Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel Poetry has died a death in modern society?

239 replies

Marmitemother · 12/11/2022 11:00

Out of curiosity I searched MN expecting to find a topic page on poetry and literature....have I missed it somewhere?

Semi retired, children flown the nest, hubbie and I always busy with projects yet still find time to read poetry most days.

I'm wondering if others, particularly younger folk (we're in our 60's) didn't learn to appreciate poetry at school or just don't have time or the inclination to read, share and discuss compared to all else available these days (TV, phones, cinema, social media etc)

I read The Journey by Mary Oliver this morning and thought about how it spoke to many posting on the Relationship page.

“One day you finally knew
what you had to do, and began,
though the voices around you
kept shouting
their bad advice --
though the whole house
began to tremble
and you felt the old tug
at your ankles.
"Mend my life!"
each voice cried.
But you didn't stop.
You knew what you had to do,
though the wind pried
with its stiff fingers
at the very foundations,
though their melancholy
was terrible.
It was already late
enough, and a wild night,
and the road full of fallen
branches and stones.
But little by little,
as you left their voices behind,
the stars began to burn
through the sheets of clouds,
and there was a new voice
which you slowly
recognized as your own,
that kept you company
as you strode deeper and deeper
into the world,
determined to do
the only thing you could do --
determined to save
the only life you could save.”

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PleaseTakeItOff · 21/11/2022 21:46

*story teller, not writer 🙄

PleaseTakeItOff · 21/11/2022 21:46

@IWannaBeInTheRoomWhereItHappens I do think Lin Manuel is a musical genius and a brilliant story writer. I’m not sure I’d consider him a brilliant poet though, almost all the best lines from Hamilton are (quite openly) taken from other rappers.

pumpkinsareshortlived · 21/11/2022 16:20

@IWannaBeInTheRoomWhereItHappens

"I don't think poetry is dying out but it's ever evolving. And tastes just vary so wildly it's often impossible to say what good poetry actually is. For me, it's words that move, that inspire, that fire, that give a window on something new, that take me somewhere else."

My thoughts on poetry in a nutshell! Thank you

pumpkinsareshortlived · 21/11/2022 16:16

stilldumdedumming · 16/11/2022 06:28

I adore poetry. Pretty much daily. But I hate to analyse it so much.

When you ask people if they like poetry - it's an odd question as it's such a diverse genre.

My ds 22 is a poetry nut. Every time I send him something he has already listened or read it.

Some rap is poetry and some not.

https://onbeing.org/series/poetry-unbound/page/2/]

This is an excellent short podcast that gives analysis without going all technical. I adore it and recently went to see Padraig O'Tuama - what a night!

@Marmitemother Have you heard this quite rare Mary Oliver interview- it's brilliant https://onbeing.org/programs/mary-oliver-i-got-saved-by-the-beauty-of-the-world/

Thank you @stilldumdedumming 😊

Ilkleymoor · 21/11/2022 09:48

Spoken word nights are massive, lots of people write their own poetry and poetry journals/comps still exist. I think it's bigger than in my youth. Depends on where you are looking. Short stories have also had a resurgence.

IWannaBeInTheRoomWhereItHappens · 21/11/2022 09:44

I'm a local poet-in-residence and very much influenced by some modern spoken word stuff; I agree rap is poetry and I think Lin Manuel Miranda is a genius.
But I also love some of the old romantics, I studied Donne at college and fell in love. I love Rosetti and Eliot - he opened my eyes to poetry at an early age with Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats which I just devoured again and again. But as a child I also loved poets like Blake because even though I didn't understand all the words I was captivated by the rhythm and cadence. I'm the same now - I like hearing poetry read aloud because I want to head the poet's take on it, the way they envisage it.

I don't think poetry is dying out but it's ever evolving. And tastes just vary so wildly it's often impossible to say what good poetry actually is. For me, it's words that move, that inspire, that fire, that give a window on something new, that take me somewhere else. I don't like Hallmark guff but I like a good limerick as much as the next woman. I like funny Haikus and I like tragic war poems and I like Shakespeare's sonnets.

I do share my poetry on social media and get a good response but I'm aware that for every encouraging voice there's someone thinking 'ugh'. And that's okay, because it's subjective and has to be so.

salsmum · 20/11/2022 17:45

I love to write poetry about many subjects of interest and also to raise awareness and folks of all adult ages seem to really like them and I find through personal experience it's a great way to get a message across. I love to read poetry on SM as I find it can be really moving. Yes rap is a form of poetry I agree and would love to see poetry make a comeback.

TheFarawayNearby · 20/11/2022 12:21

I agree @OMG12 - poetry is as varied as people are, so everyone will like different poetry. I don't like a lot of poetry that other people seem to find heartwarming, and I find some poetry dull that other people might rave about. I know a couple of poets that I love though, and I'm open to finding others. I think that poetry can get to the heart of the matter more quickly than novels etc.

MarshaBradyo · 20/11/2022 10:03

Did anyone listen to the poet on R6 during Covid?

Definitely for the masses, not elite, but very moving

Can’t remember the guy’s name though

balalake · 20/11/2022 09:58

Most people ignore poetry because most poetry ignores people.

OMG12 · 20/11/2022 09:42

HighlandCowbag · 18/11/2022 18:13

I'm a 45 year old literature and philosophy student. Blake and Coleridge left me feeling meh.

I would recommend Anna Letita Baubald for some kick ass, feminist, subversive poetry of that time.

Well that’s fine, everyone likes different things, I think the subjectiveness of poetry is what makes it wonderful, there’s much poetry mentioned here that I don’t connect to at all. I guess like some philosophy. What one person raves about I find little of interest.

Hope your studies are going well.

larkstar · 20/11/2022 08:20

@stilldumdedumming - thanks - I've cut, pasted and edited the link - you can always look for a ? in any link and delete it and everything after it and it will work fine. I hadn't seen that collection.

www.waterstones.com/book/poetry-unbound/padraig-o-tuama//9781838856328

stilldumdedumming · 20/11/2022 06:53

Bloody hell! Linky!!!! Edit button please!!

stilldumdedumming · 20/11/2022 06:53

Sorry forgot to do the kinky thing

stilldumdedumming · 20/11/2022 06:43

@larkstar thank you- I'm a bloodaxe fan. It's definitely a great jumping off point. Although I did t know about lifesaving poems. I'm just looking at the Anthony Wilson site. It's brilliant. I love the idea that he curated a collection of poems on the criterion that each had to be one he couldn't do without!! My kind of criterion. Thank you. I'll pass to ds (who will already know about it)

larkstar · 19/11/2022 19:44

@pastypirate @MadameCholetsDirtySecret You'll always get a guy with a pie!

I don't agree that poetry is in decline at all - quite the opposite - if you think that - it suggests to me that you're not really engaging with what's been going on in so many areas - as others have said poetry is not one thing - it's a very broad church and means different things to different people. If you've ever been to a poetry writing group it never ceases to amaze me how little we all have in common with one another in what switches us on - in terms of who or what we read and why we write. I often say that the world of poetry is like a long stretch of coast - a beach covered in shells - there are so many shells to pick up, examine and either keep or put down again - I think an interest in poetry is a never ending search for that handful of shells that you want to hold on to - my tastes have changed as I have discovered new writers. Publishers like Bloodaxe have brought a lot of translated poetry into the conversation (e.g. Adelia Prado) the more you keep looking the more you find. There are loads of poetry blogs where people share poems and their thoughts on them - Anthony Wilson's is excellent (anthonywilsonpoetry.com/ he lists other blogs and poets to check out anthonywilsonpoetry.com/awesomepoets/) - his brilliant collection of generally not very well known poems - Lifesaving Poems - is an excellent collection to get you enthused about new writers as are the Bloodaxe collections Staying Alive, etc. Ultimately I prefer to track down the featured authors original collections - e.g. Malena Morling (and that can sometimes be quite hard but there's a joy in that too imho) - names that probably don't spring easily to most peoples minds - because - there are so many poems, so many poets to discover - this is why - as Brain Eno has said - curators are so important in art these days.

Personally I don't read much before about 1950 - most of what I gravitate towards has been written in the last 40 years, often new work - Ted Kooser is one I follow, Simon Armitage (who might be losing his touch tbh) - but he's working hard to promote the art. He's repeated said in many different ways that "It’s never going to be very mainstream. One reason is that poetry requires concentration, both on the part of the writer and the reader. But it’s kind of unkillable, poetry. It’s our most ancient artform and I think it’s more relevant today than ever, because it’s one person saying what they really believe.”

It's not dying - it's a renaissance if anything imho.

pastypirate · 19/11/2022 15:28

MadameCholetsDirtySecret · 12/11/2022 12:21

Dr John Cooper Clarke is brilliant

johncooperclarke.com/poems/

Came on to say the same.

VioletladyGrantham · 19/11/2022 15:23

Simon Armitage: The Not Dead is my favourite book of poetry at present; it gives a voice to British veterans stemming from WW2 through to The Iraq War. I also loved The Bed: a tribute to the unnamed ww1 soldier buried in Westminster Abbey. Some of the 18th century romantics made some banging poetry, too.

OMG12 · 19/11/2022 15:04

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 19/11/2022 13:24

Indeed, and close to Aristotelean elemental thought, particularly as it relates to the interplay between spirit and body. Philosophy, theology and science are not at all far removed from one another, albeit in more recent thought they've separated into distinct disciplines. The pseudo-science of psychoanalysis, for one, was strongly rooted in ancient symbolism, particularly in the work of Jung.

The more I read into them, the more I'm concluding that the wisdom of the ancients is unparalleled, or at the very least, has never been usurped by modern knowledge. As you say, modern knowledge is merely compartmentalized differently.

I'm liking the sound of that Romantic to Modernism module! So much of Modernism is so deeply rooted in romantic thought, despite Eliot's protestation that the only cure for Romanticism is to analyse it. I'd have given a great deal to study (or develop) a course like that.

I'm loving the contributions to this thread which are giving me plenty of food for thought (and an ever-more expensive reading list on my Amazon wishlist)!

I really appreciate the work of Jung. He drew together a lot of escoteric thought from over the centuries and made a valiant attempt to make it accessible to the masses as an explanation as to how we are as we are. I know he was fascinated by the Chymical Wedding of Christian Rosenkrutz, reading that alone and deciphering the symbolism in it could take decades IMO. I suppose the problem with some of his work is that it drew on many escoteric ideas which were never meant to be exoteric so I think his appeal now largely relies on the knowledge and predisposition of the reader. I suspect the intellectual elite in the first half of the 20 th century might have been more open to his ideas. There is genius in them. But it’s perhaps a modern example of the point being made. To judge genius anachronistically is to do much disservice.

i know what you mean about the books, if only I had time to read them all😀

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 19/11/2022 13:36

In recent years I have been reading a lot more poetry. It started as a New Year’s Resolution - I decided that, instead of giving things up, I would add things to enrich my life. The first year, my resolution was to read a new poem and listen to a new (new to me, any genre) piece of music and read a new poem every week, but I enjoyed it so much, I ended up doing it almost daily. After that year, my resolution was reading a poem every day - this year I have a book with a poem to read every night, and I’ve bought an anthology of poetry for next year.

I don’t love every poem, but I have read and enjoyed a lot of poetry I wouldn’t otherwise have encountered.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 19/11/2022 13:32

NB. H.D. and Mina Loy were certainly two of the risk-taking women poets you speak of, @HighlandCowbag. In Loy, 'Song to Joannes' and the feminist manifesto are both extraordinary pieces of writing, especially for her time. She was a trailblazer, and a talented visual artist as well as a poet.

I think, given the right tools, anyone can analyse poetry and that this should never be the exclusive domain of professional literary critics. On the contrary, I've read plenty of academic criticism that I think talks complete balderdash. All that's really required is passion: something that gets your blood up and that talks to you in some meaningful way.

It would be a sad thing if the only place 'legitimized' for reading, writing and talking about poetry was the universities, especially given the state they are in today ...

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 19/11/2022 13:24

OMG12 · 18/11/2022 22:24

Yes, I mean people like Dr John Dee had a vast wealth and range of knowledge, some of which we might no longer value but that doesn’t detract from him. I think there was a much stronger ability to think across a range of subject and see how they corresponded and complimented each other. In many respects I would suggest we have lost a lot of knowledge whilst simultaneously gaining lots of information. I certainly don’t think we are any cleverer now than say 500 years ago.

i was listening to Dr Brian Cox this morning on the BBC talking about what would happen if you went into a black hole. How someone observing you would effectively see you frozen in time just before you entered the black hole. You would however carry on and everything about you would be absorbed by the black hole and become part of its fabric. I seem to recall reading somewhere how we could have all have originated from something spewed out of a black hole. How very close to emanating from and returning to source in Neoplatonic thought. A timeless source. Our intellect hasn’t really grown, our ways of expressing it have changed. History is littered with people more intelligent that we could ever imagine. You live only got to look at the Egyptians to understand that.

Indeed, and close to Aristotelean elemental thought, particularly as it relates to the interplay between spirit and body. Philosophy, theology and science are not at all far removed from one another, albeit in more recent thought they've separated into distinct disciplines. The pseudo-science of psychoanalysis, for one, was strongly rooted in ancient symbolism, particularly in the work of Jung.

The more I read into them, the more I'm concluding that the wisdom of the ancients is unparalleled, or at the very least, has never been usurped by modern knowledge. As you say, modern knowledge is merely compartmentalized differently.

I'm liking the sound of that Romantic to Modernism module! So much of Modernism is so deeply rooted in romantic thought, despite Eliot's protestation that the only cure for Romanticism is to analyse it. I'd have given a great deal to study (or develop) a course like that.

I'm loving the contributions to this thread which are giving me plenty of food for thought (and an ever-more expensive reading list on my Amazon wishlist)!

1Wanda1 · 19/11/2022 08:21

I went to a poetry reading recently. It was brilliant. It was sold out. Mainly women, about 3 men in the audience. And the "support act" was amazing - I'd never have discovered him if I hadn't been to that evening. I'll be reading more poetry as a result, I think.

Lincslady53 · 19/11/2022 07:58

Frank Skinner is a lover of poetry and has an excellent poetry podcast on Absolute Radio where he discusses a different poet each episode planetradio.co.uk/podcasts/frank-skinner-poetry-podcast/

Swipe left for the next trending thread