Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step kids and bio kids

87 replies

Laurens96 · 11/11/2022 15:48

Hi I'm just looking for a bit of advice.
I have 2 step kids a 12 year old girl and a soon to be 11 year old boy. I also have 3 daughters with my partner twin 2 year old and a 6 month old.
I've finished Christmas present shopping early so decided to get my twins birthday presents out of sales even tho their birthday in till may. Having all 3 of mygirls birthdays within 10 days I thought it best to get in front.
The twins have had £50 each for their birthday. My partner has had a go saying it's too much for their birthday as he only gives his 2 kids from his previous marriage £25 each. I pointed out I've offered every year to put extra to their birthday money for the 6 years we've been together and he always tells me no. I've done the twins birthday on my own he hasn't put anything to it either.

His 2 kids have had the same as my twins for Christmas money wise which I did the majority of myself he only really helped with the baby whose had a lot less as she doesn't need much this year. But he said it looks like I've favoured our children together there too as they've got more for the same money being so little.

My question is am I being unreasonable for saying I'm not spending more on Christmas just cuz my girls stuff was cheaper then the older kids. And am I being unreasonable by still doing £50 for my girls birthday knowing my partner won't allow his children to have more then £25 for their birthday.

OP posts:
Iwonder08 · 12/11/2022 06:59

What a jerk. Not only you buy HIS children presents (in fact he should be doing it, it is not your responsibility) but he also enforces some made up stupid rule how much you are allowed to spend on your own children! DSC is not your responsibility. He wants to give them more he can knock himself out, but you don't spend less on your girls because he has different ideas. You have many years of Xmas and bdays.. Nip it right in the bud now

ImustLearn2Cook · 12/11/2022 04:49

I liked the way my Nana did Christmas presents. No one knew how much or how little she spent on each grandchild or each of her children including two step children (my eldest Aunt and Uncle).

What we did know was that she always put thought into your gift and chose something that she thought you would like and need.

This trying to get gifts that all cost exactly the same amount seems to take away the thought that counts aspect.

GrazingSheep · 12/11/2022 02:10

You’re a mug.
But you know this already.
Just don’t have any more children with him.

Travis1 · 11/11/2022 20:53

So he’ll only spend £25 on his kids for birthdays? Has let you buy all their Christmas? You do pick ups from their mums? And you had 3 kids with this prince?

Christ on a bike. Stop the world I want off.

Laurens96 · 11/11/2022 20:43

A lot of my girls presents for Christmas are shoes and clothes in the next size up to grow into tbh with a few toys.
The babys had things like a sit in walker push along walker and an activity table then clothes as I still have all my twins baby rattles so didn't see the point having more of those.
I don't currently work but do get uc for the children although I do put half to the house bills from that except gas and electric as I have a car to pay for too so I can see family and get the stepchildren from their moms as I live an hours drive away because this was the only house we could get through an exchange.
My step kids know how much their stuff costs as they do pick out what they want and give us a list but every year tell us mom spends more then us but she only has 3 children to buy for. They do tell us to that their step dad's family spends more then my family do too.
He's only ever given his children £25 for birthday since he split with his ex wife and constantly says there's no need to up that amount.
I brought my step children's presents early this year as last Christmas we got to December and he still hadn't got a thing and I had to try sort it all last minute so they still had stuff and didn't want to be doing that again this year.

OP posts:
familyissues12345 · 11/11/2022 19:10

JenniferWooley · 11/11/2022 17:51

@BattenburgDonkey I totally get that it's more the "well they get presents elsewhere so don't need as much here" argument that gets trotted out on here when all the kids belong to the dad but not when they all belong to the mum

Yep agree, my DS's are both mine, DH is stepdad to the eldest. No way would we have had it that DS1 got less than DS2 as he got presents from his Dad.
Unpopular view no doubt, but DS2 was already at an advantage that his Mum and Dad were still together and he didn't have to be uprooted to go to his Dads over Christmas when he wanted to be at home playing with the presents we'd bought him. TBH I would be disappointed if DS2 present counted and argued that DS1 got more.

Anon1224 · 11/11/2022 19:09

Is this a fundamental difference in parenting styles rather than a step vs bio issue? If so, his view that his kids should not be overly spoilt is as valid as yours that they should. This needs to be solved by discussion and compromise.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 11/11/2022 19:03

NeedAChangeAsIAmSoooOuting · 11/11/2022 16:39

He spends £25 on his children's bdays?! I'm seriously shocked by that. I must live on another planet.

This.

What could you possibly see in a dad who is so tight-fisted that he only spends £25 each on one set of kids and nothing on the other?

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 11/11/2022 18:56

Spend whatever you like on your own children. Ignore him. It doesn't sound like he really gives a shit about any of them but especially the ones that belong to you op! Is he this much of a twat about everything else?

Whatthefuck3456 · 11/11/2022 18:51

I think you DH is being a joke to be honest. Don’t get your children less because the SC get £25 which your DH wants. The SC get off there mother aswel so why should you not spend what you want on your own children. Tell him to sort his children with whatever budget he wants and you give your children what ever budget you want. You DH is definitely a Disney dad who rolls out the red carpet for SC.

BattenburgDonkey · 11/11/2022 18:02

JenniferWooley · 11/11/2022 17:51

@BattenburgDonkey I totally get that it's more the "well they get presents elsewhere so don't need as much here" argument that gets trotted out on here when all the kids belong to the dad but not when they all belong to the mum

But in a lot of families the step grandparents don’t buy presents for the kids who aren’t biologically theirs… there’s differences in every family, comparing yourself to advice given to people in different situations to yours is just putting an unnecessary stress on yourself. There’s nothing wrong with the way you did things because it works for you, that doesn’t mean that this OP is wrong for spending a little more money on her own kids… her and her DH do things differently to you.

JenniferWooley · 11/11/2022 17:51

@BattenburgDonkey I totally get that it's more the "well they get presents elsewhere so don't need as much here" argument that gets trotted out on here when all the kids belong to the dad but not when they all belong to the mum

BattenburgDonkey · 11/11/2022 17:33

JenniferWooley · 11/11/2022 16:57

See I don't get this because the argument doesn't work the other way.

I had DD's with ex-h so they got presents from:

Me & stepdad
My parents
Stepdads parents
Ex-H
Ex-H parents

But DS got presents from:

Me & Dad
My parents
Dads parents

All DC were treated the same in my house.

Should we have bought DS more, or bought DD's less, for birthdays & Christmas to compensate for the fact that DD's got presents elsewhere that DS didn't?

No not if you were happy with it. But this family are different as the dad is trying to tell the mum what she can and cannot spend on her own children to make it ‘fair’, but the kids have different circumstances to the step kids… and she should be able to spend extra on her own kids if she wants, not her fault the dad is tight.

Goldbar · 11/11/2022 17:15

I would tell him that just because he's shit at buying/giving gifts for HIS children's birthdays/Christmas doesn't mean that you're going to be the same for YOUR children.

Also, he owes you £700 and a big thank you for organising things for his children. If he doesn't like what you do for them, he can take over the organising in future.

JenniferWooley · 11/11/2022 16:57

WeepingSomnambulist · 11/11/2022 16:50

But they get gifts from their mum, from you and dad, from 3 sets of grandparents (bio and step).

Your kids only get gifts from you and dad and 2 sets of grandparents.

His kids are getting a lot more.

See I don't get this because the argument doesn't work the other way.

I had DD's with ex-h so they got presents from:

Me & stepdad
My parents
Stepdads parents
Ex-H
Ex-H parents

But DS got presents from:

Me & Dad
My parents
Dads parents

All DC were treated the same in my house.

Should we have bought DS more, or bought DD's less, for birthdays & Christmas to compensate for the fact that DD's got presents elsewhere that DS didn't?

Dishwashersaurous · 11/11/2022 16:53

I'm really confused by £350 at Christmas, and only £25 for birthday. Would it not make sense to spread the gifts more evenly.

WeepingSomnambulist · 11/11/2022 16:50

But they get gifts from their mum, from you and dad, from 3 sets of grandparents (bio and step).

Your kids only get gifts from you and dad and 2 sets of grandparents.

His kids are getting a lot more.

Mariposista · 11/11/2022 16:46

Remember that Christmas is not all about presents (they all need to know that too).

NeedAChangeAsIAmSoooOuting · 11/11/2022 16:39

He spends £25 on his children's bdays?! I'm seriously shocked by that. I must live on another planet.

BattenburgDonkey · 11/11/2022 16:33

I’d point out to him that it’s actually the same as what his kids get then. Your kids ‘mum and dad’ (I.e you and him) have spent £50 on each of them, and for his kids he spends £25 and their mum spends £25 (although probably more).

Really bizarre to spend £350 at Christmas but only £25/50 on a birthday! But whatever works.

Goldfishmountainclimber · 11/11/2022 16:29

I don’t think that children’s presents should be about an exact monetary value for each but rather about what they want or need and then figure out how the family budget can meet those needs. For example, I wouldn’t spend much on a baby who is the youngest and you probably have lots of toys in the house already for them to play with.

jumbled11 · 11/11/2022 16:28

Oh and he should be contributing toward your twins presents too considering they are his kids. Don't fall into the trap of allowing him not to pay for anything for his kids with you because he's paying for his older ones. They are all his and equally his responsibility to contribute toward, not just yours.

jumbled11 · 11/11/2022 16:25

Sorry I'm confused... In regards to your main question, spend what you want on your twins. He doesn't get to unilaterally decide everyone gets £25 just because that's what he wants to give his older kids (and they will be getting presents from their mother too so very likely they DO get the same if not more than £50 for their birthdays).

But more importantly imo, WHY the actual fuck are YOU buying £350 worth of presents for HIS kids? I don't even contribute half towards my stepchildrens Christmas presents nevermind fork out the whole lot! Your husband, their father, should be responsible for buying and especially paying for the majority of their presents with you contributing something if you're happy to. In our house my husband buys for his older kids and I just get them a few smaller inexpensive gifts myself. I'd think he'd lost the actual plot if he expected me to go out and buy and pay for his kids presents!

You're being taken for a mug with that OP.

GrazingSheep · 11/11/2022 16:10

he's buying for his with you buying for yours.

But all 5 of the children are his.

Igotthegoose · 11/11/2022 16:06

Surely they have a mother who will be spending on them too? The twins have your presents only. Of course it’s fair

it shouldn’t be about how much you spend for a child anyway as long as they are not treated differently and it’s not glaringly obvious with the presents. Toddlers don’t know how much things cost.

is he self conscious about his own parenting or does he try and ‘make up’ for not being there all the time with his children? Sounds like it could be a sensitive issue for him

Swipe left for the next trending thread