Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD’s friends parents don't need to know about DP’s past? *potential TW?*

636 replies

xidol70080 · 12/11/2022 22:12

I'm pretty sure I posted about DP before when he was first released from prison and MN was helpful then but I've since deleted that account so I can't find the thread, some of you may remember.

Some background. I was with DDs dad (now 4) for a few months at 16, I then found out I was pregnant and we stayed together. On his 17th birthday, he was drunk and stole his dads car and crashed, his best friend sadly died and he was sent to prison. I split up with him as I was very angry and upset. He was released from prison in late 2020 (when I posted on here) and I took DD to see him, he was very remorseful and told me he wanted to be in DD’s life. I moved in with him and his dad in at the start of lockdown so DD could build a relationship with her dad and so I could get some support as I don't see my own family.

Me and him got back together in March 2021, me and DD stayed living with him and his dad, he got a job and everything relationship wise has been good. Me, him and DD moved into our own house this summer (we were saving whilst living at his dads).

DD started reception in September and has had a few playdates, one of my friends has never been happy with DD having contact with DP let alone us getting back together, so we don't talk much but this evening she messaged and asked how DD is getting on at school, has she made friends etc so I told her she has. She then asked if I mentioned DP’s past to her friends’ parents, I said no and she has said if she had a child, she'd want to know so she could judge whether to allow her child around him. Some of the parents have met him and have made their judgements without knowing.

AIBU in thinking they don't need to know something that happened when DP was still legally classed as a child, he's now 21, and it's been 5 years since it happened. Or if you were her friends parents would you want to know?

OP posts:
Cw112 · 14/11/2022 20:30

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:22

Which seems to suggest that you think all crimes should be seen as equal and people should be hounded equally? I was saying that doesn't make sense because the type and nature and context of the crime should be taken into consideration.
I have never stated that I've stated that of you believe people are rehabilitated they either are or not.

Yes, but we know that certain crimes are much much harder to rehabilitate for a whole load of reasons. Which is why some people are released sooner into the community than others and with different conditions etc. Rehabilitation is something that needs to be tailored to suit the crime that's just fact. I see no reason why a 17 year old who's accidentally killed their friend in a car crash shouldn't be rehabilitated whereas a serial sexual offender is a completely different kettle of fish to firstly work with on any level and secondly to rehabilitate because of the levels of sociopathy and anti-social mature of the crime etc. I'm not quite sure I understand your point if I'm honest? Sorry if I'm missing it!

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:28

He's probably grown up a he'll of a lot more in those 5 years than his peers have in the same period.

Oh he's better than his peers now who have got jobs and are productive members of society.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2022 20:27

Naunet · 14/11/2022 09:36

Wow, just a couple of years for drink driving and killing a kid? I feel for the poor family who lost their child.

Wait, what kid?

I had assumed (and yes I know that's never wise) that the OP's partner got into a car, drunk, with his best mate who was a similar age.

So no 'kid' - if the OP's partner is an adult then so was his best friend.

There is a world of difference between two young people, drunk (or at least passenger knows the driver is drunk) getting into a stolen car, crashing it and one of them dying...

And one person getting into a stolen car, drunk and crashing it into an innocent small child bystander...

I do doubt the latter scenario would have recieved such a short sentence!

Maybe the OP can clarify if her partners best friend was the same age and knew he was drunk?

Cw112 · 14/11/2022 20:26

WorkingTheCrowd · 14/11/2022 20:19

It’s the fact he was so willing to put anyone walking down the road, driving their car, in their garden, even in their house if he ended up crashing into someone’s house, at risk. No thought, no care. It wasn’t long ago. Why would he now have any care for my child? He’s not entitled to forgiveness from anyone.

I would say because the crime he committed was absolutely nothing to do with children so why would it affect your child or his ability to keep them safe? "No thought, no care" is exactly what most joyriding stems from- it's complete lack of understanding of the consequences and feeling like 'it'll never happen to me' - until it does. That's not the same as intentionally setting out to harm someone. In terms of maturity/brain development/emotional maturity we know that 17-21 is a big jump never mind adding in a traumatic and life altering event into that period. He's probably grown up a he'll of a lot more in those 5 years than his peers have in the same period.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:25

You don't tell anyone what to think, I can believe in rehabilitation for some crimes and not others.

I pick and choose my own justice well shouldn't others beable to choose which rehabilitation they believe

Conkersareback · 14/11/2022 20:23

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:22

Which seems to suggest that you think all crimes should be seen as equal and people should be hounded equally? I was saying that doesn't make sense because the type and nature and context of the crime should be taken into consideration.
I have never stated that I've stated that of you believe people are rehabilitated they either are or not.

You don't tell anyone what to think, I can believe in rehabilitation for some crimes and not others.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:22

Which seems to suggest that you think all crimes should be seen as equal and people should be hounded equally? I was saying that doesn't make sense because the type and nature and context of the crime should be taken into consideration.
I have never stated that I've stated that of you believe people are rehabilitated they either are or not.

WorkingTheCrowd · 14/11/2022 20:19

Cw112 · 14/11/2022 19:59

Surely type of crime matters? Huge difference between manslaughter (which this is) and premeditated murder? Huge difference in shoplifting and child abuse? Of course the nature of the crime matters as does the intent behind it and the way the offender is rehabilitated/ feels remorse which as op has shown her partner does. Do you not believe that if someone is genuinely remorseful, has accepted responsibility, held themselves accountable and has done what they needed to try to be a better person going forward that that person should never have any chance at forgiveness regardless of what their crime was?

It’s the fact he was so willing to put anyone walking down the road, driving their car, in their garden, even in their house if he ended up crashing into someone’s house, at risk. No thought, no care. It wasn’t long ago. Why would he now have any care for my child? He’s not entitled to forgiveness from anyone.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:19

*It must be very hard to live life with such a rigid idea of people and their thoughts. No understanding of nuance or context. You genuinely have my sympathy.

I'm using people's own comments against them. Apparently rehabilitation works in the case of the OP but not for other criminals. I do completely see difference but if someone has been punished isn't that enough.

Cw112 · 14/11/2022 20:19

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:04

Do you not believe that if someone is genuinely remorseful, has accepted responsibility, held themselves accountable and has done what they needed to try to be a better person going forward that that person should never have any chance at forgiveness regardless of what their crime was?

Regardless what crime is that's your words not mine. So what is it

Those are my words because you said :
"But many on here are stating people should be forgiven and not be hounded for crimes, it seems it is when it's only certain sort of Crimes."
Which seems to suggest that you think all crimes should be seen as equal and people should be hounded equally? I was saying that doesn't make sense because the type and nature and context of the crime should be taken into consideration.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 20:13

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:04

Do you not believe that if someone is genuinely remorseful, has accepted responsibility, held themselves accountable and has done what they needed to try to be a better person going forward that that person should never have any chance at forgiveness regardless of what their crime was?

Regardless what crime is that's your words not mine. So what is it

Not many people think of manslaughter and murder as the same. Not many people think of drink driving and child molestation as anywhere close to being similar.

It must be very hard to live life with such a rigid idea of people and their thoughts. No understanding of nuance or context. You genuinely have my sympathy.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:08

As always said these posters would change tune of it was child who was killed.

Conkersareback · 14/11/2022 20:07

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:04

Do you not believe that if someone is genuinely remorseful, has accepted responsibility, held themselves accountable and has done what they needed to try to be a better person going forward that that person should never have any chance at forgiveness regardless of what their crime was?

Regardless what crime is that's your words not mine. So what is it

Not my words.....

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:04

Do you not believe that if someone is genuinely remorseful, has accepted responsibility, held themselves accountable and has done what they needed to try to be a better person going forward that that person should never have any chance at forgiveness regardless of what their crime was?

Regardless what crime is that's your words not mine. So what is it

Conkersareback · 14/11/2022 20:03

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:01

*Whereas a pedophile has a sexually deviant nature?

You think they're the same, really?*

It's irrelevant there is many posts saying don't tell people of past crimes and people need second chances and the courts but it seems it depends on crime.

I completely see the difference I'm using posters own words against them, well surely this sex abuser is rehabilitated, however the posters on here need to think about justification for one sort of crime but not another.

No they don't, it's really obvious!

Because they don't write war and peace, doesn't mean they think all crime is the same.

They're referring to a young male, drink driving.

They are saying that he should rehabilitate!

They don't have to go on to say, that this doesn't refer to Fred and Rose West etc.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 20:01

*Whereas a pedophile has a sexually deviant nature?

You think they're the same, really?*

It's irrelevant there is many posts saying don't tell people of past crimes and people need second chances and the courts but it seems it depends on crime.

I completely see the difference I'm using posters own words against them, well surely this sex abuser is rehabilitated, however the posters on here need to think about justification for one sort of crime but not another.

Cw112 · 14/11/2022 19:59

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 19:52

But many on here are stating people should be forgiven and not be hounded for crimes, it seems it is when it's only certain sort of Crimes.

Surely type of crime matters? Huge difference between manslaughter (which this is) and premeditated murder? Huge difference in shoplifting and child abuse? Of course the nature of the crime matters as does the intent behind it and the way the offender is rehabilitated/ feels remorse which as op has shown her partner does. Do you not believe that if someone is genuinely remorseful, has accepted responsibility, held themselves accountable and has done what they needed to try to be a better person going forward that that person should never have any chance at forgiveness regardless of what their crime was?

Conkersareback · 14/11/2022 19:56

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 19:52

But many on here are stating people should be forgiven and not be hounded for crimes, it seems it is when it's only certain sort of Crimes.

Yep this is 100% true!

Loads of people have stated it changes for pedophiles, are you honestly saying you don't think a drink driver can ever stop? It's a wrong choice and they learn?

Whereas a pedophile has a sexually deviant nature?

You think they're the same, really?

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 19:52

But many on here are stating people should be forgiven and not be hounded for crimes, it seems it is when it's only certain sort of Crimes.

Cw112 · 14/11/2022 19:51

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 19:43

He was a drink driver, not a child abuser.

But judging by many people's logic on here, if he was a child abuser if he had served his time it's okay. Nope that's where all these people fall down.

Those are incredibly different scenarios. Abuse is intentional. Someone intentionally abuses a child in the full knowledge and understanding of the long term effects and consequences it will have on that child. Child abusers and paedophile are extremely likely to reoffend and rehabilitation has shown to be quite ineffective in such cases.

Joyriding and drink driving on the other hand was the bit that was intentional in this crime, the driver did not intend to kill someone he loved or anyone else for that matter. They did not fully understand the consequences to their actions or they wouldn't have been in the car would they? Reoffending rates for joyrider who have served prison time and who have lived through severe trauma as a result are much much lower. So these two things are really not comparable.

Also one speaks directly to someone's safety around children and the other doesn't involve children in any way.

SkylightSkylight · 14/11/2022 19:48

butterfliedtwo · 13/11/2022 00:11

By this logic all drunk drivers should be excused. They don't purposely kill people.

Doesn't matter though, does it? Their victims are still dead.

@butterfliedtwo

Who said excused?

He was sentenced, he served his time.

o have never seen sentencing that requires you to inform everyone you meet that you have been to prison.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 19:43

He was a drink driver, not a child abuser.

But judging by many people's logic on here, if he was a child abuser if he had served his time it's okay. Nope that's where all these people fall down.

IhearyouClemFandango · 14/11/2022 19:39

He was a drink driver, not a child abuser.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 19:33

It is really really sad what happened but I'm sure your DH had no intention for his friend to die he took a risk and it turned out to have absolutely devastating effects.

The problem is his friend who got in car with him died, fair enough, but he could have hit bystanders or pedestrians.

He had intent to drive a car like this.

NewtoHolland · 14/11/2022 19:15

I would distance myself from your friend.