Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"People have their own lives"

406 replies

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 09:18

We lived abroad for many years but moved back to the U.K. recently so our children could spend time with grandparents and extended family. DH in particular was really concerned that our DC were missing out from not having those family connections.

Since moving back we have found family on both sides to be a massive disappointment and one of the phrases I constantly hear when speaking to people about the situation is “yes but people have their own lives”

I have lots of friends who’s parents/aunts/cousins etc seem very interested in spending time with them and their children and this is just integrated into “their own lives”

I am well aware that everyone has different priorities in life, however AIBU to think that really that phrase just means “people can’t be fucked” and would rather just continue on as they always have without making any effort for anyone else?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sue20 · 18/11/2022 11:09

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 09:34

We moved away as a childless couple. Moved back when the DC were very young. We have been back for two years and lucky if we see GP or siblings once twice per month now. Extended family we have seen maybe two or three times in two years. Friends we don't see a lot but again they are busy with their own extended families.

I don't have any expectation of help with childcare, I pay a fortune for nursery however I've always done that so I'm used to it. Most weekends we spend on our own with the DC, I used to try and organise things but now I've given up.

Just makes me sad that we uprooted our lives and gave up so much so the DC could know their family and they barely see them

without knowing the exact geographics( village, town, city?) I’d say twice a month or near very reasonable amount of contact these busy stressed times. That’s every other week? It’s the quality that matters surely. It’s good that your children were very young when you came back as it gives all the involvement of growing up alongside. (. And remember influences for better or worse . )

CocoFifi · 16/11/2022 12:07

alfreddo82 · 13/11/2022 09:18

We lived abroad for many years but moved back to the U.K. recently so our children could spend time with grandparents and extended family. DH in particular was really concerned that our DC were missing out from not having those family connections.

Since moving back we have found family on both sides to be a massive disappointment and one of the phrases I constantly hear when speaking to people about the situation is “yes but people have their own lives”

I have lots of friends who’s parents/aunts/cousins etc seem very interested in spending time with them and their children and this is just integrated into “their own lives”

I am well aware that everyone has different priorities in life, however AIBU to think that really that phrase just means “people can’t be fucked” and would rather just continue on as they always have without making any effort for anyone else?

I live abroad, but realise my friends and family have a life where they live too. When we do see them it is quality time we spend together rather than nipping in for half an hour to see them, which is what inevitably happens when you live nearer, as everyday life takes over. You should have enough going on in your own life to not worry about your children being a disappoint, which I think is an awful thing to say.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 13:34

And its hardly fawning to never wish to organise a small and brief visit to see your own grandchildren! Nothing is compulsory, but you would think they would want to see them.....

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 13:33

It is not once or twice a month ted that she sees her dp. It is nothing like it.

The once per month I'm referring to could be that in a timespan of 30 days I see my DF when he pops in for a cup of tea for 30 mins

She only sees her father once a month for 30 minutes. The rest she described as several months passing and not seeing her or dh's family. They are twenty minutes away. So whilst I agree parents should most definitely have their own lives, interests and friends it is hard to see how a child can not feel rejected in this scenario?

TedMullins · 15/11/2022 13:08

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:17

It is somewhat different if the roles are reversed and the parents move away. I guess they would expect to need to fit around a young family with or without a move overseas. Adapting to the needs of younger family members or caring for older relatives.

The issue is one of rejection.

Rejection of a child is extremely painful, whatever the reason or circumstances. As described by op, she is very hurt and not unreasonably. She considered her family important enough to move back and that feeling has not been reciprocated. I can imagine she feels devastated on some level.

Parents should not be moving on/filling holes and gaps and somehow erasing their child out of their lives, that is what we do with distant relatives/old friends we don't see often and people that are infinitely replaceable. Children for the most part should not be replaceable by boules, brunch on a Friday and tennis.
Rejecting your child and grandchildren will be catastrophic for the relationship in the end, it will be very hard for op to move past this once she has returned, the relationship is likely to cool down even more to perhaps the absolute bare minimum and might break down altogether.

I encouraged her to share her feelings about this with them, as a result, because they deserve to know what is happening and have the chance to turn things around if they want to. Op needs to know that leaving again will compound and confirm their suspicions that she never intended to stay in the first place, and this is cruel to them. She must do all she can to avoid giving them the perfect excuse to blame her for this outcome. She is not to blame. Honesty will throw light on each view and allow a conversation to be had, and a conclusion to be reached with everyone aware of the truth, not their version of it.

I agree with you on the weirdness about people emigrating but I don’t agree with this. They're not rejecting her, they do see her (once or twice a month sounds like a lot to me) they just aren’t involved with the intensity and frequency she’d like. Of course life moves on when your children are adults! It should move on when they leave the family home, let alone emigrate. Parents shouldn’t just sit in stasis waiting for their kids to call on them, they’re people in their own right with lives and interests of their own. I don’t think they’re obligated to fawn over grandchildren either. They’ve done their time with babies and toddlers.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:53

MrsDooDaa · 15/11/2022 12:46

Time is a finite resource. If a life has been filled with friendships while family is away, you are saying that time now needs to be rescheduled from friends to family.

So the friends comment is relevant.

The GPs could now have a balancing act between friends who have been good to them while family was away and spending time with the grandchildren, who are now here.

Most people have enough time for everyone.

I have lots of friends, young teens, work and I have a large family. Most people manage to prioritise and include others as much as possible. I wouldn't drop my friends exactly, but I would explain to my friends how much it meant to me to have my dd and my gcs back. I would imagine most decent friends would not mind at all, and be happy that such a wonderful development has taken place, and would accommodate a few changes effortlessly.

I get the feeling op's parents are actively choosing not to bother, and haven't for the past two years. No one is THAT busy.

MrsDooDaa · 15/11/2022 12:46

Time is a finite resource. If a life has been filled with friendships while family is away, you are saying that time now needs to be rescheduled from friends to family.

So the friends comment is relevant.

The GPs could now have a balancing act between friends who have been good to them while family was away and spending time with the grandchildren, who are now here.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:38

MrsDooDaa · 15/11/2022 12:34

I guess it all comes down to family/friends relationships and dynamics so. Not everyone prioritises family over friends as much as you do. Friends can be just as important as family.

Your posts continue to imply that those who don't put family first and foremost are cold, lacking in love, don't value their family etc. I think that's unfair. The situation is not as black and white as you make out and, as is most often the case in life, a balance is best.

We are not talking about friends on this thread. Op is talking about family. Specifically about the total absence of interest and time with her parents since she returned.

A child may choose to distance themselves from their parents for various reasons, but if it is the parent that rejects the child, it can be very damaging to MOST children. Let us not pretend it isn't. Life isn't black and white, no but knowing you can count on your parents love, assuming they are not total monsters and abusers is quite standard.

We are talking quite specifically here about parents rejecting a child and young grandchildren.

Runaway1 · 15/11/2022 12:34

antelopevalley · 14/11/2022 18:09

Are you interested in their lives? Or are the many relatives only there for the benefit of your children?
Good relationships with relatives is still a two-way relationship. You need to be interested in them too. If you are not, they will not bother.

This. People know when they’re being used. You say you don’t want childcare but expect your kids to be taken out twice a month.

MrsDooDaa · 15/11/2022 12:34

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:25

I personally would have been thrilled if my dm had moved close to me overseas, I doubt I would have come back to the UK! I would happily rearrange things to make time for her. I guess I value and love her, call me old fashioned.

I guess it all comes down to family/friends relationships and dynamics so. Not everyone prioritises family over friends as much as you do. Friends can be just as important as family.

Your posts continue to imply that those who don't put family first and foremost are cold, lacking in love, don't value their family etc. I think that's unfair. The situation is not as black and white as you make out and, as is most often the case in life, a balance is best.

Hbh17 · 15/11/2022 12:32

Some people like their family members - some don't. Having a biological connection proves nothing & should create no obligation. For me, friends wil always be more important than family because friends are the people we choose and love. And I am talking about friendships of up to 40 years, even though none live locally.
I think, as said previously, none of us have any right to expect the "fatted calf" from our relatives, and it doesn't help anyone to have unrealistic expectations.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:25

MrsDooDaa · 15/11/2022 12:18

Considering this situation from a different perspective......

If the OPs parents had emigrated to be near the OP abroad, where the OP already had a full life setup, would the expectation be that the OP rearrange her own life priorities/friends to fit in regular visits with her parents?

I personally would have been thrilled if my dm had moved close to me overseas, I doubt I would have come back to the UK! I would happily rearrange things to make time for her. I guess I value and love her, call me old fashioned.

MrsDooDaa · 15/11/2022 12:18

Considering this situation from a different perspective......

If the OPs parents had emigrated to be near the OP abroad, where the OP already had a full life setup, would the expectation be that the OP rearrange her own life priorities/friends to fit in regular visits with her parents?

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:17

saraclara · 15/11/2022 12:03

Tethering up ones children with the idea that when/if you dare to leave then is you are out of the family nest, probably indefinitely, and we will all 'move on' and fill the 'you' sized w=hole in our lives in no time at all living no space for your return. It is massively messed up!!

Has anyone said that this happens is that it's reasonable? I don't think anyone in the 'left behind' family actually thinks that way when a family member emigrates.
What people ARE saying is that the relatives at home quite naturally and normally build their lives around what and who is around them. The alternative is that they mope and dwell on the advance of the family member.
It's not that they don't care, it's that they move in with their lives in a healthy way.

I get that it must be very disappointing for OP. The only thing I take issue with is her resentment that "they have their own lives" while not acknowledging that in leaving, they didn't particularly consider the family they left behind either, but "had their own life". I'm not saying that they should have considered others, just that you can't have your own life, but resent others having theirs. If you move abroad, it's a risk you take.

Almost all my late husband relatives emigrated. We love them dearly and love when they visit. But if they ever returned it works be to a different, yet still loving, family dynamic from the one they left. Our lives have changed in that period. Some of us have had our own families, some of us are caring for older family members, our diaries are pretty full.

It is somewhat different if the roles are reversed and the parents move away. I guess they would expect to need to fit around a young family with or without a move overseas. Adapting to the needs of younger family members or caring for older relatives.

The issue is one of rejection.

Rejection of a child is extremely painful, whatever the reason or circumstances. As described by op, she is very hurt and not unreasonably. She considered her family important enough to move back and that feeling has not been reciprocated. I can imagine she feels devastated on some level.

Parents should not be moving on/filling holes and gaps and somehow erasing their child out of their lives, that is what we do with distant relatives/old friends we don't see often and people that are infinitely replaceable. Children for the most part should not be replaceable by boules, brunch on a Friday and tennis.
Rejecting your child and grandchildren will be catastrophic for the relationship in the end, it will be very hard for op to move past this once she has returned, the relationship is likely to cool down even more to perhaps the absolute bare minimum and might break down altogether.

I encouraged her to share her feelings about this with them, as a result, because they deserve to know what is happening and have the chance to turn things around if they want to. Op needs to know that leaving again will compound and confirm their suspicions that she never intended to stay in the first place, and this is cruel to them. She must do all she can to avoid giving them the perfect excuse to blame her for this outcome. She is not to blame. Honesty will throw light on each view and allow a conversation to be had, and a conclusion to be reached with everyone aware of the truth, not their version of it.

saraclara · 15/11/2022 12:04

Sorry
The alternative is that they mope and dwell on the ABSENCE of the family member.

saraclara · 15/11/2022 12:03

Tethering up ones children with the idea that when/if you dare to leave then is you are out of the family nest, probably indefinitely, and we will all 'move on' and fill the 'you' sized w=hole in our lives in no time at all living no space for your return. It is massively messed up!!

Has anyone said that this happens is that it's reasonable? I don't think anyone in the 'left behind' family actually thinks that way when a family member emigrates.
What people ARE saying is that the relatives at home quite naturally and normally build their lives around what and who is around them. The alternative is that they mope and dwell on the advance of the family member.
It's not that they don't care, it's that they move in with their lives in a healthy way.

I get that it must be very disappointing for OP. The only thing I take issue with is her resentment that "they have their own lives" while not acknowledging that in leaving, they didn't particularly consider the family they left behind either, but "had their own life". I'm not saying that they should have considered others, just that you can't have your own life, but resent others having theirs. If you move abroad, it's a risk you take.

Almost all my late husband relatives emigrated. We love them dearly and love when they visit. But if they ever returned it works be to a different, yet still loving, family dynamic from the one they left. Our lives have changed in that period. Some of us have had our own families, some of us are caring for older family members, our diaries are pretty full.

psychomath · 15/11/2022 11:44

Tethering up ones children with the idea that when/if you dare to leave then is you are out of the family nest, probably indefinitely, and we will all 'move on' and fill the 'you' sized hole in our lives in no time at all living no space for your return. It is massively messed up!!

This is well put. I don't think seeing less of your family because you've emigrated is in any way the same as seeing less of them once you return because they've 'moved on'. If OP had decided not to emigrate in order to stay close to her family it presumably would have involved a lot of sacrifice on her part, giving up opportunities for career development, adventure and so on, and once she's over there it's difficult to come back and visit. It's not remotely comparable to not wanting to spend more time with your child who's just moved back nearby because it involves making some minor adjustments to your new social life to accommodate that, which is what some posters seem to be implying.

That said, OP hasn't elaborated on why her family aren't visiting more - if they have caring responsibilities or demanding careers for example and are already sparing as much time as they can then of course she's being unreasonable. If they're too busy because while she was gone they made new friends and joined a pilates class then I can understand why she'd be hurt by that.

MrsNowAndAlways · 15/11/2022 11:05

We moved away 7 years ago, from what I believed to be close family relationships and secure friendship groups. In that 7 years, my parents are the only people who have ever come to visit us, so much so that when we settled somewhere they've actually followed us and now live nearby so they can have a relatoinship with my children and us.

Everyone else, MIL, siblings, aunts, uncles, adult nieces and nephews and friends have all fallen by the wayside, and after the first year don't even send birthday or Christmas cards for them now. My children have zero relationship with the majority of their family, but we've come to accept it and like them, live our own life. It took me a while to come to terms with it, but it sounds like you will be much happier with the friendship groups you had built wherever you moved to, and your children aren't old enough for this move to have much of an impact.

I wish you well in your move back, and am sorry you've had to do this to find out that your family wasn't what you had hoped.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 15/11/2022 10:46

AIBU to think that really that phrase just means “people can’t be fucked” and would rather just continue on as they always have without making any effort for anyone else?

Yes I think that sometimes that phrase does mean that. I have also noticed that over a couple of decades quite a lot of people have, as the means to make and change plans last minute via mobile phones has increased, become very flaky at making actual arrangements and routines.

It depends a bit on what you mean by not enough though? And the person who said that they adjusted to you not being there all the time and now you expect them to adjust back when they have filled their lives with other things, yes that is probably the case. Were there any discussions or commitments about you moving back (pre-move) that they are now reneging on, or did you just decide to move anyway without any such thing?

I've also seen in a family quite close to me where that physical proximity almost makes them less likely to actually make plans, almost as though if you are always there the option is always there. Odd, but there it is.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 10:42

TedMullins · 15/11/2022 09:29

You’re right Venetia, there is a lot of weird bitterness towards people who emigrate. Imagine stunting your own life and ambitions because “faaaaaamily”. What a sad and narrow minded approach to life. Surely any loving and supportive family would be happy for each other fulfilling dreams and having adventures. Parents who emotionally blackmail their adult children by being “devastated” if they move away are toxic imo. If moving abroad can ruin a relationship it can’t have been that strong in the first place! If the relationship is there, it should be able to survive distance. Moving away or abroad doesn’t mean you don’t value or love your family ffs! It just seems like OP’s family wasn’t very close in the first place. Or as I said in my previous post, maybe as she’s the only one to have kids, her siblings just aren’t kid people. I wouldn’t choose to hang out with children even if they did belong to family members or close friends.

Agreed. It is very very weird and toxic.

Adult children being forced to stay in the area because their parents are literally silently or not so silently blackmailing them with being cut off for their independence. So many posts too, seem to have this very mindset, and support the op's parents position wholeheartedly. They are seemingly confused at the prospect that as a parent we should love and support our children unconditionally, and that includes decisions that are challenging/ difficult/painful for us sometimes.

Tethering up ones children with the idea that when/if you dare to leave then is you are out of the family nest, probably indefinitely, and we will all 'move on' and fill the 'you' sized w=hole in our lives in no time at all living no space for your return. It is massively messed up!! No wonder so many are stunted and don't grow into fully functioning adults if children are raised to believe this utter rot.

You can live anywhere, and you can try anything kids - and your family will still be here with open arms and hearts if and when you return. Basic parenting.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/11/2022 10:36

Once or twice a month seems quite reasonable to me tbh

catlovingdoctor · 15/11/2022 10:31

astronewt · 13/11/2022 09:28

From other people's perspective you pursued your own life when you moved away. Now you're back and you want them to revolve around you?

I echo this.

BadNomad · 15/11/2022 10:27

If you do move back to where you were before, please be aware that it might not be the same either because you've been away from that life for quite a while too and the people there may have moved on or not be able to offer the same level of friendship as before you left.

MrsDooDaa · 15/11/2022 09:58

I don't think many would begrudge their children from experiencing all the world has to offer. And equally, you shouldn't begrude this of your parents either, if they want to travel during retirement.

And posters are right, family love etc. doesn't need to be defined by distance. But also it doesn't need to be defined by X time spent together per month. But everyone has different expectations of relationships.

The point here is that OP didn't originally define the closeness of her family relationships by time spent together per month, as she emigrated. But now she does.

antelopevalley · 15/11/2022 09:43

I would encourage my children to emigrate if they want to. But your relationship is different if you can rarely see each other.