Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cleaner had her DC there with her today

461 replies

changinglanesagain · 11/11/2022 18:14

I've had my cleaned for about 3 months. She's really good. I really like her work

Anyway, I gave her a key last week and today I popped home for lunch unexpectedly. She had her DD there with her...

Apparently it's a teacher training day for them and so her DD had to come too. I asked why she couldn't reschedule to do another date or even better, come this evening?

She said she couldn't come this evening due to her DS coming home, he's disabled, and she'd just much rather not let me down for my allocated day so thought she'd just being DD along

I said okay... and that was that

AIBU to think she should've asked my permission first?

So not to drip feed, she was sat at my dining table doing colouring and had a few toys out

OP posts:
Morechocmorechoc · 12/11/2022 08:38

Wow people on here are so rude.

In what world do you bring someone uninvited into someone else's home without asking.

Of course she should have asked. It's called being polite. Clearly most people here have no manners at all.

cushioncovers · 12/11/2022 08:34

She should have asked first. You don't just turn up to work with your kids without checking with your employer first, it's bad manners in my opinion.

paintitallover · 12/11/2022 07:45

I'd be ok with it as a one off or occasional thing, but I'd definitely expect to be asked. It's my house, after all.

pewtypie · 12/11/2022 06:01

Kanaloa · 12/11/2022 05:52

The entire thread. OP is being called heartless and selfish - posters have said she should have been rushing to provide snacks and meals to the child and it’s wrong that she isn’t supporting the cleaner. But in fact she isn’t wrong.

And a child left downstairs without an adult watching them is unsupervised. They aren’t being watched or supervised.

In my case, I did provide snacks to my mum’s cleaner’s dd. She was a good kid and well behaved. It sounds like this child was quietly minding her own business too.

Fair enough if OP doesn’t want here there but plenty of people don’t mind well behaved kids being in the house.

Splitsplat · 12/11/2022 05:55

YABVU

Kanaloa · 12/11/2022 05:52

FurAndFeathers · 12/11/2022 00:10

i wouldn’t consider a child with a parent in the house unsupervised

I also doubt that bringing her child to work is a regular expectation of the cleaners as it’s not arisen before, so no I wouldn’t be expect her to set it out as an expectation in her ‘terms’. But then I’m clearly more relaxed than some on here and happy to simply pay folk for doing a good job to a decent standard 🤷‍♀️

I don’t generally trouble myself too much with establishing rigid working hierarchies to ensure my colleagues know who is boss. It all seems like a lot of angst.

Out of interest which part of me saying “Yes asking in advance would have been sensible” lead you to interpret my post as it being “unreasonable or crazy to not want somebody you’re paying for a service to leave their child playing in your home without even asking you.”

it seems rather a stretch. I’m not really sure who you’re arguing with - I’ve certainly never suggested anything of the sort!

The entire thread. OP is being called heartless and selfish - posters have said she should have been rushing to provide snacks and meals to the child and it’s wrong that she isn’t supporting the cleaner. But in fact she isn’t wrong.

And a child left downstairs without an adult watching them is unsupervised. They aren’t being watched or supervised.

Harvinius · 12/11/2022 02:17

Very late, apologies if this has already been covered,

my first reaction to this was like most others- bit snobby, op should be more sympathetic and flexible, not something to get worked up over.

however I think the reason op has an issue is not necessarily because the cleaner bought her child, but that she did it thinking nobody would be around to notice and therefore didn’t feel the need to check first, so what else might they be doing?
the cleaner has unsupervised access to ops home, and has betrayed the significant trust that’s been given them. It’s natural that op is going to be more suspicious of the cleaner about anything that might happen going forward because the relationship has been damaged by the cleaners actions.

Neggymumum · 12/11/2022 02:03

My mum was a cleaner back in the seventies/ eighties. I used to go with her all the times, it's one of the perks of being a cleaner. When I got older I used to help out. Only once did one of her clients get a bit sniffy, mum told her if she didn't like it she could get someone else, she nearly shit herself. Good cleaners then were like good cleaners now, gold dust. If she's good and honest and you trust her suck it up.

GingerScallop · 12/11/2022 01:57

She probably should have asked. May be she forgot then thought, sh*t I will just have to. May be she was too scared to ask and thought she would risk it. But kid was colouring fgs. Many women across the world struggle to balance work and motherhood so cut her some slack. To make a whole Mumsnet post about this as if she's been trying out your underwear is peak privilege. Sounds like your life is so so good you have no worries and have to make up problems or you are so privileged you can muster empathy. But may be you are empathetic and not privileged but this just ground your gears. My advice: save the stress of annoyance for truly despicable people

Furries · 12/11/2022 01:51

I remember going to houses with my mum when she cleaned. It was absolutely drummed into me to behave, not touch anything, blah blah. I have no idea if my mum had cleared it first (at a guess, I’d say she did). I did like seeing “how the other half lived”, was quite happy to sit quietly and gawp at the room I was in!

OP - I kind of get it, it would have been polite to check with you first (though I balk at your description of giving your blessing, it kind of gives something away re your thought process).

I’d be going forward thinking that you’ve been happy with her work up until now, the child was sat quietly colouring, the child had not caused any damage, your cleaner had turned up to work and not let you down. I would therefore mention briefly that, if the situation arises again, you would prefer to know in advance and that then it isn’t a problem.

I’m a believer that being understanding can go a long way - for both parties.

As an aside, am loving some of the descriptions on here, especially the horror at “random” people tagging along on a job. I don’t think anyones child is a random! Completely different to the comparisons of boyfriend/mate etc!

As someone else mentioned, it’s a bit odd that you came home unexpectedly, but hadn’t left payment for her as you knew you’d be coming home. Was it “unexpectedly” for the cleaner, but you knew that you’d be arriving home early in advance?

FurAndFeathers · 12/11/2022 00:58

Which bit of that post that you typed did I imagine?

FurAndFeathers · 12/11/2022 00:57

MissVantaBlack · 12/11/2022 00:21

@FurAndFeathers No, it was actually you who imagined that I said her intention was to make the house safe for the child! I didn't ascribe any intention to the OP - because it doesn't matter why she doesn't want the DC in the house: it's her home and it's up to her who come in.

As explained above, the health and safety bit is something that everybody who thinks this situation is fine, should consider. Not every house is safe for young children to play unsupervised.

“But OP isn't saying she won't support her cleaner. She just wanted prior notice that the DC would be there too. Then she could have put away any bits and pieces that she didn't want the DC fiddling with, or asked that the DC didn't go into the bedroom, or whatever.”

Umm… except you literally said she just wanted prior notice so she could put things away🤷‍♀️

There’s zero evidence that was her concern.

mycatisannoying · 12/11/2022 00:29

If one of our cleaners had asked as a one-off I’d almost certainly have said yes but pointed out we have a few house rules: food eaten at the table only no feet or shoes on furniture.

Yes, one can't be too careful with the commoners.

MissVantaBlack · 12/11/2022 00:21

@FurAndFeathers No, it was actually you who imagined that I said her intention was to make the house safe for the child! I didn't ascribe any intention to the OP - because it doesn't matter why she doesn't want the DC in the house: it's her home and it's up to her who come in.

As explained above, the health and safety bit is something that everybody who thinks this situation is fine, should consider. Not every house is safe for young children to play unsupervised.

FurAndFeathers · 12/11/2022 00:10

Kanaloa · 11/11/2022 23:47

Right, but op would be well within her rights to say she was uncomfortable with a quite young child being left to play unsupervised in her home. If the cleaner wanted to set those terms, she needs to make them clear right from the start - I suspect she wouldn’t do that because she’s aware that ‘child playing in the house unsupervised’ isn’t on most people’s terms when they’re hiring a cleaner. It’s not unreasonable or crazy to not want somebody you’re paying for a service to leave their child playing in your home without even asking you.

i wouldn’t consider a child with a parent in the house unsupervised

I also doubt that bringing her child to work is a regular expectation of the cleaners as it’s not arisen before, so no I wouldn’t be expect her to set it out as an expectation in her ‘terms’. But then I’m clearly more relaxed than some on here and happy to simply pay folk for doing a good job to a decent standard 🤷‍♀️

I don’t generally trouble myself too much with establishing rigid working hierarchies to ensure my colleagues know who is boss. It all seems like a lot of angst.

Out of interest which part of me saying “Yes asking in advance would have been sensible” lead you to interpret my post as it being “unreasonable or crazy to not want somebody you’re paying for a service to leave their child playing in your home without even asking you.”

it seems rather a stretch. I’m not really sure who you’re arguing with - I’ve certainly never suggested anything of the sort!

FurAndFeathers · 12/11/2022 00:01

MissVantaBlack · 11/11/2022 23:53

@FurAndFeathers OP didn't say why she wanted to be asked first, but she didn't need to. It's her home and she shouldn't have to justify why she doesn't want an unknown child left unsupervised in it for several hours.

The paragraph about the safety aspect was actually intended for all the PPs who apparently have no problem with the above scenario, to illustrate that it's not just about the home owner's rights, but also about the best interests of the child in this situation. The OP may not have considered this aspect, but its an important point none the less.

Right so you entirely imagined that her intention was to ‘put away bits and pieces’ and make the house child safe then.

There’s absolutely nothing to suggest any concern for the child in her posts. It’s very unlikely from her comments that that was her issue as she’s never mentioned it.

SandyY2K · 11/11/2022 23:55

I’m sad to read your post OP .
Cant you please be compassionate and think about how supportive you could be to this working mother ?

I can’t believe you are not pleased about a small child sitting quietly while her mother earns . imagine how good life would be if women supported each other

These kind of posts are annoying. Nonsense. Women supporting women... how good would life be ...it just comes over as weak...eith a stepford vibe.

You don't bring your kid to your place of work like this, in someone else's house WITHOUT permission. It's common courtesy.

MissVantaBlack · 11/11/2022 23:53

@FurAndFeathers OP didn't say why she wanted to be asked first, but she didn't need to. It's her home and she shouldn't have to justify why she doesn't want an unknown child left unsupervised in it for several hours.

The paragraph about the safety aspect was actually intended for all the PPs who apparently have no problem with the above scenario, to illustrate that it's not just about the home owner's rights, but also about the best interests of the child in this situation. The OP may not have considered this aspect, but its an important point none the less.

Kanaloa · 11/11/2022 23:47

FurAndFeathers · 11/11/2022 23:42

Yes asking in advance would have been sensible. I suspect though that as the OP expects to be ‘asked for her blessing’ and for the cleaner to work through the evening instead of bringing her child that she’s not the easiest person to have that conversation with.

I suspect it’s a moot point anyway. As the OP hadn’t paid her I doubt she’ll be back.

Right, but op would be well within her rights to say she was uncomfortable with a quite young child being left to play unsupervised in her home. If the cleaner wanted to set those terms, she needs to make them clear right from the start - I suspect she wouldn’t do that because she’s aware that ‘child playing in the house unsupervised’ isn’t on most people’s terms when they’re hiring a cleaner. It’s not unreasonable or crazy to not want somebody you’re paying for a service to leave their child playing in your home without even asking you.

FurAndFeathers · 11/11/2022 23:46

And it is fair to say she hasn’t paid her because she literally hasn’t.

and that’s because she was too busy interrogating her about her child to do so.

FurAndFeathers · 11/11/2022 23:45

MissVantaBlack · 11/11/2022 23:42

@FurAndFeathers OP clearly states that she would have liked the cleaner to ask first. Take a look at her opening post at 18:14 (paragraph 6), at the 18:17 post, and at the 19:23 post.

And it's not fair to say she didn't pay her. She has contacted the cleaner to arrange a bank transfer, but is waiting for her account details.

Oh yes I agree with that - she was very clear that she expected to be asked ‘for her blessing’ (!!)

it was the part you said about her needing prior notice in order to make the house safe for the child that I didn’t see. Where is that please ? Her suggestion that the cleaner should have come and cleaned in the evening instead didn’t indicate that she was planning to accommodate the child at all - only that she wanted her ‘blessing’ to be specifically sought.

FurAndFeathers · 11/11/2022 23:42

Kanaloa · 11/11/2022 23:34

But unless you’ve included that you’ll be bringing your child in those terms, the client isn’t really getting the full choice to accept the terms. They’re accepting the terms they want, which the cleaner is then not following.

If she wants to set her terms of employment as ‘I’ll be leaving my child to play downstairs while I clean the house’ then of course that’s fine! But she should advertise that from the very beginning, and allow clients to accept her actual honest terms.

Yes asking in advance would have been sensible. I suspect though that as the OP expects to be ‘asked for her blessing’ and for the cleaner to work through the evening instead of bringing her child that she’s not the easiest person to have that conversation with.

I suspect it’s a moot point anyway. As the OP hadn’t paid her I doubt she’ll be back.

MissVantaBlack · 11/11/2022 23:42

@FurAndFeathers OP clearly states that she would have liked the cleaner to ask first. Take a look at her opening post at 18:14 (paragraph 6), at the 18:17 post, and at the 19:23 post.

And it's not fair to say she didn't pay her. She has contacted the cleaner to arrange a bank transfer, but is waiting for her account details.

Kanaloa · 11/11/2022 23:34

FurAndFeathers · 11/11/2022 22:25

You seem to be struggling with the idea of self-employment. You don’t have an employer. The clue is in the title.

you set your own hours, rates of pay and terms of employment. Businesses/clients are free to accept your terms or not.

your hypothetical application of this scenario to a different role in a different industry isn’t really relevant to this thread.

But unless you’ve included that you’ll be bringing your child in those terms, the client isn’t really getting the full choice to accept the terms. They’re accepting the terms they want, which the cleaner is then not following.

If she wants to set her terms of employment as ‘I’ll be leaving my child to play downstairs while I clean the house’ then of course that’s fine! But she should advertise that from the very beginning, and allow clients to accept her actual honest terms.

FurAndFeathers · 11/11/2022 23:31

MissVantaBlack · 11/11/2022 23:13

But OP isn't saying she won't support her cleaner. She just wanted prior notice that the DC would be there too. Then she could have put away any bits and pieces that she didn't want the DC fiddling with, or asked that the DC didn't go into the bedroom, or whatever. It's a perfectly reasonable expectation.

Where did she say that? I read her saying she’d asked why the cleaner hadn’t stayed at home to watch her child and offered to come and clean in the evening instead, then not paid her…