Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband converted to Islam

592 replies

newbookonshelf · 12/11/2022 08:46

What would you make of this? Not sure what I'm asking. He's trying to find himself I suppose. We're all looking for meaning in this world. I've thought about religion many times, but just not sure what to make of it right now.

OP posts:
Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:26

MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 12:21

He already provides for us and tells me to keep what I earn

Yes. That’s the norm. A woman has her own wealth. Though nowadays women will usually contribute to the family upkeep through choice. Many men won’t accept it but the women will then quite often get round it by saying - ok, I’ll pay the school fees, or pay all of the childrens expenses. Truth be told I don’t know any woman within my friendship group or extended family circle who doesn’t have her own property bought from her salary that she also earns an income from.

I don't think that's the norm at all especially from what I read on mumsnet😅

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:24

MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 12:21

He already provides for us and tells me to keep what I earn

Yes. That’s the norm. A woman has her own wealth. Though nowadays women will usually contribute to the family upkeep through choice. Many men won’t accept it but the women will then quite often get round it by saying - ok, I’ll pay the school fees, or pay all of the childrens expenses. Truth be told I don’t know any woman within my friendship group or extended family circle who doesn’t have her own property bought from her salary that she also earns an income from.

My contribution is more manual labour as in cleaning, cooking, and house stuff as I enjoy this stuff
h

OP posts:
Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:24

monsteramunch · 14/11/2022 12:08

Same goes for inheritance law...a girl inherits 1/4 and a boy inherits 1/2 because he has to provide his family with it but whatever the girl gets she keeps for herself and gets to chose how to use it.

What if the daughter doesn't marry a Muslim and marries a man who sees her as a financial equal he doesn't need to provide for as they're an equal team?

What if the daughter never marries?

What if the daughter never marries but does end up having children to provide for financially?

What if the daughter marries, divorces and is therefore a single earner who has to provide for her children financially?

Due to all of the above and more I'm not sure how you can spin those inheritance rules as a positive or empowering thing for girls and women.

Daughter marries a non Muslim: yes this is why in Islam, Muslim women can/should only marry Muslim men. If she does she's essentially not following Islamic law is she?so she'll get her inheritance but cant expect her partner will provide for her and her children always

If she doesn't marry: that's why Muslims are encouraged to marry.

Children without marriage: again not allowed in Islam, children need to be in marriage, hence why no sex in Islam outside of marriage.

Daughter marries, divorces, children: that responsibility lies with the ex husband, he has to provide for his children financially.

In all this, if a Muslim girl does face all these situation and she was raised properly with an education and can work she can always provide for herself by working. Also if her father, brother anyone is alive they should provide for her too.

MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 12:23

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:21

Okay here's the issue I've just come to realise as well

So we have a lot of political discussions and a lot of our talk is about ideas and things, you know? I don't want to say we have intellectual discussions but we are both quite focused on our family so don't really like gossip and stuff. So we discuss things more academically.

So now I'm thinking he's going to kind of take a religions slant on everything and our conversations will change.

They could very well change for the better. It doesn’t have to be detrimental.

MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 12:21

He already provides for us and tells me to keep what I earn

Yes. That’s the norm. A woman has her own wealth. Though nowadays women will usually contribute to the family upkeep through choice. Many men won’t accept it but the women will then quite often get round it by saying - ok, I’ll pay the school fees, or pay all of the childrens expenses. Truth be told I don’t know any woman within my friendship group or extended family circle who doesn’t have her own property bought from her salary that she also earns an income from.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:21

Okay here's the issue I've just come to realise as well

So we have a lot of political discussions and a lot of our talk is about ideas and things, you know? I don't want to say we have intellectual discussions but we are both quite focused on our family so don't really like gossip and stuff. So we discuss things more academically.

So now I'm thinking he's going to kind of take a religions slant on everything and our conversations will change.

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:18

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 12:14

It might just pass OP. Or it might morph into something else. How old is he?

25

OP posts:
MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 12:16

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:43

He's already peppering his messages with things like mashallah and it really doesn't resonate with me if I'm honest, quite the opposite in fact.

🙈 I understand.

I have a real problem with Inshallah and quite often pull people up on using it insincerely. Like when you know a person isn’t going to act on something because they can’t be bothered then they say Inshallah to pretend they will.

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:16

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:08

Okay, I am seeing more why he subscribed to this from what you've said.

He already provides for us and tells me to keep what I earn. I have not given up work, I want my own income, and I use it for our daughter and myself, and him of course, and our house, and he's always been this way.

He would still provide for our daughter if we broke up too, he's said this.

I see how it aligns with his beliefs more now, and he does see himself as the head of the household and this has been a bone of contention but I do agree with a family unit being made up of a whole and not two independent adults.

Okay I'm still working this out.

I know a few Muslims and think they're great, I just never expected it to come into my home in this way and I'm scared I guess. I catastrophise and this is all a bit of a shock to me and that's very compounded by the fact we want another baby.

Yes and that's fine if you want to work and you can chose to use it whatever way you like, if you want to contribute to the house that's your choice. But it will always remain his responsibility.

I can understand OP the unknown can be scary

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 12:14

It might just pass OP. Or it might morph into something else. How old is he?

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:10

Lampedsomeoiks · 14/11/2022 12:05

@newbookonshelf

I did see your post stating you are both vegan due to ethical beliefs.

Don't let him sway you. I hope he sticks to his principles on the matter. A 'God' isn't benefitting from your abstinence from eating meat. Animals are. A tangible result.

Yes very well put.

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:09

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 12:05

OP, the way you describe his sudden peppering of texts with certain Islamic phrases etc, makes him sound like all these teenagers who have suddenly affected / adopted Islam due to their obsession with the delightful Andrew Tate. It's very shallow and definitely a fad if I ever saw one. Teens are doing the same as your husband all over TikTok etc with only the most scant understanding of what Islam actually entails. Are you sure he's not having some kind of mid-life crisis?

No he definitely is.

Do you think it will just pass?

OP posts:
Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:09

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:17

I don't know what I'm talking about and want to know this. I genuinely thought they all had oppressive laws for women.

Which nation should I look at to exemplify that this is not the case?

I wouldn't be able to tell you a nation as I don't follow the same sect as the leaders of those nations. But one community - the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community that I follow definitely has upheld the true teachings of Islam and provide equal treatment of women and men. Unfortunately this community is heavily persecuted by other sects of Islam also.

monsteramunch · 14/11/2022 12:08

Same goes for inheritance law...a girl inherits 1/4 and a boy inherits 1/2 because he has to provide his family with it but whatever the girl gets she keeps for herself and gets to chose how to use it.

What if the daughter doesn't marry a Muslim and marries a man who sees her as a financial equal he doesn't need to provide for as they're an equal team?

What if the daughter never marries?

What if the daughter never marries but does end up having children to provide for financially?

What if the daughter marries, divorces and is therefore a single earner who has to provide for her children financially?

Due to all of the above and more I'm not sure how you can spin those inheritance rules as a positive or empowering thing for girls and women.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:08

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:03

Well no he should not ask you to convert just because he is. And bringing up your child Muslim I feel that's a discussion you need to have with your husband.

As far as I'm aware a man has an Islamic duty to provide for his wife and kids and give them worldly, spiritual and moral education.

There is a lot of good in Islam which I feel you may not have not come across yet. For me I actually feel a sense of security for my family that I'm married to a Muslim. The security that he will not leave us, and always provide for his kids. Whatever he earns he is responsible to provide for the family with it, but whatever you will earn that's for yourself to keep , it's not your responsibility to provide for your family financially. Same goes for inheritance law...a girl inherits 1/4 and a boy inherits 1/2 because he has to provide his family with it but whatever the girl gets she keeps for herself and gets to chose how to use it.

Okay, I am seeing more why he subscribed to this from what you've said.

He already provides for us and tells me to keep what I earn. I have not given up work, I want my own income, and I use it for our daughter and myself, and him of course, and our house, and he's always been this way.

He would still provide for our daughter if we broke up too, he's said this.

I see how it aligns with his beliefs more now, and he does see himself as the head of the household and this has been a bone of contention but I do agree with a family unit being made up of a whole and not two independent adults.

Okay I'm still working this out.

I know a few Muslims and think they're great, I just never expected it to come into my home in this way and I'm scared I guess. I catastrophise and this is all a bit of a shock to me and that's very compounded by the fact we want another baby.

OP posts:
chakra1 · 14/11/2022 12:05

OP, the way you describe his sudden peppering of texts with certain Islamic phrases etc, makes him sound like all these teenagers who have suddenly affected / adopted Islam due to their obsession with the delightful Andrew Tate. It's very shallow and definitely a fad if I ever saw one. Teens are doing the same as your husband all over TikTok etc with only the most scant understanding of what Islam actually entails. Are you sure he's not having some kind of mid-life crisis?

Lampedsomeoiks · 14/11/2022 12:05

@newbookonshelf

I did see your post stating you are both vegan due to ethical beliefs.

Don't let him sway you. I hope he sticks to his principles on the matter. A 'God' isn't benefitting from your abstinence from eating meat. Animals are. A tangible result.

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:03

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 10:26

So not asking me to convert and willingly not bringing up our next child Muslim do you envisage that being a major problem if he gets deeper into Islam?

Well no he should not ask you to convert just because he is. And bringing up your child Muslim I feel that's a discussion you need to have with your husband.

As far as I'm aware a man has an Islamic duty to provide for his wife and kids and give them worldly, spiritual and moral education.

There is a lot of good in Islam which I feel you may not have not come across yet. For me I actually feel a sense of security for my family that I'm married to a Muslim. The security that he will not leave us, and always provide for his kids. Whatever he earns he is responsible to provide for the family with it, but whatever you will earn that's for yourself to keep , it's not your responsibility to provide for your family financially. Same goes for inheritance law...a girl inherits 1/4 and a boy inherits 1/2 because he has to provide his family with it but whatever the girl gets she keeps for herself and gets to chose how to use it.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:02

VestaTilley · 14/11/2022 11:57

Just make sure he doesn’t make you and any daughters you have start covering your heads. You can’t stop him if it’s what he wants - but don’t be browbeaten in to joining in.

Converts can often be very over zealous. If he gets very in to it you may find yourself married to a very different man.

I really would like to see him try that.

Honestly, I'm well past this. I also told him if he wants to introduce me to any new Muslims he needs to be prepared for the fact I won't pretend that I like Islam because I don't. I'm indifferent to it but if I get interrogated on my deeper thoughts they aren't going to like it. I feel the same about all religions.

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:00

Croque · 14/11/2022 11:45

I am not sure about the posts mentioning missing bacon (OP is vegan anyway) or missing out on going topless on the beach (I don't know many people who do that these days!). I would be concerned about kids having to go to mosque school for several hours every day after they finish primary school as my neighbours' kids do. It seems tiring and means that they miss out on playing with friends/downtime (although those are perceived as being shallow pursuits!).
Certainly, if OP lives in a multicultural area then the schools may serve halal food anyway and there will be muslim children from all over the world ranging from moderate Albanians to the ultra religious wahabis.

Hi, yeah I wouldn't want to go topless in public, not my thing.

Also he knows I drink and actually have zero respect for Islam or any other religion and I reiterated this. There is no obligation for me to respect the religions themselves, just people's right to believe and practise them in their own time.

My fault for not stating I'm vegan earlier but it did tickle me how many people focused on bacon! I've not had bacon in two decades, well unless you count fakon which I like. ( I know it's not real bacon, that's the point)

But no he has said he won't be stipulating anything for us.

I think I just need to wait this out but what it's revealing in myself is intolerance but you know what, that's okay. I'm allowed to be intolerant of things in my life.

OP posts:
chakra1 · 14/11/2022 12:00

"But is there an Islamic nation where it's written in law that women are equal in rights?"

No, not one that I'm aware of? But it's what you're conditioned to believe and accept, basically. That obviously applies to women everywhere.

VestaTilley · 14/11/2022 11:57

Just make sure he doesn’t make you and any daughters you have start covering your heads. You can’t stop him if it’s what he wants - but don’t be browbeaten in to joining in.

Converts can often be very over zealous. If he gets very in to it you may find yourself married to a very different man.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 11:57

But then he's still planning xmas gifts. So I guess it's not going to be that big a deal?

I'm so confused.

I could well be being really out of order on him but I don't want to be with a religious person, I never signed up for it. I find it dumb, sorry but I just do.

I'm all for it for anyone else and all for people practising their religion but when faced with it it annoys me. Maybe that's just my own uncertainty and maybe I'm being horrible which wouldn't be the first time, I'm not perfect but it's irritating me.

Maybe the silly phrases will cease but I just find it all so silly. Okay you believe in God, lovely but why say mashallah all the bloody time. Ugh

OP posts:
MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 11:48

Croque · 14/11/2022 11:26

I can only speak for my Muslim friends in various countries (including ME ones) who are really assertive, independent and confident. That is not to say they all have perfect family relationships but it is not on account of them 'not knowing their place in Islam'.
I have to say that I am less convinced by the arguments some of them put forward for wearing the hijab (@It's my choice' etc) as some conditioning seems to be in place to choose not to feel the wind blowing through your hair. There is nothing about it which screams life affirming.

I think people would be very surprised at the efforts made in some Middle Eastern countries to ensure that women are living their best life and not being held back by the teachings of the Quran. I live the life everyday and have done for more than 40 years. I’m the mother of young women and granddaughters, as well as aunt to tens of nieces living their best lives here at home. It’s not for me to defend or explain the country we live in (or the countries around us who share the same model) I know what’s fact and that’s all there is to it.

Croque · 14/11/2022 11:45

I am not sure about the posts mentioning missing bacon (OP is vegan anyway) or missing out on going topless on the beach (I don't know many people who do that these days!). I would be concerned about kids having to go to mosque school for several hours every day after they finish primary school as my neighbours' kids do. It seems tiring and means that they miss out on playing with friends/downtime (although those are perceived as being shallow pursuits!).
Certainly, if OP lives in a multicultural area then the schools may serve halal food anyway and there will be muslim children from all over the world ranging from moderate Albanians to the ultra religious wahabis.