Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School trip - what is a reasonable cost?

159 replies

oblada · 13/11/2022 09:03

Y6 school trip. Our school is asking for close to £300 for the end of year school trip (2 nights away). It doesn't include transport which is covered with fundraising.
Now I can't complain too much, I can probably afford it. I don't have £300 to burn but I can manage.
But it feels wrong. Especially at the moment.
We're in the North West. Not an affluent part of the country.
I think I have made up my mind about what to do but I would be interested to see what everyone thinks generally on the cost. School is adamant it is a reasonable cost. Most people I discuss it directly with tend to agree with me (but maybe they don't really won't knows).
My own view is that up to £150 per kid is relatively affordable for most, in installments, and should be the max budget for a school trip. Whatever the kids do together will be unforgettable to them. They don't need millions of activities crammed in.
But is that unreasonable? Are other school able to do trips for cheaper than £300 per kid? Our weekends away are far cheaper than £300 per person. Now we don't have to worry about the safety aspects etc but then I'd think they'd be savings in the number of kids involved.

OP posts:
LadyApplejack · 13/11/2022 19:04

I agree that whatever you get for the £300, it's a lot of money to ask of parents when lots of will be feeling the cost-of-living squeeze.

Meredusoleil · 13/11/2022 18:57

NRTFT

My general rule is around £100 per day, UK less/abroad more.

Dd1 went to Paris recently. 5 days/4 nights. It cost £540.

Dd2 went to Cornwall. 5 days/4 nights. It cost £380.

Apparently, it's the cost of coach hire and fuel that has shot up and is adding to the overall price.

Tiani4 · 13/11/2022 18:44

@oblada
As I said earlier , lone parent of 3 DCs, I can't afford it
Never have been able to afford £300* trips so mine don't attend those

I've saved yo when they have been £200 for a week on a few occasions but we go without to do so. And right now few people on low incomes with multiple DCs can afford to.

oblada · 13/11/2022 14:13

FacebookPhotos · 13/11/2022 13:43

OP, you haven't considered the timings. Places which cater to school groups are much more expensive mid week during term time because that's when they're in demand. You would pay a premium for outdoor activity centres mid week during the summer term. Like how places that cater to families shoot up in cost during the summer holidays.

With staffing, centres / organisations we have used offer different rates depending on how many of their staff you require. With parents attending, you'd need the absolute minimum centre staff. If you can only take minimal school staff (due to cover needed in school) you pay more for the centre staff to make up the ratios. A recent (admittedly expensive) school trip would have cost the 20 students £50 extra each if I weren't able to attend (in my half term without additional pay).

With charities, it is likely that the centre may have a special lower rate for them. Either because they can claim tax deductions or they can advertise how good they are for children with special needs (or both).

Rugby clubs (and similar) often have plenty of volunteers willing to go, and their places may be funded by the club rather than the kids going. And they often use club funds to help with the cost.

I agree with you that children shouldn't be left out if their parents can't afford it. But I also really don't like the idea of getting rid of school trips / music lessons etc entirely. Enrichment shouldn't only be for the kids whose parents can afford private school.

This is one of those things which is often discussed about London schools having a massive advantage. As it is the capital city, there are far more enrichment activities which can be done for free / minimal cost compared to those of us in other areas.

Some good points.
As i said I am not (really) questioning the actual maths/cost. I do believe the activity centre is probably taking advantage but that's not my main point. My main point is at that age they will enjoy a lot of cheaper options just as well, in my view.

OP posts:
FacebookPhotos · 13/11/2022 13:43

OP, you haven't considered the timings. Places which cater to school groups are much more expensive mid week during term time because that's when they're in demand. You would pay a premium for outdoor activity centres mid week during the summer term. Like how places that cater to families shoot up in cost during the summer holidays.

With staffing, centres / organisations we have used offer different rates depending on how many of their staff you require. With parents attending, you'd need the absolute minimum centre staff. If you can only take minimal school staff (due to cover needed in school) you pay more for the centre staff to make up the ratios. A recent (admittedly expensive) school trip would have cost the 20 students £50 extra each if I weren't able to attend (in my half term without additional pay).

With charities, it is likely that the centre may have a special lower rate for them. Either because they can claim tax deductions or they can advertise how good they are for children with special needs (or both).

Rugby clubs (and similar) often have plenty of volunteers willing to go, and their places may be funded by the club rather than the kids going. And they often use club funds to help with the cost.

I agree with you that children shouldn't be left out if their parents can't afford it. But I also really don't like the idea of getting rid of school trips / music lessons etc entirely. Enrichment shouldn't only be for the kids whose parents can afford private school.

This is one of those things which is often discussed about London schools having a massive advantage. As it is the capital city, there are far more enrichment activities which can be done for free / minimal cost compared to those of us in other areas.

Brigante9 · 13/11/2022 13:09

Time of year is key. PGL Paris is £600 in July before adding on eg Eurodisney tickets or a trip to the Louvre. Swap to February and it’s under £400.

iamjustwinginglife · 13/11/2022 12:45

*@Postapocalypticcowgirl
*
Cover is because school trips cannot go ahead with a ratio of 1:30 in primary school. So additional staff may need to attend. Staff at activity centers can count towards ratios, but at least 2 school staff should always attend- so in e.g. a one form primary, you'd need to provide cover for one other class (unless the Y6 class had a TA willing to go, but given their pay is so low, they would usually be offered overtime).

We're obviously an exception because our TAs always put themselves forwards for the trips-there's usually a waiting list to go! We have a TA per class so we don't provide additional cover and usually the SLT go up for at least a day each and give the staff doing the full week a break. Every school is different, I guess in some schools it's easier than others. One advantage of being in a deprived area is, although it's challenging, we do have more staff than most schools.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 13/11/2022 12:38

iamjustwinginglife · 13/11/2022 10:53

School staff don't get paid extra for going on residential trips-they might get a day off in lieu of going if they're lucky.

Cover is because school trips cannot go ahead with a ratio of 1:30 in primary school. So additional staff may need to attend. Staff at activity centers can count towards ratios, but at least 2 school staff should always attend- so in e.g. a one form primary, you'd need to provide cover for one other class (unless the Y6 class had a TA willing to go, but given their pay is so low, they would usually be offered overtime).

Covidwoes · 13/11/2022 12:36

I'm a teacher and that seems a lot. I don't know any teachers who work in state schools who get paid for trips. I never have. What does the trip involve? Y6 in my school go on a 5 night residential in summer term that costs around that!

Newnamefor2021 · 13/11/2022 12:36

My twins are in year 6 this year so I dread to think what the cost will be, equally I am glad they get this opportunity as my eldest didn't because of covid.

One night in London for him is £265 but they have packed loads in so I'm pretty happy with that.

oblada · 13/11/2022 12:33

Confusedteacher · 13/11/2022 12:30

Because the staff don’t have to be in loco parents the whole time, it makes it a very different trip.

But if you are really sure I guess all you can do is email the school directly and say “have you thought about using X centre next year? I went there on a trip with my charity and it only cost X amount”

My DH is a primary school teacher who spent weeks researching and visiting centres to find the right one for their Y6 trip. If you genuinely know of a better one they may be grateful for the input.

Well they weren't at all interested unfortunately 🤣

OP posts:
oblada · 13/11/2022 12:32

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 12:26

You don’t need to agree with it. Life isn’t fair. We can’t all afford to do what we want.

Those who can afford it shouldn’t miss out just because others can’t and thankfully that is the default position.

Nobody has to agree with anything but society is built on people's views and actions derived from those views. And I cannot support the idea that a non educational non necessary trip in a state funded school should exclude pupils based on means instead of doing a more inclusive trip accessible to all.

OP posts:
Confusedteacher · 13/11/2022 12:30

oblada · 13/11/2022 12:22

"The big cost is the staff at the centre." In which case I still fail to see how it differs?
The charity provided some volunteers but the activities were run by the paid staff of the activity ctr.
But again I am not particularly questioning the maths.

Because the staff don’t have to be in loco parents the whole time, it makes it a very different trip.

But if you are really sure I guess all you can do is email the school directly and say “have you thought about using X centre next year? I went there on a trip with my charity and it only cost X amount”

My DH is a primary school teacher who spent weeks researching and visiting centres to find the right one for their Y6 trip. If you genuinely know of a better one they may be grateful for the input.

Survey99 · 13/11/2022 12:30

oblada · 13/11/2022 12:08

Actually it is exactly that. Adding special needs to the equation as the charity is designed to support people with a specific condition. It is exclusive use, full board and lodging. The difference is that parents are there so absolutely you can add extra cost for staffing ratios if need be. Not that different at all otherwise and we're talking over 3x the cost here.

The staffing ratios for safety are supervising mostly are provided by the residental provider, and they package that with activities because as a business that is where they make their money, that is where most of the costs are incurred.

Unless parents are willing to attend (which defeats the purpose of the residental and opens another can of worms for safeguarding), there are limited alternative options.

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 12:26

oblada · 13/11/2022 12:09

That's an interesting view. I can't agree with that though. Not as part of state funded education.

You don’t need to agree with it. Life isn’t fair. We can’t all afford to do what we want.

Those who can afford it shouldn’t miss out just because others can’t and thankfully that is the default position.

oblada · 13/11/2022 12:22

"The big cost is the staff at the centre." In which case I still fail to see how it differs?
The charity provided some volunteers but the activities were run by the paid staff of the activity ctr.
But again I am not particularly questioning the maths.

OP posts:
Confusedteacher · 13/11/2022 12:17

Sounds about standard to me. You said that on the charity trip you are comparing it to the parents are there- that is a very different ball game! The big cost is the staff at the centre.

I’ve recently come back from a Y7 trip which was a similar price for 2 nights. All activities included such as surfing, high ropes etc. 3 meals a day for 200 kids. Fully qualified instructors at a ratio of 2-3 instructors per group of 10 kids. Evening entertainment also put on by the centre and run by their staff- karaoke, football tournament, talent show. Although we brought teachers obviously there were still duty staff who slept in the centre overnight.

Unfortunately it is what it is, these activities cost a fortune! The kids had an absolute ball though.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/11/2022 12:11

if it covers qualified tuition, equipment, insurance, all food and accommodation, bearing in mind it will be covering the teachers’ costs too, that sounds about right. Comparing to what a charity charges is comparing apples with pears.

ShiningStarQueen · 13/11/2022 12:10

That seems like loads. My DS never went on a school residential as they never had a cheaper one. It was either skiing in the alps for £4k or Alton Towers for the day for £60 (guess what
most parents chose?!) When he’d go away with his rugby club for their yearly weekend away, it was around £50 with all meals included. They’d play rugby funnily enough and do other activities like paintballing and go-karting. I’d send him off with enough snacks to sink a ship as the boys would be up all night eating, of course 😆

oblada · 13/11/2022 12:09

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 11:55

Sorry but we can’t go through life being inclusive about everything.

The cost of the trip is £300. If you can afford that great, if you can’t, that’s unfortunate.

But the trip shouldn’t have to be changed and made cheaper (or not done altogether) simply because not everyone can afford it.

That's an interesting view. I can't agree with that though. Not as part of state funded education.

OP posts:
oblada · 13/11/2022 12:08

Survey99 · 13/11/2022 12:01

But you dont need to do it in a safe centre away from the general public and for 20-30 kids that also need to be fed 3 meals a day, accomodated, supervised 24/7 and kept safe. It is a different prospect entirely and you cannot compare the two.

Actually it is exactly that. Adding special needs to the equation as the charity is designed to support people with a specific condition. It is exclusive use, full board and lodging. The difference is that parents are there so absolutely you can add extra cost for staffing ratios if need be. Not that different at all otherwise and we're talking over 3x the cost here.

OP posts:
lanthanum · 13/11/2022 12:03

Our local authority used to run its own site (in a different area of the country) which reduced costs a great deal. It was tents and a toilet block, and there were staff who were paid for the entire season who ran the activities (kayakking, abseiling, cycling, etc). Some groups went Mon-Fri and others Fri-Mon (I don't know whether some of the latter were non-school groups), and the same buses took one group there and brought the previous one back - so transport costs were nearly halved.

Survey99 · 13/11/2022 12:01

oblada · 13/11/2022 09:25

We've done that 2 months ago so it is a very current comparison.
But yes possibly a charity can do things different. I don't know.

But you dont need to do it in a safe centre away from the general public and for 20-30 kids that also need to be fed 3 meals a day, accomodated, supervised 24/7 and kept safe. It is a different prospect entirely and you cannot compare the two.

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 11:55

Sorry but we can’t go through life being inclusive about everything.

The cost of the trip is £300. If you can afford that great, if you can’t, that’s unfortunate.

But the trip shouldn’t have to be changed and made cheaper (or not done altogether) simply because not everyone can afford it.

itsjustnotok · 13/11/2022 11:54

@oblada i think the Ywar 6 stuff is ridiculous. DD’s school have thought about it a lot and organised something different to the standard residential trip which overall is £100 for the week. The parents are organising the expected ‘American style’ end of year event because the children deserve it. I don’t disagree that it’s lovely to do but that’s another £80. The response if you question affordability is well you have a year nearly. It’s not fair on the children, so you end up feeling forced into it because your child has to stand and watch as their mates go off together in limos. I’ve never know anything like it, given right now we don’t even know what finances are going to look like I really think it should be considered a little more than it is sometimes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread