Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for overreacting to comment by John Lewis

482 replies

filletofishmeal · 11/11/2022 10:04

I was on the phone to John Lewis as they failed to deliver an item ( did not put it on their load), and as the person was processing a new delivery date he was making small talk about the reason why I was purchasing a TV. I said it was for the cricket world up, and he asked who I thought I was going to win the tournament. I replied that I am British, so am backing England. He then told me that my name does not sound British, where are my parents from?
I snapped at that point and got a bit shirty with him, as I felt it was unreasonable for him to assume I am not British just because of my surname.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
minionsrule · 13/11/2022 15:15

People often ask about my surname as my husband is not British.
So I imagine if I said I was British people might question my surname.
I honestly couldn't get offended by it.
Once had a long chat with a lady at Orange in their Indian call centre (my surname is Indian) who was fascinated that I had an Indian husband, it was quite nice actually

CantFindTheBeat · 13/11/2022 14:51

@StoneofDestiny

The bizarre comment is saying Im British so I'm backing England

Why?

It's England and Pakistan playing in the final.., why is OPs comment bizarre?

Lunar270 · 13/11/2022 14:10

People can have strong connections to nationality and this can stick with people through generations. I've

Obviously we can be whatever nationality we want through naturalisation but ethnicity is different so I could never be ethnically English but have a British passport. So I consider myself British and enjoy parts of my heritage but wouldn't say I was proud to be anything.

Pride is something I find more peculiar and why one should be proud. Quite strange.

karmakameleon · 13/11/2022 12:37

I think generally they would consider themselves to be both American and the nationality of their ancestors. And they are as much Italian, Irish or whatever as I am Indian (I haven’t had a parent, grandparent etc live in or be born in India for over 70 years) and yet purfectpuss thinks I should be proud to be Indian and can’t claim to be English. I find it interesting why some people consider themselves gatekeepers to nationality but can’t explain what the rules are that they are basing their gatekeeping on.

Weightlossanne · 13/11/2022 11:27

It’s interesting what determines nationality. Many people who I would class as American claim they are Irish, Italian or Scottish yet not having family who have actually lived in that country for at least seventy years.

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 23:35

I wonder whether an hour ago you thought of Cliff Richard as English? Is he still English now in your mind? What makes him English or Indian?

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 23:29

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 23:20

Similar to the UK then? I guess Anglo Indian similar to British Asian? And when Mr Richard phones up a call centre in India...?

I would hope that when Mr Richard calls a call centre in India and they ask him which team he is supporting in the World Cup, and he says India because he’s Indian, they don’t say “well you don’t sound very Indian” or “you don’t have an Indian name, where were you originally from?”

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 23:20

Similar to the UK then? I guess Anglo Indian similar to British Asian? And when Mr Richard phones up a call centre in India...?

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 23:09

I doubt that the kind of British people living in Bangalore working for a tech firm or bank for a few years and then returning home would be.

But the British people who have settled in India longer term would. There is a significant Anglo Indian community and most Indians would consider them an Indian sub culture. My parents would often remark that Cliff Richard was Indian.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo-Indian_people

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 22:59

Are immigrants from Britain living in India considered Indian? I honestly have no idea.

This is a genuine question by the way, not meant to be inflammatory.

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 22:44

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 22:37

I don't see what skin colour has to do with anything

I agree skin colour doesn’t make you English. I wonder what does and why you can’t quite articulate why you don’t consider me English and what does make someone English. It’s a mystery.

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 22:37

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 22:35

So if you have no other options you get to be English/ British? But if you have options it’s based on the colour of your skin you default to the country of your origin?

I don't see what skin colour has to do with anything

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 22:35

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 22:22

No, I don't 'self-identify', my heritage makes be British and I have no other options to choose from because I have nothing to align me with another nation except Britain.

So if you have no other options you get to be English/ British? But if you have options it’s based on the colour of your skin you default to the country of your origin?

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 22:22

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 22:15

I consider myself English and British.

So you self identify as English? I thought you said that you don’t believe in self identification for nationality? Or is there some sort of certificate you have? I believe I’m English because I have lived here for the vast majority of my life (more than any other country). I speak the language fluently with a native accent, follow the customs etc but you refused to acknowledge my Englishness. You said: “But why do you want to 'be English'? Are you not proud of your origins?”

I have friends who are British Pakistanis, they identify as English and more specifically Yorkshire (like myself), although I'm not sure being English trumps their Pakistani heritage

Why not? Why are they more Pakistani than English? What do they think?

No, I don't 'self-identify', my heritage makes be British and I have no other options to choose from because I have nothing to align me with another nation except Britain.

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 22:15

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 21:46

I honestly don't know what you are getting at. You can't be British without either being English, Scottish, Welsh or Irish.I consider myself English and British. My ancestors, as far as I can trace them back, were all residents in England. I was born in England, have lived in England all my life, as have both my parents, grandparents, and great grandparents. I have no known recent relatives of any other nationality. My MIL is Scottish and British. She hasn't lived in Scotland for over 60 years, but she still considers herself Scottish, not English. I have friends who are British Pakistanis, they identify as English and more specifically Yorkshire (like myself), although I'm not sure being English trumps their Pakistani heritage- they certainly still identify strongly as Pakistani as we'll as British.

I consider myself English and British.

So you self identify as English? I thought you said that you don’t believe in self identification for nationality? Or is there some sort of certificate you have? I believe I’m English because I have lived here for the vast majority of my life (more than any other country). I speak the language fluently with a native accent, follow the customs etc but you refused to acknowledge my Englishness. You said: “But why do you want to 'be English'? Are you not proud of your origins?”

I have friends who are British Pakistanis, they identify as English and more specifically Yorkshire (like myself), although I'm not sure being English trumps their Pakistani heritage

Why not? Why are they more Pakistani than English? What do they think?

StoneofDestiny · 12/11/2022 22:09

The bizarre comment is saying Im British so I'm backing England

phishy · 12/11/2022 21:53

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 21:46

I honestly don't know what you are getting at. You can't be British without either being English, Scottish, Welsh or Irish.I consider myself English and British. My ancestors, as far as I can trace them back, were all residents in England. I was born in England, have lived in England all my life, as have both my parents, grandparents, and great grandparents. I have no known recent relatives of any other nationality. My MIL is Scottish and British. She hasn't lived in Scotland for over 60 years, but she still considers herself Scottish, not English. I have friends who are British Pakistanis, they identify as English and more specifically Yorkshire (like myself), although I'm not sure being English trumps their Pakistani heritage- they certainly still identify strongly as Pakistani as we'll as British.

@purfectpuss that’s all great, but I don’t think you can blame karma for being confused, as her post said she had lived in England of decades, that her parents had lived in England for decades, and instead of acknowledging her as British or English, you said:

But why do you want to 'be English'? Are you not proud of your origins? I simply cannot envisage ever calling myself something other than that which I was born and brought up as.

Anyway, it sounds like you’re basically in agreement.

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 21:46

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 21:27

There clearly is a difference between English and British. Who gets to claim to be English? There are lots of people who say they are English. What do they have in common? Which of these people who claim to be English are, and which are just incorrectly self identifying as such? If there is an objective way of determining Englishness, surely you must be able to tell us the rules?

I honestly don't know what you are getting at. You can't be British without either being English, Scottish, Welsh or Irish.I consider myself English and British. My ancestors, as far as I can trace them back, were all residents in England. I was born in England, have lived in England all my life, as have both my parents, grandparents, and great grandparents. I have no known recent relatives of any other nationality. My MIL is Scottish and British. She hasn't lived in Scotland for over 60 years, but she still considers herself Scottish, not English. I have friends who are British Pakistanis, they identify as English and more specifically Yorkshire (like myself), although I'm not sure being English trumps their Pakistani heritage- they certainly still identify strongly as Pakistani as we'll as British.

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 21:27

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 21:14

I have never specified a difference between English and British. And as for claiming to be English and passports- well that goes for all of us- I am British.

There clearly is a difference between English and British. Who gets to claim to be English? There are lots of people who say they are English. What do they have in common? Which of these people who claim to be English are, and which are just incorrectly self identifying as such? If there is an objective way of determining Englishness, surely you must be able to tell us the rules?

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 21:14

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 19:47

You have consistently and repeatedly said that just because I have lived in England a country for a significant period of time (the vast majority of my life) I can’t claim to be English from that country. You said you cannot self identify as a nationality. So until the breakdown of the Union there will be no way that I can get my English passport and claim to be English, in your opinion. Wonder what makes you able to self identify as English. You even rather crassly said that I shouldn’t be ashamed to be associated with my origins as if that is my nationality.

I have never specified a difference between English and British. And as for claiming to be English and passports- well that goes for all of us- I am British.

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 19:47

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 19:04

@karmakameleon I have not accepted or denied your Englisheness- that was just you.

You have consistently and repeatedly said that just because I have lived in England a country for a significant period of time (the vast majority of my life) I can’t claim to be English from that country. You said you cannot self identify as a nationality. So until the breakdown of the Union there will be no way that I can get my English passport and claim to be English, in your opinion. Wonder what makes you able to self identify as English. You even rather crassly said that I shouldn’t be ashamed to be associated with my origins as if that is my nationality.

IncessantNameChanger · 12/11/2022 19:38

KezzabellaB · 11/11/2022 10:19

He was only trying to be friendly and make small talk IMO so yes you were unreasonable.

I think this too. Hopefully just clumsy.

Weightlossanne · 12/11/2022 19:34

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 18:50

Why would it matter where I was born? I lived there for months rather than years and have no ongoing connection to the country.

I’ve told you that for the majority of my life, I have lived in England.

I know it’s not the same but I was born in Scotland to Scottish parents. I moved to England when I was a couple of weeks old and have lived here ever since. I say I am Scottish (or British)

purfectpuss · 12/11/2022 19:04

@karmakameleon I have not accepted or denied your Englisheness- that was just you.

karmakameleon · 12/11/2022 18:55

@purfectpuss

I do find it interesting how easily you accept my Britishness but how reluctant you are to accept my Englishness. If I’m not English, which of the four nations am I from?

Swipe left for the next trending thread