Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sat no to MIL at Christmas

236 replies

Hyggerama · 12/11/2022 21:55

She is visiting us just now, before today we hadn't seen her since the beginning of 2020 when DD was a baby. DD will be 3 soon and we also have baby DS. Dh and MIL are usually LC.

MIL is all over the kids, quite literally. She basically follows DD around as DD plays with her toys. She hovers over DS as he's playing on the floor and tries to get his attention all the time by making clicking noises. I took DS out to play in the swing, MIL wanted to come with, which was fine. I popped out through our gate to say a quick hi to a neighbour who was in his garden, she followed me all the way! After playing in the garden I was walking towards our bins carrying DS to put something small in, she actually followed me to the bins rather than going inside the house.

All of this is made more awkward by the fact that MIL doesn't speak much English (Has lived in the UK for 30+ years) so rather than trying to talk to the children she does this physical following, hovering and making weird clicking noises.

She doesn't know DS's name, she called him 'the little boy'. Small mercies, DS doesn't like it when she tries to hold him and starts crying, DD refused to give her a goodnight hug when she asked. I'm neither encouraging or stopping the children from interacting with her and I let them just do what they feel comfortable with.

So AIBU, DH said he might invite her for Christmas, which would mean a minimum 4 day stay because of the trains. He's not being the best host atm, he's playing on his phone and doing work stuff whilst she's sitting in the living room with us. I would happily accommodate a 2 day stay but 4 days would just be too much for me, and probably the DC too!

I've said that she can visit after Christmas when the trains are running normally. She has a son and lots of close friends in her hometown so she wouldn't be alone.

OP posts:
Tesal · 15/11/2022 17:17

Good luck OP and stick to your guns. Ignore all the judgemental posts and the ones that claim to know all about your MIL.🙄
Happy Christmas.

Somuchgoo · 15/11/2022 15:52

I'm glad you've got things sorted, but this stood out to me:

Can you imagine a guest who never leaves you alone, who sits with you awkwardly all day, stalks your children and won't go to bed until you do? She won't entertain herself by reading a book or going to the guest room to take a nap etc. H might come from a different culture but I have my own culture too, and anyone from my culture would find that kind of a guest exhausting.

Maybe I'm in the minority here, but I wouldn't start reading a book, or popping out, or going for a nap, if I was round someone's house. Or I might occasionally if I was feeling claustrophobic, but I'd feel very rude doing so.

When I've had guests to stay, bar perhaps then going out for a run, or popping to the shop to buy some extra snacks to share, we tend to stick together, stay up late chatting/playing games etc. I've never had a guest start reading, or going up for a nap.

Puppyseahorse · 15/11/2022 15:36

Well done @Hyggerama - good for you standing up for yourself and actually, this sounds like a good compromise- DH gets him mum staying for Christmas, which was what he wanted, and you get time to yourself (with kids.)

LOL at the idea that you’re being ‘uptight.’ You’re standing up for yourself when your husband has tried to walk all over you and disregarded your feeling & preferences. Not uptight, just not a doormat.

greenteafiend · 15/11/2022 12:17
Sorry to make light, but your whole situation is REALLY reminding me of the Father Ted episode where Father Stone comes to stay for an indefinite period....
Hyggerama · 15/11/2022 11:22

@greenteafiend someone who understands where I'm coming from, thank you! I love Christmas and I should be able to enjoy it without feeling anxious and awkward all the time.

OP posts:
Hyggerama · 15/11/2022 11:19

@MrsDooDaa it's not the season of giving up my mental health though. If she's here for 3 nights and I'm taking DC for a playdate with a close friend that's hardly stopping her from spending time with the DC.

When DD was a newborn I had to do the same thing and invent reasons just to escape the house with DD. MIL is harmless but socially awkward and a bit exhausting to be with, her own children say that so it's not just my opinion.

It should be H's job to reign her in if she becomes OTT with the DC, but if I can't trust him to do that so I need to take DC out so that we can all get a breather.

Can you imagine a guest who never leaves you alone, who sits with you awkwardly all day, stalks your children and won't go to bed until you do? She won't entertain herself by reading a book or going to the guest room to take a nap etc. H might come from a different culture but I have my own culture too, and anyone from my culture would find that kind of a guest exhausting.

OP posts:
greenteafiend · 15/11/2022 09:52

Every minute of Christmas planned to the minute - your DH sent off on his own with his mum. Sounds like a shit time to me. If a kid can't break the nap routine at Christmas, well that's just odd.

Did you even read the thread? The OP has told DH to take MIL off somewhere because she can't actually talk to anyone else in the house and if she is in the house, she follows the OP around like a lost sheep while DH plays games on his phone. Too right, I'd be ordering him to take her somewhere and spend some of his time entertaining her.

Also, some kids are a screaming mess if they miss their nap. If the OP takes a cranky overtired child to the panto who whines and cries and ruins it for everyone, everyone will judge her for that instead. Mothers literally cannot win sometimes.

Mischance · 15/11/2022 09:42

I am glad you have found a plan. I hope it works for you all.

It really is not acceptable for your OH to tell you he does not like being around his Mum, and definitely not alone together. It is often difficult having a visitor to stay (even if it is someone you love dearly, disrupting your usual routines, but pulling together as a family to help it go smoothly is what needs to happen and this includes OH - especially as it is his mother! He really is some sort of wimp to dump it all on you. And he is sending an unacceptable message to his children about the status of older people.

You need clarity for future visits, so he knows he cannot just duck out.

ImAvingOops · 15/11/2022 08:49

@LookItsMeAgain , yes of course ex pats should learn Spanish if they've moved to Spain - it's just rude not to.
Tbh I don't understand why anyone would want to spend their whole lives in a country where they can't communicate with the majority. So limiting not to be able to even go to a doctor without having someone there to translate for you.

minipie · 15/11/2022 08:46

The problem is the DH quite clearly.

The OP has arranged to go out as that is the only way she won’t be left hosting MIL while DH sits on his phone/laptop.

If the Dh could be relied on to pull his finger out, be sociable and do the bulk of chatting to his mum, ensuring she’s not being weird with the kids etc then this wouldn’t be necessary. But he’s shown he can’t be relied on to do that.

I do think it is quite odd for two adults to go out to a panto without taking DD though. I think you should allow DD to go to the panto - she’d probably enjoy it.

On the other hand I would re think your Christmas day plan. In your shoes I would offer to do the cooking as that means DH has to look after DC and MIL. If DH is doing the cooking he’ll use that as a get out from being sociable with MIL.

MrsDooDaa · 15/11/2022 08:36

From you posts OP, I don't think anyone's behaviour in this situation is great - MIL, DH or you.

It's not a great example to set for the DC all round.

Could you not be the bigger person here and be around a bit more over Xmas rather than organising playdates etc? It is the season of giving.

MichelleScarn · 15/11/2022 08:34

GADDay · 15/11/2022 06:23

I think the Hygge has left the building.

Totally get that you don't want Granny around. That's fine. Would not be my way of doing things bit hey - just tell her to piss off she isn't welcome. You come across as so damn miserable and controlling. I feel sorry for the whole family.

Every minute of Christmas planned to the minute - your DH sent off on his own with his mum. Sounds like a shit time to me. If a kid can't break the nap routine at Christmas, well that's just odd.

Your level of uptightness isn't normal - would it be ourrageous to ask if you are OK?

Am sure @Hyggerama is perfectly OK. (But probably so grateful for your condescending 'concern')
So all of this is her fault and she's your villain?
The MIL is a poor, defenceless hard done to victim and the DH is not even mentioned. Just by being female its on OP to manage everything?

DameHelena · 15/11/2022 08:33

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 22:00

@DameHelena damn right he does! I've developed a plan of action and presented it to H. Basically, he does not want to spend any alone time with his own mother because he finds her awkward. He said himself that he doesn't like spending time with her, so his idea is to use the children and I as a buffer so he doesn't actually have to host her. Not on my watch...

Here's my plan
H is working on Christmas Eve so I'm spending a nice mini Christmas with the kids at home. MIL arrives in the afternoon.

Christmas Day we have to just spend at home, some walks and lots of TV. Me playing with kiddos in a different room if necessary. H will sort out all food.

Boxing day I take DC out for a playdate with my friend and her dc, H will take MIL out shopping, for lunch etc. H and MIL go to see a panto together in the afternoon whilst I stay at home with DC. He doesn't like this idea because he'd be alone with her. He tried to say he'd take DD with them but the panto will clash with nap time or bed time, plus she wouldn't want to go without me if she knows I'm at home. He wants DD as a buffer, not happening because he has invited her so he needs to step up.

27th MIL goes home

H's face when he realised he would actually have to host! 🤣

Well done, OP!

LookItsMeAgain · 15/11/2022 08:30

ImAvingOops · 15/11/2022 07:49

@TheLadyofShalott1 why should someone be thanked for going to lessons to learn the language of the country they've lived in for 30 years?
Its basic good manners to try.
Personally I think it should be a legal requirement for people moving to England to learn English.

I have no problem with your final statement there @ImAvingOops , just so long as you also agree that all of the British ex-pats that have retired to Spain or France should be legally required to learn Spanish or French when they move there.

ImAvingOops · 15/11/2022 07:49

@TheLadyofShalott1 why should someone be thanked for going to lessons to learn the language of the country they've lived in for 30 years?
Its basic good manners to try.
Personally I think it should be a legal requirement for people moving to England to learn English.

GADDay · 15/11/2022 06:23

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 22:00

@DameHelena damn right he does! I've developed a plan of action and presented it to H. Basically, he does not want to spend any alone time with his own mother because he finds her awkward. He said himself that he doesn't like spending time with her, so his idea is to use the children and I as a buffer so he doesn't actually have to host her. Not on my watch...

Here's my plan
H is working on Christmas Eve so I'm spending a nice mini Christmas with the kids at home. MIL arrives in the afternoon.

Christmas Day we have to just spend at home, some walks and lots of TV. Me playing with kiddos in a different room if necessary. H will sort out all food.

Boxing day I take DC out for a playdate with my friend and her dc, H will take MIL out shopping, for lunch etc. H and MIL go to see a panto together in the afternoon whilst I stay at home with DC. He doesn't like this idea because he'd be alone with her. He tried to say he'd take DD with them but the panto will clash with nap time or bed time, plus she wouldn't want to go without me if she knows I'm at home. He wants DD as a buffer, not happening because he has invited her so he needs to step up.

27th MIL goes home

H's face when he realised he would actually have to host! 🤣

I think the Hygge has left the building.

Totally get that you don't want Granny around. That's fine. Would not be my way of doing things bit hey - just tell her to piss off she isn't welcome. You come across as so damn miserable and controlling. I feel sorry for the whole family.

Every minute of Christmas planned to the minute - your DH sent off on his own with his mum. Sounds like a shit time to me. If a kid can't break the nap routine at Christmas, well that's just odd.

Your level of uptightness isn't normal - would it be ourrageous to ask if you are OK?

user1477391263 · 15/11/2022 04:33

I love how, in this thread,

It's apparently the OP's responsibility to make MIL (who her own son admits is a difficult person and not easy to be around) comfortable all day long, even though useless husband is the one who invited her AND it's his mum AND she only really speaks HIS language.

It's apparently the OP's responsibility to learn the MIL's language, but not MIL's responsibility to learn some English (because language-learning is simultaneously so easy that the OP can learn it, just like that, alongside childrearing and everything else while living in the UK, AND so hard that MIL can't possibly be expected to manage a bit of broken conversation after decades of lessons).

It's apparently the OP's responsibility to make sure her children learn Husband's language, even though it's HIS bloody language and she is ALREADY getting her kids bilingual in English and her other, different language. (Trust me, trilingualism is hard and takes a lot of commitment and organization by both parents).

Hope the visit goes OK, OP. Stay busy, keep out of the house, tell DH to get off his phone or you'll "accidentally" leave it out in the back garden in the rain.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 15/11/2022 03:16

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 13:07

@TheLadyofShalott1 and you can with absolutely certainty inform me that my husband's mother doesn't speak fluent English because she's been abused and grown up in an oppressive culture, you don't even know what culture that is?

If she's divorced and has lived with her dc or on her own for a long time. What has been her barrier to learning?

Hi Hyggerama, I don't remember saying anywhere that your MiL was abused and grew up in an oppressive cultute. I certainly did not day that I was 100% sure of it.

I was trying to glean from your posts why she might be behaving in a way that was so alien to how you thought a grandmother should be, and my suggestion was that she may come from a very different culture from yours, and that if she does, it is quite possible that neither of you understand why the other one behaves in the way that they do.

As you say, I have no idea what her living arrangements have been - except that she has lived in a foreign country (to her) for 30 years, has possibly never had her DiL (you) visit her in the town she has lived in for 30 years because - maybe conveniently - she has never been at home when you visit, and apparently, even though you have to pay somewhere to stay overnight when visiting her, you never actually check that she will be at home when you do visit?

In a recent post of yours @Hyggerama you said

"... she's had years and years of English lessons..."

I speak 1 language fluently OP, I can communicate reasonably well in another language, and I can understand bits and pieces of a language we were taught at school, but that I didn't try to get a qualification in. All of the languages that I know something of, come mainly from Latin, and to a lessor extent, Ancient Greek, with a bit of Norse, and snippets from many other languages.

As we have already established, and therefore agreed upon, I hardly know anything about your MiL, but if I may use as an example a theoretical 'fact', that she comes from either Asia major or minor (you are quite right, I should just say Asia rather than Asia Major, however colloquially I hope that it will help more people understand what I mean), your MiL would have as her mother language a very different structural criteria to my own. Which of course, in very general terms, means that unlike me, and the languages I have tried to learn, your MiL's (theoretical) genealogical history, combined with her now living in a continent with languages that mainly follow a very different linguistic typology, may well have led to her inability to learn English.

Yes, of course, millions of people have managed to overcome the extra barriers caused by different linguistic types, but then there are maybe millions of more people that are never able to break those barriers down. After all it is not just about learning what, say, the French word for table is, and what the Japanese word for table is - I really hope that it isn't also "table"! Very different cultures, histories, personal upbringings, ones own confidence etc etc, will all play a part in our own abilities to learn anything, including another language.

Is there any academic subject that you are particularly bad at OP? One of my parent's was excellent at Maths, unfortunately, for several reasons, I was useless at it. I quite diligently built up a 20ft tall, and 15ft wide, metaphorical brick wall against maths/my parent(?), and it has only been in more recent years that with the help of a good friend, I have been able to start demolishing that wall - I very much doubt that I will be able to raze it completely. You have told us OP that your MiL spent many years having English lessons, which I think she should be commended for, and thanked for, for making such a tremendous effort, and commiserated with for just not being able to master such a foreign concept!

My DMiL couldn't swim, she was a very intelligent and determined lady, but she had built her own brick wall when it came to swimming. A person who has the condition Dyslexia, may very much want to be able to read and write with ease, and their desire may help them learn and perservere with all sorts of techniques, and help. If they don't succeed to the amount they want to, or heaven forbid their Son or DiL thinks they should have been able to, does that mean that they should be looked down on because of it, or ridiculed, or punished? I am trying not to judge you for judging your MiL, for being what I consider is very unkind to your MiL.

If I judge you then I am no better than you, and I am afraid that I do indeed judge the things you have said in your posts about your MiL, and in quite a few of your replys to people who have similar views to mine. I hope that you have at least questioned yourself about whether there could be any truths or insights in what any of us have said. I do indeed spend quite a lot of time trying to understand how other people tick, and what good and/or enriching lessons I can learn from them.

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 22:38

@GreenFingersWouldBeHandy oh I will. The boxing day morning playdate has already been set up. H tried to argue that MIL is coming over to be with the DC but that doesn't mean it has to be all the time every day!

I think he might be rethinking this whole visit now...

OP posts:
frazzledasarock · 14/11/2022 22:34

Good for you, that’s a perfect plan of action. The host her son should damn well be spending time with his mother, whom he invited.

carry it through. I bet he won’t be inviting her for quite so long after being forced to spend time with his own mother.

god I hate men who think they’re the dogs bollox for inviting their insufferable parents to the family home and then avoiding them completely leaving the actual work of cleaning, feeding and entertaining to their wives.

make him get her room ready too, she gets what he’s got ready for her.

LookItsMeAgain · 14/11/2022 22:08

Make sure those panto tickets are bought or he'll have an excuse "oh they were sold out" or some such.

I love that he doesn't even want to spend time alone with her. Why the actual does he think that you'd welcome spending time with her then? I mean really!!!

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 14/11/2022 22:03

Haha just saw your update. Nice one! But carry it through.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 14/11/2022 22:02

he's playing on his phone and doing work stuff whilst she's sitting in the living room with us

You have a DH problem. He needs to talk to his mother.

Hyggerama · 14/11/2022 22:00

@DameHelena damn right he does! I've developed a plan of action and presented it to H. Basically, he does not want to spend any alone time with his own mother because he finds her awkward. He said himself that he doesn't like spending time with her, so his idea is to use the children and I as a buffer so he doesn't actually have to host her. Not on my watch...

Here's my plan
H is working on Christmas Eve so I'm spending a nice mini Christmas with the kids at home. MIL arrives in the afternoon.

Christmas Day we have to just spend at home, some walks and lots of TV. Me playing with kiddos in a different room if necessary. H will sort out all food.

Boxing day I take DC out for a playdate with my friend and her dc, H will take MIL out shopping, for lunch etc. H and MIL go to see a panto together in the afternoon whilst I stay at home with DC. He doesn't like this idea because he'd be alone with her. He tried to say he'd take DD with them but the panto will clash with nap time or bed time, plus she wouldn't want to go without me if she knows I'm at home. He wants DD as a buffer, not happening because he has invited her so he needs to step up.

27th MIL goes home

H's face when he realised he would actually have to host! 🤣

OP posts:
SMrs · 14/11/2022 15:42

I can relate to this with my FIL. He doesn't bother very much with us or our children. He even has forgotten my husbands birthday and normally calls him a few days early or late each year to wish him happy birthday.

He does the same in that he is really attentive when with the kids (1 or 2 times a year). I do encourage them to be respectful and engage in the relationship and I talk about him coming a few days prior to prepare them.

I find my husband feels awkward in his presence so normally I'm a good buffer as we can just do general chit chat.

That being said, I wouldn't want to share my Xmas day with him if it was to stay over for a few nights. Sounds selfish, but Christmas is really special to us and I've made a vow to not spend it with people who don't make the effort year round as I spent years doing that in my 20s and 30s!

Xmas day will just be us this year and I'm really happy about it