Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School trip - what is a reasonable cost?

159 replies

oblada · 13/11/2022 09:03

Y6 school trip. Our school is asking for close to £300 for the end of year school trip (2 nights away). It doesn't include transport which is covered with fundraising.
Now I can't complain too much, I can probably afford it. I don't have £300 to burn but I can manage.
But it feels wrong. Especially at the moment.
We're in the North West. Not an affluent part of the country.
I think I have made up my mind about what to do but I would be interested to see what everyone thinks generally on the cost. School is adamant it is a reasonable cost. Most people I discuss it directly with tend to agree with me (but maybe they don't really won't knows).
My own view is that up to £150 per kid is relatively affordable for most, in installments, and should be the max budget for a school trip. Whatever the kids do together will be unforgettable to them. They don't need millions of activities crammed in.
But is that unreasonable? Are other school able to do trips for cheaper than £300 per kid? Our weekends away are far cheaper than £300 per person. Now we don't have to worry about the safety aspects etc but then I'd think they'd be savings in the number of kids involved.

OP posts:
Whatnow321 · 13/11/2022 10:10

I think it seems expensive for 2 nights. Our school does a yearly residential from yr1 which feels expensive to have them each year but they're cheaper than that. The 2 night trip (yr 1 and 2) was £90 and the 3 night trip (yr 3 and 4) was £180. I think the 4nights (yr5 and 6) was £350.

DaisyDando · 13/11/2022 10:09

It is a lot of money, I agree and it’s a shame. But it’s also masses of work for the teachers and other staff members who arrange and accompany the trip. So it’s a bit of both.

I think that often people agree with someone making a point when they don’t care either way just to be friendly, so the people agreeing with you (in real life) might be doing a spot of that. Although they might not.

gogohmm · 13/11/2022 10:07

To illustrate costs, a place I've used as a family which has a group bunkhouse option is £48 per night full board per person. That's simply for bed and food, each activity is around £50 for half a day including equipment, instruction etc. you then add insurance, cost of the teachers, volunteers, transport there or bus drivers accommodation (assuming pta raise the to and from bus cost), extras like prizes, first aid supplies, etc.

I have arranged trips (not outward bounds) and £300 seems cheap all in

ltscoldonthesidelines · 13/11/2022 10:07

For those who are saying there are no additional staff costs, for lots of schools this is not the case. The ratios required for a trip are higher than in school, often requiring additional staff. Cover staff may be needed in school or on the trip. Well run trips are expensive, the costs for running them have shot up over the last year in particular.

Lulu1919 · 13/11/2022 10:02

They pricing comes from ...activity staff who are qualified ,food - three meals plus snacks I assume inc staff to make the food,heating ,laundry,insurances....it soon adds up .
Yes the activity centres make a profit...but the school does not ....Ive been in many trips as a TA and would often work double my usual hours but we don't get paid extra so it's not school staff costs ...

oblada · 13/11/2022 10:01

JimmyGrimble · 13/11/2022 09:47

I think it’s unreasonable. Are school offering help for those families who will be unable to pay? I will be taking my class to London (from NW) in June for an overnight. We will travel by train and spend the night on hms Belfast. They will have a cinema trip and a meal in a restaurant. We have applied for and received a grant and we are also sponsored by a local firm. Costs to families are kept to an absolute minimum to make sure everyone who wants to go, can. However, we are a school in a deprived area. I think for things like this there are grants etc available if school look for them.

I am not aware of school offering to help those who can't afford it. Certainly hasn't been mentioned.
When i raised my concerns it was simply "we review the costs careful and we hope you let your child come" sort of thing.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 13/11/2022 10:00

I paid £120 for 2 nights 12 years ago. It's what it costs. Outdoor centres set the prices. Unfortunately you can't stick 12 kids in a bell tent these days (and tell them to bring their own sleeping bag) then make them do long hikes, campfires singing and the punishment for the naughty ones was kitchen duty peeling spuds (teachers cooked) that said mum reckons it cost £30 for 4 nights in 1983.

Sirzy · 13/11/2022 10:00

Also in the past schools will have probably subsidised some of the costs themselves to keep them down but now with their budgets being so tight they won’t have the space to do as much.

Whereisthehugeteddybear · 13/11/2022 09:57

I think there is adifference between if something is "good value" or "value for money" and whether it's expensive or a suitable price for a particular demographic.
I've seen other threads about residential school trips, where people have broken down the cost and chunk by chunk it does seem good value, (and I'm sure schools wont be making a profit - teachers aren't even paid extra to go) ....but that is kind of irrelevant if the cost would be prohibitive for lots of people.

If I saw a 5 bedroom house in Mayfair for £1m, it probably is good value for money - is it still unaffordable for lots of people? Yes!

Lulu1919 · 13/11/2022 09:56

Depends on what they doing.....if it's three or four activities per day ..like archery rock climbing,kayaking etc then these things cost money ...
But if it's just teacher led ..walking ,sandcastle building etc then it's quite expensive

Sirzy · 13/11/2022 09:55

“The bottom tier” as you put it probably wouldn’t be able to afford anything for a trip so by that logic no trips should go ahead.

oblada · 13/11/2022 09:53

ZenNudist · 13/11/2022 09:49

That's a lot. North West here and in may this year we paid £220 for 5 days in the lakes. Activities were Brockholes tree top trek, watersports on Lake windermere and gullivers theme park on the way home plus play park at keswick and a day of walking at Grasmere (free). Stayed in a hostel at Grasmere.

Ds did 2 days for his year 7 retreat in keswick in September but staying in a church run hostel and going in small groups to use the schools own transportation. So just one night away. Cost £60 which I thought was expensive as they didn't do any costly activities.

Maybe they are using a costly outdoor pursuits provider?

At our primary school if you can't pay the school will take you anyway.

That sounds so good!

OP posts:
spanieleyes · 13/11/2022 09:51

The charity will be able to do it cheaper because they have chosen a weekend, schools can't do that ( well they could but staffing might be an issue!) so it will be more expensive as the centre will charge more.

ZenNudist · 13/11/2022 09:49

That's a lot. North West here and in may this year we paid £220 for 5 days in the lakes. Activities were Brockholes tree top trek, watersports on Lake windermere and gullivers theme park on the way home plus play park at keswick and a day of walking at Grasmere (free). Stayed in a hostel at Grasmere.

Ds did 2 days for his year 7 retreat in keswick in September but staying in a church run hostel and going in small groups to use the schools own transportation. So just one night away. Cost £60 which I thought was expensive as they didn't do any costly activities.

Maybe they are using a costly outdoor pursuits provider?

At our primary school if you can't pay the school will take you anyway.

AriettyHomily · 13/11/2022 09:48

JuneOsborne · 13/11/2022 09:42

My dad has just done a one night, two long days residential trip, full of activities.

£60 pp. That included lunch, dinner, snacks, breakfast, lunch again and coach travel plus the accomodation and the activities. So £300 without travel does seem steep. I know a few families that really struggled to afford the £60. It was spread out over installments to try and help and some families who approached school and couldn't pay didn't have to pay. The school has a policy of not leaving any child behind because of cost. (We have a very active PTA that raise a lot of money throughout the year to help with this ethos: they subsidise the kids that wouldn't be able to go because of cost).

That is exceptionally cheap and must be heavily subsidised

JimmyGrimble · 13/11/2022 09:47

I think it’s unreasonable. Are school offering help for those families who will be unable to pay? I will be taking my class to London (from NW) in June for an overnight. We will travel by train and spend the night on hms Belfast. They will have a cinema trip and a meal in a restaurant. We have applied for and received a grant and we are also sponsored by a local firm. Costs to families are kept to an absolute minimum to make sure everyone who wants to go, can. However, we are a school in a deprived area. I think for things like this there are grants etc available if school look for them.

oblada · 13/11/2022 09:44

"A reasonable cost is whatever the venue and transport company charge per person, divided by the number if children attending" - isn't a reasonable cost the amount that the bottom tier of parents can afford multiplied by the number of kids, plus a bit if there is scope for some parents to pay extra to help others? That would be the way i budget at home. I see what I can afford and cut my cloth accordingly not the other way round... Just my thoughts.

And i know we don't have to go. And probably won't and that's fine. But still interesting to see what others think.

OP posts:
ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 13/11/2022 09:44

@Tommyrot which schools pay their staff for trips? In 20+ years of teaching I've never seen that. As a pp above said, the key point is that schools don't make a profit out of these trips. It costs what it costs. There maybe good reasons why they can't be flexible on dates..
.like the staff going can't be away from their own families on the cheaper dates.

AriettyHomily · 13/11/2022 09:42

Ours last year was £480 for four nights. Apparently is used to be cheaper because they were able to take their own food but because 'covid' not anymore.

All the kids complained about the food and the activities less than normal. Again 'covid'.

PGL

greenacrylicpaint · 13/11/2022 09:42

we pay about that amount for dc residential for 4 nights/5 days.

there are no additional travel costs if dc decide to cycle, otherwise it's public transport (not uk). most dc cycle as that's part of the fun.added benefit is that they sleep very well when they return

it's the activities/equipment that's costly. abseiling, surfing, escape room...

JuneOsborne · 13/11/2022 09:42

My dad has just done a one night, two long days residential trip, full of activities.

£60 pp. That included lunch, dinner, snacks, breakfast, lunch again and coach travel plus the accomodation and the activities. So £300 without travel does seem steep. I know a few families that really struggled to afford the £60. It was spread out over installments to try and help and some families who approached school and couldn't pay didn't have to pay. The school has a policy of not leaving any child behind because of cost. (We have a very active PTA that raise a lot of money throughout the year to help with this ethos: they subsidise the kids that wouldn't be able to go because of cost).

glamourousindierockandroll · 13/11/2022 09:42

That does seem expensive. I say that as someone who has organised school residentials, though ours was funded by a sponsor and involved sole use of a youth hostel.

I kept the overall cost minimal by having kind staff offer to cover internally where possible. We did all activities ourselves, so no rock climbing or canoeing etc. Biggest costs were therefore transport and accommodation.

Curta · 13/11/2022 09:40

A reasonable cost is whatever the venue and transport company charge per person, divided by the number if children attending. In some cases, schools might factor in the cost of supply to cover teachers accompanying those on the trip, as ratios are different and some children will stay at school. Mostly, they just absorb this, like the teachers themselves with the hours extra hours they're giving. You don't have to go.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 13/11/2022 09:38

Dd1 is going on her school ski trip and they set the price in June for February but the travel company has increased the cost so it’s an extra £55. We had a fortnight to pay that which I thought was poorly handled.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 13/11/2022 09:36

Ours was £320 in year 5 and £275 in year 6 - with twins it was a lot but we knew in advance (since reception) and had planned for it. I think schools should produce a letter with the costs for each year group for different trips for all parents to see so you can prep even if locations and full details change.