Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sat no to MIL at Christmas

236 replies

Hyggerama · 12/11/2022 21:55

She is visiting us just now, before today we hadn't seen her since the beginning of 2020 when DD was a baby. DD will be 3 soon and we also have baby DS. Dh and MIL are usually LC.

MIL is all over the kids, quite literally. She basically follows DD around as DD plays with her toys. She hovers over DS as he's playing on the floor and tries to get his attention all the time by making clicking noises. I took DS out to play in the swing, MIL wanted to come with, which was fine. I popped out through our gate to say a quick hi to a neighbour who was in his garden, she followed me all the way! After playing in the garden I was walking towards our bins carrying DS to put something small in, she actually followed me to the bins rather than going inside the house.

All of this is made more awkward by the fact that MIL doesn't speak much English (Has lived in the UK for 30+ years) so rather than trying to talk to the children she does this physical following, hovering and making weird clicking noises.

She doesn't know DS's name, she called him 'the little boy'. Small mercies, DS doesn't like it when she tries to hold him and starts crying, DD refused to give her a goodnight hug when she asked. I'm neither encouraging or stopping the children from interacting with her and I let them just do what they feel comfortable with.

So AIBU, DH said he might invite her for Christmas, which would mean a minimum 4 day stay because of the trains. He's not being the best host atm, he's playing on his phone and doing work stuff whilst she's sitting in the living room with us. I would happily accommodate a 2 day stay but 4 days would just be too much for me, and probably the DC too!

I've said that she can visit after Christmas when the trains are running normally. She has a son and lots of close friends in her hometown so she wouldn't be alone.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AutumnCrow · 26/12/2022 18:02

DH doesn't like MIL and doesn't enjoy her company, she's only seen us once in the past 3 years and doesn't know our son's name but she thinks she's granny of the year and constantly follows our DD when she's finally seeing her. She's socially inept and awkward and I can't have a normal conversation with her but DH has invited her for 4 days over Christmas because he thinks it'll be nice for her. Would I be U R to be pissed off?

Yes, that very much should have been your OP, @Hyggerama. It's now 'hidden' mid-thread and will get ignored by tonnes of posters who can't even be arsed reading all of the OP's posts, let alone the actual thread.

Redebs · 26/12/2022 17:44

JudgeJ · 12/11/2022 22:38

It may well be a joke but I have little patience with people, usually women, who have lived in this country for 30 years but can't speak the language although I do know from experience that that's not always been their choice.
Before we get the usual, I lived abroad and did learn the language.

In some cultures women don't feel comfortable mixing outside the family. Don't be so judgemental

KettrickenSmiled · 06/12/2022 19:55

@MichelleScarn Blush

What a sweet thing to say. Also - take comfort, you are statistically likely to be younger than me Wink

Anyway, I committed a bold fail in that post.* *Rats.

MichelleScarn · 06/12/2022 16:23

Basically everything @KettrickenSmiled has succinctly put above!
If I had written that and was younger and cooler (if cool's even a thing to be these days!) Id have added 'mike drop at the end 😎

KettrickenSmiled · 06/12/2022 16:13

Gosh what a depressing thread 🥺Personally, I can’t see what it is your MIL has done so wrong to warrant so much hate. There has to be a back story.
Don't worry, there is, & you will feel much less depressed when you RTFT.

For reasons, best known by yourself, you don’t want MIL to visit for Christmas. That should be enough. You don’t have to make plans to avoid her. Just let her know she won’t be welcome for Christmas, & why.
For reasons stated clearly by OP, neither MiL or DH really want her to be there for xmas.
Hence her now coming in January.

TBH your posts read that your husband is a selfish, lazy so and so.
More that he is avoidant, because he doesn't get on with his mother.
Yet your wrath is directed toward his mother, who would like to know her grandchildren.
She really doesn't. You'd know that if you'd RTFT.

There will be women, all over the UK, hosting their in laws this Christmas. Whether they like them or not. She may not be your mother but she is your children's grandmother. Why are you denying your children a relationship with their grandmother?
Again, if you'd RTFT, you;d know that it's the GM is the one denying herself family relationships. With her own DC, & with her GC.
The fact that other women are hosting MiL's this xmas is nothing to do with OP, & her specific situation with her MiL, who tends to avoid contact with her family, doesn't ''do' xmas anyway, & is content to visit in January instead.
OP isn't denying anybody anything.

NosieRosie · 06/12/2022 13:01

Gosh what a depressing thread 🥺Personally, I can’t see what it is your MIL has done so wrong to warrant so much hate. There has to be a back story.

For reasons, best known by yourself, you don’t want MIL to visit for Christmas. That should be enough. You don’t have to make plans to avoid her. Just let her know she won’t be welcome for Christmas, and why.

TBH your posts read that your husband is a selfish, lazy so and so. Yet your wrath is directed toward his mother, who would like to know her grandchildren.

There will be women, all over the UK, hosting their in laws this Christmas. Whether they like them or not. She may not be your mother but she is your children's grandmother. Why are you denying your children a relationship with their grandmother?

sm506156 · 20/11/2022 18:04

The phones and facetime works 2 ways not just one. You mil needs to learn English plus you need to learn her language as well. She is just trying to be close to her dil and her grandchildren and you don't see it nor appreciate it. Your husband also needs to entertain his own mom while she is there not just you and the kids.

NumberTheory · 18/11/2022 01:11

FinnysTail · 17/11/2022 21:00

And you think OP has welcomed her DC’s grandmother into their lives because….? 🤷🏻‍♀️

that’s totally besides the point since her DH hasn’t welcomed his DM into their lives but is now expecting OP to do all the mediating, buffering and facilitating.

NumberTheory · 18/11/2022 01:08

thinkfast · 17/11/2022 22:23

Have you tried being a bit more direct with her OP?

"Could you sit over there please MIL? You're too close to me and it's a bit oppressive."

"Stop clicking at DC please MIL. It's getting a bit much"

"Please stop following me MIL. I'd prefer you not to come with me right now"

"Why are you staring at me MIL. It's quite intense if you stare at me like that and you're making me feel very uncomfortable."

Probably less effective than you’re imagining when they don’t share a language (which is, you’ll recall, the reason MiL is clicking at the DC in the first place).

FinnysTail · 17/11/2022 22:34

thinkfast · 17/11/2022 22:23

Have you tried being a bit more direct with her OP?

"Could you sit over there please MIL? You're too close to me and it's a bit oppressive."

"Stop clicking at DC please MIL. It's getting a bit much"

"Please stop following me MIL. I'd prefer you not to come with me right now"

"Why are you staring at me MIL. It's quite intense if you stare at me like that and you're making me feel very uncomfortable."

Or even.. “I’m going to feed DS now. MIL Would you make us a nice cup of tea?”

Christmas - Is there anybody who hasn’t hosted their in laws for Christmas? Whether they want to or not. Everyone manages to cope with the disruption, once a year … or 3.

thinkfast · 17/11/2022 22:23

Have you tried being a bit more direct with her OP?

"Could you sit over there please MIL? You're too close to me and it's a bit oppressive."

"Stop clicking at DC please MIL. It's getting a bit much"

"Please stop following me MIL. I'd prefer you not to come with me right now"

"Why are you staring at me MIL. It's quite intense if you stare at me like that and you're making me feel very uncomfortable."

MichelleScarn · 17/11/2022 21:50

FinnysTail · 17/11/2022 21:00

And you think OP has welcomed her DC’s grandmother into their lives because….? 🤷🏻‍♀️

And the evidence the MIL has welcomed the OP into her life?...

LookItsMeAgain · 17/11/2022 21:16

@FinnysTail - your post is a personal attack on the OP, in my opinion. I didn't once get the impression that the OP thought herself as the perfect DiL.

FinnysTail · 17/11/2022 21:00

MichelleScarn · 17/11/2022 20:56

This reads like all you've taken from the thread is they haven't seen MIL in 3 years, and you've just then made some shit up!

And you think OP has welcomed her DC’s grandmother into their lives because….? 🤷🏻‍♀️

MichelleScarn · 17/11/2022 20:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This reads like all you've taken from the thread is they haven't seen MIL in 3 years, and you've just then made some shit up!

NumberTheory · 17/11/2022 20:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wow, that’s a nasty response.

I care what OP does to the extent I care about any AIBU thread.

It’s not at all clear that it is possible for OP to develop a meaningful and positive connection between her DC and her MiL. Her MiL hasn’t made the effort and her DH isn’t making the effort. It can be a struggle to balance your own needs against those of everyone else in your family, but when no one else is getting it together, martyring yourself and making your own life miserable isn’t a net improvement on the situation, or fair to yourself.

FinnysTail · 17/11/2022 20:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hyggerama · 16/11/2022 10:58

@Jimzle this DIL doesn't like MIL's behaviour because because MIL has a history of not understanding personal boundaries.

  1. Bursting into my bedroom at 2am whilst I'm half naked trying to breastfeed a crying baby. If I had needed help I would have asked my husband.
  1. Refusing to hand my baby back to me when she was crying and clearly needed a feed when I had asked repeatedly.
  1. Creeping in the corridor outside my bedroom whilst I was trying to nap with my newborn. I know this because I heard her steps and heard her stopping right outside the door for several minutes.
  1. Sitting right next to me on the sofa and openly staring at me whilst I was breastfeeding, staring the entire time. We had two sofas, she didn't have to sit right next to me.
  1. Making weird clicking noises to baby DS and standing right behind me whilst I'm playing with him in the swing. Why didn't she just speak to him in her native language if she didn't know how to interact with him in English? I never speak to him in English.

Tell me that you would have no reservations about your MIL if she behaved like this?

OP posts:
Hyggerama · 16/11/2022 10:45

@Jimzle thanks for the insight, have you read any of my posts?

I have never been unwelcoming nor hostile towards her. Yes I complain about her on an anonymous discussion forum but in RL I'm capable of being polite to a person I'm not particularly fond of. I don't need to be best friends with her and my husband said that he doesn't like his own mum. The fact that she can't speak English just makes it more awkward because it's hard to communicate. I know plenty of people who don't speak perfect English, but they are sociable people who are easy to get on with. Dh says he finds her awkward even when they speak the same language.

Making an effort to connect with children you don't know doesn't mean stalking them and trying to hug them and force them to interact with you. Rome wasn't built in a day, she can't force a loving bond with young children in the space of a few days. Children are also entitled to their personal space and DH should be reminding his mum to follow DD's lead in this.

OP posts:
Jimzle · 16/11/2022 10:36

To be fair mil isn't really being weird given the language barrier. DIL just doesn't like her because of it and is painting the efforts to connect without language as weird probably due to inexperience with this sort of situation.

But the issue is her intolerance of nonverbal communication, like affection clicking. My did used to click at me and we didn't have a language block, so her assertions of "weird" are just inexperience.

I think it's unhealthy to demonize ppl for not speaking our language as this post and some of the comments are doing.

Jimzle · 16/11/2022 10:31

YTA.

You are acting hostile and unwelcoming seemingly because she cannot speak English. She sounds loving and seems to be making a real effort to connect by making herself available.

I suspect you are the reason the kids are having trouble connecting to her because kids always know when their parents don't like someone and it's obvious you have extreme distaste for this poor woman.

I don't see why her being unable to speak english and loving being near your kids when in town is a problem and I certainly don't get why 4 days at Xmas is an issue from what you're describing. Maybe you should give your family some space while you get yourself sorted.

Somuchgoo · 16/11/2022 10:05

Hyggerama · 16/11/2022 09:41

@Somuchgoo I would assume that your Christmas guests are people that you enjoy spending time with, you want to spend time with and you can easily have a chat with? None of these things applies in my situation.

We can't chat or play games, I can't take my baby son to play outside without MIL breathing down my neck and I can't have any privacy with DH. I don't think he's actually thought about that. Our DC are great sleepers now and evenings would be a time for us to enjoy each other's company since he won't be working for change. That won't be happening with MIL sitting next to us the whole time.

Not necessarily.
My guests, sure. But my husband family, friends etc, aren't always people I would choose to spend time with.

If they are in my house, as guests of the family, it doesn't matter whether they are my best friend or someone I barely tolerate. They are our guests and I would assume they would be with me (or someone else in the household) the vast majority of the time.

Hyggerama · 16/11/2022 09:41

@Somuchgoo I would assume that your Christmas guests are people that you enjoy spending time with, you want to spend time with and you can easily have a chat with? None of these things applies in my situation.

We can't chat or play games, I can't take my baby son to play outside without MIL breathing down my neck and I can't have any privacy with DH. I don't think he's actually thought about that. Our DC are great sleepers now and evenings would be a time for us to enjoy each other's company since he won't be working for change. That won't be happening with MIL sitting next to us the whole time.

OP posts:
Hyggerama · 16/11/2022 09:34

Just a different POV. After my paternal grandfather died my family and my aunties took turns to host my grandmother over Christmas. Of course we loved her and we had known her our whole lives, but she was a very anxious person and critical person and the atmosphere would instantly change when she went home and we could actually relax. She only lived 30 min away but preferred to stay overnight. Just saying that hosting older relatives doesn't automatically create magical Christmas memories for children.

Well MIL is coming now so I'll just have to deal with it the best way I can whilst trying to find some Christmas joy.

Obviously my comments have been met with a lot of criticism and I wonder how different it would have been if I hadn't mentioned that MIL was from a different culture and didn't speak much English?

If I had simply said that DH doesn't like MIL and doesn't enjoy her company, she's only seen us once in the past 3 years and doesn't know our son's name but she thinks she's granny of the year and constantly follows our DD when she's finally seeing her. She's socially inept and awkward and I can't have a normal conversation with her but DH has invited her for 4 days over Christmas because he thinks it'll be nice for her. Would I be U R to be pissed off?

OP posts:
TheLadyofShalott1 · 16/11/2022 01:11

Somuchgoo · 15/11/2022 15:52

I'm glad you've got things sorted, but this stood out to me:

Can you imagine a guest who never leaves you alone, who sits with you awkwardly all day, stalks your children and won't go to bed until you do? She won't entertain herself by reading a book or going to the guest room to take a nap etc. H might come from a different culture but I have my own culture too, and anyone from my culture would find that kind of a guest exhausting.

Maybe I'm in the minority here, but I wouldn't start reading a book, or popping out, or going for a nap, if I was round someone's house. Or I might occasionally if I was feeling claustrophobic, but I'd feel very rude doing so.

When I've had guests to stay, bar perhaps then going out for a run, or popping to the shop to buy some extra snacks to share, we tend to stick together, stay up late chatting/playing games etc. I've never had a guest start reading, or going up for a nap.

Absolutely Somuch, I wouldn't even have thought that I could (politely) go off for a quiet nap or to read my book (however much I might have enjoyed doing that!). If they were all staying together for a week or more, that might be different, but any generally healthy adult should be able to manage a relative for 3 or 4 nights, even if that guest becomes the hosts shadow for those 3 or 4 days!

I do think that the OP should ask her husband (as he does speak his mother"s tongue) to make sure that his mum knows to make herself at home, including some time to herself if she wants it. As for it being over Christmas time, my personal beliefs are that for adults Christmas is much more about giving than receiving - especially of ones time and love.