Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD’s friends parents don't need to know about DP’s past? *potential TW?*

636 replies

xidol70080 · 12/11/2022 22:12

I'm pretty sure I posted about DP before when he was first released from prison and MN was helpful then but I've since deleted that account so I can't find the thread, some of you may remember.

Some background. I was with DDs dad (now 4) for a few months at 16, I then found out I was pregnant and we stayed together. On his 17th birthday, he was drunk and stole his dads car and crashed, his best friend sadly died and he was sent to prison. I split up with him as I was very angry and upset. He was released from prison in late 2020 (when I posted on here) and I took DD to see him, he was very remorseful and told me he wanted to be in DD’s life. I moved in with him and his dad in at the start of lockdown so DD could build a relationship with her dad and so I could get some support as I don't see my own family.

Me and him got back together in March 2021, me and DD stayed living with him and his dad, he got a job and everything relationship wise has been good. Me, him and DD moved into our own house this summer (we were saving whilst living at his dads).

DD started reception in September and has had a few playdates, one of my friends has never been happy with DD having contact with DP let alone us getting back together, so we don't talk much but this evening she messaged and asked how DD is getting on at school, has she made friends etc so I told her she has. She then asked if I mentioned DP’s past to her friends’ parents, I said no and she has said if she had a child, she'd want to know so she could judge whether to allow her child around him. Some of the parents have met him and have made their judgements without knowing.

AIBU in thinking they don't need to know something that happened when DP was still legally classed as a child, he's now 21, and it's been 5 years since it happened. Or if you were her friends parents would you want to know?

OP posts:
albapunk · 13/11/2022 02:03

@Kennykenkencat

Oh I'm not comparing the sentence length, just that 5 years in prison doesn't always mean a crime is violent, horrific etc as the poster I was replying to seems to think 5 years in prison means she expects to be told about it from people she may socialize with.

Although I also know people who have committed adult violent crimes and served much less. The justice system is interesting eh?

Flutterbybudget · 13/11/2022 02:02

Sadly, drink driving is still incredibly common. People are rightly horrified that a young man lost his life, as a result of your DPs actions, but I wonder if they feel the same way about ANYONE who got behind the wheel of a car while over the limit, as a teenager. Would they still be stigmatised in the same way? Because like it or not, your DP and his friend were tragically “unlucky” as compared to the teenager (or older person) who drank and drove and didn’t have an accident.

I see no reason why it is anyone else business, but sorry though I am to say it, I suspect that it will “get out” at some point. I’m not sure what the answer is, or how your DP feels about it. But maybe he could volunteer to speak at the local comp about how his actions that night have affected him, and his friends family. Or do something that shows how much he regrets what he did, but in a positive way.

Hand on heart, it wouldn’t affect the way I looked at your DP, or put me off having my own children be friends with your child. Providing, of course, that your DP isn’t seen to be out drinking and getting behind the wheel of a car in the future.

Phantomb · 13/11/2022 02:02

No I would not want my young DC in a house with a convicted criminal who’d served prison time for causing death or injury to someone else. No
matter that he was young and stupid and didn’t mean to steal a car and drive while drunk (not a teenage rite of passage IMO). He was still old enough to know better.

It would be different for me if it was his own car and he’d decided to drive home after a few drinks thinking he was alright so it was a down to impaired reflexes and he went into the back of something etc but he actually took someone else’s car and must have deliberately driven recklessly hence the longer prison sentence as 4 years is quite long for an under 18.. That’s a whole different type of mentality.

As for the posters saying his friend chose to get a car with him knowing he was drunk so it served him right 🤔You don’t know whether he was cajoled into the car by the driver saying he was OK (he was a child too) whether he asked him to stop as he was scared by the way he was driving (no one ever will) or what happened at all. All we know is that he ended.up dead and the driver didn’t. We don’t know if this was a long line of bad behaviour which obviously the OP is going to minimise as she has chosen to stay with him and he’s her DDs dad.

Obviously no one at the child’s school will know unless they are told as he is protected by anonymity due to his age at the time.

I probably wouldn’t offer up that info in the OP’s position until I’d made friendships with other parents and they knew you well enough to trust you and your DP.

They can make their own judgements on knowing you then. Unfortunately your DP’s crime is going to affect you and your DC, just the fact he’s got a criminal record will affect finances and going abroad. That’s for him to live with.

I’d be quite furious if my DC had a sleepover at your house and I didn’t know that there was a convicted criminal there I must say.

You did say some parents had already made judgements already without knowing his background, what does that mean?

ilyx · 13/11/2022 02:01

I agree, I am sure drink driving is sadly common as I'm sure drug driving must be too. We are Saturday night and I wonder how may cars on the road right now should not be there
There's no minimising or defending it, it's intolerable. And it happens all the time

The people who are minimising it, and even worse are finding a way to blame the poor dead child are imo drunk drivers. I can’t think of any other explanation as to why they’re so desperate to blame him. It’s absolutely revolting.

Kennykenkencat · 13/11/2022 01:57

albapunk · 13/11/2022 01:32

Why would it be your business though? You will likely know many people who have committed a crime in the past. Unless you actually vet every single person you know, you will never have a true or full idea of their past, criminal or otherwise.

I know someone who served almost the same length for fraud, it doesn't make them unfit to look after children or for it to be my business if I didn't know them, unless I was employing them.

Were they under 18 at the time because you can’t compare adult sentencing to children’s sentencing unless of course you want to go down the route of the US where you are sentencing children to a life time behind bars.

Problemoumo · 13/11/2022 01:50

ilyx · 13/11/2022 01:20

Yes that’s my point. I’m sure her DP comes across as “normal and stable” but in my opinion isn’t and I’d want to know what I was dealing with.

I think drunk driving is (sadly) common and that’s why there are so many people defending and minimising this.

I agree, I am sure drink driving is sadly common as I'm sure drug driving must be too. We are Saturday night and I wonder how may cars on the road right now should not be there.
There's no minimising or defending it, it's intolerable. And it happens all the time.

It did in OP's Dp's case, It happened, there's no going back. He went to prison. He was very young, not an excuse but what is he supposed to do with the rest of his life? Disappear from society, kill himself, what? He has a child, who is no way responsible for this. They all need a chance to go through life now without being judged by people who may or may not be better persons.
Also the family of his victim might feel differently, and that's their right imo.
Everyone else should butt out and be grateful they never made a horrible choice with irreparable consequences.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 01:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

PoundShopPrincess · 13/11/2022 01:47

It's really surprising to see so many posters trying to minimise drink driving. It's not the 1980s. Everyone I know has a zero tolerance policy towards drink drivers.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 01:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Meraas · 13/11/2022 01:43

@IAmAReader

It is obviously a tragedy either way but the teen who sadly died wasn't an innocent bystander out doing their shopping.

But he was innocent. It’s not a crime to be a passenger in a car, it’s a crime to drink drive.

Some really scummy attitudes on this thread.

AllyCatTown · 13/11/2022 01:38

Given what you say about him now, if it’s true I don’t think they need to know. I don’t see how it’d affect them, especially as he wouldn’t be driving them anywhere. Nor does he drink. And I’d bet most people who had gone through what he has would be very cautious drivers now.
I can see how people would be understandably prejudiced against the family but it’s sad your dd would suffer, so I think that’s the main reason not to tell.
Also while 5 years isn’t long. I agree in terms of maturity from 17 to 21 it is.

IAmAReader · 13/11/2022 01:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

This last bit- I was looking for someone to bring this up. It is obviously a tragedy either way but the teen who sadly died wasn't an innocent bystander out doing their shopping. From the details we have it would appear they were possibly also drinking too, and either way they knew their friend was drunk and going to drive a stolen car recklessly.So when people are saying he 'killed his best friend' this might be technically true but they should consider the context.

By the sounds of it both him and his friends were a risk to both themselves and everyone on the roads that day but it just happens that sadly his friend paid for it with his life.

I don't think everyone needs to know OP, but he should not be driving children around and he shouldn't be in sole charge of any children who come round for playdates.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 01:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Cw112 · 13/11/2022 01:34

ilyx · 13/11/2022 01:24

No I don’t but I’d expect to be told if they’d served five years in prison

Why would you expect this? Do other people come up to you and say "hi@ilyx before we get to know each other further what mistakes have you made since early childhood? I would like to know just how harshly to judge you."

Why on earth would you expect to do this to another person or think that's a normal way to treat people? You take them as you find them and trust your gut instinct. If your instinct says they seem fine and trustworthy and genuine then their past shouldn't matter. If you get the opposite vibe then you act accordingly. Its real life not AA where you get an admission with an introduction.

And you're continuing to say that the young person who died was unknowing that ops partner shouldn't have been driving. He'd just turned 17. He shouldn't have been driving alcohol or not- so they did know they shouldn't have been in a car with him regardless of the drink factor.

albapunk · 13/11/2022 01:33

Ponderingwindow · 13/11/2022 01:29

This one is tricky. I think my answer depends on if he still drinks.

OP has stated he does not drink or drive.

albapunk · 13/11/2022 01:32

ilyx · 13/11/2022 01:24

No I don’t but I’d expect to be told if they’d served five years in prison

Why would it be your business though? You will likely know many people who have committed a crime in the past. Unless you actually vet every single person you know, you will never have a true or full idea of their past, criminal or otherwise.

I know someone who served almost the same length for fraud, it doesn't make them unfit to look after children or for it to be my business if I didn't know them, unless I was employing them.

Ponderingwindow · 13/11/2022 01:29

This one is tricky. I think my answer depends on if he still drinks.

albapunk · 13/11/2022 01:27

I don't see anyone defending or minimizing the actions of OPs DP here. I simply see posters showing a level of compassion and understanding for all parties involved. This was not a violent, deliberate and pre-meditated murder, it was an accident that came from a stupid decision made by two drunk 17-year-olds. The driver risked his own life just as much as risking the passenger, who from what we can gather, likely got in the car voluntarily. Teenagers crashing a car and killing themselves, or their friend, isn't actually all that uncommon sadly and the majority of the time the driver is sober!

It was a stupid, reckless decision that ended up with a tragic loss of life, that will also have altered the drives life forever. He has been punished in line with the law as the judge saw fit. He poses no risk to children, he does not drink, he does not drive.

Meraas · 13/11/2022 01:27

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/11/2022 01:21

This will fall on deaf ears. None of the perfectly righteous will acknowledge this point.

Since the friend received the death penalty for his part in the crash, it seems wrong to imply he should take 100% of the blame. He paid for it, worse than the OP's OH.

Agreed. Apparently it’s now ‘righteous’ to blame the drink driver rather than the evil drink.

It’s not a crime to get into a car, it’s a crime to drink drive.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 01:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Clymene · 13/11/2022 01:25

I haven't replied to every single post you've made @ilyx. I've now responded to three. You're the most prolific poster on this thread with the most asinine take though.

Kennykenkencat · 13/11/2022 01:25

ilyx · 13/11/2022 01:06

Ok the amount of people are defending this, I’m 99% sure most of you are drunk drivers or have been in the past. It is absolutely horrendous. There is no excuse for drunk driving. It’s such a disgusting, selfish and evil thing to do. Being against “drunk driving” does not make someone self righteous. OP’s husband is not the victim the poor boy who died is the victim.

Why do you think that I am or have ever driven drunk just because I reasoned that if this came out it would really only affect op’s dd.

Massive difference in being a 30 year old who stole a car got drunk and killed a pedestrian than a teenager who stole his dads car after an argument and goes on a joyride with his friend where they both get drunk
The friend wasn’t forced into the car. He knew he was getting into a stolen car for a joy ride and alcohol was involved.

FWIW I don’t drink because even a liqueur chocolate has a massive affect on me.

ilyx · 13/11/2022 01:24

albapunk · 13/11/2022 01:22

@ilyx so do you go around asking every single "normal stable" person you know for a detailed history of their past? No, thought not.

No I don’t but I’d expect to be told if they’d served five years in prison

albapunk · 13/11/2022 01:22

@ilyx so do you go around asking every single "normal stable" person you know for a detailed history of their past? No, thought not.

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/11/2022 01:21

This will fall on deaf ears. None of the perfectly righteous will acknowledge this point.

Since the friend received the death penalty for his part in the crash, it seems wrong to imply he should take 100% of the blame. He paid for it, worse than the OP's OH.