Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else got DC applying for uni this year - beyond annoyed

293 replies

Lionlover11 · 12/11/2022 12:20

DD is 18 and applying for uni this year and the grades are literally insane. Good Russel groups
are asking for grades previously only oxbridge would ask for and former poly universities that previously would have been easier to get into have now shot up to 3 B’s. All because of covid deferrals. I’m absolutely livid on DD’s behalf that predicted of ABB (very good results imo) will not be enough to get her into a Russel group for the course she wants to do. It feels like this year group have suffered so much already because of the pandemic and now because of covid deferrals it’s bitten them on the backside again. I’m half considering telling DD to forget applying for this year, get the best a levels she can and just apply next year when hopefully the grades have eased off. Anyone else in the same boat?

OP posts:
Fourcandlesx · 13/11/2022 09:07

Exeter as an example for the BTEC route

Anyone else got DC applying for uni this year - beyond annoyed
Fourcandlesx · 13/11/2022 09:02

I think too many students take A levels when BTEC is often a better option. Nottingham, Sheffield, Exeter for example all accept BTEC in place of A levels for some courses - in fact almost all universities do. My son would have struggled to get 3 grade C's at A level (4's and 5's at GCSE) but he received 5 offers from universities with his BTEC predictions of DDD (distinctions), including 2 which were asking for AAA at A level. He doesn't struggle with the work either as most degrees seem to be set out the same as BTEC. They are modular with elements of coursework and essays. Of course if you are applying for a degree where you need specific A levels then this isn't the answer, but if you are looking at business or something like that then it is an excellent alternative and really worth considering.

DinkyDaisy · 13/11/2022 08:56

I hope very much RG not the be all and end all as my ds actively pursuing a non RG, with lower entry than his predicted grades as he likes their course and the passion they showed on open day. He did not get as excited at the 2 RG he visited.

Zrt · 13/11/2022 08:54

Your dd's grades are good, not 'insanely' good. Other students have done better. It seems fair to me.

Dotcheck · 13/11/2022 08:48

And Russell Group unis are NOT the be all and end all

HogwartsForever11 · 13/11/2022 08:23

I agree with others on managing expectations. Years ago I looked at RG unis for 2012 entry and ABB wouldn’t have made it, lowest was AAB, many wanted AAA

PAFMO · 13/11/2022 08:11

@WifeMotherWorker
There was an interesting thread in Higher Education a while back on the truth about all these foreigners. Lots of admissions people, lecturers etc posted on it. There were also a few people like you as well. Might be worth digging it out.

There was also a link to an official list of % of international students per university, ranging from 0.9% at Edge Hill to 44% at Buckingham.

Guess which one will probably have to close some courses over the next decade? Clue: won't be Buckingham.

Dotcheck · 13/11/2022 07:49

ghostyslovesheets · 12/11/2022 12:45

everyone gets an A star for surviving a pandemic' cohort

Thats a really nasty attitude to kids who did well in that year - the disruption to their education was catastrophic and they were not just awarded grades with no evidence - for context my eldest gained AA during covid and A A* in the exams this year - so I would say they were fair grades. The attitude that no of those A level or GCSE students deserved the grades they achieved is really unkind

Many many students got higher grades than expected. I work in a college and many students acknowledge that their grades were inflated.
Not the case for your son perhaps, but for many

PAFMO · 13/11/2022 07:44

"Every place taken by an international student is a place taken away from UK students"

Jesus. Don't let your Little Englander out too far, will you?

You'll have had it explained to you hopefully (maybe in short words so you understand) that almost all universities put international applicants on one table, and home applicants on another and take % from both.

If your child didn't get in, it's not because somebody from Canada pinched their place. It's because they weren't good enough. But if it helps you to accept that by blaming Johnny Foreigner, then crack on.

ButterflyBiscuit · 13/11/2022 07:15

It's so sad watching all this happen. Dur to reasons we are very well educated but low income - and reading threads this morning well aware that fovt isn't funding Higher Ed and that costs will go up, similarly the ambulance thread. It dies seem the givt is running it down to privatise which is ridiculous.

We can't afford 1000s on anything. Kids in grammar schools wanting to do uni and some complex health conditions in the family requiring a run down nhs.

A rich tory supporter will just not care and think they can afford it all. We can't.

DaddyPhD · 12/11/2022 22:44

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 22:14

@Leafblowertime -
”Most universities in the UK are very welcoming to international students and actually have a higher acceptance rate for international students than domestic ones.
Universities are enrolling 40 per cent more overseas students than five years ago as they favour applicants from China and India. Vice-chancellors said that inadequate income from domestic tuition fees was forcing them to target overseas students, who pay more than twice as much for the same courses.”
22 Aug 2022

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/universities-favour-foreign-students-to-bring-in-big-money-6fxnknsbn

University lecturer here.

My university loses thousands a year teaching a UK student, the income from international students (who are qualified as much as UK students by the way) does supplement UK students. Without them we'd have less UK students. You already know this from your posts, we don't get enough in funding or from UK fees.

If you think international students are too many, with the current funding model,
it will only increase.

I expect my university to increase the number of international students, it’s that or we shut up shop. OR we get a government that decided to invest in education for once. It’s the British people's choice. We choose not to.

Most of my colleagues believe this country is heading down the private route, like America, so your kids can look forward to international level of fees , so effectively even more than now, it will be the preserve of the rich or the very poor gifted scholarships.

The Ivy League has 5% international at undergrad, but fees of around 45 grand, it also has a pool of home students to choose from the size of Europe.

The only way UK students can be increased is (in the current funding model) a lifting of cap on fees, or more investment from the gov. Both are big no no's currently and have been for years.

handstich1 · 12/11/2022 22:14

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 21:21

Every place taken by an international student is a place taken away from UK students which ultimately pushes up entry requirements (and stress).
Oxford University is the top ranked UK and RG university in the UK. 23% of their students are international and their net profits at the end of the fiscal year (March 2022) we’re £93.6m. LET THAT SINK IN!

OK @WifeMotherWorker

Universities are business first, education and research second, got it. And the funding crisis has nothing to do with anything, and these business first institutions are letting in international students because they bring in cash and nothing else, its all...shockingly .....down to foreigners.

Thanks for educating me, first class honours, Distinction at Masters, on this. I've told my partner, full funded PhD graduate and he was astonished to hear this.

When our children are rejected from a top flight uni, I will blame the foreigners taking their places.

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 22:14

@Leafblowertime -
”Most universities in the UK are very welcoming to international students and actually have a higher acceptance rate for international students than domestic ones.
Universities are enrolling 40 per cent more overseas students than five years ago as they favour applicants from China and India. Vice-chancellors said that inadequate income from domestic tuition fees was forcing them to target overseas students, who pay more than twice as much for the same courses.”
22 Aug 2022

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/universities-favour-foreign-students-to-bring-in-big-money-6fxnknsbn

Leafblowertime · 12/11/2022 22:00

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 21:56

@PauliString the point OP made was the grade criteria placed on Russel Group universities making A-Level expectations incredibly pressured and in some cases unattainable for UK students. Universities are businesses first and foremost and because the sheer number of applicants versus placements available is so out of kilter they can push up entry criteria and become quite selective. Universities tend to apply an element of leniency to international students as they pay so much more in tuition fees. UK university spaces are not infinite so every place taken by an international student is a place taken from a UK student. It’s incredibly unfair to our children.

I don’t agree with this the entry requirements is the same for both.

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 21:56

@PauliString the point OP made was the grade criteria placed on Russel Group universities making A-Level expectations incredibly pressured and in some cases unattainable for UK students. Universities are businesses first and foremost and because the sheer number of applicants versus placements available is so out of kilter they can push up entry criteria and become quite selective. Universities tend to apply an element of leniency to international students as they pay so much more in tuition fees. UK university spaces are not infinite so every place taken by an international student is a place taken from a UK student. It’s incredibly unfair to our children.

Leafblowertime · 12/11/2022 21:54

PauliString · 12/11/2022 21:40

I feel we might be veering a little away from the problems of the OP’s daughter, who isn’t looking at either Imperial or Oxford as far as I can tell.

One of mine is doing well at a decent Russell Group uni with ABB at A-level, so it does depend strongly on competition for places on the specific course.

To be fair, that’s unusual though, so it needs to be quite a niche course with little uptake so they reduce to get bums seats.. Generally Russel group for most subjects are much higher. As witnessed by the ops kid.

PauliString · 12/11/2022 21:40

I feel we might be veering a little away from the problems of the OP’s daughter, who isn’t looking at either Imperial or Oxford as far as I can tell.

One of mine is doing well at a decent Russell Group uni with ABB at A-level, so it does depend strongly on competition for places on the specific course.

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 21:21

handstich1 · 12/11/2022 21:08

I'm sorry, but you're fundamentally wrong. Imperial College is not run like Tesla or WHSmiths.

Imperial dreams of being the MIT of the UK, MIT currently has around 40% international grad students

THESE ARE GLOBAL INSTITUTIONS.

To be blunt, ANY student be they British, Indian, Japanese, 93 % chance of rejection from Imperial.

Let that sink in, NINETY THREE PERCENT CHANCE OF FAILURE of getting in, when you want the best of the best, you don't care where they come from.

Walk into the development areas of Facebook offices, or cutting edge trading at Goldman Sachs or Dyson research, they don't care where you come from, they want the best brains with PhDs. To be blunt, they don't care about our children. Its not their job neither, its our job and the elected gov to care about our children and raise education standards.

Every place taken by an international student is a place taken away from UK students which ultimately pushes up entry requirements (and stress).
Oxford University is the top ranked UK and RG university in the UK. 23% of their students are international and their net profits at the end of the fiscal year (March 2022) we’re £93.6m. LET THAT SINK IN!

handstich1 · 12/11/2022 21:08

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 20:48

They may well be public research institutions, but first and foremost they are a business driven by financial targets.
There are currently over 600,000 international students studying in UK universities, London Imperial College has 49% of their students as international and the UK is ranked globally only 2nd to the USA in terms of volume of international students. Look at the size of the UK!!! This is NOT good news for our children.

I'm sorry, but you're fundamentally wrong. Imperial College is not run like Tesla or WHSmiths.

Imperial dreams of being the MIT of the UK, MIT currently has around 40% international grad students

THESE ARE GLOBAL INSTITUTIONS.

To be blunt, ANY student be they British, Indian, Japanese, 93 % chance of rejection from Imperial.

Let that sink in, NINETY THREE PERCENT CHANCE OF FAILURE of getting in, when you want the best of the best, you don't care where they come from.

Walk into the development areas of Facebook offices, or cutting edge trading at Goldman Sachs or Dyson research, they don't care where you come from, they want the best brains with PhDs. To be blunt, they don't care about our children. Its not their job neither, its our job and the elected gov to care about our children and raise education standards.

Leafblowertime · 12/11/2022 21:04

Era · 12/11/2022 19:05

Agree with previous posters, as a general rule only apply to Russel Group if predicted all A's and this has been the case for some time

my friends ds is predicted ABB. He has offers from Liverpool Manchester and Newcastle. They are asking for their standard grades Aaa and AAB but they’ve still made the offers.

It’s not relevant right, he needs to achieve more than he is predicted or he has mo offer. Can he? If the answer is yes. He has an offer, if it’s a no then he doesn’t.

Leafblowertime · 12/11/2022 21:02

CornishGem1975 · 12/11/2022 16:21

My DD is in her first term of A levels and school have given her a predicted/target grade of ABB, which is not enough to do what she wants to do, she's feeling so dejected by that I think she was ready to throw the towel in completely.

It’s hard, but in your terms it’s bcc, if it helps to translate, and I think your job is to work with the school and her to see if she can achieve more, if she cannot what other options does she have.

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 20:48

handstich1 · 12/11/2022 20:38

Universities are public research institutions, not businesses.

International students pay more than UK students, but they supplement UK students rather than displace them. We’ve had twelve years of University starvation of funds, where do you think the money is going to come from to keep these universities afloat?

The top universities of the world, Harvard, Oxford etc, all have similar amounts of international students, you can’t apply British first to University research, if everyone did , we’d have no medical or technological advances.

Look at the Oxford Covid vaccine, who were the team involved in that?

Sarah Gilbert, degree and PhD from Hull and University of East Anglia, both non- RG Uni’s

Pascal Soriot, FRENCH

Federica Cappuccini, degree from Italy and PhD from Germany.

www.itv.com/news/2020-12-30/oxford-astrazeneca-vaccine-who-are-the-people-behind-the-jab

They may well be public research institutions, but first and foremost they are a business driven by financial targets.
There are currently over 600,000 international students studying in UK universities, London Imperial College has 49% of their students as international and the UK is ranked globally only 2nd to the USA in terms of volume of international students. Look at the size of the UK!!! This is NOT good news for our children.

handstich1 · 12/11/2022 20:38

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 19:29

Universities are a business where money comes before anything else. UK students pay £9,250 per annum, international students pay two or three times that amount. Most RG universities are flooded with international students as they make far more money per head thus taking places away from UK students. It’s dreadful and shouldn’t be permitted, UK university places should be for our children not rich kids from abroad.

Universities are public research institutions, not businesses.

International students pay more than UK students, but they supplement UK students rather than displace them. We’ve had twelve years of University starvation of funds, where do you think the money is going to come from to keep these universities afloat?

The top universities of the world, Harvard, Oxford etc, all have similar amounts of international students, you can’t apply British first to University research, if everyone did , we’d have no medical or technological advances.

Look at the Oxford Covid vaccine, who were the team involved in that?

Sarah Gilbert, degree and PhD from Hull and University of East Anglia, both non- RG Uni’s

Pascal Soriot, FRENCH

Federica Cappuccini, degree from Italy and PhD from Germany.

www.itv.com/news/2020-12-30/oxford-astrazeneca-vaccine-who-are-the-people-behind-the-jab

LimitIsUp · 12/11/2022 20:18

I went to University of Sheffield back in 1986 with BBC. Times have changed!

WifeMotherWorker · 12/11/2022 19:29

Universities are a business where money comes before anything else. UK students pay £9,250 per annum, international students pay two or three times that amount. Most RG universities are flooded with international students as they make far more money per head thus taking places away from UK students. It’s dreadful and shouldn’t be permitted, UK university places should be for our children not rich kids from abroad.