Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband converted to Islam

592 replies

newbookonshelf · 12/11/2022 08:46

What would you make of this? Not sure what I'm asking. He's trying to find himself I suppose. We're all looking for meaning in this world. I've thought about religion many times, but just not sure what to make of it right now.

OP posts:
Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 18:04

@Squeezita

But ok for you to put all Muslims under one umbrella?

This post you put yourself under the umbrella I didnt and you put yourself under this umbrella and all religion is trash so yes it can be put under same umbrella and chucked in a bin, as no reasonable person in the 21st century should have religion.

Squeezita · 12/11/2022 18:01

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 17:55

And you accused me of calling you a ‘silly atheist’ when I didn’t, isn’t that you playing the victim?

The comment was about playing victim when a comment was about the whole religious divide when you assumed Islam is the thing. I was talking about.

There is no athiest group for you to offend you still aren't getting it.

You’re not making any sense.

And saying religious people are a group but atheist people are not a group makes even less sense.

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 17:55

And you accused me of calling you a ‘silly atheist’ when I didn’t, isn’t that you playing the victim?

The comment was about playing victim when a comment was about the whole religious divide when you assumed Islam is the thing. I was talking about.

There is no athiest group for you to offend you still aren't getting it.

Croque · 12/11/2022 17:55

For me, if he has converted after a month, it is unlikely to be a serious, long term conversion. I bet he will be something else by this time next year. If it does last, then the success of your relationship will largely depend upon whether you are militantly anti religion/oppositional as some posters on this thread are or whether you are genuinely tolerant of one another's beliefs without any conflict (harder than it sounds).

From what you have written, you seem to possess some strong views about the fact that you were on the same page about a few , big issues such as eating meat and you would tolerate , say, praying but if he ate meat (which he may have to do occasionally as I understand it) then that would absolutely be the end for you.

Squeezita · 12/11/2022 17:53

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 17:49

*But ok for you to put all Muslims under one umbrella?

Why are you falsely accusing me of saying ‘silly atheist’? Are you feeling ok?

And I’m not so easily offended, thanks, I believe that would be you and your fellow angry atheists on that grassy knoll.*

Except if you read my posts I didn't put Islam under the umbrella I said they were all equally shitty.

But hey let's play at being a victim.

So you’ve grouped all religious people as ‘shitty’ but are telling me ‘Nope you can't put atheists under same umbrella as there is no standard group for atheists.’

Do you see the hypocrisy?

And you accused me of calling you a ‘silly atheist’ when I didn’t, isn’t that you playing the victim?

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 17:50

*But ok for you to put all Muslims under one umbrella?

Why are you falsely accusing me of saying ‘silly atheist’? Are you feeling ok?

And I’m not so easily offended, thanks, I believe that would be you and your fellow angry atheists on that grassy knoll.*

Read post you are replying to no where does it mention Islam, it mentions religion are you only religion then?

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 17:49

*But ok for you to put all Muslims under one umbrella?

Why are you falsely accusing me of saying ‘silly atheist’? Are you feeling ok?

And I’m not so easily offended, thanks, I believe that would be you and your fellow angry atheists on that grassy knoll.*

Except if you read my posts I didn't put Islam under the umbrella I said they were all equally shitty.

But hey let's play at being a victim.

OneTC · 12/11/2022 17:48

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 14:59

*Nothing, it's just some people of the people espousing a more extreme course of action of splitting up straight away were atheists. That's clearly what the comment meant.

I do encounter an awful lot of very evangelical atheists though and find them as galling as religious atheists*

Atheists were shut down for years by religious organisations don't be offended now they are voicing their concerns.

It's interesting that many think there are groups of atheists there aren't.

I'm an atheist.

I haven't grouped atheists together, I've said that there are people, individuals, who are evangelical about it

newbookonshelf · 12/11/2022 17:40

Lampedsomeoiks · 12/11/2022 13:13

Is he going to impose and try to enforce his beliefs on you and the rest of your family?

That would be an absolute deal breaker for me.

Me too!

OP posts:
Squeezita · 12/11/2022 17:39

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 14:57

I agree with this, OP. Religious people tend to be live and let live whilst atheists are belligerently offensive to anyone who believes in a religion.

Nope you can't put atheists under same umbrella as there is no standard group for atheists. Religious people live and let live are you absolutely joking they like to interfere in lots of things.

Religious people are only getting offended by atheists now as they are more free to say what they think instead of being persecuted by said religions.

And if your god is so great why be offended what you consider a 'silly atheist' thinks.

But ok for you to put all Muslims under one umbrella?

Why are you falsely accusing me of saying ‘silly atheist’? Are you feeling ok?

And I’m not so easily offended, thanks, I believe that would be you and your fellow angry atheists on that grassy knoll.

newbookonshelf · 12/11/2022 17:37

speakout · 12/11/2022 13:01

OP did you have an islamic wedding?
Does your OH's new religion recognise his marriage?

I can't see how this matters initially since our wedding was a legal contract, secular, and it's recognised in law so if Islam didn't recognise it, so what? He can't not be married unless we divorce.

OP posts:
YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet · 12/11/2022 17:35

Hi all - we'd like to remind everyone that our Talk guidelines ask for no deliberately inflammatory posts, personal attacks or hate speech. We have no problem with considered criticism of any religious faiths but we would ask that posters don't negatively generalise about members of that faith. If such posts continue, we will take this thread down.

Thanks.

ImaniMumsnet · 12/11/2022 15:01

Hi everyone, we are receiving a lot of reports about posts on this thread so we are closing it while we take a look.

Pineappleblueberry · 12/11/2022 14:59

FYI boys don't HAVE to be circumcised actually, it's not a farz( necessity) it's a sunnah ( desirable).
I know Muslim parents who have not circumcised their boys as they prefer to leave it up to them to do when older

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 14:59

*Nothing, it's just some people of the people espousing a more extreme course of action of splitting up straight away were atheists. That's clearly what the comment meant.

I do encounter an awful lot of very evangelical atheists though and find them as galling as religious atheists*

Atheists were shut down for years by religious organisations don't be offended now they are voicing their concerns.

It's interesting that many think there are groups of atheists there aren't.

JuvenileEmu · 12/11/2022 14:59

Blueberry111 · 12/11/2022 14:48

You know this now because religion brought this teaching many centuries ago. And now it's established as 'good' without the religion tag. Also again how do you know if you did something non-intentional or didn't realise you hurt someone, would that be considered "bad" from you? You might not because you didn't intend to but they might be really hurt and want you to be answerable for it. This is why religion helps as everyone is on the same page of good and bad, and Islam goes deeper into what to do in such and such situation which make sense and are fair to me.

I do not believe that there was no morality or care for others before religion, no. And I do not believe that if religion disappeared people would stop treating each other well. And if you're going to credit religion with codifying morality, then I think you should also accept the history of religion causing wars and persecution of "non-believers", not to mention the persecution of one sect of a religion by another sect of the same religion. And accept that part of the codifying of morality in religious texts includes a hell of a lot of misogyny and homophobia.

oviraptor21 · 12/11/2022 14:58

Toddlerteaplease · 12/11/2022 14:04

Would people be considering dumping him etc if he had become a Christian?

Although I wouldn't use the word dump, I did, in the end, end a relationship with a man I loved very much because I couldn't come to terms with his Christianity. It was not 'in your face' at all but it did mean he attended church on Sundays, and other church events. His friends were other Christians. I just couldn't be easy with spending the rest of my life with someone with whom there was such a big disconnect.

Crankley · 12/11/2022 14:57

"There's a negative connotation because of the media but if he follows Islam properly, he will be an even better husband, father, son, brother, colleague and so on."

I can only assume the above was a joke.

Initially I would assume he had lost his mind. and would be extremely unhappy. If it was just the pair of you, providing he made no attempt to convert or change anything, I would give him a chance. However, you have a daughter and unless she is of an age to be firm in her own mind re her beliefs, I would not trust him not to attempt to convert her which is why I would leave.

Againstmachine · 12/11/2022 14:57

I agree with this, OP. Religious people tend to be live and let live whilst atheists are belligerently offensive to anyone who believes in a religion.

Nope you can't put atheists under same umbrella as there is no standard group for atheists. Religious people live and let live are you absolutely joking they like to interfere in lots of things.

Religious people are only getting offended by atheists now as they are more free to say what they think instead of being persecuted by said religions.

And if your god is so great why be offended what you consider a 'silly atheist' thinks.

OneTC · 12/11/2022 14:56

scaredoff · 12/11/2022 14:31

So what IS extreme about not believing in a god, then?

Nothing, it's just some people of the people espousing a more extreme course of action of splitting up straight away were atheists. That's clearly what the comment meant.

I do encounter an awful lot of very evangelical atheists though and find them as galling as religious atheists

speakout · 12/11/2022 14:51

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/11/2022 14:43

You do realise a lot of "goodness" and morality originated from religion??

Not sure about that one, Blueberry, since it's just as realistic to believe that good and bad have always existed and that religion simply "co-opted" the former to buttress its position

Obviously creating an association of the already good/well intentioned/whatever was a positive thing, but as we've seen, too often the basic principles get lost in manmade dogma, self service and sometimes downright evil

Trouble is, by the time this becomes widely noticed, the leaders who've taken the opportunity to dig themselves into positions of influence can be harder to challenge

Agreed.

The bible -or any other "holy books" are at best observational documents.
It isn't hard to watch a peaceful community and figure out what makes it so.
"Goodness" existed long before any bible was written.
Homo sapiens are tribal creatures, altruism benefits the tribe to enable peaceful and prosperous living.
Altruism isn't even confined to humans-other apes have it, wolves, birds, fish, even ants and bees use altruistic mechanisms to ensure the survival of the group and individual.

The idea that religion invented morality is laughable-and very arrogant.

scaredoff · 12/11/2022 14:50

Blueberry111 · 12/11/2022 14:32

You do realise a lot of "goodness" and morality originated from religion?? Yes in this day and age when "goodness" and morality has been established and now atheists practice it too, it's easy to say "just be a decent person" and no need to follow religion. But if you look back in history, goodness/morality/decency came from religion/holy books and scriptures whether you acknowledge it or not. My issue with atheism and concept of being "good" is, that if you're in testing times how could you guarantee you'd do the 'good' thing, how do you even know what you do is considered 'good'. If a town is starving and there is no food, and when you get something to eat, would you share it with your starving neighbour first?or fill your own and your children's belly first? I think a lot of atheists would fill their own belly first, whereas Islam/and other religions say and have examples where the neighbour was fed first. Reading religious and historical books reminds us of those good examples that we can try to incorporate in our lives. In religion it's pretty black and white what is considered 'good'..and in testing times you'd still do good because you know you'll be answerable to God.

The problem with this argument is that there is an awful lot in most religions (certainly the Abrahamic ones) that we would consider far from "good". Some that is absolutely revoting and heinous.

Whether to share scarce food with a starving neighbour for example would depend on a lot of things. Is that neighbour gay? If so then obviously they are an offence to the Lord, you're only really waiting for your God to deliver a just early death to them and send them to the Hellfire they deserve, so why would you waste food on them? Or are they minority jews within a muslim community? In which case they are second class citizens and should be paying for your food with their dhimmi tax anyway.

If you want to make the point that most modern-day western religious people don't believe or follow these aspects of their religion, but rather just cherry-pick the parts that conform to liberal western ideals of "goodness", then that's true (to an extent). But that then negates your original point. If it's possibly to cherry pick the "good" parts out of a religious teaching while rejecting the bad parts, then your sense of goodness must not originate in the religion. It must come from somewhere else, because otherwise how would you know which parts of the religion to follow and which to reject?

I's agree that some things like the parables of Jesus' life are valuable illustrations of moral principles, but no more so than plenty of other works of fiction. But if you're going to claim a religious teaching is the ORIGIN of morality, then when it comes into conflict with contemporary mores you'd have to reject the latter, not the former.

Blueberry111 · 12/11/2022 14:48

You know this now because religion brought this teaching many centuries ago. And now it's established as 'good' without the religion tag. Also again how do you know if you did something non-intentional or didn't realise you hurt someone, would that be considered "bad" from you? You might not because you didn't intend to but they might be really hurt and want you to be answerable for it. This is why religion helps as everyone is on the same page of good and bad, and Islam goes deeper into what to do in such and such situation which make sense and are fair to me.

Bedtimeforever · 12/11/2022 14:45

@steakart Love your choice of words. Imagine anybody spoke about the Jewish faith the way you speak about Islam, hell would break loose!

Secondly, as a Muslim woman, reading the comments and knowing what sort of prejudices and strong opinions that people have of us exist, it is most probably the reason we find it so much harder than others to make a successful career for ourselves, getting jobs, promotions etc. Not related directly to the thread, but just seeing the comments and how people think of us make me realise it more. We’ve been in this country for 3 generations now, please treat and talk about us individuals with a choice. Not Islamics and oppressed females and radicalised and wives of misogynistic men and all that malarky.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/11/2022 14:43

You do realise a lot of "goodness" and morality originated from religion??

Not sure about that one, Blueberry, since it's just as realistic to believe that good and bad have always existed and that religion simply "co-opted" the former to buttress its position

Obviously creating an association of the already good/well intentioned/whatever was a positive thing, but as we've seen, too often the basic principles get lost in manmade dogma, self service and sometimes downright evil

Trouble is, by the time this becomes widely noticed, the leaders who've taken the opportunity to dig themselves into positions of influence can be harder to challenge