Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask for DS to be Star of the day?

61 replies

LovelyBranches · 11/11/2022 10:54

DS has just turned 8. He’s a quiet, studious, shy and well behaved child. He works hard in school and his teacher has said he’s very good at reading.

That said, he struggles with maths, and has done for some time. In previous years he’s had some additional support from the school but I have asked the school many times if they can refer him for as assessment for dyscalculia. They keep fobbing us off so about 6 months ago we started doing Kumon lessons. DS has shown massive improvement at home with these lessons but despite his best efforts it’s not translating to school yet.

However DS came home last night and cried because he was upset that he hasn’t been the star of the day. In fact he’s never come home with any sort of ‘well done’ from the school in his entire time he’s been there.

Every teacher he’s ever had praises his lovely calm nature and his quiet way of getting on with things, but I feel he’s often overlooked because of this quiet nature. He doesn’t make a fuss when he doesn’t understand something and just struggles on his own. Similarly when he does something well, like reading or spelling he keeps it to himself. DS has got full marks in every spelling test he’s done for the last month for example but wouldn’t say anything.

I didn’t realise until last night how important the validation from the school was to him.

I know DS really likes his teacher and he wants to do well. He puts a lot of effort into his work but he isn’t being rewarded for it, and instead often ignored because he’s never naughty or attention seeking. His genuine problem in maths is also never picked up because he struggles quietly.

I’ve been in touch with the school again this week about support for maths but is it unreasonable to ask the teacher to give my son a class award like star of the day? I would feel really awkward asking the teacher for this but I was taken aback last night when I realised how much my son needed this, and how little he’s ever received recognition from his teachers or school. It seems that in his school the teachers are only concentrating on the children that are the loudest.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Clawdy · 11/11/2022 17:31

Most schools I've worked in make sure each child will get the star award at some time, which seems very fair. Although I remember sitting in a Friday assembly in one school where Stars of the Week went to the front, and one little girl near me turned and sighed "It's always the naughty ones, isn't it?" And she was right.

HUGanALPACA · 11/11/2022 17:06

im a teacher and I wd suggest sharing all of that with the teacher. Some teachers do need a steer. My daughter’s p1 teacher thought she had made my DD star of the week and she hadn’t- my DD was devastated to be the only child to miss out. Turned out the teacher kept track using pupil’s initials and my DD shared same initials with a child who had already been made Star of the Week. Thankfully we got this sorted- these things matter a lot to some kids and it frustrates me that some teachers don’t pay attention to detail. Absolutely raise it.

Mariellama · 11/11/2022 16:59

The selection for star of the week should be strategic, i.e. you keep track of children who've already had it and you made sure that everyone has it maybe once a term. Teachers will invent reasons to give it to specific pupils such as 'kind manners, kind friend, lovely smile'. I would find it odd if a child hadn't had it by Christmas.

ldontWanna · 11/11/2022 16:57

YANBU to talk to the teacher about how he feels. Overlooked,not good enough, not heard,not seen. There are many ways in which they can remedy that and it would only foster good relationships . Talking about something that isn't working for your son and is affecting his self esteem isn't being that parent. It's just being a parent.

Sparklybanana · 11/11/2022 16:53

I like the idea behind star of the week but in reality it seems to go to the kids who need the encouragement and the ones that are easy, don't win them and feel left out. My dd won only after the teacher asked who hadn't had it and she was one of two. Better is the merit system when they win for individual effort and put them on the wall for a treat at the end of term, if they 'get enough' which of course they always do. No one feels left out.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 11/11/2022 16:48

@antelopevalley so I'd encourage a civilised conversation with the teacher to make sure verbal praise, class dojo, housepoints, whatever are being used.

TheSomersetGimp · 11/11/2022 16:45

I would try and get him assessed privately if you can afford to.

YoniHuman · 11/11/2022 16:43

I would definitely speak to the teacher. So what if they think you are “that mother”. I’m glad my kids are both in high school now and we don’t have to deal with this anymore. Both were quiet and preferred to stick to the sidelines (one has now been diagnosed with ASD). They just got on with things at school. They “were a pleasure to teach, well behaved ” etc but as you say were constantly overlooked for rewards.
The high school they are at now uses an app to award good behaviour points etc and it’s nice to see they have introduced one for “zero hero”. It recognises those quieter kids that don't get any minus points that just go about their day to day, doing their work, without any drama/bad behaviour.

antelopevalley · 11/11/2022 16:43

@TenPointsFromHufflepuff That is the point though. Quiet well behaved kids often do not get verbal praise unless they are outstanding in class. They often just get ignored.

CryCeratops · 11/11/2022 16:40

My DC’s current primary school seem to have a sort of rota system for star of the week, so every child gets it at least once.
There’s all sorts of random reasons given for why children have achieved star of the week on the school newsletter.
But I like this system, as some children do get very demoralised if they never get star of the week.

My DC’s previous primary school did star of the week on “merit”. In Reception, DC1 did not get star of the week until around Easter, at which point every other child in the year had been a star of the week at least twice (they usually had 2 stars of the week). DC1 seemed oblivious to the existence of star of the week, so I didn’t say anything to the school.
And then, when DC1 did finally get star of the week, DC1’s teacher made a point of taking me to one side to tell me that DC1 hadn’t really deserved to be star of the week but she thought he could do with a boost so she’d let him have it anyway 🙄🙄🙄

Anyway, as your DS is getting upset about the lack of recognition and validation I’d definitely mention it to the school.
Especially if it’s a daily thing, they’ve been back in school long enough for star of the day to have worked it’s way around the whole class if it was given on a rota basis.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 11/11/2022 16:24

If star of the week is done so that every child in the class gets one at least once, a couple of things can influence where kids are in the running.

Kids with challenging behaviour often get it first, because they try hard at the beginning of term and teachers want to recognise that effort before it slips.

Kids will get it for something that was particularly challenging for them, an example being the quiet kid in the school play who says their one memorised line beautifully.

Equally kids might get it for something they shine at or displayed an obvious talent in: school plays, sports, art, maths competitions so when you get it can be strategic (eg just cast as the lead role, wait for final show for certificate.)

Well behaved kids can be relied on to do something good most weeks so often are left till last. Not any less valued and will be getting verbal praise, just there are more opportunities to give it to them on a 'slow' week.

Someone has got to be last. If there are 30 kids in the class you have to wait until 30 full term weeks are done until they've actually been missed.

If a kid has been violent or aggressive in the same week they had a good achievement it is usually rolled over for the following week so to not send conflicting messages and to avoid conflict with any potential victims parents. Verbal and other praise like stickers usually used in the meantime.

Nothing wrong with enquiring or offering areas you think they are trying hard in. However keep in mind that there will be many considerations of who gets it and why so it won't be instant.

susan12345678 · 11/11/2022 16:21

Star of the week is generally meaningless but if seems to mean a lot to many children, so it’s a shame how clumsily it is managed IME.

I’ve had dc at different schools, the state primary seemed to use it to encourage the normally badly behaved dc if they were suddenly improving or behaving themselves.

At private school/prep they tend to give them to the dc of the parents who have been complaining, to appease them or ensure they don’t move their dc elsewhere.

If your dc is upset about it, mention it to the teacher. Plenty of other parents do, you won’t be the first.

itsgettingweird · 11/11/2022 16:20

I would say what you've said here but not ask for the star of the week.

Say how much your is doing at home for recognition and the kumon and he's coming home upset.

Say you're worried about his mental well-being as he doesn't feel the effort he's putting in is being recognised or rewarded and ask they come up with a plan to support him.

Star of the week won't help because he'll get it this week and then not again for the rest of the year. Those feeling will return.

A personal star chart he gets noticed with and he's gets a magazine or something at home each week as a reward will help continuously support his well-being and feeling of being valued.

Beanbagtrap · 11/11/2022 16:14

I asked for my DD in similar situation and she was over the moon she got it as a result. They hadn't realised she was mentally keeping a log of when people got it and was getting more and more demoralised by the whole thing.

babysharksb1tch · 11/11/2022 16:13

I'm a teacher. I'd hope any parent would feel confident enough to be able to ask me. If a parent did ask I'd absolutely respond positively and made sure I was going further to spot opportunities to reward that child.

Truffled · 11/11/2022 16:10

Slightly different perspective here but my son was also very bright and capable yet overlooked when it came to star of the week / recognition. I also spoke to teachers about it.

Did find that at the end of term he would suddenly get loads of awards as they checked their records and made up the deficit! Really this just highlighted how fickle the system was.

My son is now nearly 18 years old, very academic (already has 3 uni offers) and what’s more he is super driven and dedicated for himself not for recognition or validation.

Cait33 · 11/11/2022 16:04

I feel your pain OP. My DS is quiet and well behaved and always seems to get passed over for these "Star" awards too. The kids who get them most often IMO are the naughty/disruptive kids who manage not to do anything too horrendous for a few days. Kids who fly below the radar and consistently work hard/behave well seem to get overlooked. My DS gets really upset about it too. I wish school would scrap these things. They do more harm than good.

Paq · 11/11/2022 16:02

How big is his class? My DD was similarly quiet and well behaved and therefore completely overlooked in primary school. It really annoyed me. DH was chair of the PTA and all so the MN theory that the PTA kids were favourited didn't hold true 😀

Never solved it and now she's in a private school with small classes and complains she has too much attention!

fairislecable · 11/11/2022 16:01

On collecting my GD aged 7 from school last week she commented that she never wants to have “Star of the Week” because it’s only given to the “naughty kids , to encourage them”!

Out of the mouths of babes Grin

ArseMenagerie · 11/11/2022 15:57

Omg definitely ask the teacher. She/he has probably just missed him off the list. Unless the school is completely awful they generally just make sure each kid gets at least one award through the year. It’s often the quiet ones that get overlooked poor little buggers so I’d say definitely say something!!

joan12 · 11/11/2022 15:52

Not your question I know, but I would keep on with the Kumon of it is helping him. Regardless of the diagnosis, he will need extra support to improve his maths, and it sounds like it is working.

And yes, I would discuss this with the teacher -- not just asking but explaining why

PurplePixies · 11/11/2022 15:52

I’m guessing that the larger class sizes are part of the problem?

At DS’s village primary school (16 in his class), all the teachers were great at praising and rewarding all the children very regularly for all sorts of endeavours. My DS is also quiet and studious, but I honestly don’t think he was overlooked.

notanothertakeaway · 11/11/2022 15:45

My experience is secondary school was/is much better at ‘seeing’ the quieter kids who always did the right thing

@TeamHerbivore I agree. My DS was often overlooked in primary, but blossomed at secondary school

Daisychainsx · 11/11/2022 15:37

In most schools star of the day or week or whatever it is goes on a rolling basis and doesn't really mean anything. In all of the schools I've worked in you mark the names off the register as you go so that by the end of the year everyone gets a certificate. It's totally wrong.

I don't think you'd be unreasonable at all to say to the teacher that he is really focused on the 'star' certificate, and comes home crushed every week he doesn't win because he's trying so hard. She will 100% (if she's not a total meanie) give him a certificate and a big well done.

antelopevalley · 11/11/2022 14:59

The apologists for this always claim that the quiet kids get loads of praise at home anyway. As if neglected and abused children are never quiet. It simply is not true.