Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School trip - what is a reasonable cost?

159 replies

oblada · 13/11/2022 09:03

Y6 school trip. Our school is asking for close to £300 for the end of year school trip (2 nights away). It doesn't include transport which is covered with fundraising.
Now I can't complain too much, I can probably afford it. I don't have £300 to burn but I can manage.
But it feels wrong. Especially at the moment.
We're in the North West. Not an affluent part of the country.
I think I have made up my mind about what to do but I would be interested to see what everyone thinks generally on the cost. School is adamant it is a reasonable cost. Most people I discuss it directly with tend to agree with me (but maybe they don't really won't knows).
My own view is that up to £150 per kid is relatively affordable for most, in installments, and should be the max budget for a school trip. Whatever the kids do together will be unforgettable to them. They don't need millions of activities crammed in.
But is that unreasonable? Are other school able to do trips for cheaper than £300 per kid? Our weekends away are far cheaper than £300 per person. Now we don't have to worry about the safety aspects etc but then I'd think they'd be savings in the number of kids involved.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Quitelikeacatslife · 15/11/2022 07:37

Iamnotthe1 · 13/11/2022 22:36

Plenty of school travel companies are desperate for business after the last couple of years and there's a fair bit of bartering to be done.

The OP has said that the price is not including travel. However, even if it was, all of the coach companies in our area have increased their prices by at least 60%. They aren't begging for business. We're having to book months and months in advance just to make sure we can have the days and times we want.

This is so true, they can't get drivers too

Dixiechickonhols · 13/11/2022 23:24

Costs have done up a lot post Covid as centres have shut, staffing issues etc.
My dc has been away with a disability charity and it was majorly subsidised by the charity. Not comparable to a school trip.
Staff costs. It’s not just mrs x taking yr 6 alone. Several staff will go for ratios. So if 3 extra staff go then the school potentially pays for cover for those 3 staff as you can’t leave classes with no staff because teacher/ta helping on trip.
Specialist activities need specialist instructor from a risk assessment point if view.
If teachers are going to run everything it’s very limiting what can do, will probably need more staff plus exhausting and not realistic for a few days.

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 23:07

I don't know. I'd like to think others would do the same as me. Maybe I am ridiculously naive.

They wouldn’t. And you are.

Untitledsquatboulder · 13/11/2022 23:01

In most schools its pretty well known that there is a "big trip" in Y6. That's a lot of years to save up if you think you might want to send your kid.

Iamnotthe1 · 13/11/2022 22:36

Plenty of school travel companies are desperate for business after the last couple of years and there's a fair bit of bartering to be done.

The OP has said that the price is not including travel. However, even if it was, all of the coach companies in our area have increased their prices by at least 60%. They aren't begging for business. We're having to book months and months in advance just to make sure we can have the days and times we want.

shinyshoes5566 · 13/11/2022 22:08

Too much. The school should have shopped around to make the trip more inclusive. Plenty of school travel companies are desperate for business after the last couple of years and there's a fair bit of bartering to be done. Very unfair on lower-income families - and for 2 nights?! That's ridiculous.

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 21:41

So i don't think it's particularly awful as an expectation.

It's an unrealistic expectation. We had a particular cohort that even 10/20/30£ trips weren't largely paid for. We'd get 5/6 parents paying, even though more could afford it. The one's that couldn't was expected and the school was happy to absorb the cost. With so many non payments though, the kids ended up with no school trips bar any free ones as the school couldn't afford to pay for 25 kids to go. No parent ever offered to pay for an extra kid either.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 13/11/2022 21:35

Make sure that you find out if others are going, it would be awful if your child doesn’t go as an act of solidarity with others who can’t afford it to then find out that they are the only one not going.

curious79 · 13/11/2022 21:33

That seems really expensive to me. My daughter’s school are going on an activity week next june and it is five nights away for approximately £340

oblada · 13/11/2022 21:31

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 21:19

As i mentioned up thread I'd be much happier with a £150max budget as I'd expect some parents to be able to then (willingly) contribute to help others.

You may not realise this as the bleeding heart liberal that you are, but nobody else would be paying anything towards other kids going.

That’s an awful expectation to have.

🤣 then I'm a bleeding heart liberal! I never knew that no!
I don't know. I'd like to think others would do the same as me. Maybe I am ridiculously naive. Maybe not.
Also i said that I'd expect people to be able to, willingly, contribute... So i don't think it's particularly awful as an expectation.
But at least with a £150 budget it would still be more accessible anyway, so still a win in my books!

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 21:19

As i mentioned up thread I'd be much happier with a £150max budget as I'd expect some parents to be able to then (willingly) contribute to help others.

You may not realise this as the bleeding heart liberal that you are, but nobody else would be paying anything towards other kids going.

That’s an awful expectation to have.

spirit20 · 13/11/2022 20:56

I'm a teacher who organises school trips, and they've become so much more expensive since the pandemic. Ultimately we don't have control over how much they cost, we just have to charge whatever the total price of everything is. I'm organising a trip to Paris at the moment that's costing over £600 for just three nights, in 2019 it would have been around 400. We've even taken out some activities to reduce the cost and will replace them with some free activities.

To be honest, I think it's a ridiculous price to pay for three nights in Paris, but our school is very keen (i.e. forcing) us to organise it and we can't make it any cheaper.

Blondeshavemorefun · 13/11/2022 20:51

300 for 2 nights seems a lot

know our school does a trip in yr6. Goes to same place every year and I see it on Fb

think they go away for 4 nights but I don’t know what the cost is

makes sense to have a saving plan from yr 4 so can save for 2/3yrs and pay £10 a month of something like that

I know if child is on pp that their money can go go towards the trip in last two years of school as my friend did that year before covid

BooksAndHooks · 13/11/2022 20:39

Ours is Monday to Friday and is around £320. This used to include coach and ferries to Isle of Wight. Post covid this covers a week at a local activity camp and doesn’t include transport.

oblada · 13/11/2022 20:33

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 20:11

@oblada what about the kids whose parents can't afford anything ? Most schools will have some of those at least. By catering to the lowest common denominator, that means schools could only do trips/activities that are local and free or that can be subsidised from the school budget, which doesn't give a lot of wiggle room.

Would you be happy with that?

As i mentioned up thread I'd be much happier with a £150max budget as I'd expect some parents to be able to then (willingly) contribute to help others.
A couple of people mentioned struggling with the £300 cost for ours. I can't do anything except sympathise and explain my child probably won't go as I don't agree with the idea.

If it was £150 I'd happily step in and pay for one more person than mine to go. We don't have to go with zero, everyone is likely to be able to contribute something and if we keep it reasonable then as a group we can include everyone in all likelihood.

OP posts:
catgirl1976 · 13/11/2022 20:27

DS will be having his first residential (Y6) in the Spring. It’s £350 for three nights but that does include transport. I think it’s reasonable and we can it in instalments but it’s still a lot of money. We are also north west

We can afford it though I can’t just throw £350 around without thinking about it. However I’m sure a lot of people can’t. The letter does say if you can’t afford it speak to the school so I assume there is some provision for those who can’t do no child misses out.

yogafairy · 13/11/2022 20:23

My dd's year 6 pgl trip for next year was £395 for 2 nights and we had to do drop off and pick up 'to keep costs down'. There was only a 50% take up so it's been cancelled and replaced with 3 separate days of activities. 2 local activity days ( still have to do pick up and drop off) and 1 day at Chessington. New cost is £150.

Iamnotthe1 · 13/11/2022 20:21

Our school residential is around £300 but it's for 5 days. I also run a youth group which runs a residential for £125 for 8 days. However, with the youth group it is heavily subsidised, in a highly deprived area and we can run things differently thus save in ways that a school can't.

There are a few of things to note here though:

  • children for whom the school receive pupil premium will likely have the costs paid for them (common in schools) which takes care of those with the lowest household incomes.
  • these trips are usually known about far in advance, even if the specific cost that year isn't known, so if cost is a concern, families could have been saving little by little over time if they wished to.
  • schools will typically support those who cannot pay in full before the deadline by either putting them in contact with charities or extending the payment window to include after the residential.
MargaretThursday · 13/11/2022 20:12

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 19:54

And i don't like the idea of people missing out because they can't afford it. It's just not fair.

Life isn’t fair.

If you choose to have children on little to no income you need to accept they will be left out of doing things. Not expect those children to miss out or have a reduced experience.

Life isn't fair, but I don't think school trips are the place to learn that. It's also disproportionally going to be the children who don't get family holidays either who mis out.

It's not always plan-able either.

I know someone who struggled because her oldest was in year 6 (5 day residential at £500) and the twins in year 4 when they decided they'd also do a residential in year 4. (3 day at £300)

She'd carefully saved up for the oldest one, knowing it was coming and was already putting a little away each month so the twins could go in year 6 too.
Adding another £600 at not a lot of notice just made it unfeasible for her.

Actually in that case the school stepped in, which I think is right.

ldontWanna · 13/11/2022 20:11

@oblada what about the kids whose parents can't afford anything ? Most schools will have some of those at least. By catering to the lowest common denominator, that means schools could only do trips/activities that are local and free or that can be subsidised from the school budget, which doesn't give a lot of wiggle room.

Would you be happy with that?

oblada · 13/11/2022 20:05

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 19:54

And i don't like the idea of people missing out because they can't afford it. It's just not fair.

Life isn’t fair.

If you choose to have children on little to no income you need to accept they will be left out of doing things. Not expect those children to miss out or have a reduced experience.

True, life isn't fair and yes some children will have fewer experiences due to parental income. Although I am not keen on your comment about "ha well you choose to have more kids etc". Things like separation, bereavement, mental and physical health (parent or child), loss of job etc are often relevant and are not "choices".
In any event I am not complaining. We can afford more than most probably. But that doesn't mean I agree with it.
I don't think that a school trip should be another opportunity to exclude the less fortunate. There are far too many inequalities already, creating one more on the back of a non educational non necessary trip is, to me, wrong. And i don't think a cheaper trip would be a reduced experience. I actually think it would create a far richer bonding experience than 15 activities crammed over a couple of days.

OP posts:
Meredusoleil · 13/11/2022 20:00

oblada · 13/11/2022 19:45

But for us it doesn't include transport though...

Oh! In that case, it's too expensive imho.

YellowTreeHouse · 13/11/2022 19:54

And i don't like the idea of people missing out because they can't afford it. It's just not fair.

Life isn’t fair.

If you choose to have children on little to no income you need to accept they will be left out of doing things. Not expect those children to miss out or have a reduced experience.

oblada · 13/11/2022 19:51

Tiani4 · 13/11/2022 18:44

@oblada
As I said earlier , lone parent of 3 DCs, I can't afford it
Never have been able to afford £300* trips so mine don't attend those

I've saved yo when they have been £200 for a week on a few occasions but we go without to do so. And right now few people on low incomes with multiple DCs can afford to.

And i don't like the idea of people missing out because they can't afford it. It's just not fair. We should do something together that all the kids can participate in. We certainly try to be as inclusive as possible when it comes to special needs, it should be the same when it comes to income.

We are lucky in that we earn well enough. But we have 4 children incl one with special needs and due to that we have a full time nanny.
So we have fairly hefty outgoings too.

Can I afford the £300? Yes probably, it would be noticed of course as an extra cost but we would manage.
But on balance I don't want to because it just feels wrong. I'm lucky that my child understands and will be fine to miss the trip.

OP posts:
oblada · 13/11/2022 19:45

Meredusoleil · 13/11/2022 18:57

NRTFT

My general rule is around £100 per day, UK less/abroad more.

Dd1 went to Paris recently. 5 days/4 nights. It cost £540.

Dd2 went to Cornwall. 5 days/4 nights. It cost £380.

Apparently, it's the cost of coach hire and fuel that has shot up and is adding to the overall price.

But for us it doesn't include transport though...

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread