Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…to not get these 24 hr in A& E ‘fly-on-the-wall’ documentaries?

54 replies

NellesVilla · 11/11/2022 22:28

Good evening, all,

So I’m watching that 24 hours in A & E show and although I’m reasonably bright, I’m just wondering how they go about filming the separate stories?

Do they just shove a camera in the face of someone who’s just broken their back and neck in a road accident or would they speak to the family first if the victim is unconscious?

It’s not like they can go “Oh mate, I know you’ve crushed your pelvis and are in excruciating pain, but before we sedate you, could you sign this waiver for filming, please?” Or say to the family: “Yes, dad’s dying but could we do a few close ups, please?”..

I’m honestly interested and fascinated about this and ethically, how people feel about genuine victims/patients being filmed in the aftermath of a horrific crash?

Also- and yes I’ve had a drink as a non-drinking person so could be overthinking this- but do we really believe that they’re like that on the arrival of a new patient? When they stand to attention and listen reverently to the head surgeon give their orders on what to do with the patient? Is this staged? Bigged up for telly? Or is A & E really like this- a theatre in a theatre?

Also the 24 hours in police custody thing: are they allowed to film the suspect? If I were a possible murderer I know you’ve probably waived some rights such as privacy, but personally I’d hardly want to be filmed and perhaps wouldn’t answer the questions properly under that pressure.

OP posts:
NellesVilla · 11/11/2022 22:47

Thanks, particularly @ElizabethBest- all really interesting.

OP posts:
Chouetted · 11/11/2022 22:44

I've seen signs up in hospitals and other locations with some version of say "Filming is taking place in this location for X, if you have concerns speak to Y".

I've never actually had concerns (I'm not that interesting...), so I don't know what happens if you do!

ElizabethBest · 11/11/2022 22:37

I can’t speak for the police, but in A&E, yes we all listen and only one person talks. Usually first the paramedic delivers the case, and then whoever is running the trauma will lead the exam and give out tasks. This could be the consultant, ENP, or a reg. We all stand still and we all listen because if we don’t pay attention and we don’t all work together then the patient could easily die because we missed something. In a lot of serious cases, you have what is called the golden hour, which is the tiny window you have to reverse or stem life threatening illness or injury. We can’t waste that by not paying attention or talking over each other.

In terms of the filming, I imagine they have fixed cameras dotted around and film basically everything and then cut down what they need subject to consent and storyline.

PickleRickBauble · 11/11/2022 22:29

I can’t answer the rest, but of course they bloody listen closely to their superior telling them how to treat a patient.

Swipe left for the next trending thread