Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband converted to Islam

592 replies

newbookonshelf · 12/11/2022 08:46

What would you make of this? Not sure what I'm asking. He's trying to find himself I suppose. We're all looking for meaning in this world. I've thought about religion many times, but just not sure what to make of it right now.

OP posts:
socialmedia23 · 14/11/2022 11:44

Treecreature · 12/11/2022 09:50

Absolutely.

I converted to liberal judaism. My DH is very irreligious, basically agnostic and i don't think it has affected his life in any way (as liberal judaism allows people to choose the practices that are meaningful to them individually). We are close to his mother who is orthodox jewish (it is how i was exposed to judaism in a very intense way as we lived with her for 3 years before buying our place). So whatever i do pales in comparison with whatever she does.

And even though i had a liberal conversion, his mum accepts me as jewish (she is a convert herself so i guess she is more open minded to conversions from other denominations) and this has meant she has warmed to me a lot more. We have something in common which is great as we are otherwise very different people and it makes life a lot easier.

I can see if you don't have any connection to Islam in general, it can be worrying.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:43

He's already peppering his messages with things like mashallah and it really doesn't resonate with me if I'm honest, quite the opposite in fact.

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:39

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 14/11/2022 11:31

I genuinely don't think I could continue a relationship with a religious person. Particularly not the 'recently converted' type who tend to be more fervent.

Nothing against Islam in particular. I'm just actively anti-organised religion and I don't think I could make enough allowances for that.

Would you give it some time in my situation?

OP posts:
monsteramunch · 14/11/2022 11:37

But is there an Islamic nation where it's written in law that women are equal in rights?

I would be interested to know this too as I'm not aware of any but happy to be educated.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 14/11/2022 11:31

I genuinely don't think I could continue a relationship with a religious person. Particularly not the 'recently converted' type who tend to be more fervent.

Nothing against Islam in particular. I'm just actively anti-organised religion and I don't think I could make enough allowances for that.

magma32 · 14/11/2022 11:28

Sorry I have just realised pp have said this already

magma32 · 14/11/2022 11:27

OP I have just read you are planning to have another baby. I think you maybe should wait first and see how things go, whilst he could be a relaxed muslim who uses common sense and not rigidly sticking to ‘sharia’ law and other rulings, there is also a chance he could go the other way and become a pain in the arse (I’m putting it nicely). There are many a scholars like the ones I mentioned above, who say a registered legal marriage counts as a marriage in the eyes of God but that’s common sense to me because I know how ridiculous it is trying to have a non legal contract when it was always intended to be legal. but the important thing is what your husband believes in and wants to stick to. I think as Muslims living in Britain we are naturally going to ‘sin’ because the sharia laws are for Islamic contexts where the Muslims are all having to follow it. Living in the U.K. and trying to follow Islamic inheritance laws for instance basically screws women over unlike in an Islamic country that practices this (not many actually do from what I’ve seen) because unlike in the Islamic context the woman will not inherit automatically from everyone else she’s supposed to to warrant the lower share from her husband. And that doesn’t even account for the fact the woman is making financial contributions over here etc. in sharia courts (the proper ones) the judge is meant to look at things case by case to make sure women aren’t being screwed over but that is not what is happening in the U.K., sharia courts and men are a law unto themselves, which makes any law redundant if it won’t be enforced which is why you see so many women in non registered marriages end up in shit’s creek. Anyway my point is if your husband is ok with ‘sinning’ that’s fine, I don’t think it’s sinning personally as I’m sure god understands you can’t operate two legal systems, one that isn’t even legally enforced, hence following the legal laws of the land you’re in. but if he starts feeling guilty that can really impact things so wait and see first is my advice. Chances are it may just be a thing he does in private or realises it’s not for him or it’s damaging your relationship and might just stop anyway but if he goes the other way you may have to prepare to leave him and I’m not sure bringing another child into uncertainty is a good idea.

Croque · 14/11/2022 11:26

I can only speak for my Muslim friends in various countries (including ME ones) who are really assertive, independent and confident. That is not to say they all have perfect family relationships but it is not on account of them 'not knowing their place in Islam'.
I have to say that I am less convinced by the arguments some of them put forward for wearing the hijab (@It's my choice' etc) as some conditioning seems to be in place to choose not to feel the wind blowing through your hair. There is nothing about it which screams life affirming.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:24

MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 11:23

I too would suggest some kind of cooling off period for both of you where you carry on with life as before and not much, if anything, is made of your husband conversion. Let him get used to praying and finding his way forward whilst you do the same, living the life you want. Give yourself 18 months or so, and yes it probably will be quite scary as your family’s future could be at stake. But most of all, please don’t become pregnant. Your child has to hear the call to prayer immediately after birth and I think it would only be then that you’d see if your husband was willing to be the only Muslim in the family (and not hold it against you and be a death knell on your marriage)

I know, but I have to basically give up any chance of having another baby. I took this risk getting with someone younger that he would change.

OP posts:
MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 11:23

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:08

Yes you are right in all you say here, thank you

I too would suggest some kind of cooling off period for both of you where you carry on with life as before and not much, if anything, is made of your husband conversion. Let him get used to praying and finding his way forward whilst you do the same, living the life you want. Give yourself 18 months or so, and yes it probably will be quite scary as your family’s future could be at stake. But most of all, please don’t become pregnant. Your child has to hear the call to prayer immediately after birth and I think it would only be then that you’d see if your husband was willing to be the only Muslim in the family (and not hold it against you and be a death knell on your marriage)

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:22

Croque · 14/11/2022 11:20

Show me one Muslim nation that is a haven of peace, prosperity and where women have freedoms and rights

There is no such thing as a nation where everybody is leading peaceful prosperous lives and all women enjoy freedoms and rights. Every nation which appears to be doing well (including the UK) has oppressed and battered women, modern slaves, trafficked women etc.

But is there an Islamic nation where it's written in law that women are equal in rights?

OP posts:
Croque · 14/11/2022 11:20

Show me one Muslim nation that is a haven of peace, prosperity and where women have freedoms and rights

There is no such thing as a nation where everybody is leading peaceful prosperous lives and all women enjoy freedoms and rights. Every nation which appears to be doing well (including the UK) has oppressed and battered women, modern slaves, trafficked women etc.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:17

MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 11:16

Show me one Muslim nation that is a haven of peace, prosperity and where women have freedoms and rights

there are plenty and if you really did know what you were talking about you’d be aware of them.

I don't know what I'm talking about and want to know this. I genuinely thought they all had oppressive laws for women.

Which nation should I look at to exemplify that this is not the case?

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:16

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 11:12

Is he's a vegan looking to find a religious label, I would have thought the Hare Krishna teachings would resonate with him most?

me too.

OP posts:
MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 11:16

Show me one Muslim nation that is a haven of peace, prosperity and where women have freedoms and rights

there are plenty and if you really did know what you were talking about you’d be aware of them.

emmetgirl · 14/11/2022 11:13

Dealbreaker for me as I'm an atheist.

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 11:12

Is he's a vegan looking to find a religious label, I would have thought the Hare Krishna teachings would resonate with him most?

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:11

"If you look at human teeth we have flat and canine"

Shows set of flat human teeth as proof.

Extremely dim perhaps

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:08

Croque · 14/11/2022 11:05

I think you have both dived too deep into it too fast. He seems to be telling you things as he learns them which may not always be 100% accurate if he took his time. You are treating it as a forever scenario when it might be a passing fad.
What is sure is that I would not be planning a pregnancy in these conditions. It just adds to the stress and uncertainty.

Yes you are right in all you say here, thank you

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:07

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/11/2022 10:56

Would you be comfortable if he started eating meat.

He has caused issues in Malaysia

meat? No that would not fly. But there's no need and I'm sure my husband will disregard whatever Dr Z says here.

Second one... listening... Dr Z says taken out of context so denies what he said?

So I would not call either of these "extreme" personally.

OP posts:
Croque · 14/11/2022 11:05

I think you have both dived too deep into it too fast. He seems to be telling you things as he learns them which may not always be 100% accurate if he took his time. You are treating it as a forever scenario when it might be a passing fad.
What is sure is that I would not be planning a pregnancy in these conditions. It just adds to the stress and uncertainty.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/11/2022 10:56

Would you be comfortable if he started eating meat.

He has caused issues in Malaysia

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 10:30

RumiGibran · 14/11/2022 09:56

I consider myself a 'moderate' muslim (I don't cover my head but try my best to pray/fast + no pork/alcohol). I came to this country for university and stayed back to pursue my career (so not British born & raised). I am not comfortable with Dr Zakir's views - they come across as extreme and intolerant to me. Would also not be ok with my children being influenced by his thoughts/ideologies. Please understand this - in Islam you must respect others. If that is not coming across in a scholar - be very wary.

Hi, are you able to elaborate on Dr Zakir please?

I just had a look at his youtube page but it all seemed okay to be honest.

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 10:26

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 10:18

If one has chosen to be a Muslim they do need to try their best to follow the Sharia law/Islamic law : this means things praying fasting, good treatment, charity....and lots of other rules, otherwise if they go against it they would be answerable to God for it. For example, you have a choice of where to send your child to a school, once you do decide you do have to follow all the rules of the school otherwise there are consequences.

But seeing reality: not many Muslims are fully aware of all the Islamic/Sharia law, or aren't religious or practicing or even forgotten. But they would be answerable for it if they intentionally do not practice or make an effort to practice Islamic law

So not asking me to convert and willingly not bringing up our next child Muslim do you envisage that being a major problem if he gets deeper into Islam?

OP posts:
Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 10:18

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 09:57

Thank you yes that makes sense.

it's nice I can agree with Islam there; I too believe you should follow the law of the country you are in and that countries should allow everyone to practise their religion.

I don't think Sharia law is something that all Muslims follow though, am I wrong?

If one has chosen to be a Muslim they do need to try their best to follow the Sharia law/Islamic law : this means things praying fasting, good treatment, charity....and lots of other rules, otherwise if they go against it they would be answerable to God for it. For example, you have a choice of where to send your child to a school, once you do decide you do have to follow all the rules of the school otherwise there are consequences.

But seeing reality: not many Muslims are fully aware of all the Islamic/Sharia law, or aren't religious or practicing or even forgotten. But they would be answerable for it if they intentionally do not practice or make an effort to practice Islamic law

Swipe left for the next trending thread