Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step kids and bio kids

87 replies

Laurens96 · 11/11/2022 15:48

Hi I'm just looking for a bit of advice.
I have 2 step kids a 12 year old girl and a soon to be 11 year old boy. I also have 3 daughters with my partner twin 2 year old and a 6 month old.
I've finished Christmas present shopping early so decided to get my twins birthday presents out of sales even tho their birthday in till may. Having all 3 of mygirls birthdays within 10 days I thought it best to get in front.
The twins have had £50 each for their birthday. My partner has had a go saying it's too much for their birthday as he only gives his 2 kids from his previous marriage £25 each. I pointed out I've offered every year to put extra to their birthday money for the 6 years we've been together and he always tells me no. I've done the twins birthday on my own he hasn't put anything to it either.

His 2 kids have had the same as my twins for Christmas money wise which I did the majority of myself he only really helped with the baby whose had a lot less as she doesn't need much this year. But he said it looks like I've favoured our children together there too as they've got more for the same money being so little.

My question is am I being unreasonable for saying I'm not spending more on Christmas just cuz my girls stuff was cheaper then the older kids. And am I being unreasonable by still doing £50 for my girls birthday knowing my partner won't allow his children to have more then £25 for their birthday.

OP posts:
mum11970 · 12/11/2022 10:47

JenniferWooley · 11/11/2022 16:57

See I don't get this because the argument doesn't work the other way.

I had DD's with ex-h so they got presents from:

Me & stepdad
My parents
Stepdads parents
Ex-H
Ex-H parents

But DS got presents from:

Me & Dad
My parents
Dads parents

All DC were treated the same in my house.

Should we have bought DS more, or bought DD's less, for birthdays & Christmas to compensate for the fact that DD's got presents elsewhere that DS didn't?

You can do whatever suits your family, but we did as the PP said and dsc generally got less off us for Christmas as they had presents at their mum’s too. Otherwise dsc we’re getting ridiculous amounts for Christmas. Dsc are well in to their adulthood now with children of their own and don’t feel they were favoured differently than their siblings in our house. Dss was actually laughing just the other day whilst telling his partner how he had the same big ticket present from both sides one year. Dss has a blended family and they do it differently and spend the same on all children as one child has no contact with one side of their family so it would definitely be unfair to spend less. It isn’t a one size fits all scenario.

aSofaNearYou · 12/11/2022 10:38

If you are each "putting money into" things - meaning you view your money as separate, then YANBU to spend what you want on your kids. He doesn't get to dictate how much you spend on them, or how much you chip in towards his kids. You'd be well within your rights to not chip into that at all. And he doesn't get to say you can only spend £25 just because that's what he does.

The figures do all sound quite bizarre, though. £350 seems a pretty excessive amount to spend on one child at Christmas. On the flip side, £50 (let alone £25) seems pretty low for a birthday. It makes the whole set up a bit difficult to understand the logic of!

Oddieconvert · 12/11/2022 10:22

Oh missed on Uc etc etc

ok puts a different dimensions on it!

Oddieconvert · 12/11/2022 10:21

Awfully early to buy op. At those ages their interests change so quickly

Oddieconvert · 12/11/2022 10:21

No one tells me how much to spend on my children. Least of all because of how much they are spending on a child that is not my child

Pinkdelight3 · 12/11/2022 10:18

I've finished Christmas present shopping early so decided to get my twins birthday presents out of sales even tho their birthday in till may. Having all 3 of mygirls birthdays within 10 days I thought it best to get in front.

You sound a bit shopping-mad tbh, buying birthday gifts now for May, not in the sales, just because you've 'finished christmas shopping early'. The logic of getting it 'in front' is nonsense and sounds more like you just wanted to buy things, which is also a bit mad for such young DC who don't need much stuff.

Reading your OP, I'd assumed you were loaded and had married a guy with the resources for umpteen kids and was just being stingy, but now it seems you're not loaded and not working and on UC. So now your DH seems more sensible (for the restraint with money if not procreation) and you sound like you need to reign it in.

Darbs76 · 12/11/2022 10:08

£25 in my opinion is a low amount for a birthday. Fair enough his kids will get from their mother too, so not too bad. The older kids can understand that their present pile is smaller, that’s what happens in households across the U.K. when you have younger and older kids.

toomuchlaundry · 12/11/2022 09:54

How much CMS does he pay?

What does he do for the kids as you seem to do the bulk of the legwork for the step kids

autienotnaughty · 12/11/2022 09:52

I spend 150 on my 2 dd (whose father I'm divorced from) and the same on my son (with his dad) my dd get £30 each from their dad. I could spend £30 less on them which would be equal but I chose not to. Ds gets more from his paternal grandparents/aunts etc than dd do. But dd get stuff from their dads family. So it all roughly works out.

You and ur dh should agree an amount to spend on ur kids and split it.(if you have separate finances) dh should pay for his kids , the fairest way would be to do roughly half what your shared kids get assuming his ex does similar so overall they get same.

Naunet · 12/11/2022 09:43

Laurens96 · 11/11/2022 20:43

A lot of my girls presents for Christmas are shoes and clothes in the next size up to grow into tbh with a few toys.
The babys had things like a sit in walker push along walker and an activity table then clothes as I still have all my twins baby rattles so didn't see the point having more of those.
I don't currently work but do get uc for the children although I do put half to the house bills from that except gas and electric as I have a car to pay for too so I can see family and get the stepchildren from their moms as I live an hours drive away because this was the only house we could get through an exchange.
My step kids know how much their stuff costs as they do pick out what they want and give us a list but every year tell us mom spends more then us but she only has 3 children to buy for. They do tell us to that their step dad's family spends more then my family do too.
He's only ever given his children £25 for birthday since he split with his ex wife and constantly says there's no need to up that amount.
I brought my step children's presents early this year as last Christmas we got to December and he still hadn't got a thing and I had to try sort it all last minute so they still had stuff and didn't want to be doing that again this year.

Why are you the one paying for all of this and buying for his kids? And why are you the one picking up his kids? Do you do all the childcare for them too whilst he sits back and dictates how you’ve done things wrong?

Coffeaddict · 12/11/2022 08:42

Pre teen/ teen presents are smaller than toddler stuff but more expensive. DSS (10) is getting a single present from us but that present contains a switch. On the other hand DS is getting 4 presents which are also larger in size but still cost significantly less than DSS.

DSS is old enough to know that something like a switch is expensive. He has been asking for it for 3 years but this was the first year we could afford it so he will be absolutely delighted

Milkand2sugarsplease · 12/11/2022 08:41

This has to be a wind up. £350 a head when on UC with no input from "D"H who now thinks, after spending £350 a head on his children, you've not been fair???

Ragruggers · 12/11/2022 08:33

How can you afford such huge amounts when you as a family claim UC? Hope you have savings for emergencies.I must be mean because have never spent such huge amounts on presents for small children.Do they really need so much?Better to buy an annual pass and enjoy all the year round with smaller gifts. Good job we are all different I suppose.

Dishwashersaurous · 12/11/2022 08:27

I think £25 for a present is reasonable on a low income, which by definition is what universal credit is for.

However. I simply cannot understand how anyone other than those with truly enormous income can afford more than £1550 on Christmas presents.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 12/11/2022 08:21

£350 each seems excessive, for the 2 year olds it seems ridiculous as does £150 on a baby who won’t even remember it. That’s £1550 just on Christmas presents for the kids before you even start with gifts for anyone else, the food or any other Christmas expenses. How are you going to afford that?

To spend £350 each on Christmas but then only £25 on the SC for their birthdays is such a huge contrast. I think your DP is being a bit tight only spending £25 on their birthdays, but I think your Christmas spending is ridiculous. How are you affording it on UC and with bills going up, surely done of that money would be better saved to give done security for when you eventually realise it’s time to leave your DP?

Bananarama21 · 12/11/2022 08:13

He saw you coming and then you've gone on to have 3 dc with him. How are you managing it with 5 kids if hes not helping? Does he contribute to the household?

billy1966 · 12/11/2022 08:13

SchoolQuestionnaire · 11/11/2022 19:03

This.

What could you possibly see in a dad who is so tight-fisted that he only spends £25 each on one set of kids and nothing on the other?

This.

🙄

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 12/11/2022 08:12

Travis1 · 11/11/2022 20:53

So he’ll only spend £25 on his kids for birthdays? Has let you buy all their Christmas? You do pick ups from their mums? And you had 3 kids with this prince?

Christ on a bike. Stop the world I want off.

This^^
why isn’t he doing more of the present purchasing for his children.

you sound like you treat them very kindly and make effort to include them. But he’s slacking. Witt having 3 of your own children so young it must be frustrating for him not to step up and sort his own childrens gifts out?

Dishwashersaurous · 12/11/2022 08:08

Universal credit is a household payment. It's based on household income.

Therefore if you are claiming uc as a couple with children then it's not possible to have separate finances and the assumption will be that you have household finances

Dishwashersaurous · 12/11/2022 08:06

And to be pedantic the Uc isn't yours. It's family income . It also must mean that your partner is on a low income.

whowhatwerewhy · 12/11/2022 07:22

I'm shocked at £350 each for Christmas, especially when you don't work.

FfayeN · 12/11/2022 07:09

I wouldn't worry about the actual cost. How will they know what everything is in money terms unless he tells them your bio girls have had more spent on them? Children should just be grateful and not be analysing them cost of things. My DSDs used to count how many each of them got...I stopped them doing it pretty sharpish. You're right to want to spoil your own as you said, they will get two lots of presents from their biological mum. He is being very unreasonable!!!

JennyJungle · 12/11/2022 07:08

Why have you stumped up the £700 for his kids Christmas presents?! + your own and he’s spent a poxy £150 compared to yours!! You are being a total door mat.

he should be covering his kids Xmas presents, plus half of your joint kids.

He has some cheek moaning at you spending £50 on your kids birthday presents. He’s totally a tight fisted Twat if he only spends £25!

Fuckedoffteacher · 12/11/2022 07:08

it sounds like you cannot afford to be spending so much on all the children at Christmas.

how long have you been with him?
what does he do for work?
why are you buying his children's Christmas presents?
how much if the parenting are you doing for the older children? Eg Are you doing the cooking etc

JennyJungle · 12/11/2022 07:03

JenniferWooley · 11/11/2022 16:05

I think you've spent far too much for Christmas on the twins & baby in all honesty but I had the same issue with all DC being mine so it's not so much a step kids issue as an age difference issue & will be worse when his girls are 16 & the twins are 6 but they should realise that their things are smaller & more expensive than the smaller kids.

But I agree with you on the birthday thing - they should get the same amount but if you have separate finances that's more difficult to do when you have different ideas of what's acceptable & he's buying for his with you buying for yours.

What are you talking about. They are all his kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread