Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School punishment

54 replies

Schnookypachooky · 12/11/2022 10:20

Aibu to think that it’s abusive to make a class of 7 year olds sit for 20 minutes without being allowed to do anything at all as punishment because they were too noisy?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lopilo · 12/11/2022 12:52

20mins is quite a long time and also a waste of time, but it isn’t abusive. I would have loved this when I was at school as I liked daydreaming without interruption. Comments above about SEN kids not being able to do this is not accurate. A lot of SEN kids love peace and quiet and would be quite happy doing this, especially if it shut the rowdy hectic kid up for a while.

SkylightSkylight · 12/11/2022 12:05

Thegreenballoon · 12/11/2022 10:49

I don’t think it’s constructive or terribly realistic (my child is incapable of sitting still in silence for twenty min if his life depended on it), and I hate whole class punishments for things, but it’s hardly abusive or traumatising.

@Thegreenballoon

i don't think I'm capable of sitting quietly for 20 minutes on an uncomfortable school chair with nothing to do!!

actually there's no 'don't think' about it! I would be unless you held a gun to my head. That might just distract me enough!

@Schnookypachooky

abusive???

FFS, how dare you try to diminish the real abuse too many children suffer.

Zosime · 12/11/2022 12:05

I don't think it is as non-useful as you might think. Life does involve the skills of learning to sit quietly at times, dealing with boredom, having some self control, being with your own thoughts and not just rushing noisily headlong into the next thing. The world is 'always on' these days. It won't have done them any harm.

I wholeheartedly agree. As I said above, I think everyone would benefit from doing this.

'Cruel'??? Jesus H. Christ on a bike.

Sherrystrull · 12/11/2022 12:00

The teacher may be struggling and if this 20 minutes of silence means that the children in the class know that the teacher will follow through with expectations of behaviour in the future, then it might be an investment into productive and effective learning in the future.

Coolyule · 12/11/2022 11:49

WhiteFire · 12/11/2022 11:18

Are you sure it wasn't just the 2 minute silence?

Yes, this is a good point!

Dogsogdog · 12/11/2022 11:46

Cruel ? Abusive ? Ffs give over

ThanksAntsThants · 12/11/2022 11:41

Why is it abusive, what is abusive about it? I don’t think it’d be very effective, but I’m struggling to see why it would be classed as abusive. Just because somebody doesn’t enjoy something, it doesn’t make it abuse. You entirely degrade the word abuse when you apply it to something like this.

Namenic · 12/11/2022 11:38

No. I’m sure kids have to be silent for SATS tests.

Untitledsquatboulder · 12/11/2022 11:36

@Feysriana why is it cruel? You get that you can't change the actual definition of words to suit your narrative right?

Yellowdahlia12 · 12/11/2022 11:36

Feysriana · 12/11/2022 11:30

It is cruel. And cruel is abuse. So actually yanbu.

Also bearing in mind that in 16% of children have special needs such as ADHD, which won’t have been diagnosed yet at age 7, that’s a lot of SEN kids being punished in a way they can’t cope with.

The bigger worry is why the school has a teacher so incompetent that they think this is a good idea. It’s going to make the children worse behaved, not better, and 20 mins of forced inactivity is 20 minutes lost learning time. Teacher would have been better off making them run laps of the playground / setting extra learning / making them pick litter on playground.

Sounds like the teacher was a sadist on a power trip.

I would raise it with the head re “Was the teacher’s action part of the school’s agreed discipline policy? If yes why is your policy so old-fashioned and ineffective and how was the 20min period chosen? If no how are you going to discipline the teacher and what is your plan for avoiding this in future?”

Easy to spot the you have never been a teacher. On what planet is sitting quietly 'cruelty?'

StickySnotBalls · 12/11/2022 11:35

Spot on @GlassDeli

GlassDeli · 12/11/2022 11:34

I don't think it is as non-useful as you might think. Life does involve the skills of learning to sit quietly at times, dealing with boredom, having some self control, being with your own thoughts and not just rushing noisily headlong into the next thing. The world is 'always on' these days. It won't have done them any harm.

Pieceofpurplesky · 12/11/2022 11:33

Were you told 20 minutes by the child? I bet it wasn't that long / and could very well been for the silence

MajorCarolDanvers · 12/11/2022 11:32

To all that abusive is absurd

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/11/2022 11:32

20 whole minutes? Are you sure that really happened?

No, it’s not abusive. It’s pointless because the same message could be delivered with five minutes being made to sit in silence, but it’s ridiculous to suggest it’s abusive.

Feysriana · 12/11/2022 11:30

It is cruel. And cruel is abuse. So actually yanbu.

Also bearing in mind that in 16% of children have special needs such as ADHD, which won’t have been diagnosed yet at age 7, that’s a lot of SEN kids being punished in a way they can’t cope with.

The bigger worry is why the school has a teacher so incompetent that they think this is a good idea. It’s going to make the children worse behaved, not better, and 20 mins of forced inactivity is 20 minutes lost learning time. Teacher would have been better off making them run laps of the playground / setting extra learning / making them pick litter on playground.

Sounds like the teacher was a sadist on a power trip.

I would raise it with the head re “Was the teacher’s action part of the school’s agreed discipline policy? If yes why is your policy so old-fashioned and ineffective and how was the 20min period chosen? If no how are you going to discipline the teacher and what is your plan for avoiding this in future?”

StickySnotBalls · 12/11/2022 11:26

In what way are you thinking it's abuse?
Good for the teacher

Zosime · 12/11/2022 11:25

Are you sure it wasn't just the 2 minute silence?

Good point!

Georgeskitchen · 12/11/2022 11:22

If anyone is still wondering why there are so many feral brats causing trouble with no consequences, here lies a big clue.
I remember the days when if you got into trouble at school and yoir parents got wind of it, you would be even more up shit creek.

Sherrystrull · 12/11/2022 11:20

I teach this age. I agree it sounds like a thoroughly fed up teacher.

Seriously, try and keep a class of 7 year olds quiet and then comment...

WhiteFire · 12/11/2022 11:18

Are you sure it wasn't just the 2 minute silence?

VioletLemon · 12/11/2022 11:12

Contravenes all right minded policy around promoting positive well being and behaviour, borders on bullying.

DriftwoodOnTheShore · 12/11/2022 11:11

Don't be ridiculous.

Thatsshallot1967 · 12/11/2022 11:10

Don't think it's abusive op. It's frustrating for the teacher and a rather strange punishment though.

As an aside, it's my guess that there will be a small handful of children who did nothing and are being collectively punished for the misdemeanours of a majority. I could bet on that. It used to happen a lot when my DC were in primary and also secondary.

ImustLearn2Cook · 12/11/2022 11:09

I agree with pp that 20 minutes would be a waste of time because not many 7 year olds would be able to sit still doing nothing for 20 minutes. They would become disruptive before 10 minutes was up.

They could reasonably be expected to do a quiet activity or listen to a story for 20 minutes but that’s being engaged in something interesting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread