Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD’s friends parents don't need to know about DP’s past? *potential TW?*

636 replies

xidol70080 · 12/11/2022 22:12

I'm pretty sure I posted about DP before when he was first released from prison and MN was helpful then but I've since deleted that account so I can't find the thread, some of you may remember.

Some background. I was with DDs dad (now 4) for a few months at 16, I then found out I was pregnant and we stayed together. On his 17th birthday, he was drunk and stole his dads car and crashed, his best friend sadly died and he was sent to prison. I split up with him as I was very angry and upset. He was released from prison in late 2020 (when I posted on here) and I took DD to see him, he was very remorseful and told me he wanted to be in DD’s life. I moved in with him and his dad in at the start of lockdown so DD could build a relationship with her dad and so I could get some support as I don't see my own family.

Me and him got back together in March 2021, me and DD stayed living with him and his dad, he got a job and everything relationship wise has been good. Me, him and DD moved into our own house this summer (we were saving whilst living at his dads).

DD started reception in September and has had a few playdates, one of my friends has never been happy with DD having contact with DP let alone us getting back together, so we don't talk much but this evening she messaged and asked how DD is getting on at school, has she made friends etc so I told her she has. She then asked if I mentioned DP’s past to her friends’ parents, I said no and she has said if she had a child, she'd want to know so she could judge whether to allow her child around him. Some of the parents have met him and have made their judgements without knowing.

AIBU in thinking they don't need to know something that happened when DP was still legally classed as a child, he's now 21, and it's been 5 years since it happened. Or if you were her friends parents would you want to know?

OP posts:
Spookypig · 13/11/2022 00:50

What a ridiculous comment! Of course you don’t need to tell them! I’d let my children around him, he made a mistake when so young and paid a huge price, the poor guy. Nothing about his story is relevant to children or implies parents need to be warned! Good for him for rebuilding his life.

ilyx · 13/11/2022 00:49

Foolsandtheirmoney · 13/11/2022 00:44

I wonder how you would feel if it was your son that did the driving? What would you feel should happen? Locked up for life for something he did as a drunk 17 year old? My ds is nearly 16 and no where near an adult. He is still very much a kid in lots of ways. I can't see him doing something like that but I can't imagine if he did I would want to see him rot in prison for the rest of his life.

I wonder how you’d feel if your son was the one killed by a drunk driver and the driver got a pathetic slap on the wrist?

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 00:48

ilyx · 13/11/2022 00:40

Actually this is scientific fact. The brain scans of 17 years old confirm that they are not completely developed enough to be able to understand long term consequences to their actions and make judgements based on that

Funny how most teenagers including myself knew not to steal my parents car and drive people around when blind drunk. My guess is you behaved similarly when you were younger?

No I didn't, but at 30 odd I'm entitled to move on from mistakes I did make at 17 as are we all. I've also met plenty of people much older than 17 who drink and drive fully informed which for me is worse. I work with loads of young people who have done this as part of their social circle. And I'd also say I feel very lucky to have grown up in a stable home environment with parents who wanted to know where i was and what i was doing. Not all kids have that in their lives so they have to figure stuff out on their own. But well done you for being perfect enough to judge without any appreciation for context or life circumstances. You should teach the rest of us mere mortals how you do it.

JonahAndTheSnail · 13/11/2022 00:48

I don't think YABU to have not mentioned it after a couple of playdates and when the kids have only known each other for a few weeks. I do understand where your friend is coming from, but it's a conversation to have down the line if and when needed. If you're supervising all playdates and your partner isn't left alone with the children or driving with them, there's no immediate danger.

Meraas · 13/11/2022 00:47

Foolsandtheirmoney · 13/11/2022 00:44

I wonder how you would feel if it was your son that did the driving? What would you feel should happen? Locked up for life for something he did as a drunk 17 year old? My ds is nearly 16 and no where near an adult. He is still very much a kid in lots of ways. I can't see him doing something like that but I can't imagine if he did I would want to see him rot in prison for the rest of his life.

Where did I say the rest of his life?

But the sentence does seem short.

Topsyturvy78 · 13/11/2022 00:46

No definitely not he's not a violent offender or a risk to children. He has served his time and shown remorse. It wouldn't be fair on your daughter to have parents gossiping about her dad. She is being rediculous.

Spinninggyro · 13/11/2022 00:44

Quote from a comment above “Normal, stable people do not behave that way”

l have to disagree with this, as a teacher I have been to funerals where an accident has been caused by 17,18 years olds (male and female) losing control of a car. They came from good, stable homes and their families were distraught. As many people have commented the teenage brain is not fully mature at that age. If someone has served their time in prison then they deserve to be allowed to get on with their lives.

Foolsandtheirmoney · 13/11/2022 00:44

Meraas · 13/11/2022 00:38

Crazy that he gets to live his life and watch his daughter grow up whilst someone else’s son and brother is in a grave because of him.

I hope you don’t live near the boy’s parents.

I wonder how you would feel if it was your son that did the driving? What would you feel should happen? Locked up for life for something he did as a drunk 17 year old? My ds is nearly 16 and no where near an adult. He is still very much a kid in lots of ways. I can't see him doing something like that but I can't imagine if he did I would want to see him rot in prison for the rest of his life.

ilyx · 13/11/2022 00:40

Actually this is scientific fact. The brain scans of 17 years old confirm that they are not completely developed enough to be able to understand long term consequences to their actions and make judgements based on that

Funny how most teenagers including myself knew not to steal my parents car and drive people around when blind drunk. My guess is you behaved similarly when you were younger?

Meraas · 13/11/2022 00:38

Crazy that he gets to live his life and watch his daughter grow up whilst someone else’s son and brother is in a grave because of him.

I hope you don’t live near the boy’s parents.

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 00:37

ilyx · 13/11/2022 00:27

At 17 our brains are not mature enough to think of consequences and in the moment acting out our emotions are everything

Oh please, 17 is not 3 years old. 99% of 17 year olds don’t steal their parents car and drive drunk. And the friend might of had no clue how drunk his friend was, not everyone who drinks comes across as drunk even when they are.

Actually this is scientific fact. The brain scans of 17 years old confirm that they are not completely developed enough to be able to understand long term consequences to their actions and make judgements based on that. It's one of the main reasons why the age of criminal culpability in the UK should be much higher than 11 years old. The friend still knew his mate was stealing a car and driving with no licence.

"Sorry but they have every right to know. I’d not want my kids being around that sort of family. I’m sure this guy is not completely normal and rational in every other area in his life if he behaves behaved that way 5 years ago I’m sure he’s was dysfunctional in many other ways. Normal, stable people do not behave that way. The parents should know about such a serious matter."

There fixed it for you.

At least OP you'll have a hell of a judgey person filter to make sure you know who you wouldn't want as your friends and can avoid them accordingly.

Foolsandtheirmoney · 13/11/2022 00:34

I dont think he needs to say anything. When I was a teenager my friend got drunk, stole her boyfriends car and killed herself. It was accident. Just like this was an accident. Sure she didn't accidently steal the car or accidently get drunk but she didn't want to die. Teenagers are stupid(not mumsnetters obviously) but in real life every single teenager I hung out with did something incredibly stupid, my friend just paid a higher price. I wouldn't judge your partner for one horrid mistake as a teen.

ilyx · 13/11/2022 00:31

You don’t need to tell anyone. It’s none of their business as it’s not relevant to their children’s safety (assuming he isn’t driving anyone).

Sorry but they have every right to know. I’d not want my kids being around that sort of family. I’m sure this guy is not completely normal and rational in every other area in his life if he behaves that way. I’m sure he’s dysfunctional in many other ways. Normal, stable people do not behave that way. The parents should know about such a serious matter.

ArcaneWireless · 13/11/2022 00:29

I think most people will be aware if you still live in the same area OP. I think it would be fair to be truthful if they asked you outright. As for your question do you have to make them aware? I’d say no if your DP is doing everything he can to turn his life around.

A family round here lost their child in similar circumstances. They requested that the lad who was driving should not receive a prison sentence. He received a driving ban instead and people were largely sympathetic to him because the family affected had been.

Until soon after when he tried to get his (very lenient in the circumstances) driving ban reduced significantly because it affected his day to day life. His remorse did not last long and that is what folk remember more. Not his actions on the day of the accident.

ilyx · 13/11/2022 00:27

At 17 our brains are not mature enough to think of consequences and in the moment acting out our emotions are everything

Oh please, 17 is not 3 years old. 99% of 17 year olds don’t steal their parents car and drive drunk. And the friend might of had no clue how drunk his friend was, not everyone who drinks comes across as drunk even when they are.

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 00:27

Stripedbag101 · 13/11/2022 00:17

but a mistake that results in the death of another person - especially when that mistake involves drunk driving surely has a longer shelf life than four years?

and we unfortunately do know that people don’t automatically change, nor do they change in such a short period of time.

this young man may well Mel be a completely different person, but it is just as possible that he still has questionable judgment. Many teen offenders go on to reoffend. I think it would be naive to assume all teen joyriders are upstanding citizens by their 21st birthday.

again I am not saying he should be ostracised by other parents - just trying to say it’s okay for people to be cautious.

these crimes are stigmatised in society for a reason.

"These crimes are stigmatised in society for a reason". There's your number one reason right there for why many offenders go on to reoffend. Because they aren't properly reintegrated and accepted back into society. Because other people will still hold past mistakes over their head so they feel like they can't move on and be a different person. Now I fully stand by that for some crimes like sexual offences and offences against children where reoffending is highly likely for different reasons. But a 17 year old kid stealing and trying to drive a car drunk... very different. I know plenty of kids - in fact the vast majority I've worked with have gone on to get their qualifications, go to tech or uni or into employment and have settled down and had families. No reoffending, they really were motivated to turn things around. The few who haven't have usually had much more complex needs in the first instance like addiction/severely poor mental health/ been kicked out of the care system at 18 completely institutionalised and they honestly sadly find prison earlier to manage than normal life because of the structure and the routine and the boundaries to it. The statistics are still people at the end of the day and people are grey. You can't apply a black and white approach to everyone with an offending history. Plus I would imagine age and likely first offence plus good behaviour in prison and genuine remorse have led to that length of sentence. People can change extremely quickly when something deeply traumatic happens.

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/11/2022 00:25

You don’t need to tell anyone. It’s none of their business as it’s not relevant to their children’s safety (assuming he isn’t driving anyone).

Unless he’s changed his name or you are living far away I would assume it will come out sometime though, so keep that in mind.. it might be better for you to manage that.

He did kill his friend though, it is important not to minimise that. He shouldn’t drive any of your DD’s friends obviously, and I would avoid him playing a significant role when friends are around. Be clear that you are always around. This will help manage things when/if it does come out. It will be different in 10 years, but right now this is very recent history.

ilyx · 13/11/2022 00:25

Ihatethenewlook · 12/11/2022 22:32

This is the most ridiculous case of minimising I have come across. My teenage mistakes were forgetting to set my alarm and being late for school. Or at most starting smoking when I knew it was bloody stupid. This man got illegally pissed, stole a car and killed his best friend ffs. I can’t believe he’s not still in prison. What a disgusting sentence be must have received. His victims family must be distraught!

U.K. Justice System what do you expect 🤡

Kennykenkencat · 13/11/2022 00:21

People saying he chose to steal a car, he chose to get drunk, it might be harsh but his friend also chose to get into a stolen car with his drunk friend.
At 17 our brains are not mature enough to think of consequences and in the moment acting out our emotions are everything. All we can do for our children is try to instil in them to take a moment before careering headlong into actions that could have life altering consequences. Or making decisions that could be reckless and based on instant gratification.
We also need to help them recognise their emotions and give them the confidence to say no to their friend/s and be able to call their friends out on risky or criminal behaviour.

Whilst the parents of the friend will never get over this it doesn’t sound like this guy will ever get over the death of his friend either

He has served his time and has made the decision to not drink alcohol or get behind the wheel of a car. He has done a lot of growing up in the last 5 years. He will live with the death of his friend forever and the person who this information being made public will affect the most is his and op’s Dd.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 00:21

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

butterfliedtwo · 13/11/2022 00:20

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 00:15

Does it mean they're unsafe to be around children though? If they are no longer drinking and driving and have wised up? Noone excused this guy, he went to court, went to prison and served his time. According to the justice system he's made his amends. So where are you getting that he's being excused from?

I think he should not drive children, but since op says he's not, fine.

What I objected to is the "he didn't do it on purpose" minimising. No drunk driver thinks they'll kill anyone. Doesn't mean people don't die because of their decision.

I'm stepping away from this thread now. It's hitting too close to home.

Stripedbag101 · 13/11/2022 00:17

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 00:09

Lots of teens fall into this category for loads of different reasons- for a start brain development isn't complete at age 17. Most teenagers feel invincible and don't think something bad will actually happen to them until it does. If you then factor in other issues like adhd etc that can affect impulsivity or decision making. Never mind the fact that we know alcohol impairs judgement.

I'm not giving excuses it was the wrong call he made getting behind the wheel, I'm just saying that at 16/17 people are very different to 21/22 anyway and this guy has been through a life changing event, an extremely traumatic event and has served time as a result. So I don't think it's a massive leap to assume you don't come away from that the same person you were on your 17th bday.

In the area I live it's hugely common to steal cars, joyride and drink at that age and most Youth workers myself included work with loads of young people who've either been driving or been passenger. And a lot of them have only wised up after losing a friend. It doesn't make it OK but it is, sadly really common. I don't think it's fair to expect teen mistakes to follow someone for a lifetime no matter how much they try to move on and be better for it, no.

but a mistake that results in the death of another person - especially when that mistake involves drunk driving surely has a longer shelf life than four years?

and we unfortunately do know that people don’t automatically change, nor do they change in such a short period of time.

this young man may well Mel be a completely different person, but it is just as possible that he still has questionable judgment. Many teen offenders go on to reoffend. I think it would be naive to assume all teen joyriders are upstanding citizens by their 21st birthday.

again I am not saying he should be ostracised by other parents - just trying to say it’s okay for people to be cautious.

these crimes are stigmatised in society for a reason.

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 00:17

butterfliedtwo · 13/11/2022 00:15

No. But I don't think five years is enough for killing someone either to be honest.

But the judge clearly did and none of us know the ins and outs of the case. I imagine his age played a big factor. Very different a 17 Yr old kid doing something stupid and dangerous with their mates not aware of the consequences than a 50 year old man doing it fully aware of the consequences.

SkylightSkylight · 13/11/2022 00:16

ChimpMcGarvey · 12/11/2022 22:56

Difficult one OP, because the other parents probably will find out at some point (whether you tell them yourself or not).

Actions have consequences, some people will judge him for this for the rest of his life, and the consequences of that may affect you and your child.

Honestly - If you told me upfront and gave me assurances that he’d never be left alone with my child, never drive my child anywhere, etc, I’d probably be ok with that. If I was left to find out through the grapevine I’d likely encourage my own child more towards friendships with some of the other 29 kids in the class whose father hadn’t killed someone 4 years ago.

@ChimpMcGarvey

he was a teenager who took his Dads car without permission, had an accident that resulted in the death of his best friend.

why shouldn't he be left alone with children??

it's not like abused a child?

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 13/11/2022 00:15

hugznotdrugz · 12/11/2022 22:26

I think if he's ever going to take one of her friends in a car (if he still has a licence?) Then they definitely need to know. However I'm not sure they just need to know for a playdate

This
For just a playdate, not so much.
Going anywhere in the car with him, absolutely would want to know!