Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD’s friends parents don't need to know about DP’s past? *potential TW?*

636 replies

xidol70080 · 12/11/2022 22:12

I'm pretty sure I posted about DP before when he was first released from prison and MN was helpful then but I've since deleted that account so I can't find the thread, some of you may remember.

Some background. I was with DDs dad (now 4) for a few months at 16, I then found out I was pregnant and we stayed together. On his 17th birthday, he was drunk and stole his dads car and crashed, his best friend sadly died and he was sent to prison. I split up with him as I was very angry and upset. He was released from prison in late 2020 (when I posted on here) and I took DD to see him, he was very remorseful and told me he wanted to be in DD’s life. I moved in with him and his dad in at the start of lockdown so DD could build a relationship with her dad and so I could get some support as I don't see my own family.

Me and him got back together in March 2021, me and DD stayed living with him and his dad, he got a job and everything relationship wise has been good. Me, him and DD moved into our own house this summer (we were saving whilst living at his dads).

DD started reception in September and has had a few playdates, one of my friends has never been happy with DD having contact with DP let alone us getting back together, so we don't talk much but this evening she messaged and asked how DD is getting on at school, has she made friends etc so I told her she has. She then asked if I mentioned DP’s past to her friends’ parents, I said no and she has said if she had a child, she'd want to know so she could judge whether to allow her child around him. Some of the parents have met him and have made their judgements without knowing.

AIBU in thinking they don't need to know something that happened when DP was still legally classed as a child, he's now 21, and it's been 5 years since it happened. Or if you were her friends parents would you want to know?

OP posts:
Naunet · 14/11/2022 09:36

Wow, just a couple of years for drink driving and killing a kid? I feel for the poor family who lost their child.

HelensToenail · 14/11/2022 09:31

CecilyP · 14/11/2022 09:10

About 4 or 5 pages back several PP posted about different reparative acts this young man could do, to at least in part to redeem himself - the OP didn't respond and the ideas didn't get any purchase from other posters either.

While these are valuable schemes, they are fairly niche, depend on funding, and probably couldn’t be done by someone with a full time job . It also takes someone with a certain kind of outgoing personality to cart it off.

I agree with you - uncommon and costly ATM but that's a choice that's been made by us/ our society

The Maori tribal/family group conference type projects are sometimes better suited to people with certain skills/personalities

Nonetheless reparative interventions have been proven to be helpful to both offenders and the rest of society

My point really was that it wasn't even acknowledged as a possibility

CecilyP · 14/11/2022 09:10

About 4 or 5 pages back several PP posted about different reparative acts this young man could do, to at least in part to redeem himself - the OP didn't respond and the ideas didn't get any purchase from other posters either.

While these are valuable schemes, they are fairly niche, depend on funding, and probably couldn’t be done by someone with a full time job . It also takes someone with a certain kind of outgoing personality to cart it off.

CecilyP · 14/11/2022 09:02

I’d teach about drink driving in GCSE physics lessons - pointing out how long it takes to stop a car at various speeds, and how drink/ drugs affect the way you drive, and reaction times etc.

Interestingly, when I was a SAHM and there were only 4 tv channels, I watched a school maths series that related maths to everyday life. There was one that showed how much your reactions slowed with different levels of drink and was definitely related to driving. I’ve no idea if it would have affected drink driving levels among the generation that watched it.

I’d also point out that teenage drivers are involved in a disproportionate number of road accidents. This is even the case where no drink is involved and the car is being driven legally. One contributory factor is having other young people in the car.

HelensToenail · 14/11/2022 08:57

Stripedbag101 · 14/11/2022 07:22

I am simply responding to all the people who are dismissing what happened as a childhood mistake. Who are clearly implying that what happened doesn’t in any way speak to his character. It does.

yes he was punished - and while OP says he is sorry I have no idea if that is true or not.

a lot of people are very quick to say what happened wants a big deal. It has to be a big deal - becomes so many people are killed by these type of actions.

if we as a society say it’s okay let’s all move on then the deterrent isn’t there.

reckless acts which result in a loss of life have to be a Shadow over people’s lives. I have read articles about people who have committed these types of devastating crimes. One man killed his friend and he was left in a wheel chair. He travels round schools taking about the life long impacts of what he did. To show young people it isn’t a case of a year in prison then bang life starts again. He wants to stop young people joyriding and drunk driving brocade it is so devastating and the slate is never wiped clean.

sorry this is a huge personal issue for me. I am also entitled to my views and we should be able to debate issues without becoming personal and attacking each others characters.

I agree with much of what you say but reparation and indeed prevention don't play a large part in our current criminal justice system. About 4 or 5 pages back several PP posted about different reparative acts this young man could do, to at least in part to redeem himself - the OP didn't respond and the ideas didn't get any purchase from other posters either

A while ago I was involved with a YOT team doing work with young joyriders before they killed themselves or other people - the project was shelved not because it was ineffective but because it was costly and seen to be in some ways rewarding antisocial behaviour.

These are the political choices we've made as a society and these are the costs

I must say I'm irked by the 'he was only a child' refrain - a child to me is under 12
and it's usual to call 17 yr olds 'young people' or even 'young adults'. Obviously, adulthood is not an event but a process taking place over 10 years or so with different social, psychological and legal milestones along the way.

WRT to legal milestones - it's good to remember that10 is the age of criminal responsibility in the UK. So being an actual child doesn't remove being responsible for immature, impulsive criminal acts etc
The CJS acknowledges this by treating young people between 10 and 18 differently - doing preventative work via YOT, sentencing guidelines, housing them separately from adult criminals in YOI, and writing off some convictions committed before the age of 18 etc

So 17yr olds aren't children in the eyes of the law - they're 'not adults' but they're 'youths'

And mitigating factors of which there maybe many don't generally detract from knowing the difference between right and wrong so responsibility remains

To my mind a lot of this discussion has been more about social stigma rather that the safety of 4 yr olds on playdates - parents don't want their children mixing with 'criminal' families/individuals and being tainted by the social contagion of so doing. And that's a real risk for parents to negotiate.

I'll get off my soap-box now

Flutterbybudget · 14/11/2022 08:24

From a personal point of view, I see the awful fact that his friend died, almost as irrelevant, or “luck of the draw”. The fact is that drink (and drug) driving is still common place, and if we all ostracised anyone who had ever got behind the wheel of a car, while over the drink driving limit, we would be living much more isolated lives. That’s not to belittle the crime at all. And the victim impact is huge. But that doesn’t actually change what he did.
Again, a personal opinion, is that EVERY drink/ drug drive offence should be treated as if someone lost their life. I’d teach about drink driving in GCSE physics lessons - pointing out how long it takes to stop a car at various speeds, and how drink/ drugs affect the way you drive, and reaction times etc.
I’m really glad for the whole family, that he HAS learned from his actions, and has changed as a result, and I really don’t see the need to continue to beat him up over it, it sounds as if he’s done enough of that himself. He will live with the guilt for the rest of his life. He will live with the weight of his friends family behind him. He doesn’t need the judgement of strangers and nor should his DC.

Spidey66 · 14/11/2022 08:23

I'm in 2 minds.

I got arrested at 16 for stealing a couple of lipsticks from Boots and got a police caution. It scared the living daylights out of me, I was very sorry and 40 years later have never repeated it. I was a stupid kid who made a stupid mistake, and of course it shouldn't follow me around into adulthood. BUT my stupid mistake did not cause someone else to die, and as several decades have past it is apparent I've grown up. It does sound like he's learnt from it, I'd hope to give him the benefit of the doubt, but I'd understand why people would be wary.

I've got splinters in my bumper from sitting on the fence. Sorry.

CecilyP · 14/11/2022 08:21

we can’t just shrug our shoulder and say boys will be boys. We have to be outraged. This has to be appalling - there has to be shame attached to drunk driving and joyriding. It has to stop.

Of course there has to be but if people don’t let their kids play with the DD because of this how does that make it stop? She would be the one being punished; how exactly would that help?

Katelyn88 · 14/11/2022 08:16

Block that friend. Clearly a bitch!

Stripedbag101 · 14/11/2022 08:15

We will agree to differ.

while I very difficult watch, I thought the adverts which asked people if they could live with the shame of killing a child were excellent. They really rammed home that if you get behind a wheel drunk or drive recklessly the consequences are live long.

I remember when drunk driving was routine. I am pleased that it is now seen as shameful.

CecilyP · 14/11/2022 08:14

Not saying I wouldnt let my dc be friends with their dd but I would want to know so it would be on my terms until I was comfortable with both the parents.

I doubt they need your friendship on your terms; it’s a play date with a school friend not a lifelong commitment. Small children are fickle, probably having different friends in Y1 to YR. You are not important enough for them to wait for your evaluation.

TheMorigoul · 14/11/2022 08:07

I don't agree at all with reckless acts have to follow you around. Shame is an awful burden to carry. The New Zealand tribal restorative way is excellent at punishing and then integrating the person back into the tribe and has much lower rates of reoffending when done without the authorities involved. The UK reoffending rate is extremely high. Prison doesn't stop reoffending, it's there to keep the lynch mob type of people happy.

I don't even believe this young man shouldn't ever have another alcoholic drink. He's repented his mistake. He's gone to prison for his best friends life. He deserves to move on and not have this follow him around for the rest of his life. Shame doesn't equal good behaviour. Feeling bad about yourself leads to all kinds of issues.

Stripedbag101 · 14/11/2022 07:22

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 23:36

"We have to be outraged. This has to be appalling - there has to be shame attached to drunk driving and joyriding. It has to stop."

Ok @Stripedbag101 how much shame do we give someone who's made that poor choice 5 years ago, shown remorse, tried to turn their life around and now no longer drinks or drives. How should we shame them? What exactly would you suggest? And when exactly have they been shamed enough that they can go on with their lives? Or do we shame them endlessly forever? Make sure their job opportunities, mental health, families and prospects all suffer for the rest of their life until they die of old age? What exactly would you suggest?

I am simply responding to all the people who are dismissing what happened as a childhood mistake. Who are clearly implying that what happened doesn’t in any way speak to his character. It does.

yes he was punished - and while OP says he is sorry I have no idea if that is true or not.

a lot of people are very quick to say what happened wants a big deal. It has to be a big deal - becomes so many people are killed by these type of actions.

if we as a society say it’s okay let’s all move on then the deterrent isn’t there.

reckless acts which result in a loss of life have to be a Shadow over people’s lives. I have read articles about people who have committed these types of devastating crimes. One man killed his friend and he was left in a wheel chair. He travels round schools taking about the life long impacts of what he did. To show young people it isn’t a case of a year in prison then bang life starts again. He wants to stop young people joyriding and drunk driving brocade it is so devastating and the slate is never wiped clean.

sorry this is a huge personal issue for me. I am also entitled to my views and we should be able to debate issues without becoming personal and attacking each others characters.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 06:02

You can see how public hangings were so well attended.
He has been to prison and paid the penalty. He is now moving on and attempting a better life.
Isn’t that the whole point of our penal system?

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2022 04:08

Isn't it funny how a 17 year old in other threads, say about exams, work, paying board blah blah - is still very much a child in the eyes of MN'ers... but as soon as a crime is committed, particularly if they're male - they are an adult!

I can't see why anyone else needs to know - they are not employing him, they are not leaving their children to get into his car with him driving, they are not leaving their children in his care.

He doesn't drink or drive now. Exactly what risk does he pose as a direct result of his crime, which he has been punished for sufficiently in the eyes of the legal system?

Your friend is being malicious and I'd warn her strongly to shut her fucking trap or don't bother speaking to me again. She's not protecting anyone from anyone, she is shit stirring.

Survey99 · 14/11/2022 00:28

Sorry, should have been clearer. Living together again so quickly with a child who grew into a man in prison. She had no idea how that experience would have impacted him. Obviously he should be allowed visitation, supervised initially.

saraclara · 14/11/2022 00:26

If you're still reading, OP, a lot of the responses on this thread deomnstrate the exact reason why you should not tell people about your DH's past. If the proportion of parents who wouldn't want their child having anything to do with you and your child is the same as it is on here, your DD's schools life will be miserable.

You'll be the subject of gossip from people you don't even know, and it will be to no purpose whatsoever. Please don't do this to your child.

saraclara · 14/11/2022 00:21

I would also be concerned with a woman who let that man back into her own daughters life

He's her father, FFS. And obviously no danger to her at all. OP would have no right or reason to keep him from her.

Survey99 · 14/11/2022 00:11

AIBU in thinking they don't need to know something that happened when DP was still legally classed as a child

He was nearly an adult, but if you want to minimise by classing him as a child, then also say he killed a child.

I would want to know if my child was spending time with a man recently released from prison. Especially one convicted of a serious crime causing a death and spent his young adult years growing into a man in a prison environment. I would also be concerned with a woman who let that man back into her own daughters life so quickly and readily because she felt she had no other support.

Not saying I wouldnt let my dc be friends with their dd but I would want to know so it would be on my terms until I was comfortable with both the parents.

saraclara · 13/11/2022 23:41

there has to be shame attached to drunk driving and joyriding. It has to stop.

And he is ashamed. And he has reformed. The incident happened a quarter of his life ago and he seems to be rehabilitated, is working and stepping up to being a decent partner and a caring Dad.

I'm not sure what people want. For all the talk of rehabilitation, it seems that people would prefer that it didn''t happen, and that everyone get full life imprisonment or when they leave prison they should wear an 'EX-CON' tee shirt at all times so that we all know what they did.

What he did was terrible. If it was my child that died, of course I'd find it close to impossible to forgive him.
But our justice system sentenced him within the rules and guidance for his offence, he's come out of prison a changed person, and he should be allowed to continue that path. It's not down to the schooparent community to continue to punish him and his four year old child.

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 23:36

"We have to be outraged. This has to be appalling - there has to be shame attached to drunk driving and joyriding. It has to stop."

Ok @Stripedbag101 how much shame do we give someone who's made that poor choice 5 years ago, shown remorse, tried to turn their life around and now no longer drinks or drives. How should we shame them? What exactly would you suggest? And when exactly have they been shamed enough that they can go on with their lives? Or do we shame them endlessly forever? Make sure their job opportunities, mental health, families and prospects all suffer for the rest of their life until they die of old age? What exactly would you suggest?

Stripedbag101 · 13/11/2022 23:23

It’s not dramatic language - it’s what happened. Someone was killed. He was driving. He killed his passenger.

i am shocked at the number of people on this thread minimising what happened.

we can’t just shrug our shoulder and say boys will be boys. We have to be outraged. This has to be appalling - there has to be shame attached to drunk driving and joyriding. It has to stop.

Ponoka7 · 13/11/2022 23:15

Lots of dramatic language around him killing someone. He caused the death by being the driver. His friend who died, also chose to steal a car and be a passenger, while his friend was drunk. If either had been alone, it might not have happened. It could have just as easily been the OP's partner who died. They were both culpriral, sadly one paid with his life, the other with his liberty.

OP, don't tell the child while still at primary, they won't be able to process it safely. Don't tell anyone else. I think that your friend is a bit pissed off that life is working out and wants to burst your bubble. Ditch her. There's a few on this thread who'd like to see your world come crashing down. Keep your focus on your immediate family and growing together.

Stripedbag101 · 13/11/2022 23:04

Dontlikeveg · 13/11/2022 22:52

So according to your well thought out load of rubbish, what do you predict could possibly happen during an in-house play date, that he has a drink then drives a car through the front door into the sitting room and crashes the car killing children!!! Unbelievable. Very scary to think it's unqualified members of the public like you attending jury service.

its that his crime speaks to his character and his judgement.

he was a joy rider who drunkenly killed someone.

does he have any sense of right and wrong. Will he assess risk in the way parents if a small child will expect? Does he associates with other joyriders, or criminals he met in prison?

juries are asked to take someone previous character into account. That is what is happening here. His character is the issue.

Dontlikeveg · 13/11/2022 22:52

MrsTerryPratchett · 12/11/2022 22:19

Well it hasn't even been 5 years. And talking about it as 'when he was a child' and 'his friend sadly died' is really minimising. Which won't be helping your friend think you take it very seriously. There's an awful lot of trauma with him killing his friend and then prison, I think I'd be a bit worried too.

If you don't want to tell people, it's reasonable not to have in-house play dates, don't leave him in sole care of any DC, just be the parent who is there, rather than him.

Bear in mind that things get out.

So according to your well thought out load of rubbish, what do you predict could possibly happen during an in-house play date, that he has a drink then drives a car through the front door into the sitting room and crashes the car killing children!!! Unbelievable. Very scary to think it's unqualified members of the public like you attending jury service.