Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a proposal one...

56 replies

Hopefullynaive · 11/11/2022 21:48

I'm feeling sorry for myself and need a bit more of a beating for being so naive so hello aibu!

Before I start, I'm not desperate to get engaged, we have 2 beautiful kids and I've been married and divorced so it's not so important that I'll be popping the question myself. I can happily live with the relationship whatever happens.

That being said, from the moment I met my partner I knew he was the one to make me reconsider my "never getting married again" post divorce mantra. And apparently he felt the same telling me he was going to marry me one day. Anyway skip a couple of babies and a pandemic and we've had more in depth conversations about marriage and agreed that it's something we'd both like (no, this does not make us engaged already). He spoke to my dad and asked permission, even went so far as to hint that he would be buying the ring this month (sale discounts = the way to my heart). Today however he's decided that actually he won't be buying it now, he'd rather pay more but have time to save more to get something better which i find a bit confusing but there we go. I've told him before I'd be happy with a £100 or less ring as its the symbol but he's not apparently.

So tell me the truth, he's not actually going to do it is he? This is a "shits got real" backing out a bit situation isn't it 😳

OP posts:
WordtoYoMumma · 12/11/2022 07:30

I'm another one who doesn't really understand proposals and why the man gets to decide when being engaged becomes an Actual Thing - but I am very much in my minority among my friends so I know this isn't a widespread opinion!

If it were me (in fact this is what happened when it was!) I'd just suggest going shopping for a ring together! Then you get what you want and you can show him that you don't need something big and flash and a big surprise proposal etc. (I bought my own ring, my friends were horrified 😂)

If he keeps making excuses then you have to consider maybe he doesn't want to marry you are all. But stop with the passive waiting to be allowed to be engaged to him and make it happen (or not)

WhyOY · 12/11/2022 07:30

Hopefullynaive · 12/11/2022 04:25

No I'm saying they already saw it but I couldn't see it at the time. But they're not the type to get involved unless asked.

Then they wouldn't have told you he was an arse unless you asked.

WhatTheHellIsAQuasar · 12/11/2022 07:27

My DH and I went ring shopping together, I chose the one I wanted and he paid for it then put it away so he could do his proposal. Why not suggest that - it does sound to me like he’s changed his mind

Ekátn · 12/11/2022 07:26

Hopefullynaive · 11/11/2022 23:28

Like I said I was having a pity party for one, usually if I had an issue I would absolutely speak to him but I knew deep down I was just being irrationally insecure today. Sometimes you just need a head wobble from mumsnet!

But one thing I need to clarify for the pp who said I was desperate for my dad's permission, not once did I say that. I do value his opinion but it was more of a joke than anything else. Desperation is so far away from disappointment that my ex hadn't done it. Maybe if he had I would have found out that they disliked they way he put me down and disrespected me and I'd have seen it for myself before wasting money and time on a dead end marriage.

Or maybe, like many people do you would have just carried in and got married anyway and it could have caused further problems. If he had said no about your dp would you refuse to get engaged?

Often, when your adult kids are in bad relationships, speaking up pushes the couple closer together. The ‘it’s us against the world’ mentality makes people more determined. So maybe they wouldn’t have.

I am sure if they thought speaking up would stop you doing it, they would have anyway.

WhyOY · 12/11/2022 07:22

Maybe if he had I would have found out that they disliked they way he put me down and disrespected me and I'd have seen it for myself before wasting money and time on a dead end marriage. you could have asked them what they thought?

Ekátn · 12/11/2022 07:19

This is all so strangers you were disappointed your ex didn’t ask your dad? But was only joking this time?

Did your dp ask your dad for permission to get you pregnant? That’s a massive commitment. So why not ask then? If you didn’t need his permission then, why now?

and what happens if your dad said ‘no actually. I don’t give my permission or blessing.’ Would that change the outcome?

You have already tied yourself to this man, through your kids, forever. You will even be connected when then are adults. Just talk to him.

Fuckedoffteacher · 12/11/2022 07:12

marcopront · 12/11/2022 07:08

we've had more in depth conversations about marriage and agreed that it's something we'd both like (no, this does not make us engaged already)

What does being engaged mean to you?

a date and starting planning?

i no longer consider people engaged who just wear a ring for years with no intention of getting married.

marcopront · 12/11/2022 07:08

we've had more in depth conversations about marriage and agreed that it's something we'd both like (no, this does not make us engaged already)

What does being engaged mean to you?

Rainbowqueeen · 12/11/2022 06:16

@Whataretheodds has nailed all the important things.

Having said that, I give him until January and if nothing then yes I’d assume it’s not going to happen and organise my life accordingly.

JamMakingWannaBe · 12/11/2022 06:15

Whataretheodds · 12/11/2022 04:48

Do you own your house in joint names? Are you working full time? Did he contribute to keeping up your pensions contributions when you were on mat leave /if you phased back in PT ?

These are all bigger concerns than a 'proper' engagement ring.

∆ THIS - with massive bells on! I hope you both have Life Assurance and Wills too.

Fuckedoffteacher · 12/11/2022 06:11

Whataretheodds · 12/11/2022 04:48

Do you own your house in joint names? Are you working full time? Did he contribute to keeping up your pensions contributions when you were on mat leave /if you phased back in PT ?

These are all bigger concerns than a 'proper' engagement ring.

Yes all of this

Fuckedoffteacher · 12/11/2022 06:10

You've discussed it. You know he asked your dad. He told you his plan to buy a ring. He told you his new vague plan to buy a ring…

this is all really odd. Why would he even tell you all this? Is he a bit of a fantasist generally? Likes the idea, not the action?

CJsGoldfish · 12/11/2022 05:55

He spoke to my dad and asked permission
WTF? Before or after you had kids together?

The whole 'proposal' thing is just bizarre. So much sitting around, wringing hands, waiting for a man to say he might marry you sometime in the future. After tying themselves together forever already by deciding to have children. 🙄

Whataretheodds · 12/11/2022 04:48

Do you own your house in joint names? Are you working full time? Did he contribute to keeping up your pensions contributions when you were on mat leave /if you phased back in PT ?

These are all bigger concerns than a 'proper' engagement ring.

Hopefullynaive · 12/11/2022 04:25

TuisealGinideach · 12/11/2022 00:10

Hang on, are you actually saying that you’re expecting your father to have magically divined your ex-DH was going to morph into a shit if said shit had asked his permission to marry you, even though you yourself, the person having the relationship with him, didn’t?

No I'm saying they already saw it but I couldn't see it at the time. But they're not the type to get involved unless asked.

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 12/11/2022 00:13

Who gives a shit about a ring at this point? You already have two kids, FFS. Just go to the registry office and get married. It seems to me your boyfriend is using every trick in the book to stall this.

TuisealGinideach · 12/11/2022 00:10

Hopefullynaive · 11/11/2022 23:28

Like I said I was having a pity party for one, usually if I had an issue I would absolutely speak to him but I knew deep down I was just being irrationally insecure today. Sometimes you just need a head wobble from mumsnet!

But one thing I need to clarify for the pp who said I was desperate for my dad's permission, not once did I say that. I do value his opinion but it was more of a joke than anything else. Desperation is so far away from disappointment that my ex hadn't done it. Maybe if he had I would have found out that they disliked they way he put me down and disrespected me and I'd have seen it for myself before wasting money and time on a dead end marriage.

Hang on, are you actually saying that you’re expecting your father to have magically divined your ex-DH was going to morph into a shit if said shit had asked his permission to marry you, even though you yourself, the person having the relationship with him, didn’t?

insweetharmony · 12/11/2022 00:07

are you your dad’s property, to be passed onto another man? 🙄

Hopefullynaive · 11/11/2022 23:28

Like I said I was having a pity party for one, usually if I had an issue I would absolutely speak to him but I knew deep down I was just being irrationally insecure today. Sometimes you just need a head wobble from mumsnet!

But one thing I need to clarify for the pp who said I was desperate for my dad's permission, not once did I say that. I do value his opinion but it was more of a joke than anything else. Desperation is so far away from disappointment that my ex hadn't done it. Maybe if he had I would have found out that they disliked they way he put me down and disrespected me and I'd have seen it for myself before wasting money and time on a dead end marriage.

OP posts:
Isthatascratchonmygrandmother · 11/11/2022 22:37

Yeah I'm with PP. I was 20 when I said the same thing to my husband, regarding asking my Father. I look back now (33) and I cringe. I wasn't my father's to 'give away'. I am not property and if I marry its because I make a conscious and controlled decision to do so, not because my Father gives it the go ahead. I love my Dad but he's not my keeper. I genuinely thought that tradition had died with me. I hope you get your marriage OP but please don't focus on these so called traditions around permission and proposals.

Meagainalready · 11/11/2022 22:26

You lost me at being desperate for him to ask your dad’s permission

You are a previously married now divorced and co-habiting mother of two and yet you still feel your father owns the rights to you?

good grief

IfOnlyIKnewThen · 11/11/2022 22:23

YABU.

OP you sound very much like you care about getting marrief and there is nothing wrong with that. I would find it annoying tbh if my partner said they weren't bothered and then started to try and speed up the process.

So your partner wants to save for a ring. You know him better than we can. Why wouldn't this be true? Unless your dead set against that kind of money being spent then let him do that. My DH did as he wanted me to be able to choose what I wanted within reason and for him feeling proud of what he bought was important and he could afford to do it.

If you are doubting his commitment to getting married even after he asked your Dad then I see that as a bit of a red flag to be honest. This is a matter of trust. It would be really shitty of him not to go through with it now. If you suspect that he could cause you that level of hurt and embarrassment and not even be straight with you that he has changed his mind I wouldn't be marrying him. The second red flag is why after having 2 kids with this man you are not able to ask him all these things directly. The third red flag would be if you suspect he will react badly to you feeling insecure rather than reassuring you.

tickticksnooze · 11/11/2022 22:18

It sounds a bit ridiculous.

I can't get past asking your father for permission (do you have no agency?) when he already has two children with you. You can't even argue "oh but tradition" on that.

What do you want from him?

PottyDottyDotPot · 11/11/2022 22:14

It sounds ok, stop
mentioning it.

HungryandIknowit · 11/11/2022 22:13

Based on the information you've given it doesn't sound like he's backing out. Unless you've felt something is "off" or have a gut feeling he's cooling on the relationship.