Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Printout of cost to NHS

269 replies

1dontunderstand · 13/11/2022 00:16

I don’t think IBU but here goes:

I think every patient should be given a printout of how much their care has cost the NHS.

Every GP visit
Every vaccine for them or their child
Every midwife/health visitor
Every blood test
Every ambulance or A & E visit

I don’t think people have any idea how much their health care costs

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 13/11/2022 16:12

YABU
What would be the point? Personally, it would make me feel awful guilt about what I cost over the years despite the fact I can not help that. I am not the sort to go running to the GP for every tiny ailment.

fjäl · 13/11/2022 16:04

JenniferBooth · 13/11/2022 14:32

OP perhaps members of the public should also do printouts showing all the sacrifices they made during the lockdowns to protect the NHS

I am a member of the public who made sacrifices during lockdown. I also work for the NHS. Everyone made sacrifices.

memorial · 13/11/2022 15:17

Facecream · 13/11/2022 14:23

I’d be up for this when they also print and post to all the patients who attend the clinic of the consultant who sexually assaulted m how they paid me to try to get me to shut up, how much their retainer solicitor is getting for every email sent, how much they will eventually have in legal fees and compensation when my claim ends.

Similarly I’d be happy for them to print my therapy costs and time spent writing to the bunch of arseholes who are defending him.

oh and when they print the amount of costs (legal, compensation, tribunal costs) every time one of their beloved medical staff sexually assaulted people in their care, mistreated them (the doctor who punched a patient in the face)…

then I’ll happily see how much my medical care costs (and my Dd) and I’ll enjoy it.

You really cannot tar every NHS worker with you however tragic experience. That is literally bonkers.

memorial · 13/11/2022 15:15

JenniferBooth · 13/11/2022 14:32

OP perhaps members of the public should also do printouts showing all the sacrifices they made during the lockdowns to protect the NHS

That doesn't even make any sense

JenniferBooth · 13/11/2022 15:10

"But it costs the same to the NHS regardless, the patient knowing or not doesn't change that, but for some it would perhaps make them fight a bit harder to protect the NHS"

a. wow Great way to minimize all the sacrifices made by the public during the lockdowns to protect the NHS.
b. are you admitting that those lockdowns didnt work and didnt actually achieve that protection?!

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 14:57

YANBU

It would also help educate a large chunk of the (mainly older) population who are under the impression they’ve ‘paid their share’

The majority of people in this country will never pay their share towards the NHS, especially if they have children.

Guitarbar · 13/11/2022 14:53

JenniferBooth · 13/11/2022 14:32

OP perhaps members of the public should also do printouts showing all the sacrifices they made during the lockdowns to protect the NHS

Yes because the health service was already teetering on collapse due to years of government neglect and underfunding. If we had a fully functioning and fit for purpose health service, if the pandemic wargame actions had been completed as they should have been, and if services hadn't already been cut to thr none with savage staff shortages then there would have definitely been a degree of 'sacrifice', but not to the extent we saw it. The NHS also isn't a singular entity, personally the blame lies squarely with the government.

EmilyGilmoresSass · 13/11/2022 14:33

What miffs me is people looking for paracetamol on prescription or using Minor Ailments Scheme to get it

JenniferBooth · 13/11/2022 14:32

OP perhaps members of the public should also do printouts showing all the sacrifices they made during the lockdowns to protect the NHS

Facecream · 13/11/2022 14:23

I’d be up for this when they also print and post to all the patients who attend the clinic of the consultant who sexually assaulted m how they paid me to try to get me to shut up, how much their retainer solicitor is getting for every email sent, how much they will eventually have in legal fees and compensation when my claim ends.

Similarly I’d be happy for them to print my therapy costs and time spent writing to the bunch of arseholes who are defending him.

oh and when they print the amount of costs (legal, compensation, tribunal costs) every time one of their beloved medical staff sexually assaulted people in their care, mistreated them (the doctor who punched a patient in the face)…

then I’ll happily see how much my medical care costs (and my Dd) and I’ll enjoy it.

Moonatics · 13/11/2022 13:22

WotsitsMadeIn1927 · 13/11/2022 11:53

I think a lot of people have misunderstood why OP wants people to know the real cost of the NHS.

To make them appreciate it more and understand what they’d be really paying without it.
The difference between the UK and America.
How lucky we really are to have the NHS and how dire things would be without it.

But things are already dire. Choosing to tell me that the last three times I've contacted the NHS has cost x amount when I'm still ill and no sign of it ending will not make me think the NHS is fantastic or how lucky I am to be left in this state, it will make me fucking angry at the waste of money when simply seeing an actual dr could have made me better already.

yoyo1234 · 13/11/2022 13:18

I knew years ago that people were shown to be better at keeping up the medication (completing the course of e.g. antibiotics) etc for their pets than medication prescribed from the NHS. This could be linked with appreciating the costs involved?

Nanatokidsdogshampsters · 13/11/2022 12:43

I don't know about anything else but on the system for prescriptions there is a button the staff can press which will say how much each item costs.

CantFindTheBeat · 13/11/2022 12:00

I'm not against your idea, OP, but what problem at your trying to solve with it?

Whereisthehugeteddybear · 13/11/2022 12:00

I think a lot of people have misunderstood why OP wants people to know the real cost of the NHS.

To make them appreciate it more and understand what they’d be really paying without it.

...but if you give someone that info, you cant control or prescribe how they must feel about it.
Some people will take an interest out of curiosity.
some will feel grateful. Some might not take any notice and think its a waste of paper since its not actually a bill they need to pay. Some will feel guilty at the cost. Some might think they're a burden and might not seek treatment next time....

Guitarbar · 13/11/2022 11:59

Will all be paying soon anyway!! Then people feeling guilty will be replaced by people literally not being able to afford treatment. In the US leading cause of bankruptcy and losing a house etc is apparently a cancer diagnosis :( so sad.

Jonaskahnwaldplease · 13/11/2022 11:58

alexdgr8 · 13/11/2022 00:24

so that's taking a worker away from doing treatment-related work.
and computer systems to gather and collate and spew out all this information.
and then probably a complaints procedure and staff to deal with errors/ disputes as to actual costs...

My job is lliterally to "gather and curate this information " so that part is already being done.

How do you think primary care trusts bill the nhs for work done?

Where do you think the office of national statistics gets it's health data from?

We do it so as not to take " a worker away from doing treatment-related work."

Though yes there would need to be people to deal with disputes.

IncessantNameChanger · 13/11/2022 11:56

To add to my above post and the poster below mine, I was saying to ds that people live longer than they used to. In the UK with the current NHS that's going to change soon. You can't survive a heart attack or stroke waiting hours for an ambulance so we all have to look forward to in old age. Falling and laying on the floor for ten plus hours. Two years on a waiting list. Do this for five years and you naturally decrease SC etc costs. But is it moral? Is what you want for you or your mum? Because let's be honest it saves lots of nhs costs down the line when you can see a gp, get an ambulance etc.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 13/11/2022 11:54

Sone of this information is available. The PSSRU publishes unit costs for e.g cost of an A&E admission, cost of a GP visit, cost of a care home bed

Unit costs health & social care

WotsitsMadeIn1927 · 13/11/2022 11:53

I think a lot of people have misunderstood why OP wants people to know the real cost of the NHS.

To make them appreciate it more and understand what they’d be really paying without it.
The difference between the UK and America.
How lucky we really are to have the NHS and how dire things would be without it.

Moonatics · 13/11/2022 11:51

1dontunderstand · 13/11/2022 00:34

I thought that people would me more mindful and appreciative of the wonderful service they received

In the last 3 weeks I've had the most awful time with GPs and the NHS in general.
A letter telling me how much it cost to not actually treat me would have me raging, then sending a letter back saying I cried at their "treatment" of me and have decided going forward that i am opting out of everything that the NHS offer as standard like breast screening, and will where at all possible use a private drs service if I can possibly afford it at the time. Yay I'm saving the fucking NHS fortune now.

Shiningsilverargent · 13/11/2022 11:50

Some of us have conditions that need medication just to keep us living and regular appointments to support us. How do you think this would make us feel? More importantly, what is it you think the more unscrupulous media outlets might do with information like this? What could be the outcome for people with chronic conditiond and disabilities?

Whereisthehugeteddybear · 13/11/2022 11:50

I can believe that there are a small percentage of people who misuse and abuse the health service (calling ambulances unnecessarily, turning up to A and E with minor ailments that could be treated at home, deliberately missing appointments etc)

However the large majority of people will be trying to use the NHS in the manner it was designed, and the system is failing because people are living longer and surviving illnesses that were previously fatal, which although is a positive thing, it means a far greater numbers are trying to access care than can adequately given.

Add in overworked staff and poor morale , staff leaving, brexit, poorly paid HCPs and carers and not enough investment or resource to update admin or IT systems and that is partly why the NHS is failing for both the people that work within it and the patients it's designed to care for.

The collapse of the NHS is not caused by Janet not bothering to turn up for her GP appointment and Roy turning up at A and E because he has a blister.

IncessantNameChanger · 13/11/2022 11:45

Why? Do you know how much chemo and cancer surgery costs? I think if you was tolerating chemo with a less than garanteed outcome it would make some people guilty into giving up.

Do you know how much I paid in until my dc disability meant I had to "cash out"

Do you know your just one car accident away or stroke away from being several disabled forever? To be viewed by your former self as a parasitic drain?

Do you know how much neonatal intensive care costs? Do you how much the air ambulance costs? Would you refuse the cost if it was you needing your legs amputated at the scene of crash to release you from twisted metal? Do you think the cost is on the Drs mind when they are sawing your legs off while your conscious on the A2?

Please try to imagine a life outside of your own experiences. A few unessary trips to the gp is piss in the ocean to a course of cancer treatment. I personally think everyone should pay a token £5 to see a gp unless on UC but I Don not and never will condone paying trns of thousands to save a premature baby or a mum with cancer.

If we had a set amount on our head of nhs money everyone would die of cancer. Most baby's under 37 weeks would die. People would bleed out in their cars.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/11/2022 11:35

Why? If a person needs treatment, they need treatment. What’s the point of that? It would cost a fortune.

Swipe left for the next trending thread