connections. Best friend has her mum for childcare any time she needs it and spends time with extended family pretty much every weekend.

I just hope when my DC are older they want to spend time with me!

But presumably you didn't value family all that much as you left them behind to live abroad!

Or is this another case where care and interest is only expected from the top generation down? It's okay for adult kids to move away without a thought for family connection, but it's not okay for their own parents to 'have their own life'?

RaeRae84 · 14/11/2022 23:34

Totally agree with you.
I realised during covid that I was always the one rushing around and arranging everything. I definitely don't make the same effort now. I used to get so frustrated. I think I expect too much from people (thinking they are the same as me but obviously not!!)

Fanakerpan · 14/11/2022 22:26

Do you have to use the F word? Particularlarly in relation to children, very offensive in my book.

I am expecting some abusive replies, however, I don't care, I just wish to express that making a point can be done without the expletives.

DobbleBobble · 14/11/2022 22:25

I guess this is a bit of people just saying what they think is the right thing, we have a teenager and a pre teen, moved abroad ( not far) when the teenager was 2. Grandparents come to visit more than once a year (barring COVID) extended family less often but they have been and are always available when we go back, every year or two, so I am sure if we lived there they would see a lot more of their family.

Sopharsogood · 14/11/2022 21:30

It’s difficult to find time if you work full time though. At the weekend, once you’ve done the cleaning, the washing and shopping, the weekend has gone!

antelopevalley · 14/11/2022 21:13

I would expect them to make some space, but they will have to give up things to have space to do this.

Wheatandchaff · 14/11/2022 21:09

mam0918 · 14/11/2022 21:04

Notice how that starts with 'if' and then goes to talk about how other people would feel... its an utter non sense statement because there ZERO way you could possibly know thats how THEY would feel in 30 year time if that happened.

You can't predict the future, you can't speak for other and the entire thing didn't happen so is entirely hypothetical.

Its entirely different visiting an abroad relative and having a kid expect you to drop everything to take their kids (who you have never previously had a relationship with) out every weekend.

They have made space, they see their grandkids OP has just deemed it 'not enough'.

I have never moved away and my family (who I get on perfectly fine with, all live in the same county and we are a small family and I would say perfectly close knit without living in each others pockets) see my DC less than her family see hers.

Why? because they are busy as are we or have life circumstaces that effect their ability too.

I know my family. They would want to see my DC no matter how long we were apart.

And it’s not entirely hypothetical because as I said, we did it. We lived abroad. Nothing changed, they still wanted to see us, they still wanted to see my DC.

mam0918 · 14/11/2022 21:04

Wheatandchaff · 14/11/2022 20:53

You can’t leave your families to live abroad for years and then be upset that they can’t just slot back in perfectly when you turn up later wanting family for your children.

This is a strange concept to me. If I was away for 30 years when I came back my family would want to see me and especially my DC. Because my DC are their DGC. We lived abroad for a while and GP all came out to visit and we’re desperate to see DC and have updates on DC’s lives. They were all overjoyed when we moved back. The idea that they’re Luke be too busy to make some space for their own DGC is very alien to me.

OP have you asked them why? Just asked what’s going on?

Notice how that starts with 'if' and then goes to talk about how other people would feel... its an utter non sense statement because there ZERO way you could possibly know thats how THEY would feel in 30 year time if that happened.

You can't predict the future, you can't speak for other and the entire thing didn't happen so is entirely hypothetical.

Its entirely different visiting an abroad relative and having a kid expect you to drop everything to take their kids (who you have never previously had a relationship with) out every weekend.

They have made space, they see their grandkids OP has just deemed it 'not enough'.

I have never moved away and my family (who I get on perfectly fine with, all live in the same county and we are a small family and I would say perfectly close knit without living in each others pockets) see my DC less than her family see hers.

Why? because they are busy as are we or have life circumstaces that effect their ability too.

Wheatandchaff · 14/11/2022 20:53

You can’t leave your families to live abroad for years and then be upset that they can’t just slot back in perfectly when you turn up later wanting family for your children.

This is a strange concept to me. If I was away for 30 years when I came back my family would want to see me and especially my DC. Because my DC are their DGC. We lived abroad for a while and GP all came out to visit and we’re desperate to see DC and have updates on DC’s lives. They were all overjoyed when we moved back. The idea that they’re Luke be too busy to make some space for their own DGC is very alien to me.

OP have you asked them why? Just asked what’s going on?

antelopevalley · 14/11/2022 20:38

@Venetiaparties For me the issue is about whether OP is actually interested in her relatives lives, or of she just wants them to relate to her kids?

WednesdaysChild11 · 14/11/2022 20:35

YANBU as aren't half the ppl on these threads the last week lol. I keep saying threads like this time and time again lol.

Pinkcadillac · 14/11/2022 20:27

Venetiaparties · 14/11/2022 18:34

What am I reading?

'missed the window' did you actually read the children's age - 6 months and two years old. Babies. They were SMALL kids and no window was missed. It was the perfect moment to move back whilst the children were so tiny. No doubt her parents came out to see the babies when they were born, so barely missed anything before op moved back. Please read the facts before you just guess and post.

For example I would priories someone I had a close relationship over some family remember I haven’t really seen

So you would prioritise everything but your own children and grandchildren despite them moving back to be closer to you Lily?

I think it’ll take time for your families to warm up

Righto, how long?? They have been back for over TWO whole years. Are we talking ten or twenty years for this warm up to happen? Maybe never, after all the buggers moved miles away they deserve to suffer indefinitely. How dare they explore the world and have a life beyond mother's postcode.

I have found this thread, quite frankly, alarming to read. With a bunch of myopic inward looking people that can not imagine life beyond their own street and way behold anyone getting ideas about sniffing past the local town and god forbid actually moving somewhere else - you will be forever banished from the tribe.

I don't know and have never met anyone that seriously thinks like this. It is staggeringly narrow minded.

Your kids are your kids whatever they decide to do, wherever they decide to live and whoever they decide to be, there should not be a big 'warm up' of years if they decide to head home, and for it to take years for said parents to work up some interest in their baby grandchildren and decide if they have forgiven them or not. Do people seriously live and think like this? Clearly they do.

Almost like the bird that falls or flies out of the nest, and gains another scent and is thus rejected. Weird as hell given we are talking about conscious, supposedly intelligent human beings Confused

Great post by Venetiaparties