Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD’s friends parents don't need to know about DP’s past? *potential TW?*

636 replies

xidol70080 · 12/11/2022 22:12

I'm pretty sure I posted about DP before when he was first released from prison and MN was helpful then but I've since deleted that account so I can't find the thread, some of you may remember.

Some background. I was with DDs dad (now 4) for a few months at 16, I then found out I was pregnant and we stayed together. On his 17th birthday, he was drunk and stole his dads car and crashed, his best friend sadly died and he was sent to prison. I split up with him as I was very angry and upset. He was released from prison in late 2020 (when I posted on here) and I took DD to see him, he was very remorseful and told me he wanted to be in DD’s life. I moved in with him and his dad in at the start of lockdown so DD could build a relationship with her dad and so I could get some support as I don't see my own family.

Me and him got back together in March 2021, me and DD stayed living with him and his dad, he got a job and everything relationship wise has been good. Me, him and DD moved into our own house this summer (we were saving whilst living at his dads).

DD started reception in September and has had a few playdates, one of my friends has never been happy with DD having contact with DP let alone us getting back together, so we don't talk much but this evening she messaged and asked how DD is getting on at school, has she made friends etc so I told her she has. She then asked if I mentioned DP’s past to her friends’ parents, I said no and she has said if she had a child, she'd want to know so she could judge whether to allow her child around him. Some of the parents have met him and have made their judgements without knowing.

AIBU in thinking they don't need to know something that happened when DP was still legally classed as a child, he's now 21, and it's been 5 years since it happened. Or if you were her friends parents would you want to know?

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 14/11/2022 11:55

I would want to know.

IAmAReader · 14/11/2022 11:53

ilyx · 13/11/2022 03:39

Why on earth are you bringing up some random States in USA?! You’re British and you’re pretending not to know the law in your own country and pretending you think it might also be a crime here, yet you know that in a couple of States in America the passenger could also get in trouble? What does that have to do with anything?! We aren’t the USA!!

In some States women are also jailed for having an abortion?! Shall we do that here too?! It’s so pathetic of you. So the passenger is almost as bad as the drunk driver because in a country thousands of miles away from us, not even on the same continent, in a few states within that country, a passenger can also get in trouble. Ridiculous.

As I said, which you completely ignored just to be rude and goady is that even if it's NOT illegal here there are still moral implications of this. You completely picked apart two lines of what I said and disregarded the main point which I making which is it's irresponsible and morally wrong as well as unwise to be getting into stolen cars especially if the driver is drunk. If anyone on the road was mowed down by this car I'm sure they'd be angry at both the teens in the car.

Re. your faux outrage at mentioning America - although spent more of my life here I used to live there and still spend a lot of time there and have dual nationality. My point bringing it up was it's not completely far fetched for this to be considered a crime, I was sure on the law there regarding this but not sure about here...but if it's not a crime here in the UK fair enough but don't tell me what I'm pretending to know.

That aside, I genuinely was not sure if someone getting into the car of a drunk person who had stolen a car had criminal culpability in the UK, and if the case is that they don't personally I think they should.

However the main thrust of my argument still stands re. making a wrong decision to get into the car. Just because something is legal it doesn't make it morally or ethically right or wise and sadly in this case poor decisions all round had tragic consequences for one young person and I repeat this is NOT saying he had it coming.

saraclara · 14/11/2022 11:50

don't let people shame you into disclosing this information. It won't help anyone but it will hurt your daughter. This is not a truth that you owe anyone.

Yes. And I can't say it strongly enough, having read the comments on this thread. There are people who will never let your DH live his life normally, and will happily see your child suffer for it.

For the record, over the last few years I have appointed two people with prison sentences in their relatively recent past. They are now among our most valued and trusted employees. At the time of their appointment of course their record was not shared with anyone else in the organisation. But in both cases, over time, those people have felt able to trust their colleagues (we are a very small organisation) have been open about their past and have been accepted without question. But it was their choice to do that, and no-one should ever feel pressured to disclose completed sentences (though obviously serious sexual ones will have to be).

FallingsHowIFeel · 14/11/2022 11:48

You have no idea about most people your kids come into contact with.

You don’t, but I think as you talk to people and get a feel for how they speak to their children and listen their views on certain things, you can often judge their character.

In this case, a dad that has driven under the influence of alcohol and a mum that has got back with him and showed poor judgement, I bet that there would be things I would pick up on that would mean I wouldn’t want them anywhere near my child.

Tessabelle74 · 14/11/2022 11:42

@Stripedbag101 would you rather he wore a t shirt for the rest of his life with it written on to make sure he never moves on? In that case, are you saying that prison is pointless as even serving your time doesn't atone for mistakes? That rehabilitation doesn't exist?

steppemum · 14/11/2022 11:37

Fattoushi · 14/11/2022 11:26

What a bizarre take....you often don't know about people's pasts, so when you do know, you shouldn't care.
Mental.

what an interesting interpretation of something I didn't say.

And no I am not 'mental' (what a disgusting phrase that is,)

My point was simply that you never know what is in anyone's past or present. The idea that you can filter all your kids encounters is a myth. They are going to come into contact with many people with a past.

You do not have the right to know at all. And you simply don't know.

It is a bizarre idea that you would know what is in everyone's background.

Of course you care when you find out, and take steps accordingly, but that still leaves all the people that you don't know about.

While you are busy protecting them from person A, they have regular encounters with person B who seemed so nice....

fairycakes1234 · 14/11/2022 11:32

BabyBumps2 · 14/11/2022 11:28

There's too much baying for blood on this thread. I'm out of here.

Op, I wish you and your family all the best. Again, don't let people shame you into disclosing this information. It won't help anyone but it will hurt your daughter. This is not a truth that you owe anyone.

Totally agree

fairycakes1234 · 14/11/2022 11:32

BornIn78 · 12/11/2022 22:27

His best friend didn’t “sadly die”, he was killed by your drunk DP, only a few years ago.

I agree with a PP, if you don’t want to tell anyone then don’t have play dates at your home, don’t have him driving anyone else’s children around other than your own, and don’t leave him unsupervised with any child other than your own.

he was in the car with him? He has paid the price, stop being so judgemental

BabyBumps2 · 14/11/2022 11:28

There's too much baying for blood on this thread. I'm out of here.

Op, I wish you and your family all the best. Again, don't let people shame you into disclosing this information. It won't help anyone but it will hurt your daughter. This is not a truth that you owe anyone.

Fattoushi · 14/11/2022 11:26

steppemum · 14/11/2022 11:25

What I find interesting about this thread is that there will be many parents that your dc come into contact with that have a past (or evena present)

You are completely unaware of any of that. eg a family in domestic violence.
Many many parents will have points on their licence for speeding. Some may have points for being over the limit. Some may have points for things like jumping a red light.

It is interesting that people think that they have the right to know.

One family we know has 2 boys. The older one was close friend of dd1 and by coincidence the younger one was a close friend of dd2. They often played together. Usually at our house and if it was at theirs I stayed for a cup of tea, didn't leave the kids there because I wasn't 100% comfortable with the Dad. That family were friends with my dds through a divorce, and both remarried etc.

Suddenly kids were with mum 100% and dad off the scence. Mum eventually told me that he was arrested for abuse to his step daughters.

You have no idea about most people your kids come into contact with.

What a bizarre take....you often don't know about people's pasts, so when you do know, you shouldn't care.
Mental.

steppemum · 14/11/2022 11:25

What I find interesting about this thread is that there will be many parents that your dc come into contact with that have a past (or evena present)

You are completely unaware of any of that. eg a family in domestic violence.
Many many parents will have points on their licence for speeding. Some may have points for being over the limit. Some may have points for things like jumping a red light.

It is interesting that people think that they have the right to know.

One family we know has 2 boys. The older one was close friend of dd1 and by coincidence the younger one was a close friend of dd2. They often played together. Usually at our house and if it was at theirs I stayed for a cup of tea, didn't leave the kids there because I wasn't 100% comfortable with the Dad. That family were friends with my dds through a divorce, and both remarried etc.

Suddenly kids were with mum 100% and dad off the scence. Mum eventually told me that he was arrested for abuse to his step daughters.

You have no idea about most people your kids come into contact with.

BabyBumps2 · 14/11/2022 11:24

FallingsHowIFeel · 14/11/2022 11:13

I don’t think the poster does, it reads as though she would like it to be taught in physics lessons doesn’t it?

My kids learnt about the effect of alcohol and other drugs on the body and how it can affect driving amongst other things in Biology lessons. Also in personal development classes as part of staying safe and being responsible.

I think it’s a dreadful crime to commit, up there with the worst of them and there should be a stigma.

Oh I missed that little "would". Anyway, it's a great idea and I agree that how alcohol affects your driving should he rammed in at every opportunity that school (and parents) get.

I agree that there should be a stigma when people do drink and drive. Social rules can be stronger motivators than legal ones.

I totally disagree that someone who has committed this particular crime (with tragic consequences), has paid for it and is now trying to build his life again should be punished again and again..I totally disagree that his daughter should be punished for his crime.

BabyBumps2 · 14/11/2022 11:15

Fattoushi · 14/11/2022 10:50

I think you are both missing the point. I don't care about his remorse, or guilt, or his feelings on others judging him. I'm not even particularly judging him....but the questions asked included people sending their kids to his house to play.

I can judge all the fuck I like when it comes to who is looking after my child. I can decide, for any reason I choose, that someone is not good enough to do that. I can certainly decide that I don't want a young drunk driving killer to be a babysitter.

What's more, all of you talking about unfair judgements would think the exact same thing if it was your actual child and not a hypothetical argument on the internet!

Of course you can judge all you like and have preferences on who looks after or spends time in the presence of your child.

The question though is does the op have a moral obligation to disclose this information to you and my opinion is no she doesn't. We all make judgment calls on what info to disclose to others and most of us wouldn't dream of listing every possible lapse of judgment we have shown or every bad decision we have made. I had an abortion many years ago and for many years I believed this made me unfit to not just be a mother but look after a child. I think most of you would agree it doesn't but that's what I thought back then. It is now that I see that it has nothing to do with how much I value the life of a living person and because of my constant underlying feeling of guilt to actually try harder to be careful and responsible.

This is slightly similar in that it involves death and therefore brings out a lot of emotional responses and knee jerk reactions. Someone died. We want something so huge to have a big impact. We identify with the family of the victim and think there need to be severe consequences for causing so.much pain but you have to ask yourself honestly what risk does op's partner pose to other children? Especially considering he doesn't drink anymore and doesn't drive?

The fact that op has decided to arrange the play date means that she personally believes she can ensure the safety of your child. Just as I decide every time we have a child over that I can provide a safe environment. I don't ask other parents. I just make this decision myself. As you all do. Why should this little girl be made to suffer when op clearly believes that her partner is no danger, that this information has no bearing on how safe another child is around him? Do I have to tell every parent whose child I ever look after that I've once had an abortion just because someone because of their own views and beliefs (mistakenly) thinks that it makes a difference to how responsible I am?

Guilt is a strong motivator. Being responsible for someone or something not being alive has a massive impact on how you view death. You start to understand that you can be the cause of something so big. That something you do can deprive someone / something of their life. Who knows. Maybe because of his experiences and because of what he has done op's partner is actually the safest person to be around.

FallingsHowIFeel · 14/11/2022 11:13

BabyBumps2 · 14/11/2022 11:01

I love that you use your physics lesson to teach about drink driving. Brilliant and really inspired. I hope my kids will have lots of teachers like you!!

I don’t think the poster does, it reads as though she would like it to be taught in physics lessons doesn’t it?

My kids learnt about the effect of alcohol and other drugs on the body and how it can affect driving amongst other things in Biology lessons. Also in personal development classes as part of staying safe and being responsible.

I think it’s a dreadful crime to commit, up there with the worst of them and there should be a stigma.

Cw112 · 14/11/2022 11:08

HelensToenail · 14/11/2022 10:55

Forgiveness doesn't seem to feature much here

In the OPs posts on this thread and her previous one in 2020 she has repeatedly stressed how remorseful he is - the judge took his remorse into account as a mitigating factor in sentencing

Unintentionally killing your best friend is surely emotionally a potentional life sentence

Perhaps, the best friends family and friends have been able to forgive him - I hope so

Obviously every family is different and circumstances are different, but the last funeral I went to both families were in attendance with each other because they knew their kids were friends who cared about each other and would never have intentionally set out to hurt one another. They were stupid and reckless and in that instance both lost their lives as a result.

I strongly agree with pps who have argued that we need to be educating young people around the risks and dangers so they can start to process the consequences to their actions in advance. And funding is the huge issue there. Brexit has most charities in my area on their knees and this is the consequences of that- there's really good work there to be doing that we can't get at because we need the money to do it and that affects entire communities. Young people need a redirect, if they grow up disillusioned and seeing all their mates joyriding for the crack regularly then they're not going to stop and think about actually I could seriously harm someone- they're thinking it'll never happen to me. So they need a place and a way to learn and process that.

BabyBumps2 · 14/11/2022 11:01

Flutterbybudget · 14/11/2022 08:24

From a personal point of view, I see the awful fact that his friend died, almost as irrelevant, or “luck of the draw”. The fact is that drink (and drug) driving is still common place, and if we all ostracised anyone who had ever got behind the wheel of a car, while over the drink driving limit, we would be living much more isolated lives. That’s not to belittle the crime at all. And the victim impact is huge. But that doesn’t actually change what he did.
Again, a personal opinion, is that EVERY drink/ drug drive offence should be treated as if someone lost their life. I’d teach about drink driving in GCSE physics lessons - pointing out how long it takes to stop a car at various speeds, and how drink/ drugs affect the way you drive, and reaction times etc.
I’m really glad for the whole family, that he HAS learned from his actions, and has changed as a result, and I really don’t see the need to continue to beat him up over it, it sounds as if he’s done enough of that himself. He will live with the guilt for the rest of his life. He will live with the weight of his friends family behind him. He doesn’t need the judgement of strangers and nor should his DC.

I love that you use your physics lesson to teach about drink driving. Brilliant and really inspired. I hope my kids will have lots of teachers like you!!

HelensToenail · 14/11/2022 10:55

Forgiveness doesn't seem to feature much here

In the OPs posts on this thread and her previous one in 2020 she has repeatedly stressed how remorseful he is - the judge took his remorse into account as a mitigating factor in sentencing

Unintentionally killing your best friend is surely emotionally a potentional life sentence

Perhaps, the best friends family and friends have been able to forgive him - I hope so

Cw112 · 14/11/2022 10:52

Stripedbag101 · 14/11/2022 07:22

I am simply responding to all the people who are dismissing what happened as a childhood mistake. Who are clearly implying that what happened doesn’t in any way speak to his character. It does.

yes he was punished - and while OP says he is sorry I have no idea if that is true or not.

a lot of people are very quick to say what happened wants a big deal. It has to be a big deal - becomes so many people are killed by these type of actions.

if we as a society say it’s okay let’s all move on then the deterrent isn’t there.

reckless acts which result in a loss of life have to be a Shadow over people’s lives. I have read articles about people who have committed these types of devastating crimes. One man killed his friend and he was left in a wheel chair. He travels round schools taking about the life long impacts of what he did. To show young people it isn’t a case of a year in prison then bang life starts again. He wants to stop young people joyriding and drunk driving brocade it is so devastating and the slate is never wiped clean.

sorry this is a huge personal issue for me. I am also entitled to my views and we should be able to debate issues without becoming personal and attacking each others characters.

I'm not attacking your characte in any way, I understand your perspective and I also know people who have lost their lives due to joyriding and driving under the influence. I'm just asking what you would suggest people do differently? There's a lot of people on the thread saying we need to be more outraged but noone giving a clear idea of suggestion of what can this guy actually do to prove that he's living his life differently. To me the fact he pled guilty from the start and seemed to be genuinely remorseful and no longer drives or drinks are all clear signs that he's learnt from what happened. It's not that it isn't a big deal it's just me questioning how long do you hold something over someone when they're trying to move forward and do better?

Fattoushi · 14/11/2022 10:50

saraclara · 14/11/2022 10:38

He will live with the guilt for the rest of his life. He will live with the weight of his friends family behind him. He doesn’t need the judgement of strangers and nor should his DC.

Exactly. He was judged in court and served the sentence that society required of him. If he had come out of prison unapologetic and continuing that way of life, then of course everyone should be wary of him. But from what we've been told, he's rehabilitated, behavinng lawfully, working and being a good dad. Presumably that's what we all want from convicted criminals. For them to leave prison and be changed people.

He's not living scot-free. His ongoing punishment is going on within him. He will never forget that he killed his best friend.

I think you are both missing the point. I don't care about his remorse, or guilt, or his feelings on others judging him. I'm not even particularly judging him....but the questions asked included people sending their kids to his house to play.

I can judge all the fuck I like when it comes to who is looking after my child. I can decide, for any reason I choose, that someone is not good enough to do that. I can certainly decide that I don't want a young drunk driving killer to be a babysitter.

What's more, all of you talking about unfair judgements would think the exact same thing if it was your actual child and not a hypothetical argument on the internet!

saraclara · 14/11/2022 10:38

He will live with the guilt for the rest of his life. He will live with the weight of his friends family behind him. He doesn’t need the judgement of strangers and nor should his DC.

Exactly. He was judged in court and served the sentence that society required of him. If he had come out of prison unapologetic and continuing that way of life, then of course everyone should be wary of him. But from what we've been told, he's rehabilitated, behavinng lawfully, working and being a good dad. Presumably that's what we all want from convicted criminals. For them to leave prison and be changed people.

He's not living scot-free. His ongoing punishment is going on within him. He will never forget that he killed his best friend.

ShouldIdo · 14/11/2022 10:38

ilyx · 13/11/2022 01:06

Ok the amount of people are defending this, I’m 99% sure most of you are drunk drivers or have been in the past. It is absolutely horrendous. There is no excuse for drunk driving. It’s such a disgusting, selfish and evil thing to do. Being against “drunk driving” does not make someone self righteous. OP’s husband is not the victim the poor boy who died is the victim.

Don't be so ridiculous!

Just because you don't have forgiveness, don't start accusing everyone of wrongdoing.

99% sure most of us are drunk drivers.......... what a ludicrous statement.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 10:37

“True remorse”
What does that look like to you?
How do you know the extent of his remorse?
Would be rather he killed himself as a sacrifice to society?
Would you rather he locked himself away for the rest of his life or until you deem him suitably remorseful?

How is getting a job and being a good father not a sufficient level of redemption?

It’s like the Middle Ages on here. Bring back hanging! Bring back the stocks!

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 10:34

PlutoCritter · 14/11/2022 10:24

I feel for the poor family who lost their child.

exactly.

can you imagine being that poor dead friend's parents and getting an INKLING of some of the sentiment posted here? OP's DP was a "child", "made a mistake", has learned from it.. etc

all the while your son is cold and dead in the ground due to HIS actions less than 5 years ago.

i'm disgusted at the minimising going on here.

his character is flawed, OP. a short jail sentance doesn't fix that.

only time and true remorse (which you don't get as you walk out of a jail cell automatically) could truly "rehabilitate" the OP's "DP".

Be disgusted. Redemption is part of a civilised society.

PlutoCritter · 14/11/2022 10:24

I feel for the poor family who lost their child.

exactly.

can you imagine being that poor dead friend's parents and getting an INKLING of some of the sentiment posted here? OP's DP was a "child", "made a mistake", has learned from it.. etc

all the while your son is cold and dead in the ground due to HIS actions less than 5 years ago.

i'm disgusted at the minimising going on here.

his character is flawed, OP. a short jail sentance doesn't fix that.

only time and true remorse (which you don't get as you walk out of a jail cell automatically) could truly "rehabilitate" the OP's "DP".

Brefugee · 14/11/2022 10:06

I believe firmly in the rehabilitation of offenders and it sounds as though OPs DP has engaged with this. Other people have other ideas, but as long as our society is like this we should respect it. Personally? I believe that if you get in a car when drunk you should have some rather firm conditions attached to future driving licences, but that is neither here nor there.

There is a lot of feeling on the thread (and outside i would guess) that causing death when drunk driving should have harsher sentencing than often happens. I agree but OP, her DP and anyone else can't address this under current laws. There are mitigating circs in sentencing that it would be hugely unfair to ignore for some crimes and not others. (admitting guilt etc)

This feeling colours people's attitudes, including OPs so-called friend. I would assume in OPs shoes that "friend" will let people know one way or another so OP and her DP need to agree on a strategy. Either wait to see if people ask - then answer honestly, or be more upfront. I prefer the former but it depends how fast and hard any reaction affects DD. But in general for non reportable actions (eg being put on the sex offenders register) i don't see that a conviction and prison sentence is anyone else's business.

Swipe left for the next trending thread