Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School punishment

54 replies

Schnookypachooky · 12/11/2022 10:20

Aibu to think that it’s abusive to make a class of 7 year olds sit for 20 minutes without being allowed to do anything at all as punishment because they were too noisy?

OP posts:
PinkSyCo · 12/11/2022 11:09

I actually think it’s a really good punishment IF the duration of it was cut by half, so teacher imo was a little harsh but abusive? No.

GreenWheat · 12/11/2022 11:09

Oh good grief, what a ridiculous dramatic response. No, it is not "abusive". Do you know what that word means? One of the reasons class discipline is so poor is that the kids have parents who think consequences for poor behaviour is "abusive"..... I think 5-10mins would have been more appropriate at that age though.

Coolyule · 12/11/2022 11:07

Abusive?! Not remotely
as pp has said are you sure it was 20 minutes? My 7 year old wouldnt be able to reliably understand the concept of 20 minutes.
but even if it was, it’s not abusive to be bored for 20 minutes if they’ve been disruptive and difficult for the teacher.

Zosime · 12/11/2022 11:06

Good for the DC to control themselves, reflect and look inwards for a short period of time.

Most people would probably benefit from taking a period of time each day to sit quietly with no distractions (including no screens).

cansu · 12/11/2022 11:04

Being quiet for 20 mins is not abusive.

ImustLearn2Cook · 12/11/2022 11:03

20 minutes seems a bit over the top. Are you sure that the teacher made them sit quietly for a whole 20 minutes and not 5 minutes? Were you there? Or did a child tell you that it was 20 minutes (5 minutes could feel like 20 minutes to a child who is made to sit still and do nothing)?

Thereisnolight · 12/11/2022 11:03

zingally · 12/11/2022 10:56

Speaking as a teacher of that same age group, no, it's not abusive, but it IS a waste of time. I might do something similar, but for 5 minutes. Certainly not 20.
It sounds like a teacher who was thoroughly fed up, and all previous attempts to shut them had failed.

I disagree that controlling yourself and being calm and reflecting is a waste of time.

Ramble0n · 12/11/2022 10:58

Doesn't sound like a great teacher.

Yellowdahlia12 · 12/11/2022 10:57

Of course it's not abusive. Why does every little attempt at discipline end up by being abusive?
Shouting - abuse
Isolation - abuse
Naughty step - abuse
No wonder so many schools are bear pits of uncontrollable children. Read the recent thread about the supply teacher.

When I went to school back in the fifties, children got the cane for talking. I'm not advocating going back to that, but I think today's society, in general, has become too permissive, resulting in entitled children and parents.

zingally · 12/11/2022 10:56

Speaking as a teacher of that same age group, no, it's not abusive, but it IS a waste of time. I might do something similar, but for 5 minutes. Certainly not 20.
It sounds like a teacher who was thoroughly fed up, and all previous attempts to shut them had failed.

Thereisnolight · 12/11/2022 10:51

NuffSaidSam · 12/11/2022 10:32

Abusive to sit quietly for 20 minutes?!

It's no wonder they're badly behaved if they've got parents who think that's abusive!

Exactly.
Good for the DC to control themselves, reflect and look inwards for a short period of time.
Very strange OP.

Thegreenballoon · 12/11/2022 10:49

I don’t think it’s constructive or terribly realistic (my child is incapable of sitting still in silence for twenty min if his life depended on it), and I hate whole class punishments for things, but it’s hardly abusive or traumatising.

PotentiallyPolly · 12/11/2022 10:49

20 mins sat quietly is the perfect way to calm them down and assure the rest of the day proceeds the same way.

PotentiallyPolly · 12/11/2022 10:48

PMSL 🤣

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 12/11/2022 10:32

Abusive no, unreasonable yes.

NuffSaidSam · 12/11/2022 10:32

Abusive to sit quietly for 20 minutes?!

It's no wonder they're badly behaved if they've got parents who think that's abusive!

TrashyPanda · 12/11/2022 10:31

Definitely not abusive

they have not suffered any harm

being bored is not abuse

luxxlisbon · 12/11/2022 10:31

@Spookypig agree on ‘abusive’ being thrown around so much!

I imagine it’s incredibly hard for teachers to control their class if parents phone up hysterical about ‘abuse’ over ever little thing and undermining any disciple in the classroom.

Onandgrowing · 12/11/2022 10:30

Not abusive.

Not ideal either but if it’s a one off I wouldn’t be doing / saying anything about it. If repeated, I might feel the need to discuss with teacher / head.

Sunnyqueen · 12/11/2022 10:30

Why do people insist on throwing these serious words around, making them buzz words and basically watering down the original meaning so now they mean nothing. Obviously, that is not 'abusive'

VickyEadieofThigh · 12/11/2022 10:29

Of course it's not "abusive" - it's a punishment and as such, not meant to be enjoyable.

I never did this myself as a teacher but have the utmost sympathy for any teacher whose class wound her up this much that she resorted to it!

BuryingAcorns · 12/11/2022 10:27

No it's not abusive. It's boring. It's designed to make them choose not to experience such dullness again by shutting up in class and listening.

Spookypig · 12/11/2022 10:25

No. It’s a punishment. It is meant to be dull and unenjoyable.

The term ‘abusive’ is thrown around so much that it’s verging on offensive. I’m sure a real victim of abuse would not appreciate their suffering being compared to a child sitting on their chair and not being rowdy for 20 minutes.

mikado1 · 12/11/2022 10:24

Not good behaviour management, not abusive.

Putonyourshoes · 12/11/2022 10:24

Not abusive, you can’t say sitting in silence for 20 minutes caused them any harm, can you?
I don’t think it’ll be effective though and seems a lazy form of discipline.