Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband converted to Islam

592 replies

newbookonshelf · 12/11/2022 08:46

What would you make of this? Not sure what I'm asking. He's trying to find himself I suppose. We're all looking for meaning in this world. I've thought about religion many times, but just not sure what to make of it right now.

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 14/11/2022 15:09

Didn't the OP say he had gone behind her back and did the conversion process

He also seems to have converted quickly, which is another red flag.

potniatheron · 14/11/2022 15:05

Faultymain5 · 14/11/2022 12:35

Faith and religion are two different things.

I don't think that's true. I am religious. I also have faith. My partner is not religious. But he has faith.

I presume you're trying to differentiate organised religion from faith and that's valid I guess in a Lutheran, fide sola, non acta kinda way. But lots and lots of religious people have faith and would regard faith as an integral part of their religion and not separate to it.

Againstmachine · 14/11/2022 14:57

Didn't the OP say he had gone behind her back and did the conversion process, that would be over for me, I don't think he is being honest in this relationship.

arctica · 14/11/2022 14:34

PopsicleHustler · 14/11/2022 10:11

This is excellent news and I hope you too also find it in your heart to change to Islam also.

I reverted several years ago, and it was the best decision of my life. I was a Christian but I had enough of church and every single Sunday is worship Jesus. And I felt very uncomfortable with the idea of worshipping Jesus and putting him higher than God. I stopped attending church and I also was single and looking to get married. I never really was interested in dating. I was more wanting a serious commitment which is just what Muslims do. I actually prayed to Allah and asked him to bring me a good and religious man and literally a week later, I met my husband and everything was perfect he told me he's a serious guy looking for a serious relationship. And we clicked and fell in love I told him I was a chrsitian and he said fine, I am a Muslim. No problem. I am very open minded and have numerous friends who are Muslim. We were married not long after meeting and a few months down the line after that, I accepted islam. I was so happy. I wear hijab full time also. And just feel like the happiest person everyday and now we have lots of children and happy expecting another. He's very polite, kind and warm and everything I could wish for.

A lot of people think badly of Muslims and that is unfortunate because stupid people like isis and the taliban and its a shame because those peoplehave killed.more Muslims than they have killed anyone else. And they actually go against the quran. Because the quran says don't hurt people, don't kill and hurt people,. The quran also says to treat animals equal to humans and don't be horrible to animals
And to treat your Muslim neighbour and your non Muslim neighbour equal, and to give charity and help the poor and the orphans. And to not lie, backbitin, steal, bribe or oppress anyone.

People assume my husband forced me to wear the hijab which I think is so small minded. The bible also says to cover your hair. Just like mother Mary did.

I wish your husband all the best in his journey in this wonderful faith.

Did you miss all the parts where OP says she has absolutely no intention to convert?

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 14/11/2022 13:49

newbookonshelf · 12/11/2022 10:20

Thank you. I think the leaving him stuff is over the top. We communicate very well. I will remain non religious but I'm not an atheist, it seems atheists have the more extreme view. I've ever been an atheist because I know I can't know if there's a "God" or not. Of course I'm not going to leave him but I would if he went all weird and started asking me to do anything.

I know a few Muslims and think they are very lovely people. I've just never felt necessary to label myself as any religion.

There have been around 3000 recognised gods in the last few (tens of) thousand years.

A religious person, believing in their 1 god, doesn’t believe in the other 2999 potential gods.

An atheist just doesn’t believe in 1 more god than the religious person. It’s not really extreme!

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 13:49

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 13:23

OP, as your husband is still only 25, it's quite possible that this could be just a phase.

Also, my DH and I have what, on the face if it, would appear to be a very traditional marriage set-up as I don't work at all and haven't for almost 20 years, di he has always been the financial provider and that's that. Not a popular lifestyle on MN tbh, but there you go. This has nothing whatsoever to do with religion though. Nor does it mean I would support an inheritance system that encourages women becoming financially dependent on husbands / male relatives by default. Just because it works for us, doesn't mean the potential pitfalls for other women are not glaringly obvious.

100% agree, and while we operate this way and it can be a great way to operate a family it's not that we would tell our children this is how you have to operate. It's just what we both like. I am fully against any society being prescriptive over how people live unless it harms others.

OP posts:
Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 13:42

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/11/2022 13:09

I would not treat my children differently due to their sex. That is structural inequality that fosters the idea that women are and should be dependent on men. I absolutely would not expect my DS to look after me unless they chose to and I wanted them to. It is my responsibility to prepare appropriately for my old age.
I also don't need spiritual or moral guidance from my DH. I am perfectly capable of working these things out for myself. It is categorically not men's role to guide women - men are responsible for the majority violent and sex crimes in the world - maybe they should focus on a bit of moral guidance for themselves.

DH is a good man and his religion is very important - and I respect that. However, as you might tell from my postings I am confident in my own view of the world and DH has had to accept that. We have reached a happy compromise after 20+ years of marriage.

I think our difference in approach really gets to the core of the OP's situation. Neither of us are wrong, we just see the world differently. Some of things that give you comfort, make me uncomfortable. If our roles were reversed perhaps, you would be uncomfortable with being the provider when you wanted to focus on supporting the family in a different way. As the OP's DH works through his journey the OP will be faced with questions about what she is comfortable with and what she isn't. I have a couple of dealbreakers that luckily have never arisen but if we had had a daughter and DH had insisted on a sharia split of inheritance, I would have divorced him.

It's not about differentiating because of sex. And neither about structural inequality more like accomodating biological differences..as it's a women who gets pregnant and breastfeeds her child, during this time she actually is dependant on a man.

I didn't say husbands are responsible for your moral/spiritual, I said they're responsible for your children's. Yes a man cannot tell you what to do, I Agree. And neither does Islam tell husband's to tell their wife what to do, because in God's eyes they're equal. They can ofcourse remind eachother of the teachings of Islam however.

Looking after parents is the responsibility of both gendered children. The concept is that a parent looked after you when you were small and vulnerable and they return the favour to you when your old and vulnerable. there is great reward in Islam for looking after your parents.

If you only had a daughter with your hubby obviously all your inheritance goes to her.

socialmedia23 · 14/11/2022 13:42

Xenia · 14/11/2022 13:34

I only mentioned the no payment of interest point because it is such a huge deal for some (I never said all) muslims, to such an extent a vast new area for lawyers in the UK has developed of "Sharia" finance. There is a similar issue with obtaining student loans.
www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/what-is-islamic-finance

Not everyone is strict within their religion and some jews even eat bacon sandwiches and presumably some muslims too just as most catholics in the UK use birth control. Hopefully the husband in this case will just have a short phase of this and then not press on and/or will not become too extreme.

Whether a convert is strict or not depends on the community and also the context. I am not strict at all but i converted in a liberal synagogue. Half the converting class were spouses of Jewish men who were not very strict in the first place. Different from my MIL who converted orthodox, she didn't even go to her own brother's wedding cos it was in a church and she eats a special diet and she sent her children to a primary school where no English or Maths was taught.. my mum was a catholic convert but she converted because my dad wanted a catholic wedding so it was a formality in a sense. She has never read the bible or is familiar with scripture, there are many non catholics who are more knowledgeable than her.

Religion is a spectrum, its not all or nothing. There are plenty of people who call themselves religious but are actually nominally so. I don't know what kind of mosque OP's DH converted in but i find it strange they can convert with no input from the spouse. When i converted, my rabbi interviewed my DH and my DH was encouraged to come to classes with me and he was there during my final interview with the jewish court. A lot of family involvement.

Xenia · 14/11/2022 13:34

I only mentioned the no payment of interest point because it is such a huge deal for some (I never said all) muslims, to such an extent a vast new area for lawyers in the UK has developed of "Sharia" finance. There is a similar issue with obtaining student loans.
www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/what-is-islamic-finance

Not everyone is strict within their religion and some jews even eat bacon sandwiches and presumably some muslims too just as most catholics in the UK use birth control. Hopefully the husband in this case will just have a short phase of this and then not press on and/or will not become too extreme.

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 13:30

Also, if was working, I wouldn't want to keep "my money" separate to his. And I certainly would not be giving our daughters less in inheritance. We have 4 DC (2 boys, 2 girls) and they will all be treated the same in that respect.

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 13:23

OP, as your husband is still only 25, it's quite possible that this could be just a phase.

Also, my DH and I have what, on the face if it, would appear to be a very traditional marriage set-up as I don't work at all and haven't for almost 20 years, di he has always been the financial provider and that's that. Not a popular lifestyle on MN tbh, but there you go. This has nothing whatsoever to do with religion though. Nor does it mean I would support an inheritance system that encourages women becoming financially dependent on husbands / male relatives by default. Just because it works for us, doesn't mean the potential pitfalls for other women are not glaringly obvious.

monsteramunch · 14/11/2022 13:13

I would not treat my children differently due to their sex. That is structural inequality that fosters the idea that women are and should be dependent on men.

You've worded this better and more concisely than me. This is where I stand too and would be a dealbreaker for me if my partner felt differently and said he wanted to split inheritance unequally based on each child's sex. I personally couldn't and wouldn't marry someone who wanted to do that.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/11/2022 13:09

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:56

But if you are the higher earner, and you had both a girl and a boy. She would not only inherit your 1/4, but will also inherit from her husband when he passes away.
Whereas your son will not inherit from his wife.
I didn't understand your comment about the son/boy has his own life to lead...you mean his own family life?

I would not treat my children differently due to their sex. That is structural inequality that fosters the idea that women are and should be dependent on men. I absolutely would not expect my DS to look after me unless they chose to and I wanted them to. It is my responsibility to prepare appropriately for my old age.
I also don't need spiritual or moral guidance from my DH. I am perfectly capable of working these things out for myself. It is categorically not men's role to guide women - men are responsible for the majority violent and sex crimes in the world - maybe they should focus on a bit of moral guidance for themselves.

DH is a good man and his religion is very important - and I respect that. However, as you might tell from my postings I am confident in my own view of the world and DH has had to accept that. We have reached a happy compromise after 20+ years of marriage.

I think our difference in approach really gets to the core of the OP's situation. Neither of us are wrong, we just see the world differently. Some of things that give you comfort, make me uncomfortable. If our roles were reversed perhaps, you would be uncomfortable with being the provider when you wanted to focus on supporting the family in a different way. As the OP's DH works through his journey the OP will be faced with questions about what she is comfortable with and what she isn't. I have a couple of dealbreakers that luckily have never arisen but if we had had a daughter and DH had insisted on a sharia split of inheritance, I would have divorced him.

MrsThimbles · 14/11/2022 12:58

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:26

I don't think that's the norm at all especially from what I read on mumsnet😅

HI, It is in the region where I live. What a woman earns is hers and no one else has any claim on it. In fact it can even added to a marriage contract. But most young women nowadays will put into the family finances and will do it by providing for the children. Can you imagine what it would feel like if you helped build a family home, furnish it and pay some bills and a subsequent wife ends up sitting pretty in it. Of course it does happen but most women who work would use her salary to keep herself, contribute to the children's upbringing and build her own house. And if she couldn’t afford to build the house herself it’s pretty common for sisters to build one together. Twin villas or an apartment for each sister as they’d spend way less on land that way.

monsteramunch · 14/11/2022 12:57

I didn't understand your comment about the son/boy has his own life to lead...you mean his own family life?

I think they meant the burden of providing for a sister if she isn't married as you mentioned that they should do this.

Chuckle94 · 14/11/2022 12:56

Moonatics · 12/11/2022 12:31

I really dont get this attitude.
If one person in a couple no longer wants to be there, then that's it. There doesnt have to be a reason even.
Boundaries are healthy and good.
If my boundary is "no man buns" and my DP grows a man bun I am perfectly happy to tell him to remove it or I will leave.
If you think that's a silly reason, so what? Absolutely no reason is needed.
Trying to shame people into staying in a relationship wont work and more to the point, why would you? It has no impact on you if OP leaves because of his new religion or because his farts stink terribly. Either reason or none is good enough to leave someone.

@Moonatics I know the ‘no man buns’ you mentioned was an example but you would really say “ if you don’t remove it I will leave” that’s not a boundary, that’s controlling behaviour. I can’t imagine being with someone that threatens to leave me because they don’t like my hairstyle. Toxic and controlling.

Op, your partner has made a decision to convert and that’s his choice. Both of you need to have a conversation about what this means for your relationship now.

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:56

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/11/2022 12:46

You see I find that questionable. I am also married to a Muslim, and I am by far the higher earner. The thought that if we had a daughter, she would be expected to inherit less from my hard work is not acceptable to me. I also think it is unacceptable to place the burden of looking after the family on a son, when they have their own life to lead. It is an equal duty of parents to support their children in the way that makes the most of their ability to contribute.

But if you are the higher earner, and you had both a girl and a boy. She would not only inherit your 1/4, but will also inherit from her husband when he passes away.
Whereas your son will not inherit from his wife.
I didn't understand your comment about the son/boy has his own life to lead...you mean his own family life?

monsteramunch · 14/11/2022 12:55

@Blueberry111

Thanks for coming back to me, I do appreciate and want to understand other peoples point of view.

Daughter marries a non Muslim: yes this is why in Islam, Muslim women can/should only marry Muslim men. If she does she's essentially not following Islamic law is she?so she'll get her inheritance but cant expect her partner will provide for her and her children always completely understand the logic of that but I guess from an atheists point of view it seems pretty awful to base your child's inheritance on whether or not they continue to observe your faith, whereas their male sibling is less affected by whether they do or not. It's sexist.

If she doesn't marry: that's why Muslims are encouraged to marry. again, I understand that but if she never meets someone she loves, doesnt want to marry, is gay etc then again she is basically being punished for not following the expectations of the religion. Which so the parents prerogative obviously as it's their money, but again, her male sibling would be less affected by staying single / being gay than she would. It's sexist.

Children without marriage: again not allowed in Islam, children need to be in marriage, hence why no sex in Islam outside of marriage. as above

Daughter marries, divorces, children: that responsibility lies with the ex husband, he has to provide for his children financially. legally he only has to pay child maintenance. There's absolutely no guarantee that an ex husband will continue to provide for his children financially over and above that.

In all this, if a Muslim girl does face all these situation and she was raised properly with an education and can work she can always provide for herself by working. Also if her father, brother anyone is alive they should provide for her too.

Absolutely she can and should provide for herself in order to have independent financial security. But my point is that it's a sexist set up because it relies on the woman to rely on men, otherwise she is disadvantaged in comparison to a male sibling even if they make exactly the same choices (eg not to get married).

I appreciate that everyone has the right to their religious beliefs. But I do think that one is sexist.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/11/2022 12:50

No I am Christian, but I saw the inheritance patterns when DH's parents died and his sisters got half of what the brothers got. I was very uncomfortable with that.

We don't have a daughter but if we had, I would refuse to allow a sharia based split.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:47

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/11/2022 12:46

You see I find that questionable. I am also married to a Muslim, and I am by far the higher earner. The thought that if we had a daughter, she would be expected to inherit less from my hard work is not acceptable to me. I also think it is unacceptable to place the burden of looking after the family on a son, when they have their own life to lead. It is an equal duty of parents to support their children in the way that makes the most of their ability to contribute.

Hi, so are you Muslim also?

So is your husband in agreement with you that your daughter will inherit?

It does seem like you can pick and choose what to follow then, which I suppose is a good thing.

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/11/2022 12:46

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:03

Well no he should not ask you to convert just because he is. And bringing up your child Muslim I feel that's a discussion you need to have with your husband.

As far as I'm aware a man has an Islamic duty to provide for his wife and kids and give them worldly, spiritual and moral education.

There is a lot of good in Islam which I feel you may not have not come across yet. For me I actually feel a sense of security for my family that I'm married to a Muslim. The security that he will not leave us, and always provide for his kids. Whatever he earns he is responsible to provide for the family with it, but whatever you will earn that's for yourself to keep , it's not your responsibility to provide for your family financially. Same goes for inheritance law...a girl inherits 1/4 and a boy inherits 1/2 because he has to provide his family with it but whatever the girl gets she keeps for herself and gets to chose how to use it.

You see I find that questionable. I am also married to a Muslim, and I am by far the higher earner. The thought that if we had a daughter, she would be expected to inherit less from my hard work is not acceptable to me. I also think it is unacceptable to place the burden of looking after the family on a son, when they have their own life to lead. It is an equal duty of parents to support their children in the way that makes the most of their ability to contribute.

Faultymain5 · 14/11/2022 12:35

potniatheron · 14/11/2022 10:05

Wow there's a lot of Islamophobia and general anti-faith sentiment on this thread.

I believe that faith is most generally a good thing. There's a reason why people who have a faith live longer, report better mental health and have better, longer lasting relationships.

I think it's great that your husband has chosen to follow Islam and hope that you enjoy exploring it with him - maybe you will choose to follow Islam too, or some other religion or practice.

Faith and religion are two different things.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:31

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:30

I think you're worrying or overthinking a lot OP. Give it time honestly and then see how things work.
I wouldn't advice pregnancy just yet..wait a few months even 1-2 months and see how things are like, he might not change the slightest and you might be completely fine with it. So dont worry honestly.

You're right. I think this is where I'm at, thank you.

OP posts:
Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:30

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:21

Okay here's the issue I've just come to realise as well

So we have a lot of political discussions and a lot of our talk is about ideas and things, you know? I don't want to say we have intellectual discussions but we are both quite focused on our family so don't really like gossip and stuff. So we discuss things more academically.

So now I'm thinking he's going to kind of take a religions slant on everything and our conversations will change.

I think you're worrying or overthinking a lot OP. Give it time honestly and then see how things work.
I wouldn't advice pregnancy just yet..wait a few months even 1-2 months and see how things are like, he might not change the slightest and you might be completely fine with it. So dont worry honestly.

newbookonshelf · 14/11/2022 12:27

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:26

I don't think that's the norm at all especially from what I read on mumsnet😅

I think she meant in Islam but it's our norm anyway, it's how our family functions, it works best for us because we both enjoy our roles.

OP posts: