Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to help DD out with childcare?

556 replies

reesep · 10/11/2022 17:34

DD has a son with special needs age 5, and a daughter age 1.

She has requested I look after them one day at a weekend, every month. She has also requested I do some daytime childcare during the school holidays

This is so she can get into nursing. She's desperate to be a nurse and has been accepted into a Healthcare Assistant role on bank, meaning she can pick shifts

AIBU not to provide such rigid help? It's too much of an expectation and I can't handle it

I do feel bad but it's just too much. She also lives 1.5 hours away so it would mean bringing the DC here

AIBU?

OP posts:
Acidburn · 11/11/2022 12:18

Of course you don't have to. But, when you become old and in need of help due to your age - she is also not obliged to help you.
That is not the kind of relationship I would want with my mother.

Breakinthesun · 11/11/2022 12:13

If she was expecting you to do regular childcare she should of discussed it with you first before having more kids. She is being unreasonable and unrealistic.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/11/2022 12:12

It's a great shame but sometimes being a good parent means having to say No and supporting your child through that disappointment

Absolutely spot on - even more so because OP was clear that, instead of wanting to discuss the issues, her DD takes an airy fairy "I'll cross that bridge when I come to it" attitude

Trying to improve yourself within what's possible is admirable, but as someone else said this sounds like a person who wants what they want and to hell with the consequences to others, and life doesn't work like that

NightfeedsandNetflix · 11/11/2022 12:02

Don't think your daughter has thought it through, and I fully appreciate after a split she wants to get cracking and do well for herself. I'm no expert but won't she have to do random shifts or long hours at some point? She is setting herself up for mega stress with childcare, it's brilliant she is wanting to forge a solid future but unfortunately it can't be at the detriment to your life. It's better to say no for now to revisit in the future when you have less responsibility, then agree and let her down in the future. I also find people underestimate how much child care they need from others giving the bare minimum as a guide to only pressure for more help? Once you are invested how do you then say no to the extras?

saraclara · 11/11/2022 11:32

There are no bursaries for nursing training now, either. So how will DD find the money to pay back a large loan? A loan for a qualification that she's highly unlikely to be able to use to earn a nurse's salary?

I can quite understand OP being reluctant to take on this commitment, when she knows that it won't ultimately be of any benefit.

SirMingeALot · 11/11/2022 10:59

As someone who would wade through fire for my kids, I would probably find a way to try to make this work, although I think people, including the OP's DD are being ridiculously unrealistic about the overall long-term workability of the plan, but, yes, this post is spot on.
The amount of mother shaming on this thread is shocking. I think there's a whole lot of projection here.

Yes, and of course what's needed here isn't a once only sacrifice like walking through fire. I too would do that for mine, but what we wouldn't be able to do is make this situation workable, make it a sensible idea to embark on a plan like this without the necessary support in place. Short term pain is much easier to weather than impossible logistics!

Some posters are evidently struggling with the concept that this isn't actually a situation where some unselfish motherly sucking it up from OP will solve the problem and mean DD gets what she wants. This is why I think the OP biting the bullet and being upfront and honest about the situation now is actually in the interests of DD as well as all the kids involved. Because this plan is a circle that can't be squared.

BadNomad · 11/11/2022 10:48

Also, if nursing is her lifelong dream as she claims, it is quite a strange decision to have 2 children first and then try to pursue it. I have a dream...but I'm going to wait until my life is ten times harder and need other people to help me accomplish it. This sounds like a woman who wants what she wants when she wants it and doesn't care what it means for everyone else.

whumpthereitis · 11/11/2022 10:48

Luckycatt · 11/11/2022 10:36

OP daughter is the one that chose to take that on, OP did not.

I can't imagine that having a disabled child and a partner that won't help out was a choice.

But she did indeed make the choice to have children, which, unless she relinquishes custody to the state, makes her the one responsible for them. Not OP.

TalkisChips · 11/11/2022 10:47

I think it's a shame if once a month is too much to help out.

Once a month is not going to help her nursing career. As a student or when she’s qualified.

rookiemere · 11/11/2022 10:42

Luckycatt · 11/11/2022 10:36

OP daughter is the one that chose to take that on, OP did not.

I can't imagine that having a disabled child and a partner that won't help out was a choice.

No absolutely, but being brutal she did choose to have a second DC in those circumstances. That was totally her choice, and I only raise it because some posters seem to be implying that OP was being selfish by having more DCs so therefore unable to take on major GC caring.

Luckycatt · 11/11/2022 10:36

OP daughter is the one that chose to take that on, OP did not.

I can't imagine that having a disabled child and a partner that won't help out was a choice.

SirMingeALot · 11/11/2022 10:16

She unfortunately has childcare needs that are incompatible with nursing.

Yes, this is what it comes down to unfortunately. And @throwa summed it up excellently.

I have a lot of sympathy with DD. Her situation must be very hard. She's also wanting to embark on something that she isn't going to be able to achieve without very substantial childcare support. That evidently isn't going to come from her useless twat of an ex, and it's also not going to come from the state. Neither is it likely to be met in the childcare sector itself, even if money were no issue, given the needs of DC1. This doesn't have to be fair to be true.

Nothing we've heard suggests there is any other source available aside from the OP. And even the 'some' school holidays bit is actually pretty telling. It's going to end up being a huge undertaking, whether DD has fully got her head around those practicalities at this point and is asking in the full knowledge that it'll be more or whether she's yet to realise it.

To that end, it would be better for all parties if OP were to make clear to DD that she is not going to be in a position to provide the absolutely colossal childcare support necessary to make this work.

Mummyford · 11/11/2022 10:14

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 11/11/2022 09:54

This is a fairly horrifying thread. Here we have a grown woman wanting to return to a career, which is proving very difficult because she has two young children, one disabled, and cannot afford specialist childcare. And instead of blaming the absent feckless father, or the useless government for failing to provide a solution, all the blame and vitriol is being heaped upon her MOTHER, whose parental responsibility ended some time ago, who lives an hour and a half away and has her own life and two children still living at home, and SHE's the one who should be facilitating her daughter's career!
Because apparently being a mum, everything is your duty and responsibility, no matter what Confused
OP, YANBU

As someone who would wade through fire for my kids, I would probably find a way to try to make this work, although I think people, including the OP's DD are being ridiculously unrealistic about the overall long-term workability of the plan, but, yes, this post is spot on.

The amount of mother shaming on this thread is shocking. I think there's a whole lot of projection here.

InSpaceNooneCanHearYouScream · 11/11/2022 09:54

This is a fairly horrifying thread. Here we have a grown woman wanting to return to a career, which is proving very difficult because she has two young children, one disabled, and cannot afford specialist childcare. And instead of blaming the absent feckless father, or the useless government for failing to provide a solution, all the blame and vitriol is being heaped upon her MOTHER, whose parental responsibility ended some time ago, who lives an hour and a half away and has her own life and two children still living at home, and SHE's the one who should be facilitating her daughter's career!
Because apparently being a mum, everything is your duty and responsibility, no matter what Confused
OP, YANBU

whumpthereitis · 11/11/2022 09:47

Luckycatt · 11/11/2022 09:41

@whumpthereitis quite. My point being that, unless she gets carers to support at home, mum is looking after child on a 1:1 basis without a second adult. Whilst also looking after a 1 year old.

Yes, but if OP doesn’t feel capable of doing the same, it’s not unreasonable at all of her to choose not to. It’s better she does just that, in fact.

OP daughter is the one that chose to take that on, OP did not.

throwa · 11/11/2022 09:41

I do wish sometimes people would actually look at the facts of the matter as they are being presented, rather than waffle on about OP being unsupportive, evil, or disinterested in her DD and GC, before they make sweeping pronouncements.

DD lives 1.5 hours away. A 3 hour return journey. She will not want to do that before and after a 12 hour nursing shift - that's 18 hours before she even starts to eat / sort kids / etc. How much will this fuel add to her cost of living - is this affordable?

The GC has high enough SEN that he needs 2:1 care, is at a specialist SEN school and has a specific transport bus laid on for him which gets him to / from the school at specific times of the day. This sounds like DD has got him nicely settled in, is dealing well with her local council and his educational needs are being met. She is not going to want this disturbed in any way. Who will ensure that the GC is there to meet the transport bus before and after school, as this will be from his 'normal' address and not the OPs? How does this work with the child being at OP's home 1.5h away?

The OP has children of her own, the elder can do some ad hoc childcare for their sibling but is in an exam year and this must take priority. The younger is still at the stage where they do need a bit of attention, plus they will be moving up to secondary next year and this can be a lot of change which creates its own issues. People suggesting that OP moves her own family (increasing the daily commute for husband - whether or not he is father to DD) at this stage in OP's family's life are unrealistic.

Nursing is well known for its anti social hours, and whilst I'm sure that the course will be as supportive as possible, DD will still have to do 12 hour shifts, night shifts, shifts in different locations etc, as well as the academic side of things (and you can't be expected to produce decent essays etc whilst looking after a baby and a high SEN needs child).

The one day a weekend, once a month, and 'some childcare' in the school holidays is probably fine, if that is what it is. But what are the childcare arrangements for the rest of the time? Who makes sure that the SEN child is there for his bus? What's happening to the baby? What happens to them once DD actually qualifies and gets a job? How does the DD study for the academics without some time to herself without them? I strongly suspect that this would expand, especially once the reality of the commute settles in.

The logistics and practicalities for this would mean a No from me before I even got onto the question on whether I'd like to do this or not - emotion or caring doesn't even come into it, you cannot just wing it for the next 3 years of studying and then into a job, on 1 day a month's agreed childcare. Huge stress, huge waste of time and money and it has been set up to fail from the start.

Unfortunately nursing is just not the right career path unless you have rock solid childcare arrangements, and back up alternatives for when these fall through. I am sure that there are other options for the DD which would be more realistic and pragmatic solutions, and which the OP would feel much more able to support.

It is also a salutary lesson in making sure that, if at all possible, you do the training etc for careers like this, with tricky training schedules, before you have children, as you will be in a much better position with much less commitment than after. Obviously it's a bit late for the DD in this case, and indeed for many others, but it is still easier to do it this way round.

Luckycatt · 11/11/2022 09:41

@whumpthereitis quite. My point being that, unless she gets carers to support at home, mum is looking after child on a 1:1 basis without a second adult. Whilst also looking after a 1 year old.

whumpthereitis · 11/11/2022 09:32

Luckycatt · 11/11/2022 09:10

The 5 yr old DS has such severe needs that he his ratio is 2 adults when he is in a formal setting.

But presumably mum has to look after him entirely on her own when he's at home.

Well yes. Unless she places him into care and relinquishes parental responsibility, she’s the one responsible for him. That’s generally how it goes.

Cuppasoupmonster · 11/11/2022 09:29

Moominfanjo · 11/11/2022 01:59

The nastiest of the ones against op started a thread entitled ‘Why should I pay for you to have a child?’ and has comments where she appears pretty salty at having to pay out so much for childcare and in others she says she has a 'nightmare family ' so yes that person possibly is projecting here slightly. I actually thought she might be a troll given the goady nature of many of her threads and posts. I'm sure she'll be back again soon to ask me what im rambling on about 😂

If you had read that thread, it’s because I was sharing a Guardian article where a woman addresses the tired ‘why should I pay for you to have a child’ trope that so many people trot out. And I was saying what a great article it is. But you didn’t read it, did you?

Luckycatt · 11/11/2022 09:10

The 5 yr old DS has such severe needs that he his ratio is 2 adults when he is in a formal setting.

But presumably mum has to look after him entirely on her own when he's at home.

Luckycatt · 11/11/2022 09:07

@Moominfanjo your post is very goady to be fair. It's not healthy to be digging up dirt from posting histories to make a point in a separate thread. Nor is troll hunting within the guidelines.

GingerKombucha · 11/11/2022 08:55

You sound utterly and completely unsupportive of your poor daughter. I was shocked that you said she would drive them to you, I thought your only reasonable complaint would be the drive to pick them up but even so any reasonable parent would drive to help out their child. She's been utterly abandoned by her husband and mother and I feel so sorry for her.

NukaColaQuantum · 11/11/2022 08:40

DSis attempted Access Nursing as a lone parent to 1DC. The amount of help she required from me was, frankly, ridiculous. From picking her up from the childminder because she’d missed the free college bus that only takes 30 mins to get back and needed to get the normal buses - 2, which took 90 mins, to me having her on the days DSis wasn’t at college (they only fund the days at college) as she needed to revise/do coursework, or having my niece for days on end as she was too unwell for the childminders.

I was happy to do this because she’d had DNiece very young, had zero support from our family who had pretty much disowned her for it.

I repeatedly asked her what she planned to do about the degree considering the hours they’d expect, and she told me that I’d just have to have her child (alongside my other 2 children and I was pregnant with my 3rd…). Unfortunately, she didn’t get higher than a Pass grade in any module and therefore stood no chance of getting into Uni.

A few years later, I was 30, I started an Access course - STEM - single mother to 3DDs, aged 7/5/6 months old. I went to an RG Uni for UG and PG.

Zero help from anyone. I asked DSis if she would collect elder DDs from school once a week and give them dinner (niece was at the same school), she refused.

I powered through anyway, because a) had the drive to do it and b) had chosen a realistic goal based on my academic ability and personal circumstances.

Your DD isn’t doing that, so YANBU.

rookiemere · 11/11/2022 08:38

The 5 yr old DS has such severe needs that he his ratio is 2 adults when he is in a formal setting.

But somehow it would be fine for a 10 & 15 yr old to be quite heavily involved in his care, or indeed that of a 1 year old baby.

This is cloud cuckoo land talk. Those DCs are just that DCs. One is heading into exam territory and the other is still a child. Maybe they could push the baby round the block for half an hour, but I'm not sure what other care people think that DCs should be providing.

PicaNewName · 11/11/2022 08:32

Blimey... you have a 10 and a 15 year old who could help you and learn some care and be part of a family and you can't commit to one day a month?
And trying to talk your daughter out of bettering herself?
I hope she'll be able to find a solution, as family clearly doesn't matter to you, at least now, that you have a 'new' one. She could look into finding an apprenticeship route.