Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband converted to Islam

592 replies

newbookonshelf · 12/11/2022 08:46

What would you make of this? Not sure what I'm asking. He's trying to find himself I suppose. We're all looking for meaning in this world. I've thought about religion many times, but just not sure what to make of it right now.

OP posts:
Meraas · 15/11/2022 15:22

That was until I saw it with my own eyes yes.

So despite claiming you have Muslim friends and not being bothered by praying, just the sight of your husband at the prayer mat has given you the ‘the ick’?

newbookonshelf · 15/11/2022 15:18

He was lying on his front kind of thing with his hands out in front of him.

OP posts:
newbookonshelf · 15/11/2022 15:18

Meraas · 15/11/2022 15:11

I think it's rather silly to be praying to a god on the floor.

He went to the mosque once, did the oath, and that was that and now he's saying phrases in his speech and sprawled out on the floor a few times a day.

You seem to have made an about face OP, as previously you said 'The praying doesn't bother me. We both WFH and if he's praying up there I wouldn't even know let alone care.'

Your shift from being 'live and let live' to spouting things like being 'silly' and 'sprawled on floor' is quite dramatic.

I'm wondering how much of what you have said is true now as one thing Muslims definitely don't do is 'sprawl' on a prayer mat. They are either standing, kneeling or sitting. Never sprawling.

That was until I saw it with my own eyes yes.

OP posts:
Meraas · 15/11/2022 15:11

I think it's rather silly to be praying to a god on the floor.

He went to the mosque once, did the oath, and that was that and now he's saying phrases in his speech and sprawled out on the floor a few times a day.

You seem to have made an about face OP, as previously you said 'The praying doesn't bother me. We both WFH and if he's praying up there I wouldn't even know let alone care.'

Your shift from being 'live and let live' to spouting things like being 'silly' and 'sprawled on floor' is quite dramatic.

I'm wondering how much of what you have said is true now as one thing Muslims definitely don't do is 'sprawl' on a prayer mat. They are either standing, kneeling or sitting. Never sprawling.

chakra1 · 15/11/2022 14:54

Good luck OP. It does sound like insecurity on his part, but still, very annoying and difficult for you. Book a yoga retreat with delicious vegan food and 24/7 Buddhist chanting quick - he might come back 'converted' again!

newbookonshelf · 15/11/2022 12:39

chakra1 · 15/11/2022 12:36

Hi OP, I do think it's quite possible that this is just a phase with him. Can I ask - does he have many friends in real life? Maybe it's just that some men have made a particular effort with him at the mosque and he felt an 'acceptance' he doesn't get from male friends elsewhere? I mean, how long was it between him visiting the mosque to announcing he is now a Muslim? It sounds like he just enjoys going there, like a hobby, but he hasn't thought at all about the implications for his family and wider life. As I said yesterday, the men at his mosque will assume you are now a Muslim household, by default. It would be his duty to god, as a Muslim husband and father, to instil certain values in his household. Maybe he already gives money to charity, but there is an obligation for him to give a certain percentage of savings now too. On what level do you think he is comprehending his conversion? I don't think many people would seriously convert without putting the impact on the family first and foremost, as the family is so fundamental in Islam.

Thanks. No he doesn't speak with his friends and yes, this is totally about what you say.

He went to the mosque once, did the oath, and that was that and now he's saying phrases in his speech and sprawled out on the floor a few times a day.

The damage is done. He's just weak and changeable. I can't know him or what he will do next.

OP posts:
chakra1 · 15/11/2022 12:36

Hi OP, I do think it's quite possible that this is just a phase with him. Can I ask - does he have many friends in real life? Maybe it's just that some men have made a particular effort with him at the mosque and he felt an 'acceptance' he doesn't get from male friends elsewhere? I mean, how long was it between him visiting the mosque to announcing he is now a Muslim? It sounds like he just enjoys going there, like a hobby, but he hasn't thought at all about the implications for his family and wider life. As I said yesterday, the men at his mosque will assume you are now a Muslim household, by default. It would be his duty to god, as a Muslim husband and father, to instil certain values in his household. Maybe he already gives money to charity, but there is an obligation for him to give a certain percentage of savings now too. On what level do you think he is comprehending his conversion? I don't think many people would seriously convert without putting the impact on the family first and foremost, as the family is so fundamental in Islam.

newbookonshelf · 15/11/2022 11:51

magma32 · 15/11/2022 11:34

I would think he would be more accepting of Catholicism and Judaism as he technically can be married to ‘people of the book’ without them needing to convert to his religion.

If he’s happy married to OP being an atheist and is okay with her lifestyle and her beliefs don’t bother him (so he says right now) I don’t know how OP converting to one of those religions and becoming more godly is worse especially when his religion says it’s ok to be married to women who are of that religion 🤷‍♀️ but then he could whinge and complain that OP has changed too much and he preferred OP when she hadn’t converted to said religion and then maybe he’ll realise what he’s put OP through.
Maybe OP should just pretend to be of a more conflicting religion or lifestyle (although I don’t think you can get more at odds with religion than atheism, maybe satanist?) and see his reaction -he might change his tune once he realises OP can do the same 😂

OP I could tell the more I read from your posts that you were getting the ick and that’s natural, especially if you are becoming more or are atheist - he’s changed from someone you had a lot in common with which is why you married him into someone you don’t really know at all.
And for me, if I couldn’t respect my partner I really couldn’t be with them.
So I think you can either be honest with him and say exactly what you’ve said here or you can hope for the best but you clearly don’t have much respect for him so I’m not sure how you can get over that and if you’d even want to?

I personally think at 25 he doesn’t really know what he’s doing anyway but by the time he realises it will probably be too late for your relationship.

Thank you, yes you get it.

I have totally told him all this. I don't keep my feelings in, I see no point.

He seemed hurt but honestly so am I.

I don't know what to do. I am hoping the ick subsides and that's all I can hope for. If we split up it means time away from my daughter. I'm trying to keep it together but what I'm going to do is create a life outside my family. I had dedicated myself to being a wife and mother and I feel like he's breached out little contract.

Ultimately it doesn't matter why I feel how I do. I feel it and nothing can be done about that.

OP posts:
magma32 · 15/11/2022 11:34

monsteramunch · 15/11/2022 10:28

I would try to explain your discomfort to him based on your these circumstances.

Now that he identifies as Muslim, would he be happy if you said you've converted to Judaism or Catholicism? Would he really not be uncomfortable with it?

Because you identify as atheist so him converting to Islam is the same as you doing those things.

A conflicting framework to live by that is at odds with everything you believe.

If he would now feel uncomfortable if you came home tomorrow and said you're now a Catholic, he's being a hypocrite to expect you to feel otherwise.

I would think he would be more accepting of Catholicism and Judaism as he technically can be married to ‘people of the book’ without them needing to convert to his religion.

If he’s happy married to OP being an atheist and is okay with her lifestyle and her beliefs don’t bother him (so he says right now) I don’t know how OP converting to one of those religions and becoming more godly is worse especially when his religion says it’s ok to be married to women who are of that religion 🤷‍♀️ but then he could whinge and complain that OP has changed too much and he preferred OP when she hadn’t converted to said religion and then maybe he’ll realise what he’s put OP through.
Maybe OP should just pretend to be of a more conflicting religion or lifestyle (although I don’t think you can get more at odds with religion than atheism, maybe satanist?) and see his reaction -he might change his tune once he realises OP can do the same 😂

OP I could tell the more I read from your posts that you were getting the ick and that’s natural, especially if you are becoming more or are atheist - he’s changed from someone you had a lot in common with which is why you married him into someone you don’t really know at all.
And for me, if I couldn’t respect my partner I really couldn’t be with them.
So I think you can either be honest with him and say exactly what you’ve said here or you can hope for the best but you clearly don’t have much respect for him so I’m not sure how you can get over that and if you’d even want to?

I personally think at 25 he doesn’t really know what he’s doing anyway but by the time he realises it will probably be too late for your relationship.

newbookonshelf · 15/11/2022 10:32

monsteramunch · 15/11/2022 10:28

I would try to explain your discomfort to him based on your these circumstances.

Now that he identifies as Muslim, would he be happy if you said you've converted to Judaism or Catholicism? Would he really not be uncomfortable with it?

Because you identify as atheist so him converting to Islam is the same as you doing those things.

A conflicting framework to live by that is at odds with everything you believe.

If he would now feel uncomfortable if you came home tomorrow and said you're now a Catholic, he's being a hypocrite to expect you to feel otherwise.

Yes but as with all such situations it's easy for him to just say 'yes, I would' and that's exactly what he did of course.

We'll see where it goes. To be totally honest it's making me feel more and more atheist because I just find this whole religion thing icky. Apologies to anyone who is religious but I only say this because I'm trying to be honest and it's the subject of the thread.

I support anyone to be free to practise and believe their religion but if you were to ask me if I respect the religion itself no I don't, I think it's rather silly to be praying to a god on the floor.

Don't get me wrong. I speak to "god" whatever it may be, it's my own thing, and never would that come out to others.

Submission to a god? Surrendering of your own mind? Not attractive.

OP posts:
monsteramunch · 15/11/2022 10:28

I would try to explain your discomfort to him based on your these circumstances.

Now that he identifies as Muslim, would he be happy if you said you've converted to Judaism or Catholicism? Would he really not be uncomfortable with it?

Because you identify as atheist so him converting to Islam is the same as you doing those things.

A conflicting framework to live by that is at odds with everything you believe.

If he would now feel uncomfortable if you came home tomorrow and said you're now a Catholic, he's being a hypocrite to expect you to feel otherwise.

newbookonshelf · 15/11/2022 10:22

We've had a few chats now and I've response honestly because I'm not really capable of anything else and see no point. In a marriage it's about openness.

So, I've conveyed to him I'm just not a fan and we'll have to see where this goes. He said he expected a negative reaction from some of his family but not me. Why?

Why would I have an indifferent reaction? That's silly. And as for positive, again why would be positive? There's no reason for me to champion following a religion when I have never wanted to do so nor be with someone who does.

I'm actually not that happy but as I said to him we'll see where it goes now.

OP posts:
Meraas · 15/11/2022 07:35

steakart · 14/11/2022 07:13

Sorry OP but as you can see I am quoting from the original texts that all Muslims rely on not from a random book written by someone.

Your nonsensical random quoting is laughable. You sound eaten up by hatred.

MrsThimbles · 15/11/2022 06:09

Blueberry111 · 14/11/2022 12:56

But if you are the higher earner, and you had both a girl and a boy. She would not only inherit your 1/4, but will also inherit from her husband when he passes away.
Whereas your son will not inherit from his wife.
I didn't understand your comment about the son/boy has his own life to lead...you mean his own family life?

I was thinking about this and it’s worth mentioning that nowadays it’s quite common for a parent to give money or property to their daughters whilst still alive. Yes, other family members have to agree to this but I’ve not come across any family who have said - no, it’s not happening. Instead, people usually go along with it because it’s what the parent wants. There is also the fact that a person can bequeath month to a person as long as it’s no more than (I think) 30 percent of what they have. Again, this is commonly done nowadays to even up what is given to a persons children.

hford19 · 15/11/2022 02:11

steakart · 14/11/2022 07:13

Sorry OP but as you can see I am quoting from the original texts that all Muslims rely on not from a random book written by someone.

All Muslims? I think you may be one of those internet scholars. This is hadith and a large proportion of Muslims do not rely or even believe the hadith.

Moonatics · 14/11/2022 18:14

Chuckle94 · 14/11/2022 12:56

@Moonatics I know the ‘no man buns’ you mentioned was an example but you would really say “ if you don’t remove it I will leave” that’s not a boundary, that’s controlling behaviour. I can’t imagine being with someone that threatens to leave me because they don’t like my hairstyle. Toxic and controlling.

Op, your partner has made a decision to convert and that’s his choice. Both of you need to have a conversation about what this means for your relationship now.

Yeah the man bun was a terrible example, I blame menopause for lack of brain power. I don't even care about man buns.

Still the theme stands. You can leave anyone at any time for any or no reason.

Faultymain5 · 14/11/2022 17:27

OneTC · 14/11/2022 16:55

Being part of a theist religion pretty much depends on faith. You're giving yourself over to something unknowable, which is an act of faith.

You can have faith without religion though, agreed.

But they're not entirely separate concepts

They are like tuna and mayonnaise two separate and distinct things but together they work for some people, just not everyone.

Faultymain5 · 14/11/2022 17:23

potniatheron · 14/11/2022 16:25

I did not say that. My partner has faith but is not religious. Exactly as you describe.

I was responding to a previous poster who said faith and religion are two entirely different things. I responded to say that that is not true. Faith is integral to true religion. However you can also have faith outside of an organised religion. Therefore faith and religion are not two entirely different things.

Sorry you responded to my post, so I thought you were responding to me.

OneTC · 14/11/2022 16:55

Being part of a theist religion pretty much depends on faith. You're giving yourself over to something unknowable, which is an act of faith.

You can have faith without religion though, agreed.

But they're not entirely separate concepts

potniatheron · 14/11/2022 16:25

Faultymain5 · 14/11/2022 16:21

But lots of people have faith neither follow nor believe in religion, organised or otherwise. For those people that statement is very true.

Essentially you can have faith without religion. Can’t see how you can argue otherwise just because that’s not how it works, for you.

I did not say that. My partner has faith but is not religious. Exactly as you describe.

I was responding to a previous poster who said faith and religion are two entirely different things. I responded to say that that is not true. Faith is integral to true religion. However you can also have faith outside of an organised religion. Therefore faith and religion are not two entirely different things.

Faultymain5 · 14/11/2022 16:21

potniatheron · 14/11/2022 15:05

I don't think that's true. I am religious. I also have faith. My partner is not religious. But he has faith.

I presume you're trying to differentiate organised religion from faith and that's valid I guess in a Lutheran, fide sola, non acta kinda way. But lots and lots of religious people have faith and would regard faith as an integral part of their religion and not separate to it.

But lots of people have faith neither follow nor believe in religion, organised or otherwise. For those people that statement is very true.

Essentially you can have faith without religion. Can’t see how you can argue otherwise just because that’s not how it works, for you.

Croque · 14/11/2022 15:56

I suppose that somebody will come along and say that is exactly what he is doing but I would say that Islam has become a hot topic in the last twenty years, demonized and propagandized and topical on social media in every form. It hasn't been quietly doing it's thing in the corner like some of the other Faiths,

Croque · 14/11/2022 15:51

Young people are very easy to indoctrinate whether via religion, peer pressure or social media. But those beliefs are different to working it out for yourself which involves breaking away from familial and cultural norms and forging your individual path with a level head without all the passion and procession.

potniatheron · 14/11/2022 15:36

Croque · 14/11/2022 15:25

This will sound patronising but I don't think twenty five year old guys know their own mind at such a young age in terms of beliefs even if they are convinced that they do! Religiously/spiritually, I am in a completely different place to when I was twenty five as is my OH. I don't think the OP has anything to worry about at all now.

Hmmmm I dunno you do get some incredibly religiously committed people in their 20s.

In fact ime, younger people can be more fiery in their beliefs, whether that's religious, political, environmental, etc. When they get older they tend to be more nuanced and less raw passion.

Croque · 14/11/2022 15:25

This will sound patronising but I don't think twenty five year old guys know their own mind at such a young age in terms of beliefs even if they are convinced that they do! Religiously/spiritually, I am in a completely different place to when I was twenty five as is my OH. I don't think the OP has anything to worry about at all now.