Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sat no to MIL at Christmas

236 replies

Hyggerama · 12/11/2022 21:55

She is visiting us just now, before today we hadn't seen her since the beginning of 2020 when DD was a baby. DD will be 3 soon and we also have baby DS. Dh and MIL are usually LC.

MIL is all over the kids, quite literally. She basically follows DD around as DD plays with her toys. She hovers over DS as he's playing on the floor and tries to get his attention all the time by making clicking noises. I took DS out to play in the swing, MIL wanted to come with, which was fine. I popped out through our gate to say a quick hi to a neighbour who was in his garden, she followed me all the way! After playing in the garden I was walking towards our bins carrying DS to put something small in, she actually followed me to the bins rather than going inside the house.

All of this is made more awkward by the fact that MIL doesn't speak much English (Has lived in the UK for 30+ years) so rather than trying to talk to the children she does this physical following, hovering and making weird clicking noises.

She doesn't know DS's name, she called him 'the little boy'. Small mercies, DS doesn't like it when she tries to hold him and starts crying, DD refused to give her a goodnight hug when she asked. I'm neither encouraging or stopping the children from interacting with her and I let them just do what they feel comfortable with.

So AIBU, DH said he might invite her for Christmas, which would mean a minimum 4 day stay because of the trains. He's not being the best host atm, he's playing on his phone and doing work stuff whilst she's sitting in the living room with us. I would happily accommodate a 2 day stay but 4 days would just be too much for me, and probably the DC too!

I've said that she can visit after Christmas when the trains are running normally. She has a son and lots of close friends in her hometown so she wouldn't be alone.

OP posts:
DameHelena · 14/11/2022 15:31

Your DH needs to step up and host his mother.
Tell him clearly and calmly that you'll be going out and doing things (with and without the DC) and so he'll be 'in charge of' his mother. As a pp said, things like 'I’m nipping out for a bit/going for a bath/having an early night… tomorrow I’m going for a long walk with my friend so you and MIL are looking after the kids.

And if he says you're a horrible person, you are allowed to push back. Get angry with him! Tell him straight, no, you just need him to take his turn with his mother.

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 15:14

@Fattoushi I do agree. I particularly love the fact that it's MY fault my DC are only learning 2 languages. We live in the UK and MIL has had decades to learn without any barriers, she's had years and years of English lessons, but obviously it's my fault she's struggling to communicate with her grandchildren.

She's not a bad person but I feel uncomfortable hosting her. I have the right to have feelings and opinions, even if she is my children's grandmother.

Not that it matters that she's got a 9 year old grandson (DN), whom she's seen 3 times since he was born. Granny of the year anyway!

OP posts:
DeborahVance · 14/11/2022 15:13

*you

DeborahVance · 14/11/2022 15:13

I've no idea why you're getting quite such a hard time here. Your husband is the problem, if he wants his mother here then he should support her. He sounds like an absolute arse in the way he is undermining your

Labnehi · 14/11/2022 15:05

Soozikinzii · 14/11/2022 14:44

I was going to say this . It will be great for your children to be bilingual . Such a big advantage in life and good for the brain. I am a covid GP and it has been difficult making the GP/GC bonds at this time I think weve only just about caught up . Although I do agree 2 days is enough to stay with family at any time of year for me Xmas or not !

OP's kids are already bilingual, on her side. OP's husband has chosen not to teach them his language, and he has that right.

Soozikinzii · 14/11/2022 14:44

FinnysTail · 12/11/2022 22:27

Why haven’t your dc learnt to speak their fathers cultural language as well as their mothers? Surely parents provide their dc with knowledge of both their birth cultures?

I was going to say this . It will be great for your children to be bilingual . Such a big advantage in life and good for the brain. I am a covid GP and it has been difficult making the GP/GC bonds at this time I think weve only just about caught up . Although I do agree 2 days is enough to stay with family at any time of year for me Xmas or not !

Fattoushi · 14/11/2022 14:35

OP, MN has decided they know far more about you and your MIL than you do. I'd give up if I were you!

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 13:07

@TheLadyofShalott1 and you can with absolutely certainty inform me that my husband's mother doesn't speak fluent English because she's been abused and grown up in an oppressive culture, you don't even know what culture that is?

If she's divorced and has lived with her dc or on her own for a long time. What has been her barrier to learning?

OP posts:
Mischance · 14/11/2022 12:46

There is nothing to stop your OH spending time with her with the children there, engaging in some play/activities with them together and facilitating them getting to know each other in a gentle way..... "Why don't you give that toy to Grandma?" etc. He needs to step up. I would be furious with him.

When my FIL used to visit, my OH, who didn't get on with him, used to duck out and leave me to deal with him. It made me so mad!

LadyKenya · 14/11/2022 10:56

TheLadyofShalott1 · 13/11/2022 05:52

I'm sorry, but I just don't understand why so many of you commenting here are talking in such a very unlikeable, judgemental, and obtuse manner. Is it because you totally believe the OP's version, even though we all know that the human condition makes most of us exaggerate when we want to both make an (often unsavoury) point, and have as many people as possible agree with us?

The culture that the OP's MiL comes from is probably so different to the Western European one, that even if they learned to speak our language when living in this country, but without them being in a community full of people from their own culture, they might struggle to be happy. Most of us have grown up in a country where women are allowed to be strong, allowed to have, and to get to the top of any profession we have chosen for ourselves. Yes, we might think that we are still treated badly by many men in our own culture, but I promise you, that compared to the women from the different cultures I am thinking about, we already have almost total freedom and power.

The OP's poor MiL probably comes from a culture where very few men consider women to have any value whatsoever, except to be used for sex, to have children, cook and clean, and really just be there to look after and obey the males in their families. Many are not allowed to have any form of education, and certainly don't have either the confidence, or the expectation of success, to beg their husbands, fathers, brothers, and adult sons, to let them do anything different, such as learn another language. So, for the millions of women who still live like that, even if they haven't lived in their country of birth for over 30 years, it may well have not even crossed their minds that they could (or may be allowed to) learn another language.

The OP's husband might have been low contact with his mother because he may feel that she is no longer of much use to him, as he now has his own wife to fulfil the roles of both a mother and a wife. So many men from the cultures I am thinking of still feel that females are at the very best, second class citizens, and that their whole role is to serve the males in their society. Of course in the Western World, those men have had to modify their outward behaviours to a certain extent, if they wanted to attract women from cultures other than their own, but I honestly believe that for at least some of them, deep down, they still have very little respect for women. Of course I don't think that all men from those cultures still think and act like that, but I do think that a significant number of them still do, even if they hide it well.

So to judge an older lady, who may well still live in a culture like that - and if she does she almost certainly has little or no
self-confidence - for not learning our language, and for not pushing to see her Grandchildren, who she obviously adores, and also for maybe feeling that she is not wanted or needed by her son's new family, is just nasty in my opinion. The OP seems to be judging her MiL against Western women, and how we behave and react. I am just very glad that I was born into, and that my ancesters (at least the recent ones that I know about) were also born into, our Western European culture. I think that the OP's attitude, and apparent lack of compassion, or empathy, for her MiL, is actually quite horrible (eg she is happy when her children - unintentionally- hurt their poor Grandmothers feelings).

You have made so many valid points in this post. Some of the comments on here are just unnecessarily thoughtless, with no real understanding at all about the barriers some people may face in life.

Fattoushi · 14/11/2022 10:55

I am sorry - but you do not have to be "thrilled" - we all do things with our families that we might have preferred not to, but we do them out of kindness and thoughtfulness.

But only the OP...the MIL goes away with friends every time OP visits MILs home town, but its OP who needs to be more kind and thoughtful?

WTF is up with this thread? IT's like MIL is perfect and can do no wrong, against all info to the contrary.

Mischance · 14/11/2022 10:09

I am sorry - but you do not have to be "thrilled" - we all do things with our families that we might have preferred not to, but we do them out of kindness and thoughtfulness.

There is no reason at all why your DD should feel comfortable about hugging someone she barely knows - but that is just normal and happens in all families - not all would regard this as signifying some pathology in MIL, but just as a small passing incident.

I really think you need to cut her some slack - it is not as if she is going to be living with you permanently. Your OH needs to put in the effort when she visits, just as we all do with our relatives. Honestly, 4 days is just a drop in the ocean; and if you feel that she has not yet got to know your DC, then here is the golden opportunity.

Talk to her - or get your OH to, if the language barrier will not allow - and say that she needs to take it gently and give the children a chance to get to know her bit by bit.

Your OH really is ducking out here, especially as he shares her language. You need to have firm words with him - not so he will "tell her off" but so he will do things with her; and especially things involving him and the children so that MIL can gradually get to know the children with someone who she can converse with there to gently curb her excesses.

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 09:58

SIL and her partner visited us recently. SIL was always the favourite child but she hasn't seen MIL for over a year. SIL also said she finds spending time with her awkward and uncomfortable and she prefers spending Christmas with her partner's family. If her own daughter finds her awkward why would I be thrilled to bits to spend 4 days straight with her?

OP posts:
Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 09:48

@Mischance yes small mercies because MIL quite clearly thought that the dc would bond with her instantly and she wouldn't have to put any effort in. She was a complete stranger to my DC, why would DD be hugging her and wanting to hold her hand etc when effectively she's never met her granny before. Trying too hard over a period of 2 days doesn't make up for no effort over 3 years.

H has admitted that her behaviour is strange and she probably has some kind of special needs, but he says her behaviour is harmless. It might be harmless but this obsessive following really makes me uncomfortable. My thoughts and feelings matter too!

DD is only little so she doesn't have the vocabulary to express if she feels really uncomfortable, apart from saying no to hugs and holding hands etc. What if she does feel uncomfortable, do we force her to bond with MIL if she doesn't want to? Do her feelings not matter?

OP posts:
Mischance · 14/11/2022 08:57

I have not read all the thread, but it sounds as though you are being a bit harsh on her, when the problem lies with your OH who is playing on his phone in another room rather than engaging with his own mother.

I hear that you find her behaviour irritating, but reading what you have written there seems nothing there that is objectionable. But when something gets under your skin it looms larger in your mind. So I hope some of the posts here, from a distant view, might help you to achieve some balance.

It sounds as though she is trying hard - maybe a bit too hard - to the point where you find her annoying - and where you can seriously write that your DC refusing her friendly advances is seen as a "small mercy." That is simply downright cruel.

These children are going to have to learn to get on with her - she will be around throughout their childhoods at the very least; and also learn about respecting people of any age. You need to change your attitude and set them good example for the rest of their lives.

I hope that in the fullness of time you do not find yourself spurned by your son's wife.

You need to do two things:

  • rethink what matters in life and the values you want your children to learn by example.
  • have a very firm conversation with your OH about his responsibilities to his mother and how it is entirely unacceptable that he is distancing himself from her during her visit. He needs to be engaging with her, sharing memories with her, taking her out and generally putting some effort into making her visit a happy one.
LookItsMeAgain · 14/11/2022 08:38

Also, your DH is taking time off work to spend with his mother as well as with you so let him spend time with his mother! I'd wonder how many future trips would be shelved if he was spending one-on-one time with just her without you and the kids there to talk to and do things with.

LookItsMeAgain · 14/11/2022 08:36

I thought one of the treatments for arthritis is to try to keep moving so your bones and muscles don't seize up. It doesn't have to be a power-walk (as in what you would see in the Olympics as the Walking Race), just a gentle stroll but the fact that he isn't even trying is speaking volumes.

Book those flights to see your family. You've spent time with his family and now it's time to spend time with yours.

Puppyseahorse · 14/11/2022 08:14

Why would your H be livid if you spent time with your own parents at Christmas?

or left the house on your own?

both those things are concerning

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 08:11

@mathanxiety this is the issue, whilst MIL seemed perfectly happy just sitting on the sofa or following the children around obsessively, I found it very suffocating. I suggested that DH takes her for a walk just that she gets out of the house but he can't apparently because she's got arthritis. He doesn't think he needs to plan any activities for her.

My only option will be to plan activities for just me and the dc so basically sneak them out of the house just to get some space because otherwise MIL will insist on coming too. H would be very upset if I did this but I can't honestly see how I'll cope with being with her all the time for 4 days and not being able to be with my children without her stalking me (or them)

Or maybe I could plan to fly to see my parents on boxing day, but again this would make H livid because he's taking time off work for Christmas.

Her lack of English isn't an insult to immigrants, I'm an immigrant too. I mentioned it to highlight why I find it awkward to host her, and H doesn't seem likely to host.

OP posts:
StampOnTheGround · 14/11/2022 05:28

I have a similar issue with FIL following DS around and never giving him space, it's so annoying and I wouldn't want that on Christmas Day, it would be unbearable!

mathanxiety · 14/11/2022 04:06

You have a big problem with your H.

Make it clear that if he doesn't spend all of his time for the M's visit entertaining her and organising her, she is not crossing your threshold again.

It's completely up to him to decide what level of contact with your family this woman has - if he fails to behave as you need him to then that's the consequence of his choice.

Her behaviour when you were recovering from an EMCS (and his too) is beyond gobsmacking.

AliceAbsolum · 14/11/2022 00:55

This thread is ridiculous.
OP say no to this woman! That intensity would drive me insane for 4 days. Spend a day or 2 with her at some point. That's fine

PrincessFiorimonde · 14/11/2022 00:44

I have not read the whole thread, but I have read all the OP's posts.

Why on earth should the OP be expected to host her MIL when her husband is not pulling his weight here? If he wants his mother to stay over - either at Christmas or at any other time - why is he just "playing on his phone and doing work stuff whilst she's sitting in the living room with us" while his mother is visiting at the moment?

Puppyseahorse · 14/11/2022 00:22

RunLolaRun102 · 13/11/2022 22:28

Don’t be ridiculous: she’s their GRANNY. Kindness goes beyond languages - perhaps you need to work on that

I really can’t get on with this assumption that sharing DNA with a child creates an automatic bond or obligation of love. OP’s kids don’t owe their GRANNY anything. It doesn’t sound like MIL has made much effort in the past. So, yes, she is a virtual stranger to the DC right now, GRANNY or not.

OP, I would hate this situation- particularly the one in your latest update. As others have said, this really is a DH problem. Over Christmas, make your own plans and get out of the house (to the extent possible.) Let DH entertain her. Do not prepare for her visit & tell DH you expect Christmas prep to be on his shoulders. That’s all you can do. That, and seriously put some work into deciding if this marriage is for you.

and yes, it is obnoxious not to bother to learn the language of your new country after 30 years.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 13/11/2022 23:58

Just a quick one this time
@Hyggerama Could you please clarify for me (and probably some of the other PP's as well) how your visits to your MiL's town ever always coincide with her being away coincidentally, as I am finding it hard to understand the situation?

In my family and circle of friends, a visit to see someone important to us, but who lived far enough away that we would be staying overnight in some sort of commercial establishment, would start with this conversation:

"Hi friend/loved one, we have the weekend of xx/xx/xxxx free, will you be available if we stay at ????? ?????, that weekend, as obviously there is no point in us coming if you are going to be away, or too busy?"

await the reply, then after having a response from them, my reply would be along the lines of:

"Oh that's a pity that you will be away that weekend. Can you let me know a selection of dates when you will be at home please, as we are really looking forward to seeing you again - it has already been too long!"

Swipe left for the next trending thread