Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else got DC applying for uni this year - beyond annoyed

293 replies

Lionlover11 · 12/11/2022 12:20

DD is 18 and applying for uni this year and the grades are literally insane. Good Russel groups
are asking for grades previously only oxbridge would ask for and former poly universities that previously would have been easier to get into have now shot up to 3 B’s. All because of covid deferrals. I’m absolutely livid on DD’s behalf that predicted of ABB (very good results imo) will not be enough to get her into a Russel group for the course she wants to do. It feels like this year group have suffered so much already because of the pandemic and now because of covid deferrals it’s bitten them on the backside again. I’m half considering telling DD to forget applying for this year, get the best a levels she can and just apply next year when hopefully the grades have eased off. Anyone else in the same boat?

OP posts:
maplesaucewithbacon · 12/11/2022 17:58

Actually the 'poly-universities' have been around since 1994 so that's nearly 30 years, although there are some instituations that got their uni status later that were not polytechnics but colleges of various types who previously had their degrees awarded by a partner university. And some of these 1994-or-later universities are very high up in the tables especially for certain subjects. Most of them deliver excellent teaching, often better than Russell group unis - check out the teaching and satisfaction tables.

OP although I understand to an extent where you are coming from you sound like a university snob who doesn't actually know what you are talking about and therefore not best placed to advise your DD.

Also dare I say it but in practice, a 2:1 from a slightly 'lesser' university is usually more useful than a 2:2 from a Russell group one as 2:1 is a threshold for entry to some jobs, master's and for PhD funding. Don't encourage her to go somewhere she might struggle.

This is the cohort that your daughter is going to have to go through uni with and apply for jobs againt, bearing in mind that courses are 3-5 years long and some people take a year out first, so the yeargroups get scrambled anyway. She needs to apply to somewhere she thinks is just about attainable, do her best, and see how the cookie crumbles. If she is prepared to be flexible, she can also attempt to get something in clearing if she doesn't hit her choice(s).

karalimed · 12/11/2022 17:58

When I applied to uni 13 years ago RG unis wanted AAB+. The most popular courses like English and Law needed AAA even then.

You need to be realistic. ABB is good but not amazing (I got A*BB myself so it's not a dig). Your DD needs to be looking at less popular courses or lower ranked unis.

Kr1st1n37374 · 12/11/2022 17:55

Very few employees will give a shit which Uni you went to.

Knickerthief1 · 12/11/2022 17:52

I don't think that's anything new. But don't get caught up on the Russell Group unis. It just means they are good for research which may be irrelevant for what your daughter wants to do anyway. Look at The Times review of universities and see which uni's are rated best for the subject area you want. As others have said look at the grades for different course. My daughter is at a Russell Group uni - her offer was A,B,B because of the course she was doing.

Dishwashersaurous · 12/11/2022 17:49

It's the introduction of the A star which makes a difference.

So years ago the highest you could get was AAA.

Now it's Astar AStar Astar.

Therefore in modern terms a ABB. Is the equivalent of an old BCC. Which is perfectly fine, but not good or high grades.

If you think that she's going to do better than predicted then might be worth delaying application. But if that is likely what she is going to get then no point delaying.

Norma27 · 12/11/2022 17:48

I agree. When I graduated only 4 people (all female!) out of at least 200 achieved a First on my course.

ghostyslovesheets · 12/11/2022 17:47

@Lionlover11 isn’t coming back I don’t think but what I suspect was a goady little thread has turned into an interesting discussion!
glad most people have a decent perspective on the issue

PiccoloPenguin · 12/11/2022 17:46

RG is just a marketing group. People get too hung up on it. Exeter got into the club on the back of incorporating a medical school. It's not such a huge deal and for some courses RG isn't best.

PiccoloPenguin · 12/11/2022 17:44

@RampantIvy I don't think a first class degree has the same kudos as years ago. I got a First in a difficult subject from a highly ranked university twenty five years ago. I remember it being asked about at length by interviewers at graduate interviews and I'm sure job offers came mostly on the back of it. Wouldn't be such a big deal now.

GyozaGuiting · 12/11/2022 17:43

You say ‘ex poly’ like they’re shit.
Loughborough is an ex poly, regularly top 10 and beats RG Unis now.

Greenalien1 · 12/11/2022 17:39

I wouldn't say they've gone up loads? I needed BBB to get into Plymouth Uni nearly 10 years ago now and that's not a redbrick or Russell group. When I look at places like Exeter they were all AAB or above which I knew was too much for me

Bigbadmama · 12/11/2022 17:38

midgetastic · 12/11/2022 12:41

Sometimes it's worth thinking about the course choice

Some slightly less obvious courses can be very good but much less heavily subscribed

Agreed. sometimes its easier to get into a joint honours course, especially if a course involves modern languages. She may be able to switch courses once she gets there.

Rewis · 12/11/2022 17:36

If they have enough quality applicants with high grade requirements then RG universities don't really have an incentive to make lower requirements.

RampantIvy · 12/11/2022 17:32

but AAA can also be bought by those with money to fund extracurricular activities

What extra curricular activities can you buy to get AAA unless it is extra tuition?

DD had to work hard to achieve AAA in 2018, and I find it depressing that her achievement is being dismissed by some posters. I suppose her first class degree in a STEM subject from an RG university is nothing to shout about either these days 😢

mizu · 12/11/2022 17:31

DD1 applying this year. Needs AAA or AAB for most of the unis she applying for. Really wants to study at Edinburgh but apparently hard to get in. We weren't surprised at those grades needed.

Sestriere · 12/11/2022 17:26

Grades at Leeds University are the same as they have been since 2015 when DD went, I have just checked.

surreygirl1987 · 12/11/2022 17:26

I went to a RG University almost 20 years ago and I needed AAB then (A had to be in that subject). It went up after the introduction of A* grades. I do agree that children going to uni at the moment and over the last couple of years have it tough, but it's not just due to covid. Also, students are still competing against each other as they always have - if they're good enough they'll get in. I don't think ABB would ever have been good enough though, at least not for the more academic, reputable courses.

Aldith · 12/11/2022 17:26

I meant to add to the above that my husband does not have a single higher or A level to his name but he still managed two university degrees in architectural technology and building surveyor. He found another way of achieving it and got straight into third year for his second degree (Scotland so four year course). Not getting the grades doesn’t mean you can’t achieve what you want it may just take a slightly different or creative approach.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 12/11/2022 17:24

My DBro missed out on going to a Russel group uni back in 2002 because he got ABB in his exams. His offer was AAB. So I don’t think it’s a new thing at all.
he went to a non Russel group uni through clearing and was very happy there. Russel group isn’t the best all and end all.

imtheglue · 12/11/2022 17:24

My DD has applied for 2023 and received an offer yesterday at a Russell Group with ABB requirements - she’s predicted AAA

Hdudfuw3 · 12/11/2022 17:23

I work in a Russell group uni, high grades are nothing new. We actually took more students last year and have a bulge. When I did mine AAB got you into Oxbridge so no idea how easy is it to get the A*AA that we now expect but there are plenty of students to choose from. Have to say the quality of our students hasn't gone up so I can only think that its easier to get those A'level results same as its certainly easier to get a 1st than 20 years ago, thats grade inflation for you

PiccoloPenguin · 12/11/2022 17:21

@Grumpybutfunny it's not the A Levels that are the so significant now for medicine - it's clinical entrance exam score that is the key differentiator. Medicine is actually relatively low tariff at AAA generally (lower for contextual) . For comparison computer science at Manchester is A STAR A STAR A STAR. The UCAT bar is rising every year. It is positive that the personal statement is relied on less and that GMC ruling was because more advantaged students had unfair advantage there and you can even engage PS consultants to (help) write them. There is ample opportunity for med applicant DC to get over what they have done in volunteering etc. in their interviews, which count for a lot in the process, so it is not as if this element is being ignored.

Aldith · 12/11/2022 17:18

My friends husband went to university around 25 years ago and got a degree in English. He now has a job that he loves and earns good money doing it but he would not have needed a degree to do the job and he is paying the student debt for a degree he didn’t need.

University isn’t everything. Depending on what career you want there may be another way. My DH has two university degrees but after surgery on his back he can no longer do the job he trained for. He earns more money driving an HGV than the job his degree lead to offered.

Norma27 · 12/11/2022 17:14

One of above posts made me think of my Bristol offer. I was a slightly mature student applying for law in 1998. I had sat one a level after one year and got A. Bristol then offered me B,B even though others still asked for at least AAB from my remaining 3 A levels. Another I was sitting in one year.

Ralphswife · 12/11/2022 17:13

40 years ago I got into a RG uni with AAC after an interview with the Head of Department. I am now an academic at the same uni and can't say our grade requirements have changed over the years. As other have said, Oxbridge is a different process so less reliant on grades.
My advice is to make sure your DD is looking at the right course and then pick the uni that is the right fit for her. I teach postgraduate students - a mix from Oxbridge, RG and non-RG unis, and they all go on to do amazing things.
These days a degree is another step on an education/career journey that can take many years, the key is to make sure each step on the journey is taking you in the right direction.