Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for overreacting to comment by John Lewis

482 replies

filletofishmeal · 11/11/2022 10:04

I was on the phone to John Lewis as they failed to deliver an item ( did not put it on their load), and as the person was processing a new delivery date he was making small talk about the reason why I was purchasing a TV. I said it was for the cricket world up, and he asked who I thought I was going to win the tournament. I replied that I am British, so am backing England. He then told me that my name does not sound British, where are my parents from?
I snapped at that point and got a bit shirty with him, as I felt it was unreasonable for him to assume I am not British just because of my surname.

OP posts:
Charlieiscool · 12/11/2022 10:46

Easier to simply focus on the absolute essential communication and unless someone is white with a British sounding name don’t risk saying anything. Is that really how it should be? Walking on eggshells? Culture is interesting and personally, I don’t mind discussing mine if anyone expresses interest. Why would I be offended? I’m not ashamed of my background so I’m happy to talk about it and I don’t feel attacked if anyone asks.

threegoodthings · 12/11/2022 10:23

I think your reply was a bit odd tbh - "I'm British so I'm supporting England"...I wonder what tone you said that In?

TheSomersetGimp · 12/11/2022 10:16

phishy · 12/11/2022 09:57

Make chit chat by all means but after we have told you we’re British, don’t say ‘your name does not sound British, where are your parents from?’ (as was said to OP). Is that really so hard?

No. But I think it's probably much easier not to engage at all apart from the basics required. That way there's no risk of causing offence. Offense something that is so easily taken these days, even if it's not given.

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 10:13

phishy · 12/11/2022 09:47

You have responded to people’s posts so why can’t karma respond to you?

The fragility of people on this thread is unreal.

Agree. I’m always perplexed by the line of thought where being accused of racism is far worse than being subject to it. There really are some snowflakes in this thread and I don’t mean the OP and others who are offended by racist small talk.

filletofishmeal · 12/11/2022 09:59

Thank you! You are one of only a few commenters who understand my issue. I have nothing wrong with small talk and talking about culture, but the call centre worker wouldn't have asked me for my parent's heritage if my last name was Smith for example.

OP posts:
phishy · 12/11/2022 09:57

TheSomersetGimp · 12/11/2022 09:47

Oh ok. So it's fine to make chit chat with white people. Not BAME people. Ok got it. Although sad for those BAME people who don't mind. But it's not worth the risk is it.

Make chit chat by all means but after we have told you we’re British, don’t say ‘your name does not sound British, where are your parents from?’ (as was said to OP). Is that really so hard?

TheSomersetGimp · 12/11/2022 09:47

phishy · 12/11/2022 09:37

Another poster dismissing a BAME OP’s concerns and making it all white centric.

Your white Mamarsupial. You have no idea what BAME people go through in this country.

Oh ok. So it's fine to make chit chat with white people. Not BAME people. Ok got it. Although sad for those BAME people who don't mind. But it's not worth the risk is it.

phishy · 12/11/2022 09:47

fairydustt · 12/11/2022 09:17

@karmakameleon "I wonder if my old headmaster, Mr Higginbottom, was ever asked by a call centre operator about where his surname was from or its history. I mean, after all, it is unusual and probably has some history. Or would that just have been seen as rude?"

Not sure why you're asking me, why don't you ask him? I would imagine with a surname like that though he had lots of comments on it. Not sure what your point is though?

You have responded to people’s posts so why can’t karma respond to you?

The fragility of people on this thread is unreal.

TheSomersetGimp · 12/11/2022 09:44

So the moral of the story is don't make small talk with anyone who has a forrin sounding name. Don't ask them about where their name is from, anything about their heritage, nothing. Just stick to the functional conversation only and don't learn anything new about each other. Presumably it is still fine for obviously white Brits to ask each other where their names come from, where they live, where they were born and so on. It all sounds really sad and divisive. Particularly as chit chat small talk is a big part of British culture. I love those little snippets of conversation when I'm out and about.

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 09:40

OnTheRoll · 12/11/2022 09:34

I am white, have lived in the UK for longer than in my home country, have a British passport and have grown up children. Yet I still have a non-English name and an accent. And it does get tiring after 20 odd years when, whatever topic has started the conversation, the second question I get asked is Where did you come from?

YANBU

But why wouldn't people question you? You are a non native British person in Britain so why would you expect people to not wonder about that- it's a talking point. Surely a British person in your native country would be questioned in the same way.

phishy · 12/11/2022 09:38

*you’re

phishy · 12/11/2022 09:37

Mamarsupial · 12/11/2022 08:08

It doesn’t sound like he was being discriminatory, more just curious?

I mean it’s a plain fact that some names are not British in origin. I have a Polish surname because my grandad was from Poland, having escaped here during the War. It is very obviously not an English name and I don’t expect people not to notice that!

Occasionally people are surprised when they meet me because they were expecting a Polish person and I am as English as they come. I understand that and I’m happy to tell them about my grandad. I am proud of my Polish roots and I suppose I consider myself 1/4 Polish 3/4 English so am not offended by the assumption that I am not 100% English- I would agree with them!

So I don’t think the man was unreasonable to ask you about it, but at the same time YANBU to not want to discuss it. I’m sure there are people with more mixed feeling about their heritage and would like to disassociate from it?

Another poster dismissing a BAME OP’s concerns and making it all white centric.

Your white Mamarsupial. You have no idea what BAME people go through in this country.

OnTheRoll · 12/11/2022 09:34

I am white, have lived in the UK for longer than in my home country, have a British passport and have grown up children. Yet I still have a non-English name and an accent. And it does get tiring after 20 odd years when, whatever topic has started the conversation, the second question I get asked is Where did you come from?

YANBU

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 09:31

@fairydustt

Not just aimed at you but everyone who thinks this is harmless small talk. I’m sure Mr Higginbottom had plenty of comments about his surname. And I doubt he thought of it as “harmless small talk” but variously irritating, rude and unnecessary. Similarly the OP doesn’t like it, especially as it comes from a place of not recognising her as British i.e racism.

PearlclutchersInc · 12/11/2022 09:26

ancientgran · 11/11/2022 16:02

That reminds me of when I was doing a Saturday job at M&S in the 60s. It was a really hot summer and we didn't have air conditioning. A customer commented on how uncomfortable the heat was and I agreed with her. She snapped at me and told me I was being paid so not appropriate for me to comment.

The public can be truly awful to deal with at times and even talking about the weather isn't safe.

It just needed one to spoil your day 🙄

fairydustt · 12/11/2022 09:17

@karmakameleon "I wonder if my old headmaster, Mr Higginbottom, was ever asked by a call centre operator about where his surname was from or its history. I mean, after all, it is unusual and probably has some history. Or would that just have been seen as rude?"

Not sure why you're asking me, why don't you ask him? I would imagine with a surname like that though he had lots of comments on it. Not sure what your point is though?

satelliteheart · 12/11/2022 09:01

@SkylightSkylight well I disagree with you. Asking where someone's parents are from is, like a pp said, only one step away from asking "where are you REALLY from?" Which is a phrase the majority accept is racist. It suggests op and her family are "newcomers" to the UK and that a person's britishness can be quantified based on how many generations of the family were born in the UK

Mamarsupial · 12/11/2022 08:08

It doesn’t sound like he was being discriminatory, more just curious?

I mean it’s a plain fact that some names are not British in origin. I have a Polish surname because my grandad was from Poland, having escaped here during the War. It is very obviously not an English name and I don’t expect people not to notice that!

Occasionally people are surprised when they meet me because they were expecting a Polish person and I am as English as they come. I understand that and I’m happy to tell them about my grandad. I am proud of my Polish roots and I suppose I consider myself 1/4 Polish 3/4 English so am not offended by the assumption that I am not 100% English- I would agree with them!

So I don’t think the man was unreasonable to ask you about it, but at the same time YANBU to not want to discuss it. I’m sure there are people with more mixed feeling about their heritage and would like to disassociate from it?

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 07:47

ellieboolou · 11/11/2022 21:53

Well in that case, as a general rule non white people think all white people are racist surely?

As a general rule most people (white and non-white) are racist to a degree. Look up the Harvard unconscious bias test if you want to learn more. Racism (and other types of discrimination) is so ingrained in our thinking we have to make an actual effort to fight them.

ScarlettnotOHara · 12/11/2022 07:12

@filletofishmeal I think you’re the one not understanding the posts here !! Maybe the people asking are just interested at your unusual name, I seriously don’t think for one minute they are trying to undermine you !

autienotnaughty · 12/11/2022 06:02

He's making small talk but actually being offensive by suggesting that only certain names are British. It's similar to asking a black person where they are from originally. I've not experienced this but I would find it offensive.

Splitsplat · 12/11/2022 05:52

I had this when younger because of my first name and also my skin colour. I always felt
proud that my name and skin colour may reflect some of my family history and that it may tell a story. I am not suggesting that others should feel the same, I’m really not. But it never made me feel like I was being discriminated against. I must emphasise that was my personal experience and I know it’s different for others.

Conkersareback · 12/11/2022 05:35

He was making small talk, helps the day go quicker!

onlythreenow · 12/11/2022 05:35

Oh for goodness sake, he was being friendly and making small talk. Reading MN is like being in another world sometimes. Get over yourself.

phishy · 12/11/2022 05:03

seafish · 12/11/2022 02:04

If you have an Asian sounding surname it's very reasonable for him to assume you may not be supporting England. South Asians particularly do not support England during cricket tournaments, always their ancestral countries. Incredibly big thing in my area.

What a load of tosh. Plenty of South Asians do support England (or Scotland etc).

To say South Asians always support their ancestral countries is racist.

What the actual fuck is wrong with people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread