Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sat no to MIL at Christmas

236 replies

Hyggerama · 12/11/2022 21:55

She is visiting us just now, before today we hadn't seen her since the beginning of 2020 when DD was a baby. DD will be 3 soon and we also have baby DS. Dh and MIL are usually LC.

MIL is all over the kids, quite literally. She basically follows DD around as DD plays with her toys. She hovers over DS as he's playing on the floor and tries to get his attention all the time by making clicking noises. I took DS out to play in the swing, MIL wanted to come with, which was fine. I popped out through our gate to say a quick hi to a neighbour who was in his garden, she followed me all the way! After playing in the garden I was walking towards our bins carrying DS to put something small in, she actually followed me to the bins rather than going inside the house.

All of this is made more awkward by the fact that MIL doesn't speak much English (Has lived in the UK for 30+ years) so rather than trying to talk to the children she does this physical following, hovering and making weird clicking noises.

She doesn't know DS's name, she called him 'the little boy'. Small mercies, DS doesn't like it when she tries to hold him and starts crying, DD refused to give her a goodnight hug when she asked. I'm neither encouraging or stopping the children from interacting with her and I let them just do what they feel comfortable with.

So AIBU, DH said he might invite her for Christmas, which would mean a minimum 4 day stay because of the trains. He's not being the best host atm, he's playing on his phone and doing work stuff whilst she's sitting in the living room with us. I would happily accommodate a 2 day stay but 4 days would just be too much for me, and probably the DC too!

I've said that she can visit after Christmas when the trains are running normally. She has a son and lots of close friends in her hometown so she wouldn't be alone.

OP posts:
Tryagainforthethirdtime · 13/11/2022 08:49

Excellent post @TheLadyofShalott1

My parents came to the UK in the 70s and their speaking of English was never more than basic. And here’s why:

They both went to work as soon as they arrived, in factories. Long days, poor pay. My dad worked six and a half days a week, we never went on holiday. Their days were spent working and looking after their children, that’s it. This thread is not the place to talk about the casual racism they constantly encountered, or about how my mum was hounded out of one job for being Asian, suffice to say they felt safer within their own community.

They had some sympathetic, nice English friends who were lovely people. I could count them on one hand. My mum tried to have English lessons. I remember a woman coming round at weekends to help her. She just couldn’t do it, it was too hard, she was too tired. And others mocked her trying to learn, asking if she thought she was better than everyone else. She soon stopped.

I married a white, English man. My parents speak to him in their broken English. He hasn’t learnt one word of their language, not even hello, has no interest.

I haven’t taught my children my language as and I really regret it now. They are however, involved in their Asian culture wherever I can manage it.

OP doesn’t say where her MIL is from, or why her DH is LC. I think this is important as different cultures have different ideas of family means.

Absolutely agree OP’s DH should step up here. He should be facilitating the relationship between his DM and his children but also between his DM and OP.

ChubbyMorticia · 13/11/2022 08:15

I’m not understanding some of the suggestions on this thread, especially the ones saying OP should learn MIL’s language and teach the children.

OP is ALREADY bilingual, AND has ensured the children are as well! Why does she need to learn a third language?!

This is completely on her husband. HE should be teaching the kids, if anyone, but has chosen not to. That’s completely on him. He sits on his phone, rather than engage his mother. He’s seemingly done nothing to make this visit work.

Why would the OP want a repeat on the holidays for even longer?

This is wholly on the relationship between the DH and his mother, imo. Expecting the OP to manage with a language barrier, with the MIL at her heels constantly is ridiculous.

Completely unreasonable and unfair to dump the situation on his wife and expect her to make it work.

IncompleteSenten · 13/11/2022 08:09

I would say oh yes she can visit if you stay off your fucking phone the entire time and actually interact with her instead of buggering off to play with your toys and leaving it all up to me

LuckySantangelo35 · 13/11/2022 08:06

Just be nice to her op
it’s not hard

LuckySantangelo35 · 13/11/2022 08:04

@Hyggerama

“She doesn't know DS's name, she called him 'the little boy'. Small mercies, DS doesn't like it when she tries to hold him and starts crying, DD refused to give her a goodnight hug when she asked“

what do u mean small mercies?

PlinkyPlonk1 · 13/11/2022 07:53

It seems quite suffocating to me, having someone following you around everywhere. That would annoy the fuck out of me. The clicking would too!

I also don't get the living in a different country for 30 years and not at least learning the basics of the language. I think that most people would at least pick something up in the first few years. I have friends that are bilingual and I ask them to teach me the basics of their language so that I can use it. I think it shows a sign of respect.

Similarly, if I visit a country where I don't know the language, I think it's respectful to speak their language much as possible and not presume or expect them to speak English to me.

It is mostly your DH's responsibility to host your MIL if you're not able to communicate with her and he is. I wouldn't want a Christmas visit either.

LostDaydream · 13/11/2022 07:42

JeanRondeausMadHair · 12/11/2022 22:43

I can't imagine living somewhere for thirty years and not learning the language.

We don’t know her story. Maybe she was young and in an abusive relationship in the early years of being in England (or wherever OP lives) and wasn’t allowed to go to English classes. Or maybe she was 40 when she came here and it’s harder to learn a new language as you get older. You couldn’t learn online 30 years ago.

WarmWinterSun · 13/11/2022 07:34

Buying her a subscription to English lessons is insensitive because it’s not really a gift. It’s a way of telling your mil that you think she should learn English dressed up as a gift. Get her a proper gift at Christmas and treat the language issue as a separate thing to be addressed with care. My gp lived in an English speaking country for many years, at 30, and did not learn English. She was not really educated and had many fears if the world. I wish she had learnt to speak English but I think she would have been hurt by being given a ‘helpful’ English language course as a present. This is an issue to handle with care and for the OP to discuss with her husband

FlamingBells · 13/11/2022 07:29

The Op's post comes from a position of privilege whereby she has no interest in the mil's culture. The op regards her own is the dominant one & her kids are more familiar with it.

I've seen this in mixed relationships before whereby one culture is more dominant than the other. The children identify with one culture more and the second one slowly is faded out.

Pamlar · 13/11/2022 07:26

I hear where you're coming from: irritating house guests are draining. But I also feel sorry for her. She isn't natural with the kids, but it seems like she wants to be close to them.
There are ways to foster a better relationship with them -the kids will follow your and your dh's lead if you encourage them to do activities with her. But it's up to you how much you feel like making an effort.
I get that mil has made little effort but longterm it would benefit everyone if your kids had a good relationship with her.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/11/2022 07:05

I really don’t see what your mil has done so very wrong. I understand she’s annoying when benchmarking her against an assertive and engaging mature woman, who is fluent in English. However, it sounds as though she’s a product of her own culture and upbringing.

What did your mil do so very badly that your dh is LC? Do you realise that by not engaging with her in front of the children or explaining to her what her grandmother is doing is actually hostile and a continuation of LC? Do you see your husband is also continuing LC with her in your own home? Your children are taking your lead. They can sense there is something wrong and are reacting by copying the LC.

I am not surprised she has cried. Or that you have seen so very little of her. It must be taking a great deal of courage to visit you all. She sounds very anxious and completely out of her comfort zone with a son, who hardly acknowledges her existence and a dil, who is not facilitating a relationship with her gc’s despite her desperately trying to make a connection with them.

Please try to show some kindness to this woman. All you need to say things like ‘granny is trying to do x’ or ‘Granny wants a hug good night. Would you like to give her a hug? No? Ok. Blow her a kiss then’.

My DD’s grandfather desperately wanted to have a connection with her but was too ill and had lost the ability to speak - motor neurones. Darn right I tried my best to facilitate that by talking to dd about him and how to act around him. That in no way means forcing her. I never forced dd and she really struggled. But she knew everyone was on her side.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/11/2022 06:51

@TheLadyofShalott1
That is such a thought evoking post. I hope that op tries to understand life from her mil’s perspective, which is so very different from her (and my) privileged position of being fluent in other languages.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 13/11/2022 05:52

I'm sorry, but I just don't understand why so many of you commenting here are talking in such a very unlikeable, judgemental, and obtuse manner. Is it because you totally believe the OP's version, even though we all know that the human condition makes most of us exaggerate when we want to both make an (often unsavoury) point, and have as many people as possible agree with us?

The culture that the OP's MiL comes from is probably so different to the Western European one, that even if they learned to speak our language when living in this country, but without them being in a community full of people from their own culture, they might struggle to be happy. Most of us have grown up in a country where women are allowed to be strong, allowed to have, and to get to the top of any profession we have chosen for ourselves. Yes, we might think that we are still treated badly by many men in our own culture, but I promise you, that compared to the women from the different cultures I am thinking about, we already have almost total freedom and power.

The OP's poor MiL probably comes from a culture where very few men consider women to have any value whatsoever, except to be used for sex, to have children, cook and clean, and really just be there to look after and obey the males in their families. Many are not allowed to have any form of education, and certainly don't have either the confidence, or the expectation of success, to beg their husbands, fathers, brothers, and adult sons, to let them do anything different, such as learn another language. So, for the millions of women who still live like that, even if they haven't lived in their country of birth for over 30 years, it may well have not even crossed their minds that they could (or may be allowed to) learn another language.

The OP's husband might have been low contact with his mother because he may feel that she is no longer of much use to him, as he now has his own wife to fulfil the roles of both a mother and a wife. So many men from the cultures I am thinking of still feel that females are at the very best, second class citizens, and that their whole role is to serve the males in their society. Of course in the Western World, those men have had to modify their outward behaviours to a certain extent, if they wanted to attract women from cultures other than their own, but I honestly believe that for at least some of them, deep down, they still have very little respect for women. Of course I don't think that all men from those cultures still think and act like that, but I do think that a significant number of them still do, even if they hide it well.

So to judge an older lady, who may well still live in a culture like that - and if she does she almost certainly has little or no
self-confidence - for not learning our language, and for not pushing to see her Grandchildren, who she obviously adores, and also for maybe feeling that she is not wanted or needed by her son's new family, is just nasty in my opinion. The OP seems to be judging her MiL against Western women, and how we behave and react. I am just very glad that I was born into, and that my ancesters (at least the recent ones that I know about) were also born into, our Western European culture. I think that the OP's attitude, and apparent lack of compassion, or empathy, for her MiL, is actually quite horrible (eg she is happy when her children - unintentionally- hurt their poor Grandmothers feelings).

FinnysTail · 13/11/2022 05:29
  • Hindi
FinnysTail · 13/11/2022 05:18

Fattoushi · 13/11/2022 00:28

Whatever, I still can’t see what your MIL did that was so wrong, especially when nobody is able to converse in the same language

She hasn't bothered to learn her grandsons name.....

Thats a bit of a stretch.

My sons paternal family don’t refer to family members by name. They refer to them as son/daughter, brother/sister, cousin, nephew/niece…. As a term of endearment.

I always used to wonder why my ds’s grandparents called them both Peter when neither are called Peter. It turns out they were calling them Beta which is Hindu for son/child.

It seems OP’s MIL is making an effort to speak English if she’s calling her GS “The Little Boy”.

greenteafiend · 13/11/2022 02:27

if you think people would harangue an old Brit immigrant to learn Spanish in Spain then you’re wrong.

No, but people on Mumsnet frequently criticize such people---rightly.

Trust me, some immigrants - regardless of where they are immigrated to - are a bit lazy, and think that lessons are magic and that the language learning will just happen even if they are living in a bubble and not bothering to use the language in their daily lives.

I know a few people like this.

They annoy their fellow immigrants, because they are always getting themselves into situations where they can't sort things out, and then they are on the local FB group begging for help, "Can someone just take a few hours off work? My kid's having issues at school and I need to be able to talk to the teacher..." Or clogging up the group feed with endless photos of paperwork and things that have come through the mail. Nobody minds helping out a newbie, but people like this are really annoying when the requests just keep on coming and you know they've been in the country for years.

askmenow · 13/11/2022 02:23

LillianGish · 12/11/2022 22:42

You've married someone from a different culture, but you sound as if you don't want to make any concession to that. It must be incredibly awkward for your MIL if she doesn't speak much English and your DH/her son is not making an effort to include her. She may of course be a totally inconsiderate pain in the a* , but by making it about the language difference it reads as if you are not being very hospitable. Do you speak any words of her language? Will your DH teach your children? Try and put yourself in her shoes for a moment. You can't just edit her out of your life because she's not English - she's your children's granny.

Im sorry, WTF! Mil has lived in this country for 30 years and doesn't speak the language ??? What concession has MIL made? She has made no attempt to learn English! Given she's been here for 30 years, I take it she's on the census and can vote, yet hasn't attempted to integrate at all.

Sweetiepie14 · 13/11/2022 01:48

My children don’t have any family apart from me ,their mum .My mum died a year ago from cancer and she was another mother to the children, they simply adored her .My brother,my childrens uncle was also extremely close to my children sadly passed away too.I am the only person left in their world there is no other family on either side and I know my children would do anything to have their nan (and uncle ) back in their life …I can fully understand her being in your home (and face)would feel irritating ,especially with the communication barriers and the fact you are very unfamiliar with her ,however ,If hubby can do his part to make things easier and give you a break from the intensity ,then I think for a few days over Christmas,I would try it out .It’s about making memories and life is short .Try to embrace family for the sake of your children ,it is their grandmother and she sounds as though she just wants to be with them ,I know it’s hard but don’t take that for granted as the more family that can bond with your children,the better

GADDay · 13/11/2022 01:40

One day you too will be old and lonely.

You will realise this OP. I just hope it's not too late. Arseholery is a choice.

Mlb123 · 13/11/2022 01:33

Hyggerama · 12/11/2022 22:19

@EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall from what DH has told me she only socialises and works with other people from her community. She's got a translator when she sees a GP etc and DH did a lot of translating and helping when he was young, so basically she's never really had to learn English.

Unless you raise your children to be bilingual it will be hard for them to have a meaningful relationship with your mil as they get older. It's hardly ideal now with her clicking constantly and making gestures. No wonder the little ones are freaked out and you irritated. If she is that interested in a relationship with you then you would think that she would at least have learned some simple English . I wouldn't want her there for 4 days at Xmas either . Let her come for a night, two at most after Xmas xx

Meraas · 13/11/2022 01:20

greenteafiend · 13/11/2022 01:11

What do you think about British people who go abroad and never learn the language, do you think that’s acceptable I wonder?

I do know what you mean. There is a certain brand of very right-on reverse-xenophobia (oikophobia?) on these boards, where UK people who live abroad without learning to speak good Spanish (or whatever) get scorn poured on them (racist, Brexiteers, gammon, typical useless Brits), but immigrants who live in the UK without learning to speak English are Noble But Oppressed Persons of Color who must have every excuse made for them.

Immigrants to the UK are just people, not saints, Like everyone else in the world, they vary; some immigrants to the UK genuinely are cowardly or lazy about learning the language. Or do that thing of saying that "Of course I want to learn to speak English well" and going to classes, BUT insulating themselves from any need to use the language in their day to day lives (using interpretors all the time, only talking with other members of their diaspora). You don't learn a language unless you deliberately put yourself into situations where you have to actually use itlessons aren't enough! Yes, some people esp women may have been trapped at home in restrictive traditional marriages which can make things hard. Still, my own experience (I am an immigrant in a non English speaking country) is that it is mostly about attitudepeople who actually want to learn their language, invariably find a way.

That said, she's old (presumably) and learning English now would be a bit of an ask--the moment has passed and she's probably too used to interpretor-workarounds to fix this now. Get DH to spend time with her. It's his job, if he's the one who speaks her language. He needs to get off the screens and stop being idle.

You sound very smug and if you think people would harangue an old Brit immigrant to learn Spanish in Spain then you’re wrong.

So don’t do it here.

Moonshine5 · 13/11/2022 01:17

Not everyone is lucky enough to have the resource / confidence / support to learn a language. Don't entertain her if you do not wish to but don't blame the lack of language. Btw communication can be felt in many forms both positive and hostile.
Christmas could be considered a compassionate for time with family, friends and loved ones.

Morestrangethings · 13/11/2022 01:16

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 12/11/2022 22:15

She's lived in the country for over 30 years but still can't speak the language? Why not!

Could be a heap of reasons. Maybe she’s really bad at learning new languages. Shrug. Not speaking English is not a moral failure.

OP: your husband really needs to step up. Imo, he’s being a bad host and son and a lazy.

greenteafiend · 13/11/2022 01:11

What do you think about British people who go abroad and never learn the language, do you think that’s acceptable I wonder?

I do know what you mean. There is a certain brand of very right-on reverse-xenophobia (oikophobia?) on these boards, where UK people who live abroad without learning to speak good Spanish (or whatever) get scorn poured on them (racist, Brexiteers, gammon, typical useless Brits), but immigrants who live in the UK without learning to speak English are Noble But Oppressed Persons of Color who must have every excuse made for them.

Immigrants to the UK are just people, not saints, Like everyone else in the world, they vary; some immigrants to the UK genuinely are cowardly or lazy about learning the language. Or do that thing of saying that "Of course I want to learn to speak English well" and going to classes, BUT insulating themselves from any need to use the language in their day to day lives (using interpretors all the time, only talking with other members of their diaspora). You don't learn a language unless you deliberately put yourself into situations where you have to actually use itlessons aren't enough! Yes, some people esp women may have been trapped at home in restrictive traditional marriages which can make things hard. Still, my own experience (I am an immigrant in a non English speaking country) is that it is mostly about attitudepeople who actually want to learn their language, invariably find a way.

That said, she's old (presumably) and learning English now would be a bit of an ask--the moment has passed and she's probably too used to interpretor-workarounds to fix this now. Get DH to spend time with her. It's his job, if he's the one who speaks her language. He needs to get off the screens and stop being idle.

Smallonesaremorejuicy · 13/11/2022 01:07

I feel kinda sorry for her , give her a chance.