Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel Poetry has died a death in modern society?

239 replies

Marmitemother · 12/11/2022 11:00

Out of curiosity I searched MN expecting to find a topic page on poetry and literature....have I missed it somewhere?

Semi retired, children flown the nest, hubbie and I always busy with projects yet still find time to read poetry most days.

I'm wondering if others, particularly younger folk (we're in our 60's) didn't learn to appreciate poetry at school or just don't have time or the inclination to read, share and discuss compared to all else available these days (TV, phones, cinema, social media etc)

I read The Journey by Mary Oliver this morning and thought about how it spoke to many posting on the Relationship page.

“One day you finally knew
what you had to do, and began,
though the voices around you
kept shouting
their bad advice --
though the whole house
began to tremble
and you felt the old tug
at your ankles.
"Mend my life!"
each voice cried.
But you didn't stop.
You knew what you had to do,
though the wind pried
with its stiff fingers
at the very foundations,
though their melancholy
was terrible.
It was already late
enough, and a wild night,
and the road full of fallen
branches and stones.
But little by little,
as you left their voices behind,
the stars began to burn
through the sheets of clouds,
and there was a new voice
which you slowly
recognized as your own,
that kept you company
as you strode deeper and deeper
into the world,
determined to do
the only thing you could do --
determined to save
the only life you could save.”

OP posts:
HighlandCowbag · 19/11/2022 07:47

VictorianGothic · 19/11/2022 00:32

@HighlandCowbag shout out to Anna Letitia Barbauld! She's amazing. And would have been right at home with the visionary turn this thread has taken. She was on to Coleridge though: accurately diagnosed him: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/51902/to-mr-st-coleridge

Yes she was very astute. I am doing a romantic to Modernism module. I have found the women poets fascinating to study, especially the contextual side of them. Have just done a short essay on Rights Of Woman and found Barbaulds background fascinating. Also Heman using Byrons lines in her own work is fabulous.

These women were revolutionaries and in very vulnerable positions socially and financially. To publish the stuff they did, when they did is akin to publishing anti-trans poetry now, or speaking up in the workplace about sexual harassment or fronting the Me Too movement.

I'm definitely not clever enough or literary enough to do their work justice by analysing it but can definitely appreciate the risks they took.

Endlesssummer2022 · 19/11/2022 03:51

Kendrick Lamar’s ‘United in Grief’ and ‘Alright’ are fantastic examples of modern poetry.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 19/11/2022 03:42

There will always be a hunger for poetry - I teach it in a men's prison, and the work I see moves me and inspires me to persevere with my own work.
Read poetry aloud, listen to its cadences and pauses, then look at the shape of it on the page. Especially the spaces around the text.

VictorianGothic · 19/11/2022 00:32

@HighlandCowbag shout out to Anna Letitia Barbauld! She's amazing. And would have been right at home with the visionary turn this thread has taken. She was on to Coleridge though: accurately diagnosed him: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/51902/to-mr-st-coleridge

NeverDropYourMooncup · 18/11/2022 22:37

I am constantly in awe of the first modern sound engineers. They weren't fiddling with valves and electrical current, though. They were constructing cathedrals, inventing new ways of supporting structures and creating spaces where human voices could create waveforms that, in reflection and replication, would increase in amplitude and change perceived direction in a way that the voices would move around the space and travel upwards - they specifically engineered the spaces so that they achieved their aim of carrying voices up to Heaven.

And why do Western orchestras tune to Middle A? It's now set at 440Hz, but before the adoption of Even Temperament, was around 428-435Hz. Guess what people would have heard that vibrates at that frequency range? A Bumblebee when buzz pollinating a flower. People created instruments that echoed the tones of a warm Summer's Day - they found ways of emulating and evoking peace and the creation of life through sound without the knowledge that this was what they were doing.

Genius has always been with us.

OMG12 · 18/11/2022 22:24

SarahAndQuack · 18/11/2022 21:14

I was talking to someone yesterday about the ease of being a polymath in the 18thC, particularly if male. As knowledge was much more scant, it wasn't even possible to be a specialist if educated (and let's be honest, it was only really men that were fully educated).

Honestly, this is such nonsense. Just because there are things that people thought were true in the eighteenth century, which we now believe to be wrong, doesn't mean 'knowledge was more scant'. Of course people were specialists - both then and for centuries before that. It's so incredibly arrogant to assume that only our own contemporaries can possibly have grappled with a wealth of knowledge and a need for specialism.

It's also so very sexist and snobby to say that only men were 'fully educated'. What do you mean by 'fully educated'?

Yes, I mean people like Dr John Dee had a vast wealth and range of knowledge, some of which we might no longer value but that doesn’t detract from him. I think there was a much stronger ability to think across a range of subject and see how they corresponded and complimented each other. In many respects I would suggest we have lost a lot of knowledge whilst simultaneously gaining lots of information. I certainly don’t think we are any cleverer now than say 500 years ago.

i was listening to Dr Brian Cox this morning on the BBC talking about what would happen if you went into a black hole. How someone observing you would effectively see you frozen in time just before you entered the black hole. You would however carry on and everything about you would be absorbed by the black hole and become part of its fabric. I seem to recall reading somewhere how we could have all have originated from something spewed out of a black hole. How very close to emanating from and returning to source in Neoplatonic thought. A timeless source. Our intellect hasn’t really grown, our ways of expressing it have changed. History is littered with people more intelligent that we could ever imagine. You live only got to look at the Egyptians to understand that.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 18/11/2022 22:21

Jacopo · 16/11/2022 03:11

I love all kinds of poetry but there’s a particular kind of poetry reading that I can’t stand, when the speaker is all dreary and solemn and reads in a “special” poetry-reading voice.

The worst experience beyond the excruciating Poetry Slam group who fulfilled the requirements of every stereotype at a festival - throwing a strop at the Sound Engineer and Stage Manager because they couldn't march on during the last song of the band that was on before them (so they could put their packed lunches, anoraks and picnic chairs in front of the drum riser) - and starting with an absolute banger called 'Forest'

''Ahem. Forest. I walk through the forest and look at them all. Some trees are

(pregnant pause)

Big.

And some trees are

(He's not going to do it, is he? He's not really going to go there? He can't. Oh God, he is)

Small.''

  • was having to listen to recordings of Dylan Thomas and TS Eliot during my A Levels.

It was bad enough spending hours to end up with poetry shattered into metaphorical pieces over my desk, but to have the authors destroy the images they could create with their words in toneless drones? Ugh.

For me, poetry is a performance. And for a performance, you need a talented performer. If somebody can hold a mob of six year olds completely lost in the description and call and response of Macavity or Measles, transport the listener to the hearth of a thousand year old fire listening to the blueprint/script for every monster movie, or have somebody come over all unnecessary because Middle English just sounds so darned sexy, they are the person who should be sharing the words.

(By the way, English Lit teachers, if you're doing The Wasteland, don't do it in the depths of a cold, wet, dark and miserable February. It's supposed to be in April and if you do it as soon as everybody's back from Christmas, you're going to be stuck with 30 depressed teenagers for the next few weeks until you cheer them up with Chaucer.)

SarahAndQuack · 18/11/2022 21:14

I was talking to someone yesterday about the ease of being a polymath in the 18thC, particularly if male. As knowledge was much more scant, it wasn't even possible to be a specialist if educated (and let's be honest, it was only really men that were fully educated).

Honestly, this is such nonsense. Just because there are things that people thought were true in the eighteenth century, which we now believe to be wrong, doesn't mean 'knowledge was more scant'. Of course people were specialists - both then and for centuries before that. It's so incredibly arrogant to assume that only our own contemporaries can possibly have grappled with a wealth of knowledge and a need for specialism.

It's also so very sexist and snobby to say that only men were 'fully educated'. What do you mean by 'fully educated'?

GravyDramas · 18/11/2022 20:57

daretodenim · 16/11/2022 06:33

If only modern poetry readings
that perform
consonant cunnilingus
with written words
would
d
i
e.

Poetry,
written as prose,
dividing sentences

randomly

SHOULD BE READ AS PROSE!

This did
make
me

chuckle.

OMG12 · 18/11/2022 20:35

EastCoker · 18/11/2022 18:30

@OMG12

There is nothing obtuse about Blake and his poisoned tree.

Maybe it was how he felt.

And maybe the thistle was right.

I was talking to someone yesterday about the ease of being a polymath in the 18thC, particularly if male. As knowledge was much more scant, it wasn't even possible to be a specialist if educated (and let's be honest, it was only really men that were fully educated).

The need for true specialism has only become incumbent as we understand more about our very nature, and the nature of the universe in which we dwell.

Post Renaissance, post Enlightenment, knowledge was still seen holistically because there was much less knowledge.

(And indeed knowledge should still be seen holistically, because we are all part of a whole, but the whole is now understood to be much more complex than previously thought).

I don't buy Coldridge and Blake as 'The best that ever there was'.

They were OK. For their time.

I guess it’s a matter of taste, maybe I’m drawn particularly to Blake , especially his prophetic works, due to my interest in Hermetic Qabalah and the need for balance and interdependence of opposites and emanationism, I see this throughout his work. Whether or not he belonged to any formal Rosicrucian society he was certainly Rosicrucian in spirit. All these things I am drawn to, and, I think we are drawn to poetry where we see a reflection of ourselves. For me, Blake is equal to, if not better than, Shakespeare. I see the meaning of life in his works, a spiritual journey to enlightenment. Others might not see this or value it. Poetry, I think more so than any other art form Is subjective. It is the secondary imagination described by Coleridge.

it’s an interesting proposition regarding being a polymath in the 18th century as opposed to, say, now. I think, yes there was less knowledge, but at the same time, it was far more difficult to access this knowledge than now. I think there is a difference though between then and now in that I think a natural curiosity, talking to a wide variety of people of different views in the salons has been replaced by echo chambers of social media and the need to be “right”. There’s a lack of interest in true debate, most discussions end in ad hominem. Amongst many circles having a good debate is frowned upon either as being argumentative or intellectual posturing. There’s an information overload, meaning it can become impossible to know anything, if you exercise Curiositas rather that studiositas It’s becoming increasingly difficult to learn outside whichever silo you’re in. Society is more divisive, being able to talk across a wide variety of topics is becoming increasingly difficult for all these reasons, as well as many others.

Which poets do you like and why?

GoldenCupidon · 18/11/2022 19:22

Enjoying the variety of tastes on this thread, I also HATE Hardy and his stupid bleak bush.

GoldenCupidon · 18/11/2022 18:57

BryanAdamsLeftAnkle · 12/11/2022 18:33

My 7 year old adores poetry. I have no idea how to support this love. What books do you recommend

When I was this 7 year old my mum took me to a big bookshop with a poetry section/kids poetry section and said I could buy a book of my choice from it. Having that choice and the time to flick through and find things you liked was brilliant. I bought a collection of funny poems.

If you want to buy online I think Michael Rosen has edited a lot of anthologies of kids poems.

Childrens' poetry anthologies are a great starting point, your child can find the poets and styles s/he loves most and follow them up online with your support. They tend to be a lot more diverse than poetry anthologies for adults (I had no idea how boring most poetry collections for adults were until I went through my dad's bookshelves).

EastCoker · 18/11/2022 18:30

@OMG12

There is nothing obtuse about Blake and his poisoned tree.

Maybe it was how he felt.

And maybe the thistle was right.

I was talking to someone yesterday about the ease of being a polymath in the 18thC, particularly if male. As knowledge was much more scant, it wasn't even possible to be a specialist if educated (and let's be honest, it was only really men that were fully educated).

The need for true specialism has only become incumbent as we understand more about our very nature, and the nature of the universe in which we dwell.

Post Renaissance, post Enlightenment, knowledge was still seen holistically because there was much less knowledge.

(And indeed knowledge should still be seen holistically, because we are all part of a whole, but the whole is now understood to be much more complex than previously thought).

I don't buy Coldridge and Blake as 'The best that ever there was'.

They were OK. For their time.

HighlandCowbag · 18/11/2022 18:13

I'm a 45 year old literature and philosophy student. Blake and Coleridge left me feeling meh.

I would recommend Anna Letita Baubald for some kick ass, feminist, subversive poetry of that time.

OMG12 · 18/11/2022 18:12

ErrolTheDragon · 18/11/2022 17:42

Imagination hasn't died a death. It may now be exercised more now in different and accessible genres - most obviously science fiction and fantasy. Imagined worlds in books and on the screen. Some of it is pap, but not all of it. I really don't agree that it's all 'seen as childish, unscientific, frivolous and unworthy.'

I think with the educational system it has!!

OMG12 · 18/11/2022 18:10

EastCoker · 18/11/2022 18:04

Ha! @OMG12.

That's quite funny.

Blake and Coldridge did hit some high notes, under the auspices of masculinity, opium and education that may have been beyond their intelligence.

And then to drop Aldous Huxley, another drug-addled, educated man as your reference point?

This is your apogee? Your zenith?

This is your reference for the best expression of the educated and searching mind?

I pity you.

Is this how Blake felt when he was talking to a thistle🤔

EastCoker · 18/11/2022 18:04

Ha! @OMG12.

That's quite funny.

Blake and Coldridge did hit some high notes, under the auspices of masculinity, opium and education that may have been beyond their intelligence.

And then to drop Aldous Huxley, another drug-addled, educated man as your reference point?

This is your apogee? Your zenith?

This is your reference for the best expression of the educated and searching mind?

I pity you.

ErrolTheDragon · 18/11/2022 17:42

Imagination hasn't died a death. It may now be exercised more now in different and accessible genres - most obviously science fiction and fantasy. Imagined worlds in books and on the screen. Some of it is pap, but not all of it. I really don't agree that it's all 'seen as childish, unscientific, frivolous and unworthy.'

OMG12 · 18/11/2022 17:25

I actually think it’s wider, it’s about imagination dying a death. My favourite poets are Blake and Coleridge. Both held imagination up in divine terms. Schooling and wider society has devalued imagination. It’s seen as childish, unscientific, frivolous and unworthy. In short Newtons Sleep is the MO of modern society.

As a result, real empathy and ability to step outside our own perspective has been damaged.

Far from cleansing out doors of perception the soma of modern society has clouded them further.

A Brave New World indeed.

Luckily I’ve found a group of people who value the imagination very highly indeed.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 18/11/2022 17:19

I agree W B Yeats is amazing. 'Leda and the Swan' is often thought to be one of the most technically brilliant examples of the English sonnet form ever written. 'Sailing to Byzantium' is another beaut - obviously got under Cormac McCarthy's skin since he pinched its first line for one of his titles - but my personal favourite is 'Easter 1916'.

And some of James Joyce's stuff might have been written as prose but is every bit as lyrical as poetry. I really love the Irish modernists.

EastCoker · 18/11/2022 17:04

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/11/2022 17:10

Well, your mistake there was in talking to an elitist twat somebody who has no musical knowledge. Or he'd have known that there is as much attention paid to the gaps as there is the dots.

I actually do believe @NeverDropYourMooncup that all art, music, literature and architecture, is the art of enclosing space. The space in which we live, the distance between us, as people, or the distance between us and the natural world.

It's an attempt at meaning, of breaching the unknowable space with connection that we as humans can understand.

Of course, that man was a twat an worded it badly. And it's quite obvious that music too breaches the unfathomable space.

Hence the space will always be just out of his grasp. His loss.

VictorianGothic · 17/11/2022 23:23

@Piseog agreed, of course people find Pulitzer-winning works not to their taste. But it's just the sneery way in which people call Mary Oliver naff, hallmark stuff, 'poyums' as someone's written earlier in the thread - seems to imply a value judgement instead of a personal dislike.

VapeVamp12 · 17/11/2022 12:56

My husband recently took me to see John Cooper Clarke perform some poems and it was amazing! There was another poet called Luke Wright who started the show off and he was equally as good. It really made me enjoy poetry and I've bought some books recently.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 17/11/2022 12:41

MavisChunch29 · 16/11/2022 06:32

St Gertrude’s, Sidcup

Nuns, now: ladies in black hoods for teachers – surely that was surprising?

It seems not. It was just England: like houses made of brick, with stairs, and dark skies, and Christmas coming in winter, and there being a war on.

I was five, and unsurprisable –

except by nasty dogs, or the time

When I ran to catch the bus from school and my knickers fell down in the snow.

That's the sort of thing that would've hooked me in at school, not some airy fairy stuff about a bird.

This is, of course, the fundamental problem when teaching literature. These sorts of poems would have turned me off entirely at school (and, indeed, now). At school, I enjoyed Shakespeare, Beowulf, Chaucer and a lot of the same classic formal poetry which a lot of other posters found dull and interminable. No school can cater to every child's taste, and every choice of text will infuriate some, while pleasing others.

Fortunately at my school we did cover a range of styles and poets which meant that, while I hated some of them, I was also aware that there were others I loved.

Piseog · 17/11/2022 08:22

VictorianGothic · 16/11/2022 23:41

@chyra @TuisealGinideach I don't understand the hate for Mary Oliver. Pulitzer prize winning poetry. Always been fashionable to diss her (maybe because she appeals to middle-aged women...) but to me she seems like she's writing in a much longer Romantic/Whitman tradition.

It’s perfectly permissible to find Pulitzer-winning works not to your taste, surely. I don’t like Norman Mailer either. Or Anne Smiley.