Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Printout of cost to NHS

269 replies

1dontunderstand · 13/11/2022 00:16

I don’t think IBU but here goes:

I think every patient should be given a printout of how much their care has cost the NHS.

Every GP visit
Every vaccine for them or their child
Every midwife/health visitor
Every blood test
Every ambulance or A & E visit

I don’t think people have any idea how much their health care costs

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Greytea · 16/11/2022 23:54

Biker47 · 16/11/2022 23:35

The people who aren't mindful and appreciative, wouldn't care if you provided them with a list of what it cost, they'd only care if it started coming as a bill.

No, those who aren’t appreciative often don’t appreciate it because they had shocking, negligent, nonexistent “care” that in some cases has shortened their life significantly.

NameChangeForARaisin · 16/11/2022 23:54

You will just guilt trip the sickest people (ie those on the most expensive medications).
Far better to target the dicks who repeatedly DNA (then moan that they have to wait for a rearranged appointment ).

Biker47 · 16/11/2022 23:35

1dontunderstand · 13/11/2022 00:34

I thought that people would me more mindful and appreciative of the wonderful service they received

The people who aren't mindful and appreciative, wouldn't care if you provided them with a list of what it cost, they'd only care if it started coming as a bill.

memorial · 16/11/2022 22:54

Abraxan · 14/11/2022 16:53

Next time the coughing child is actually in resp distres and needs oxygen and admission or the chest pain is a heart attack and needs an ECG drugs and admission or the low mood is acutely suicidal and needs a bit more time and referral to crisis (which can take bloody ages) or the old lady walks in having fallen bleeding all over the floor or the abdo pain is an acute abdo needing 999 or or or.

Whilst most people accept this and understand delays happen, this still doesn't justify recording it as a DNA when someone having to leave after an hour to collect their child or get back to work. A morning's supply cover for me at school costs my schools a lot of money. I can't just leave the children on their own into the afternoon so I have to get back if the supply cover has to leave at lunch time.

I've been the one needing a longer appointment whilst an ambulance was called for me as I was so poorly. But even so, whilst I understand the reason for delays, I don't understand why some medical staff can't understand they not everyone can wait for an hour or more to be seen and that they will need to leave without being seen. That shouldn't be recorded as DNA. You need a new code for this situation if DNA is the only current choice - something for: did attend but appointment ran so late they couldn't wait any longer.

It isn't recorded as a DNA. One person on here said they thought they might have been when they couldn't wait. I dont know a single practice that records people that couldn't wait as DNA. We record those who actually do DNA FGS they don't come or phone or cancel.
Talk about a straw man....

DdraigGoch · 16/11/2022 12:48

bloodyeverlastinghell · 14/11/2022 18:56

That was 😂 I think I might go back and binge watch yes minister.

It is incredibly expensive to care for the elderly. I plan on taking up cigarettes, gin and other disreputable behaviour when Im older. I suspect the state will of embraced euthanasia by then and will gently bump us off anyway.

I might take up extreme sports when I retire. If I have to die attached to an oxygen cylinder, I'd far rather that it was halfway up a mountain than in a care home.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 14/11/2022 18:56

DdraigGoch · 14/11/2022 18:28

And look how it turned out. We are indeed stuffed by the costs of caring for an aging population.

Sir Humphrey was right:

That was 😂 I think I might go back and binge watch yes minister.

It is incredibly expensive to care for the elderly. I plan on taking up cigarettes, gin and other disreputable behaviour when Im older. I suspect the state will of embraced euthanasia by then and will gently bump us off anyway.

DdraigGoch · 14/11/2022 18:28

bloodyeverlastinghell · 14/11/2022 14:02

I remember my tax law professor saying as a country we’d be stuffed if everyone stopped smoking and drinking not only due to decreased tax revenue but also the massive increase in pension/ care bills.

And look how it turned out. We are indeed stuffed by the costs of caring for an aging population.

Sir Humphrey was right:

jtaeapa · 14/11/2022 17:16

1dontunderstand · 13/11/2022 00:16

I don’t think IBU but here goes:

I think every patient should be given a printout of how much their care has cost the NHS.

Every GP visit
Every vaccine for them or their child
Every midwife/health visitor
Every blood test
Every ambulance or A & E visit

I don’t think people have any idea how much their health care costs

Well it certainly wouldn't make any difference to the majority of us who can't even get an appointment. I know how much a GP appointment costs because I've paid privately the last time my ds needed one and I needed one.

Asher33 · 14/11/2022 17:12

I had an appointment today and he was 10 minutes late despite me being his first patient

BosaNova · 14/11/2022 17:09

MarshaBradyo · 14/11/2022 16:45

Now I think of it I did get a breakdown of cost for the one time we used our private healthcare. It was a top consultant and it was high

It did make me think yeh that’s expensive but if you need the service it can’t really change your behaviour

Unless you charge a high amount at initial point of access then I can imagine it would put some people off before getting sicker

The problem is that with lots of people it would change the behaviour because it would come with guilt tripping about NHS use.
It's already happening. There are thousands of people not going to doctors because "it's under stains and we need to protect it" when they need to go before things become worse.
That's my main issue with issuing this information to everyone rather than letting people find out if they want to.

Abraxan · 14/11/2022 16:53

Next time the coughing child is actually in resp distres and needs oxygen and admission or the chest pain is a heart attack and needs an ECG drugs and admission or the low mood is acutely suicidal and needs a bit more time and referral to crisis (which can take bloody ages) or the old lady walks in having fallen bleeding all over the floor or the abdo pain is an acute abdo needing 999 or or or.

Whilst most people accept this and understand delays happen, this still doesn't justify recording it as a DNA when someone having to leave after an hour to collect their child or get back to work. A morning's supply cover for me at school costs my schools a lot of money. I can't just leave the children on their own into the afternoon so I have to get back if the supply cover has to leave at lunch time.

I've been the one needing a longer appointment whilst an ambulance was called for me as I was so poorly. But even so, whilst I understand the reason for delays, I don't understand why some medical staff can't understand they not everyone can wait for an hour or more to be seen and that they will need to leave without being seen. That shouldn't be recorded as DNA. You need a new code for this situation if DNA is the only current choice - something for: did attend but appointment ran so late they couldn't wait any longer.

MarshaBradyo · 14/11/2022 16:45

Now I think of it I did get a breakdown of cost for the one time we used our private healthcare. It was a top consultant and it was high

It did make me think yeh that’s expensive but if you need the service it can’t really change your behaviour

Unless you charge a high amount at initial point of access then I can imagine it would put some people off before getting sicker

Abraxan · 14/11/2022 16:22

Memorial

Not a whole hour?? Wow. I bet the GP was off playing golf or drinking coffee eh?? Shame on them


But not everyone can wait for over an hour. They may have other commitments later in the day such as work appointments, collecting children form school, etc.

We all understand that delays Halle . However no one should be penalised and recorded as DNA if they have to leave after waiting an hour, regardless of what the GP was dealing with.

Surely you understand that?

LoveAngelLove · 14/11/2022 16:11

You can just Google it if you really want to know.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 16:06

What about the people who didn't know they had an appointment? Or the letter notifying them arrived on the day of the appointment

Exactly this my mum had letters arrive about appointments after the date, also they would move appointments about to various different times and then they would end up at same time as the original appointment.

If we start charging for missed appointments, then every appointment better we'll be on time, not my problem whatever reason It is which with GPs it's them walking in door for a day that that starts at 9 at 9.30 and yes I have seen it happen.

Fizbosshoes · 14/11/2022 16:00

IMO when patients miss an appointment without notifying the service they should get a letter sent out explaining the cost of that appointment.

What about the people who didn't know they had an appointment? Or the letter notifying them arrived on the day of the appointment or days after the appointment? Or those who tried to cancel but weren't able due to online systems or that called up to cancel and it wasn't noted. These are also regular occurrences. (There have been several threads about them)

Although it's much easier to keep blaming patients rather than address a system as huge as the NHS.

PeloFondo · 14/11/2022 15:59

I know I cost a fortune, I don't need telling!
One of my drugs alone is £6000 a year
Another is £7800 a year
That's before bloods, other meds, GP appointments, being seen by 2 consultants... I'm very grateful

NewNameWhoDis2 · 14/11/2022 15:47

Something should be done though about missed appointments.

It's not enough to just stick up a generic notice in the waiting room for everyone who is actually there to read.

IMO when patients miss an appointment without notifying the service they should get a letter sent out explaining the cost of that appointment.

Don't make people feel bad for the service they rightly use and are entitled to use and pay for via tax. Show the consequences to the people who abuse and pisstake by costing the NHS money and preventing another patient from being seen.

And before anyone says 'and how much will that cost to do?' not much. The clinician who was supposed to be seeing that patient can do it in seconds. And hopefully over time it would reduce the number of missed appointments.

NewNameWhoDis2 · 14/11/2022 15:44

MCHammersmutha · 13/11/2022 05:08

A few of the local gps used to (precovid) total the monthly missed appointments and place them on the waiting room wall to let people see how much wasted appointments there were from people just not showing up. Don't know if it made any difference though. I'm a nurse and the blasé attitude from patients who didn't go to hospital or gp appointments and not make any attempt to cancel them, used to make me so mad.

I work for the NHS. Every week I am expected to see 20 hour long sessions, so I have to book in 25-30 because we know every day every clinician will get at least one appointment either DNAed or cancelled at such short notice we can't do anything else with it. The cost to the service and the NHS as a whole is sickening. It's not like we need that empty time either to cope, on the rare occasion every attends it's absolutely fine. Some people just don't care. They just don't.

BosaNova · 14/11/2022 15:18

You absolutely don't have to. Understandable!
Yeah, some people genuinely would believe they are forever debted to the health service, so just wanted to make sure 😁

Lampedsomeoiks · 14/11/2022 15:16

BosaNova · 14/11/2022 14:20

I guess I owe them more than a pound of flesh.

"Them" who @Lampedsomeoiks . The healthcare system is just that. A healthcare system to ensure people have healthcare. That is it's primary function. You don't own helathcare system pound of flesh, it did what it is supposed to.
If you are talking about some great doctors and nurses, that's different, but it's their job afterall so while gratitude for job well done and kidness is totally fine, you still don't own them pound of flesh😉

Figure of speech.

And I don't have much positivity to exude and bestow to those that did what they did to me plus how they referenced me (I obtained all medical notes 0-18 years). I can't and won't go into specifics due to the nature of what it was and the fact it would possibly help to identify me due to the rarity etc.

Lampedsomeoiks · 14/11/2022 14:25

To add to further accounts of poor treatment.

My mum nearly died of appendicitis due to the utter incompetency and negligence of numerous doctors and nurses.

She was fobbed off as having a stomach bug until two weeks later she was hospitalised with pain that even morphine would not touch. She was writhing around on the floor all whilst nurses stood around not calling for a doctor. I was told off for bringing flowers to her room however.

It got to 1am where a registrar had to force a consultant to operate. This is where they found 2 litres of poison.

How she didn't die is a miracle. And then to top it an ICU nurse wouldn't give her a drink as she was "too busy".

MarshaBradyo · 14/11/2022 14:24

I think the mh impact makes it a no goer

People will feel awful and lack control over it anyway, poor mh costs more eventually

BosaNova · 14/11/2022 14:20

I guess I owe them more than a pound of flesh.

"Them" who @Lampedsomeoiks . The healthcare system is just that. A healthcare system to ensure people have healthcare. That is it's primary function. You don't own helathcare system pound of flesh, it did what it is supposed to.
If you are talking about some great doctors and nurses, that's different, but it's their job afterall so while gratitude for job well done and kidness is totally fine, you still don't own them pound of flesh😉

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 14:17

@bloodywhitecat
If someone had presented me with a breakdown of costs for DH's 'wonderful' care after his last stay in hospital I don't think I would've been responsible for my actions. His 'care' from the start to the finish of his cancer journey fell far short of wonderful and I am now a widow.

Same here but my mum, the care was shoddy, and the GP delays through incompetence which could have contributed to her death, no I would livid with a breakdown of costs.

Whilst we have many great people in the NHS let's not pretend there isn't a lot of incompetence there too. The difference between this and normal jobs is this costs people's lifes.