Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DD’s friends parents don't need to know about DP’s past? *potential TW?*

636 replies

xidol70080 · 12/11/2022 22:12

I'm pretty sure I posted about DP before when he was first released from prison and MN was helpful then but I've since deleted that account so I can't find the thread, some of you may remember.

Some background. I was with DDs dad (now 4) for a few months at 16, I then found out I was pregnant and we stayed together. On his 17th birthday, he was drunk and stole his dads car and crashed, his best friend sadly died and he was sent to prison. I split up with him as I was very angry and upset. He was released from prison in late 2020 (when I posted on here) and I took DD to see him, he was very remorseful and told me he wanted to be in DD’s life. I moved in with him and his dad in at the start of lockdown so DD could build a relationship with her dad and so I could get some support as I don't see my own family.

Me and him got back together in March 2021, me and DD stayed living with him and his dad, he got a job and everything relationship wise has been good. Me, him and DD moved into our own house this summer (we were saving whilst living at his dads).

DD started reception in September and has had a few playdates, one of my friends has never been happy with DD having contact with DP let alone us getting back together, so we don't talk much but this evening she messaged and asked how DD is getting on at school, has she made friends etc so I told her she has. She then asked if I mentioned DP’s past to her friends’ parents, I said no and she has said if she had a child, she'd want to know so she could judge whether to allow her child around him. Some of the parents have met him and have made their judgements without knowing.

AIBU in thinking they don't need to know something that happened when DP was still legally classed as a child, he's now 21, and it's been 5 years since it happened. Or if you were her friends parents would you want to know?

OP posts:
DontStopMeNow7 · 13/11/2022 04:42

OP, you’re getting opposing opinions on what you should do. I think that, likewise, if your DD’s friends’ parents knew, they could also fall either way. Another option would be to tell them, and see who shows mercy instead of judgment. In general terms, openness is a good way to find out who your real friends are

But the question is more about whether they have a right to know. I don’t think so. But what do you think, objectively? Put yourself in their shoes and see what you come up with.

And most of all you now want to protect the feelings and the wellbeing of your loved ones. Even though your partner did something terrible, it’s not as if he’s going to do it again. Should his life be adversely affected forever? I don’t think so. What good does that do?
And if the answer were yes, is it fair for your DD to be affected? No, in which case you should go your separate ways. Lots of difficult feelings with something like this, but this is the logic. I’m guessing your friend is talking from an emotional place but it doesn’t make anything better. It doesn’t help either of you to remain in contact in my opinion.

kateandme · 13/11/2022 04:36

My big issue here is this will impact the dc now.and sadly will continue a cycle of behaviour for your poor dc.she will be the one who suffers if this is shared.
and the ongoing position that pushes her into won’t be good for her future.
you can say he doesn’t drive or drink.avoids those problems of lifts etc
dc is the innocent in all this but will be the one who suffers

Flutterbybudget · 13/11/2022 04:04

Phantomb · 13/11/2022 02:53

@IAmAReader how on earth do you know it was a ‘tragic accident’? The driver stole a car, drunk drove on either the very first day he’d passed his test or had no licence at all. That’s no ‘accident’.

The OP hasn’t said what actually happened with the friend, she doesn’t know and wasn’t there. The driver could have been doing 100mph for all we know with his friend begging him to slow down. The friend was not in control, the driver was.

He did kill someone. That’s not something that can be dismissed as well he’s done his time, move on.

Read some crap on here but this tops the lot!

@Flutterbybudget he wouldn’t have served a full sentence though would he? So would probably have got double that.

The point is, that even assuming that he only served half his initial sentence (and that’s not a given) 4 years is not a long sentence, as you stated , when he could have been given a significantly longer one.

I don’t know all the circumstances, only what we’ve been told by the OP but making stuff up doesn’t help anyone.

Blowthemandown · 13/11/2022 03:45

Barnybrown · 12/11/2022 22:16

I would contact with this “friend”. She has no right to be so judgmental.

It sounds like your partner made a terrible mistake which he is very remorseful for but you and him have worked hard to rebuild a life and a family. That is to be commended. It is totally up to your partner who he tells or doesn’t tell - there are no safeguarding issues here , the offence didn’t involve children.

Your “friend” doesn’t sound like much of a friend at all to me.

Agree. Nothing to do with so-called friend.

ilyx · 13/11/2022 03:45

You realise the prison system in the USA is extremely corrupt as certain states have for-profit prisons and that’s why those states have the most draconian prison sentences for minor non violent offences as well as locking up children as young as 13. It’s because the private prison companies bribe sorry I mean finance the politicians in those states. It’s a completely different system to any European country. If you’re going to compare us to another country at least pick a European one.

ilyx · 13/11/2022 03:39

IAmAReader · 13/11/2022 02:27

No, what's scummy is misrepresenting what happened in a tragic accident by mindlessly repeating 'he killed his best friend' without giving due consideration to the context @Meraas

I don't know about UK law on this matter, but in some American states you'd also be found guilty of a crime if you knowingly got into a car that was stolen with a driver you knew was under the influence. At the very least here in Britain there are moral implications of this - I personally would not have at any age got into a car with my friend who presumably had no licence, had no legal right to the car and most significantly was stinking of alcohol... because I'd have believed we were putting everyone on the road at risk.

OP's partner showed terrible judgement with fatal consequences but by the sounds of it his friend also made a poor decision to join him on this joyride, which is sad and understandable too because he too was only a teenage. So I am not saying this to condemn him, merely to point it out it's not quite the same as another teen out walking their dog and getting mowed over by this drunk young person. And it's definitely not the same as if in a moment of rage he turned on his friend and deliberately killed him.

And no, I'm not a drink driver or drink driver sympathiser. Unfortunately I don't even drive and I've been teetotal since I was about 18! For what's it worth I think drink driving should carry harsher penalties in terms of the jail sentences and driving bans but that doesn't change my opinion re. OP's partner.

Why on earth are you bringing up some random States in USA?! You’re British and you’re pretending not to know the law in your own country and pretending you think it might also be a crime here, yet you know that in a couple of States in America the passenger could also get in trouble? What does that have to do with anything?! We aren’t the USA!!

In some States women are also jailed for having an abortion?! Shall we do that here too?! It’s so pathetic of you. So the passenger is almost as bad as the drunk driver because in a country thousands of miles away from us, not even on the same continent, in a few states within that country, a passenger can also get in trouble. Ridiculous.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 02:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Kennykenkencat · 13/11/2022 02:54

Phantomb · 13/11/2022 02:02

No I would not want my young DC in a house with a convicted criminal who’d served prison time for causing death or injury to someone else. No
matter that he was young and stupid and didn’t mean to steal a car and drive while drunk (not a teenage rite of passage IMO). He was still old enough to know better.

It would be different for me if it was his own car and he’d decided to drive home after a few drinks thinking he was alright so it was a down to impaired reflexes and he went into the back of something etc but he actually took someone else’s car and must have deliberately driven recklessly hence the longer prison sentence as 4 years is quite long for an under 18.. That’s a whole different type of mentality.

As for the posters saying his friend chose to get a car with him knowing he was drunk so it served him right 🤔You don’t know whether he was cajoled into the car by the driver saying he was OK (he was a child too) whether he asked him to stop as he was scared by the way he was driving (no one ever will) or what happened at all. All we know is that he ended.up dead and the driver didn’t. We don’t know if this was a long line of bad behaviour which obviously the OP is going to minimise as she has chosen to stay with him and he’s her DDs dad.

Obviously no one at the child’s school will know unless they are told as he is protected by anonymity due to his age at the time.

I probably wouldn’t offer up that info in the OP’s position until I’d made friendships with other parents and they knew you well enough to trust you and your DP.

They can make their own judgements on knowing you then. Unfortunately your DP’s crime is going to affect you and your DC, just the fact he’s got a criminal record will affect finances and going abroad. That’s for him to live with.

I’d be quite furious if my DC had a sleepover at your house and I didn’t know that there was a convicted criminal there I must say.

You did say some parents had already made judgements already without knowing his background, what does that mean?

I have known a few people who have done things in their youth they are not proud of and been sent to youth offenders institutions

In all cases they said it was the shock that straightened them out and set them on a better path.
Is no one allowed to forget stuff they are not proud of doing in their teenage years. Must they be reminded and avoided at all costs forever more. Must their children be punished as well.

As for the posters saying his friend chose to get a car with him knowing he was drunk so it served him right

I actually didn’t say “served him right” I was making the observation that he got into a stolen car knowing it was a stolen car

I followed it up with the fact that we need to instil confidence in our children. Try to get them to not be ruled by their emotions and instant gratification. Try to make them be more aware of situations that put them in danger and to walk away and encourage their friends to walk away as well.

What happens if your dc does the same.
No parent in the world can predict what their child’s teenage years are going to be like. You just have to hope you have put in enough that something sticks to keep them out of trouble and safe. Then hang on for the ride.

Phantomb · 13/11/2022 02:53

@IAmAReader how on earth do you know it was a ‘tragic accident’? The driver stole a car, drunk drove on either the very first day he’d passed his test or had no licence at all. That’s no ‘accident’.

The OP hasn’t said what actually happened with the friend, she doesn’t know and wasn’t there. The driver could have been doing 100mph for all we know with his friend begging him to slow down. The friend was not in control, the driver was.

He did kill someone. That’s not something that can be dismissed as well he’s done his time, move on.

Read some crap on here but this tops the lot!

@Flutterbybudget he wouldn’t have served a full sentence though would he? So would probably have got double that.

Problemoumo · 13/11/2022 02:47

Omg this is getting beyond.
OP good luck, I wish you all the best, your little DD deserves no less than her friends with blameless, perfect parents, and beware of that 'friend' who really is a ghoul loving the gravity of what happened and your predicament, she will make sure people know.

Ibouncetothebeat · 13/11/2022 02:42

Busy bodies looking for something to gossip about! He isn’t a threat to the children so no they don’t need to know. Drunk driving, whilst really bad with extreme consequences, has no bearing on him being around children.

belles001 · 13/11/2022 02:41

You are so kind. You are also terrifically tolerant, and way more than I would be in your situation.

Snoozer11 · 13/11/2022 02:38

So you moved in with him and his dad before you were together?

You fully immersed your daughter in his life before really knowing what he was like?

Sounds like a big mess and a lesson in how not to be a parent.

belles001 · 13/11/2022 02:36

Sorry I got that the wrong way around. Yes I would want to know.

ElEmEnOhPee · 13/11/2022 02:27

My step brother was killed in a similar way so that colours my view of the situation. The person driving when my step brother died wanted to run off from the scene, another friend wouldn't let him. He also was laughing and joking around in court. A few posters have said about OPs partner having paid the price, how it will stay with him forever blah blah blah ... Just know that not all young drink drivers who kill people are remorseful and will forever remember the pain and suffering they've caused.

Obviously due to my own circumstances I would want to know. I wouldn't stop my child playing with yours but I wouldn't want my child anywhere near your partner, ever. I'd also steer clear of you because I'd feel you condoned his behaviour, I appreciate that probably isn't the case, I appreciate that your partner may be genuinely remorseful and I'd be judging you based on my own circumstances but I'm just being honest.

Kind of sad how many people are minimising drink driving and the consequences of it. It tore our family apart and it was 20 years ago now, each year we ask would he have been married now, would he have had kids, where would he be working, it never goes away. A couple of years in prison is an insult to families who have lost loved ones through drink driving.

IAmAReader · 13/11/2022 02:27

Meraas · 13/11/2022 01:43

@IAmAReader

It is obviously a tragedy either way but the teen who sadly died wasn't an innocent bystander out doing their shopping.

But he was innocent. It’s not a crime to be a passenger in a car, it’s a crime to drink drive.

Some really scummy attitudes on this thread.

No, what's scummy is misrepresenting what happened in a tragic accident by mindlessly repeating 'he killed his best friend' without giving due consideration to the context @Meraas

I don't know about UK law on this matter, but in some American states you'd also be found guilty of a crime if you knowingly got into a car that was stolen with a driver you knew was under the influence. At the very least here in Britain there are moral implications of this - I personally would not have at any age got into a car with my friend who presumably had no licence, had no legal right to the car and most significantly was stinking of alcohol... because I'd have believed we were putting everyone on the road at risk.

OP's partner showed terrible judgement with fatal consequences but by the sounds of it his friend also made a poor decision to join him on this joyride, which is sad and understandable too because he too was only a teenage. So I am not saying this to condemn him, merely to point it out it's not quite the same as another teen out walking their dog and getting mowed over by this drunk young person. And it's definitely not the same as if in a moment of rage he turned on his friend and deliberately killed him.

And no, I'm not a drink driver or drink driver sympathiser. Unfortunately I don't even drive and I've been teetotal since I was about 18! For what's it worth I think drink driving should carry harsher penalties in terms of the jail sentences and driving bans but that doesn't change my opinion re. OP's partner.

Problemoumo · 13/11/2022 02:27

ilyx · 13/11/2022 02:01

I agree, I am sure drink driving is sadly common as I'm sure drug driving must be too. We are Saturday night and I wonder how may cars on the road right now should not be there
There's no minimising or defending it, it's intolerable. And it happens all the time

The people who are minimising it, and even worse are finding a way to blame the poor dead child are imo drunk drivers. I can’t think of any other explanation as to why they’re so desperate to blame him. It’s absolutely revolting.

No.
Drink/drug driving happens all the time.
Minimising doesn't happen all the time. No one is minimising or saying it's ok to drink or take drugs and drive. Literally no one on this thread is saying that.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 02:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 02:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

IAmAReader · 13/11/2022 02:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

@Imnothereforthegiggles At this point I believe it's wilful ignorance, they are deliberately ignoring the very important point you made and instead painting anyone who suggests reflecting on the context of him 'killing his friend' as ' stealth drink drivers' who are 'minimising his crimes'🙄

I don't know the full facts of the case, but if it comes out as the other teen in the car who died genuinely didn't know his friend had stolen the car/wasn't meant to be driving/wasn't drunk, okay I stand corrected but this is not the way it usually goes with teens involved in this kind of thing. They usually discuss it with their friends who often egg them on and join them in the full knowledge they're getting into a stolen car with a driver under the influence. Note - the friends who don't egg them on will not be getting into a car with them!

Phantomb · 13/11/2022 02:15

If it happened on his 17th birthday, had he even had any driving lessons? Had he passed his test that day? Drunk driving in a stolen car when you can’t even drive is not a mistake!

Imnothereforthegiggles · 13/11/2022 02:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Flutterbybudget · 13/11/2022 02:11

Phantomb · 13/11/2022 02:02

No I would not want my young DC in a house with a convicted criminal who’d served prison time for causing death or injury to someone else. No
matter that he was young and stupid and didn’t mean to steal a car and drive while drunk (not a teenage rite of passage IMO). He was still old enough to know better.

It would be different for me if it was his own car and he’d decided to drive home after a few drinks thinking he was alright so it was a down to impaired reflexes and he went into the back of something etc but he actually took someone else’s car and must have deliberately driven recklessly hence the longer prison sentence as 4 years is quite long for an under 18.. That’s a whole different type of mentality.

As for the posters saying his friend chose to get a car with him knowing he was drunk so it served him right 🤔You don’t know whether he was cajoled into the car by the driver saying he was OK (he was a child too) whether he asked him to stop as he was scared by the way he was driving (no one ever will) or what happened at all. All we know is that he ended.up dead and the driver didn’t. We don’t know if this was a long line of bad behaviour which obviously the OP is going to minimise as she has chosen to stay with him and he’s her DDs dad.

Obviously no one at the child’s school will know unless they are told as he is protected by anonymity due to his age at the time.

I probably wouldn’t offer up that info in the OP’s position until I’d made friendships with other parents and they knew you well enough to trust you and your DP.

They can make their own judgements on knowing you then. Unfortunately your DP’s crime is going to affect you and your DC, just the fact he’s got a criminal record will affect finances and going abroad. That’s for him to live with.

I’d be quite furious if my DC had a sleepover at your house and I didn’t know that there was a convicted criminal there I must say.

You did say some parents had already made judgements already without knowing his background, what does that mean?

He didn’t serve 4 years, though, did he? The accident happened on his 17th birthday. Then you have the length of the court case, before sentencing. And he’s been out of prison for 2 years. Meaning that he probably served around 18 months, possibly 2 years.

belles001 · 13/11/2022 02:11

No. I wouldn't.

notangelinajolie · 13/11/2022 02:10

OP I disagree, you are minimising.
However, your partner has served his sentence and I believe everyone should have a second chance.
I think you should consider moving away from the area you live and start afresh as a family in a place nobody knows you.
You sound committed to each other and your child and I wish you both well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread