Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel Poetry has died a death in modern society?

239 replies

Marmitemother · 12/11/2022 11:00

Out of curiosity I searched MN expecting to find a topic page on poetry and literature....have I missed it somewhere?

Semi retired, children flown the nest, hubbie and I always busy with projects yet still find time to read poetry most days.

I'm wondering if others, particularly younger folk (we're in our 60's) didn't learn to appreciate poetry at school or just don't have time or the inclination to read, share and discuss compared to all else available these days (TV, phones, cinema, social media etc)

I read The Journey by Mary Oliver this morning and thought about how it spoke to many posting on the Relationship page.

“One day you finally knew
what you had to do, and began,
though the voices around you
kept shouting
their bad advice --
though the whole house
began to tremble
and you felt the old tug
at your ankles.
"Mend my life!"
each voice cried.
But you didn't stop.
You knew what you had to do,
though the wind pried
with its stiff fingers
at the very foundations,
though their melancholy
was terrible.
It was already late
enough, and a wild night,
and the road full of fallen
branches and stones.
But little by little,
as you left their voices behind,
the stars began to burn
through the sheets of clouds,
and there was a new voice
which you slowly
recognized as your own,
that kept you company
as you strode deeper and deeper
into the world,
determined to do
the only thing you could do --
determined to save
the only life you could save.”

OP posts:
Jacopo · 16/11/2022 03:11

I love all kinds of poetry but there’s a particular kind of poetry reading that I can’t stand, when the speaker is all dreary and solemn and reads in a “special” poetry-reading voice.

malificent7 · 16/11/2022 03:07

But I also think some of the older poems are shear magic.

My favourites are:

The Darkling thrush by Thomas Hardy
Introspection by Christina,Rossetti
Mid term break by Seamus Heaney and Wild Swans of Coole by WB Yeats.

I mean some lines are pure brilliance. In the second coming this sends shivers of horror down my spine:

" What rough beast, it's hour come at last, slouches towards Bethlehem to be born."

malificent7 · 16/11/2022 03:04

I almost did a masters in poetry before I decided it didn't pay! I love it! George the poet is one example of poetry.

EastCoker · 16/11/2022 03:00

I love poetry.

Good poems make me feel flayed. Stripped bare. In the same way that some music does.

There are certain lines and certain chords that make me feel naked.

Clear night, thumb-top of a moon, a back-lit sky.
Moon-fingers lay down their same routine
On the side deck and the threshold, the white keys and the black keys.
Bird hush and bird song. A cassia flower falls.

I want to be bruised by God.
I want to be strung up in a strong light and singled out.
I want to be stretched, like music wrung from a dropped seed.

I want to be entered and picked clean.

And the wind says “What?” to me.
And the castor beans, with their little earrings of death, say “What?” to me.
And the stars start out on their cold slide through the dark.

And the gears notch and the engines wheel.

That makes me feel raw.

Firethrice · 13/11/2022 22:41

pointythings · 13/11/2022 17:31

I grew up in the Dutch school system where there are no set books - not in Dutch andEnglish (compulsory at any level) nor in any MFL. Schools can set a list for people to choose from, but the list is literally hundreds of books long. And it's always possible to approach a teacher with a book that isn't on it and ask if you can include it. It's then up to the teacher to ensure they have sufficient familiarity with the book to examine you on it (the exam is spoken for MFL and English, written for Dutch and moderated by another school whose staff do not know the students). It's so much better and you can read so much more widely. For French I had to read a total of 15 books for my A level, of which three had to be plays, one had to be a volume of poetry, at least three had to date from before 1800 and a further two from before 1900. Parameters for the other languages were very similar, except for Dutch which was more complex. It really encourages you to think about your choices and you're more likely to actually enjoy what you're reading.

Ds did French A level - he loved the language but detested the books that were chosen by the teacher/exam board - such a personal thing - it’s a shame it can be so off putting

pointythings · 13/11/2022 17:31

I grew up in the Dutch school system where there are no set books - not in Dutch andEnglish (compulsory at any level) nor in any MFL. Schools can set a list for people to choose from, but the list is literally hundreds of books long. And it's always possible to approach a teacher with a book that isn't on it and ask if you can include it. It's then up to the teacher to ensure they have sufficient familiarity with the book to examine you on it (the exam is spoken for MFL and English, written for Dutch and moderated by another school whose staff do not know the students). It's so much better and you can read so much more widely. For French I had to read a total of 15 books for my A level, of which three had to be plays, one had to be a volume of poetry, at least three had to date from before 1800 and a further two from before 1900. Parameters for the other languages were very similar, except for Dutch which was more complex. It really encourages you to think about your choices and you're more likely to actually enjoy what you're reading.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/11/2022 16:55

'Poetry' is an enormous collection of words spanning a vast number of sub genres. And genre is one area in which people tend to get very territorial. There was an 'I Love 80s Goth' group online once, which I left once it started to get heated about what did belong in the genre and what didn't. People just love policing generic boundaries - that's a fun enough topic for a literature class on its own!

Homer, Dante, Milton and Ovid wrote some of the greatest epics in literature whose effects and influences can still be felt everywhere. A world without Paradise Lost and The Divine Comedy would be a sad world. I'm hooked on the modernist poets, Djuna Barnes and Mina Loy in particular. But I'm with the 'some rap is poetry' PPs. Eminem's lyrics are superb. For me, Bob Dylan and Jim Morrison fall firmly into the camp of poetry too.

The beat poets, Ginsberg in particular, go down well with today's generation of undergraduates and represent some amazing writing. Poe's 'The Raven' is another one that often goes down well with students.

You could make up a brilliant course comprising several sub genres: old classics, maybe Plath's and Duffy's rewritings of Ovid, for example to link the influences, popular as well as classical culture. As for poetry being up its own backside, just check out Khadijah Ibrahim's 'Leeds Young Poets' and her own excellent writing.

Whoever devised the latest school literature curriculum should be sentenced to five years of studying it, IMO. That is what I'd call poetic justice. As for the teacher who discouraged her students's interest in Plath, I'm betting she hadn't read beyond the curriculum and was afraid she'd be found out!

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/11/2022 12:28

There’s a lot of it about, you do need to search it out a bit, though.

Cerys Matthews has produced a kids’ version of Under Milk Wood. She (brilliantly) read an extract on Loose Ends yesterday, looks great, beautifully illustrated too.

zingally · 13/11/2022 12:24

I quite enjoyed poetry as a child of the 90s. I feel like we did a lot of poetry at school, and had it read to us quite a lot.
Nowadays, I'm not interested in poetry. Occasionally I stumble across one I quite like, but I certainly don't go searching it out.

Hobbi · 13/11/2022 12:13

emptythelitterbox · 12/11/2022 12:47

Rap is poetry? Haha I don't think so!

Yeah okay you need to get done done done done
That’ll work come over
We just need to slow the motion
Don’t give that away to no one
Long distance I need you
When I see potential I just gotta see it through
If you had a twin I would still choose you
I don’t wanna rush into it if it’s too soon
But I know you need to get done done done done

More...

Mummy Don’t Know
Daddy’s Getting Hot
At The Body Shop
Doing Something Unholy

Lucky Lucky Lucky Girl..

Lucky Lucky Girl
She Got Married To A Boy Like You
She’d Kick You Out If She Ever
Ever Knew

’bout All The **
You Tell Me That You Do
Dirty Dirty Boy
You Know Everyone Is
Talking On The Scene

Choosing a random example is disingenuous. Are W McGonagall or Julia A Moore representative of all 'proper' poets? Just because you don't like or, more likely, understand something, it doesn't make it less worthy.

RampantIvy · 13/11/2022 12:05

Thank you for opening my eyes. I will look at some of the recommendations on here.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 13/11/2022 12:02

RampantIvy · 13/11/2022 11:42

I think poetry is perceived as being boring or whatever, but that's just lazy

I must be lazy then, or a complete philistine. I just don't enjoy reading poetry. I enjoy reading, but much prefer a proper piece of prose than something that I find pretentious (this is my opinion only).

The only "poetry" I like is silly humorous stuff like limericks and other jokey stuff.
DD hated poetry when she took English lit GCSE, and so did all of her friends.
I'm not a Shakespeare fan either.

Or, to put it another way - you enjoy poetry, in the form of limericks and comic poems (as PP, check out Brian Bilston if you haven't already!), but you're not fussed about the more serious stuff.

I love poetry, but that doesn't mean I enjoy all poems or poets equally. There are plenty of (otherwise well-loved) poets who leave me cold. And there are plenty of keen poetry fanatics who would roll their eyes at me trotting out endless quotations from TS Eliot, Lovelace or whoever.

reluctantbrit · 13/11/2022 11:56

NadjaCravensworth · 13/11/2022 09:18

To be honest I don't really know the exact reasons

I hate words in rhythm and shoehorned rhymes.

I also don't like short stories

Exactly. Give me a novel, can easily be several hundred pages and I am happy reading. I love the way characters develop and the story unfolds.

A short story or a poem doesn't bring this to me. Reading a poem gives me a "So, what now" feeling.

To the ones saying schools murder English Lit: We just had one 6th Form open evening and DD was until then torn between English Lit and Sociology. After the English Lit talk she turned to me and said "really, that's what I am supposed to enjoy?" All proposed topics were dry and lots of fairly classical literature instead of looking at modern texts and how literature is evolving.

No wonder teens are not wild on poetry.

JolieJ · 13/11/2022 11:54

And if anyone hasn't heard this beautiful poem by Amanda Gorman, they're missing out:

amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/jan/20/amanda-gorman-poem-biden-inauguration-transcript

The Hill We Climb

JolieJ · 13/11/2022 11:52

Hamilton the musical has some excellent poetry too, highly recommend it

TheFarawayNearby · 13/11/2022 11:49

@RampantIvy, sorry, I shouldn't have said lazy earlier - I suppose I think that there's some poetry that will appeal to everyone, it's just about finding it. Have you read any of Brian Bilston's poetry? A lot of it is quite funny, I really enjoy it. I definitely find some poetry completely impenetrable though.

RampantIvy · 13/11/2022 11:42

I think poetry is perceived as being boring or whatever, but that's just lazy

I must be lazy then, or a complete philistine. I just don't enjoy reading poetry. I enjoy reading, but much prefer a proper piece of prose than something that I find pretentious (this is my opinion only).

The only "poetry" I like is silly humorous stuff like limericks and other jokey stuff.
DD hated poetry when she took English lit GCSE, and so did all of her friends.
I'm not a Shakespeare fan either.

Satsuma2 · 13/11/2022 11:36

JolieJ · 12/11/2022 13:16

I enjoy slam poetry

Me too.

Metabigot · 13/11/2022 11:24

TeenDivided · 12/11/2022 11:03

Isn't Rap just poetry at its core?

Yep. Love a bit of Eminem that early 21st century literary genuius

CulturePigeon · 13/11/2022 11:18

SarahAndQuack · Today 10:32
CulturePigeon · Today 10:23
I love poetry, but it's always been an elite interest. The fact that probably only 10% of people, if that, care about poetry doesn't mean it's dying.
By definition it's a distilled, intellectual form of expression and can require a bit of effort to get the most out of it. Not everyone is going to bother - not a problem - their loss!
I don't think that's true at all. What about all the poems that people used as mnemonics or work songs or ways of communicating in illiterate communities?
I don't see why poetry has to be intellectual, either.

On the whole, I agree, SarahAndQuack. The OP didn't define what they meant by poetry, and only a brave or foolish person would try to do that! It's like trying to define what is art. I think that art is anything which someone creates with the intention of creating art - from a pencil line on a piece of paper to the Sistine Chapel ceiling. Similarly with poetry - if you intend it to be poetry, or someone finds poetry in it, then it IS poetry in my opinion. So your examples certainly are poetry if you believe they are.

But I do think that whether or not these things are any good as poetry or art can only be judged by history. Will they endure and find a resonance with people in 20 or 50 years' time? Some things are ephemeral, and there's nothing wrong with that, but I do think time will tell.

And again, it depends on your definition of 'intellectual'. I meant that word in the sense of thinking about, being aware of the words, rhythm, meaning as a created thing - all of which people would do with a rap or a shanty etc. I love folk songs and shanties - and I would count them as poetry - someone took the trouble to compose them.

Marmitemother · 13/11/2022 11:14

Thanks for all your comments, lovers and haters of poetry alike. Much food for thought. I will certainly be exploring poets mentioned I've not come across before.

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/11/2022 11:13

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 13/11/2022 09:26

I strongly dislike musicals as well

To be fair that's just a sign of sanity.

Funny - stage musicals are not for me either, and I love theatre, I love music, and I love poetry (at least some of it, it's a big genre).

When they come together on the stage they just don't work for me (love T S Eliot, loathe the abysmal 'Cats').

I'll make an exception for Calamity Jane because Doris Day was amazing 😻

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/11/2022 11:00

Thingsdogetbetter · 12/11/2022 11:09

Kar Tempest sells out huge venues. Rap and Grime is spoken word poetry. There are still rap competitions which are free flow poetry.

Personally- as an English Lit teacher - schools being restricted to heritage poetry has turned young people off poetry. 17th century romantic poems are never going to resonate with a bored teenager.

It's tragic the way English Literature is being taught at GCSE and A' levels. The subject is shrinking and dying at degree level, quite aside from issues like the removal of caps from the Russell Group during COVID and a current low demographic affecting student numbers. Students are being put off studying it.

I'd anticipated that would happen with some of the niche subjects that sprung up and expanded during the boom years, much the same way it did with the likes of Sociology and Gender Studies. But a major decline in English - language and literature - is one I didn't see coming.

Sad. We do need STEM graduates, undoubtedly. But degrees are currently selling on the back of filling specific deficits in the labour market and if you keep that up you will always end up with a surfeit. The Arts and Humanities matter. A country without them will end up culturally impoverished.

sueelleker · 13/11/2022 11:00

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 12/11/2022 11:12

Most days a poem or two pops up in my Facebook feed. More recently because of Remembrance. Same on Twitter. Depends who you follow. Social media is a great way to engage with poetry rather than simply displacing it.
Dd has poems on her bedroom wall too, along with photos, postcards, concert tickets…

I was reciting "For The Fallen" to myself on Friday. (That's the one that 'we shall grow not old' comes from. I have a lot of older poems memorised.

SarahAndQuack · 13/11/2022 10:32

CulturePigeon · 13/11/2022 10:23

I love poetry, but it's always been an elite interest. The fact that probably only 10% of people, if that, care about poetry doesn't mean it's dying.

By definition it's a distilled, intellectual form of expression and can require a bit of effort to get the most out of it. Not everyone is going to bother - not a problem - their loss!

I don't think that's true at all. What about all the poems that people used as mnemonics or work songs or ways of communicating in illiterate communities?

I don't see why poetry has to be intellectual, either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread