Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses, what result are you expecting from the strike?

111 replies

ImEasyLikeSundayMorning · 11/11/2022 18:50

At work we all assume it will be less than 17% because negotiation is better than strike.

One said the full 17%

Another said she would die of shock if we got 8%

What ate other nurses opinions?

OP posts:
Hobnobsandbroomstick · 12/11/2022 11:18

@KnittedCardi I did say it was never going to happen, but in an ideal/dream world. Didn't realise that they brought the bursary back in 2020. That's one thing at least.

The NHS pension is good, but the employer contributions make no difference to how much people actually get. It could be 100% of your salary, but you will still be entitled to 1/54th of your salary for each year.

I would disagree that the employee contribution is in line with most schemes. My friends who work in the private sector pay a maximum of 4% into theirs, not 9.8%. It is a good scheme, but I do pay nearly £300 into it each month for it. I would like to start making extra contributions, because I can't imagine working as a nurse past 60.

Topgub · 12/11/2022 11:16

@KnittedCardi

No, breaks aren't paid. Nurses are paid an hourly rate.

They work (generally) 12.5 hours and are paid 11.5. Or work 13.5 and are paid 12.5

KnittedCardi · 12/11/2022 11:01

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 12/11/2022 10:26

The bursary ended in 2016. They pay fees now too. I was very "lucky" to have a bursary of just under £400 per month and free fees when I trained.

I’m not a nurse, but I imagine many nurses would prefer better working conditions (eg reduced hours, more staff, better resources, more funding), free hospital parking etc to a 17% pay rise.

Yes, my "demands" in an ideal world wouldn't be more money, they would be:

  • Bring back a none means tested bursary for nursing students and get rid of fees.
  • Reduce full time from 37.5 hours with unpaid breaks (which no one gets), to 34.5 hours with unpaid breaks (that people actually get).
  • Free parking.
  • Guarantee that employee pension contributions will not rise again in the next decade.
  • Employers to start having to pay the NMC fee of £120 a year.
  • Reduce the age you can get a full NHS pension from 68 to 63.

...never gonna happen I know 🤣

Nurses DO get a bursary and additional means tested help. Everyone gets £5k, and there is additional means tested bursaries, and training places are many times oversubscribed, so I don't accept that there is a barrier to training. Retention is the main issue.

I also don't understand the unpaid breaks thing. Nurses are salaried so you get paid whatever, surely? Paid breaks is a hangover from the dark ages. Yes, you should get breaks, of course you should, and extra nurses are needed to enable that, and scheduled breaks to be taken.

Unpopular opinion here, but no-one ever talks about the pensions package. The NHS (government/taxpayers) pay 20% into nurses pension. This is huge. I think that is a very valuable part of the package, and should be acknowledged. Employee contribution is in line with most schemes.

Free parking is a great idea as is payment of NMC fee.

Reduced age for the pension, not going to happen. Completely unaffordable unless you reform the pension scheme, to make it less generous.

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 12/11/2022 10:47

@Ninananna

Sorry for your poor experiences.

I have good and bad experiences when on the other side.

I would say that nursing is my job, not my vocation. I burned out in 2020 and now I will not martyr myself.

I also doubt that an actual strike will ever happen.

Changechangychange · 12/11/2022 10:44

@Ninananna what would you call a monopoly employer imposing a 20% pay cut on junior doctors, and saying if you don’t like it you can leave the profession? Is that not blackmail?

Hope you enjoy paying private healthcare costs when the NHS collapses. When I worked in Canada, nurses earned $60-120k. Consultants were on $300-500k. Wages in the NHS have been artificially held down for decades.

Topgub · 12/11/2022 10:42

@Ninananna

How odd that your observations are the exact opposite of mine.

Ninananna · 12/11/2022 10:35

So much for nursing being a vocation and not just a job. I have spent many hours over the years by the side of a sick relative. I have seen elderly patients fall out of bed unnoticed, emergency buzzers completely ignored by nurses just chatting, patients left for hours on the lavatory unable to get themselves back to bed, relatives ignored by gaggles of nurses more interested in gossiping, night nurses on their phone for hours to boyfriends, patients too afraid to complain because the nurses would take it out on them later. Patients dinners left on the side unable to feed themselves. Nurses go into the town in their uniforms and straight back on to the wards without a worry about contamination. That is just a snapshot of observations. The caring profession, certainly not the majority. Striking is blackmail and you should never give in to blackmailers.

Changechangychange · 12/11/2022 10:30

@Sushi7 it is a chicken and egg situation with more staff - if you can make more in Aldi or McDonalds than you can as a band 5 on a cardiology ward (which is the case currently), you aren’t going to retain staff in the NHS. That then has an impact on workload and conditions for the remaining staff and they all leave too.

And no there is no bursary, it was removed in 2016 with predictable results on university nursing applications. The government then had to hastily implement a “Learning Support Fund” in 2019, but it’s not as generous.

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 12/11/2022 10:26

Sushi7 · 12/11/2022 10:13

I’m not a nurse, but I imagine many nurses would prefer better working conditions (eg reduced hours, more staff, better resources, more funding), free hospital parking etc to a 17% pay rise. Do nursing students get a bursary at university? They should do. More staff means services aren’t as stretched (and nurses aren’t as stressed). I really worry about patients who have to visit the hospital for treatment every week. How will they be affected by the strikes?

The bursary ended in 2016. They pay fees now too. I was very "lucky" to have a bursary of just under £400 per month and free fees when I trained.

I’m not a nurse, but I imagine many nurses would prefer better working conditions (eg reduced hours, more staff, better resources, more funding), free hospital parking etc to a 17% pay rise.

Yes, my "demands" in an ideal world wouldn't be more money, they would be:

  • Bring back a none means tested bursary for nursing students and get rid of fees.
  • Reduce full time from 37.5 hours with unpaid breaks (which no one gets), to 34.5 hours with unpaid breaks (that people actually get).
  • Free parking.
  • Guarantee that employee pension contributions will not rise again in the next decade.
  • Employers to start having to pay the NMC fee of £120 a year.
  • Reduce the age you can get a full NHS pension from 68 to 63.

...never gonna happen I know 🤣

Topgub · 12/11/2022 10:19

@Sushi7

Personally I think nurses deserve all of that and a pay rise

Sushi7 · 12/11/2022 10:13

I’m not a nurse, but I imagine many nurses would prefer better working conditions (eg reduced hours, more staff, better resources, more funding), free hospital parking etc to a 17% pay rise. Do nursing students get a bursary at university? They should do. More staff means services aren’t as stretched (and nurses aren’t as stressed). I really worry about patients who have to visit the hospital for treatment every week. How will they be affected by the strikes?

NeedAHoliday2021 · 12/11/2022 10:07

I don’t think it’s just nurses struggling with under staffing and stress in the nhs. My team of 4 is now 2 and I’ve taken lots more responsibility with no additional pay. That’s what I see all around me. I also worked through the pandemic, long hours, weekends with no extra pay because I’m a band 7 it seems to be expected.

Topgub · 12/11/2022 09:54

My preference would be an upgrade for all nursing staff

So all band 2s up to a band 3 etc

LionsandLambs · 12/11/2022 09:53

WingBingo · 12/11/2022 09:10

Nurses are in the agenda for change pay scales, as well as many other staff in the NHS, including non-clinical. This includes me.

not sure how the rise can just be given to nurses without allocating the rise to the rest of the agenda for change staff.

They can take nurses off AFC (my preference)
or make a targeted payment to nursing staff.

Changechangychange · 12/11/2022 09:49

Based on the junior doctors, you’ll get 2% imposed in stages over 5 years.

I hope your leaders are less spineless than ours were! But the government will not want to be seen to concede at all, and will try to punish you for striking. You can also expect a lot of Daily Mail articles about holidays nursing leaders have been on, and pictures of their houses to show how rich and greedy nurses are, for wanting a pay rise.

Jeremy Hunt was the health minister when we went on strike, and he was an absolute dick about it, so wouldn’t hold your breath for major concessions.

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 12/11/2022 09:43

*forgot to say, because the difference of basic pay is £33.78, I've taken a sort of pay cut, because I don't work weekends now.

zizza · 12/11/2022 09:42

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 12/11/2022 09:25

I worked out last night that since 2010, nurses at the top of band 5 have had an average pay rise of something like 1.6% each year.

I think we'll get fucked over with something that sounds better than it actually is, like that 3 year pay deal we had a few years ago, which even the unions didn't realise was a load of shite until they'd signed on the line, and then issued us with a written apology 🤣.

I also expect that we'll get fucked over with the pension (again).

I was coming on to say similar about the pension (I'm not a nurse but am an AfC B5). Be careful what you wish for.... If there's an increase in pay we need to call for an increase in the pension band amounts otherwise you could end up paying all your payrise into the pension scheme!

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 12/11/2022 09:42

Shinyandnew1 · 12/11/2022 09:28

And as a precious top band 6 I essentially took a pay cut with loss of enhancements when I got promoted

Can you explain this? Why are Band 6 precious? Why did you take a pay cut to become a Bank 7?

I'm guessing precious is a typo for previous, but could be wrong 🤣.

I recently moved from top of band 5 (not very precious 🤣) to a band 6 role, and am financially worse off. The difference between basic pay (no antisocial hours etc) of top band 5 and bottom band 6 is an extra £33.78 a month for me, after student loan pension contributions. As a band 5, I worked evenings, weekends, holidays etc. As a band 6 I would be happy to still do this, but they don't want to pay me. I'm planning on sticking it out for a year and then might move back to band 5.

I know a band 6 sister who has just moved back to a band 5 working permanent nights because she needs to extra money.

x2boys · 12/11/2022 09:38

Shinyandnew1 · 12/11/2022 09:28

And as a precious top band 6 I essentially took a pay cut with loss of enhancements when I got promoted

Can you explain this? Why are Band 6 precious? Why did you take a pay cut to become a Bank 7?

Most band 7,s ime only work office hours ,so they wouldnt get weekend and night enhancements which can boost basic pay quite a bit .

Topgub · 12/11/2022 09:35

@Shinyandnew1

They obviously meant previous band 6. And it's a pay cut because when you move up a grade you move from the top of 1 band to the bottom (roughly) of the next band.

Band 7s rarely do nights or weekends so they will also have lost all their enhanced pay. Meaning a technical pay cuT

WingBingo · 12/11/2022 09:34

@Hobnobsandbroomstick that’s what I mean. I’d prefer nurses and clinical staff to benefit. I’m an 8c, I don’t think it would be fair for me to benefit.

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 12/11/2022 09:33

Redup · 12/11/2022 09:21

Nurses, is it correct that you got 3% last year plus a payout of £1400? Some of the lowest paid got 9.3% increase? Please confirm whether or not this was the case.

No. It was a minimum of £1400 increase for everyone.

Top of band 5 pay went from £31,534 to £32,934, so they just lazily stuck the minimum £1400 on it. An increase of just over 4% for the top of band 5, but then pension contributions also went up by 0.5%. The pension contribution rate actually increased more for the lower paid bands, and less for the top bands. Go figure.

x2boys · 12/11/2022 09:29

I
Im not a nurse anymore but how is this going to work because its not just nurses in rhe banding system ,is it an NHS.pay rise you are fighting for?
When i was a nurse i remember the labour government saying they had given nurses a 9% payrise ,this was before Agenda for change ,what they had actualy done was given all Top E grades ( roughly equivalent to Band fives ) a 9 % payrise

Shinyandnew1 · 12/11/2022 09:28

And as a precious top band 6 I essentially took a pay cut with loss of enhancements when I got promoted

Can you explain this? Why are Band 6 precious? Why did you take a pay cut to become a Bank 7?

AC2022 · 12/11/2022 09:26

@willstarttomorrow Very well said.