Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to not want a man and his son using girls changing rooms

236 replies

shatteredmama · 10/11/2022 17:08

Took dd 7 for her swimming lesson, there are separate open plan girls and boys changing rooms (it’s in a school). Was surprised to see a man come in with his young son for him use the showers.

I felt uncomfortable with this, especially as the boy goes to the same school as dd. Also pissed off at the air of entitlement from the man. Couldn’t think of any valid reason for both males to use the girls room.

No other women in there batted an eyelid though. I’ve emailed the swim school to complain but not heard anything back.

Its left me second guessing myself and wondering if I’m making a big deal out of this, and given it was children only getting changed, not women, or the man thankfully!, does that make it ok??

OP posts:
Naunet · 10/11/2022 21:40

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:37

I've walked into the wrong changing rooms due to partial blindness before and not realised- does that mean I'm a bad person and undeserving of benefit of the doubt? Again I'm not saying that's what happened here op clearly got a bad vibe from this guy earlier on I'm just saying mistakes do happen we are all human so it isn't always something super untoward but I can see why people lean towards that due to statistics and negative experiences. This is why I said there should be male/female/neutral facilities in the first place so everyone has something that caters for them.

You walked in, and then what? Did you shower and change and then only realise after you left?

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:37

Naunet · 10/11/2022 21:34

Well he disregarded the safeguarding steps put in place, good people don’t tend to do that, so why would he deserve the benefit of the doubt?

I've walked into the wrong changing rooms due to partial blindness before and not realised- does that mean I'm a bad person and undeserving of benefit of the doubt? Again I'm not saying that's what happened here op clearly got a bad vibe from this guy earlier on I'm just saying mistakes do happen we are all human so it isn't always something super untoward but I can see why people lean towards that due to statistics and negative experiences. This is why I said there should be male/female/neutral facilities in the first place so everyone has something that caters for them.

FacebookPhotos · 10/11/2022 21:36

I have never agreed with this rule of thumb. 8 is too young for a child to go into facilities on their own, it's a safeguarding risk and several years before puberty in almost all cases, moreso for boys.

The solution, of course, is to campaign for more family changing and toilets. Not ignoring the privacy needs of 8yo children, many of whom are not comfortable with even their opposite sex parent helping with when undressed (eg in the bath).

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 21:34

maplesaucewithbacon · 10/11/2022 21:29

the general rule of thumb is children under 8 go into the changing room of their parent, after 8 they go in the correct one for them.

I have never agreed with this rule of thumb. 8 is too young for a child to go into facilities on their own, it's a safeguarding risk and several years before puberty in almost all cases, moreso for boys.

No it isn't too young at all, especially if the parent is waiting outside.

Also, girls can get their periods at 10, like I did. I also had big breasts before I got my first period, so you're wrong on the puberty timeline. I had boobs at aged 9, which is only one year older than 8. I certainly would not have wanted other boys/men seeing my boobs which even at that age were big enough for a sizeable training bra. Or my tampon string at aged 10 (although I didn't use tampons til much later and on used pads).

J0CASTA · 10/11/2022 21:34

breadandroses93 · 10/11/2022 20:58

Well yes this thread has gone off on a tangent from the original post and quite a few people have quoted me now so just going to reply to everyone then go...

It's my understanding that trans people go through lots re. mental health. Therefore if a trans woman who had obviously been through medical treatments/lifestyle changes was to share a changing room with me, I would assume that person had dealt with a lot of internal pain and trauma to get to that point and bloody leave them alone. I definitely would not suspect them of being a pervert as a default. Same goes for if I knew I was getting changed next to a lesbian.

I will say I do understand the point that it could be easy to just put on a dress and pretend to be trans. Just found this thread completely devoid of any empathy.

I find your post comparing lesbians to men who identify as trans / Transwomen to be grossly offensive and homophobic.

Naunet · 10/11/2022 21:34

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:31

What I was responding to was a pp who accused him of going in there to teach his son how to sneak a peak on naked women. I'm not saying he was accused at the time.

Well he disregarded the safeguarding steps put in place, good people don’t tend to do that, so why would he deserve the benefit of the doubt?

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:31

Naunet · 10/11/2022 21:27

No one was accused, where did you get that from? That wasn’t the issue, the issue was that he was there, the steps put in place to help women feel safe, were over ridden by an entitled male.

What I was responding to was a pp who accused him of going in there to teach his son how to sneak a peak on naked women. I'm not saying he was accused at the time.

Wauden · 10/11/2022 21:29

It is very disappointing that no one challenged the man when it happened.

maplesaucewithbacon · 10/11/2022 21:29

the general rule of thumb is children under 8 go into the changing room of their parent, after 8 they go in the correct one for them.

I have never agreed with this rule of thumb. 8 is too young for a child to go into facilities on their own, it's a safeguarding risk and several years before puberty in almost all cases, moreso for boys.

FOJN · 10/11/2022 21:28

It's my understanding that trans people go through lots re. mental health. Therefore if a trans woman who had obviously been through medical treatments/lifestyle changes was to share a changing room with me, I would assume that person had dealt with a lot of internal pain and trauma to get to that point and bloody leave them alone. I definitely would not suspect them of being a pervert as a default. Same goes for if I knew I was getting changed next to a lesbian.

You are operating on an outdated understanding of what it means to be trans which in 2022 makes you transphobic. Transwomen do not owe hormones, surgery or feminity in order to earn your validation, their beards and penises are all perfectly womanly.

As for your lesbophobia.... I would like to report your post for the implication you make about lesbians but I think it's important for everyone to see how bigoted "being kind" can make you.

FYI 98 - 99% of sexual offences are committed by males regardless of how they identify.

Naunet · 10/11/2022 21:27

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:21

Yes of course. Should we do that with every person we meet on the street now? Obviously we have no way of knowing for sure if someone has malicious intent or not but you also can't accuse every man of being an inherent sexual predator just because they are male or of grooming their child. We all take steps to protect ourselves etc (we shouldn't have to in the first place) but we also can't go around accusing everyone of being malicious in their intent. If we lived like that we'd never leave the house. And safeguarding needs to be based in fact if I did my job like that I'd be stuck off and families would be damaged as a result. No point in safeguarding unless you're going to get it right.

No one was accused, where did you get that from? That wasn’t the issue, the issue was that he was there, the steps put in place to help women feel safe, were over ridden by an entitled male.

QuebecBagnet · 10/11/2022 21:27

If the showers in the mens are broken you go home without a shower. Simple. No way would the staff say oh go and walk in that room there full of naked women!

BreatheAndFocus · 10/11/2022 21:26

lifeturnsonadime · 10/11/2022 21:08

But it doesn't matter if he's a creep or not. He's made women and girls uncomfortable in a single sex space. That's the entire point.

Exactly this. It doesn’t matter whether he was a predator. He probably wasn’t. But women are entitled to single sex spaces not just because most sexual assaults are committed by males, but for reasons of privacy and dignity.

You we’re right to complain, OP.

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:24

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 21:20

What if someone was creeping him out watching his son in the male showers so he was trying to remove them?

What if, what if, what if. It's all gymnastics and whataboutery. Your example makes it even worse! Because he decided it's fine to creep out women, instead. Actually, your example makes it far far worse and shows (in that example) that the entitled man thinks nothing of creeping women out and doesn't stop to think about how vulnerable women might feel, it's all about male entitlement.

It's occam's razor. If it were innocent, he would have immediately retreated.

I literally did say that wouldn't have been the correct response in my reply didn't I? So thank you for telling me what I have already said and know. My point is that is an example of classic male privilege which is not great by any means but its definitely better than actively being a sexual predator. It's still a much lower end of the scale.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 21:24

breadandroses93 · 10/11/2022 21:21

I don't see it as entitlement. I see it as that person living a personal dream come true just by simply using a changing room.

Is it not possible to have empathy for everyone including women and not know what the awnser is? Because that's where I am. I have a six year old son and I'm sorry you feel that way about men.

You honestly don't think a man's feelings being more important that womens safety, is entitlement?

No man has the right to live their 'personal dream' at the expense of vulnerable women. I don't care about their entitled 'dreams', I care about the reality of womens safety.

It worries me that you say you have a son that you may be teaching them to be entitled too, because you genuinely don't see why womens safety comes before mens entitled 'dreams', I hope I'm wrong.

QuebecBagnet · 10/11/2022 21:22

And I totally agree it makes little difference if the person is stupid or a pervert. We are allowed to have boundaries regardless.

TedMullins · 10/11/2022 21:22

Naunet · 10/11/2022 20:49

I didn’t mention transpeople.

So you do agree then, this man shouldn’t have used the women’s changing room?

Yes in that scenario he shouldn’t have gone in. But by the time I commented the thread had moved onto a wider debate. My views on undressing/nudity pertain to unisex or mixed changing areas which some people had said they also don’t like.

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:21

Naunet · 10/11/2022 21:14

And you work in safeguarding?!

Did you have to have a DBS check even though the chances of you not being a criminal outweighed the chance that are?

Yes of course. Should we do that with every person we meet on the street now? Obviously we have no way of knowing for sure if someone has malicious intent or not but you also can't accuse every man of being an inherent sexual predator just because they are male or of grooming their child. We all take steps to protect ourselves etc (we shouldn't have to in the first place) but we also can't go around accusing everyone of being malicious in their intent. If we lived like that we'd never leave the house. And safeguarding needs to be based in fact if I did my job like that I'd be stuck off and families would be damaged as a result. No point in safeguarding unless you're going to get it right.

breadandroses93 · 10/11/2022 21:21

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 21:06

So because these men (trans women) have 'gone through a lot' mentally, they means it's aok for them to be so entitled to use womens spaces? I think womens pain and trauma, especially rape victims', outweighs the trauma of these biological men.

95-97% of trans women retain their penis and testicles. It's penis and testicles that are a threat to women. Taking hormones (and that's if they even bother to go that far even) doesn't erase the fact that they have a penis and testicles, and are displaying those penis and testicles in womens spaces.

A lesbian is a biological woman, she does not have a penis. You cannot compare a lesbian, to a biological male with a penis.

This thread (with a few exceptions who appear to be devoid of empathy for vulnerable women) has empathy for vulnerable women in womens spaces. Not empathy for male bodies. Which is how it should be.

I don't see it as entitlement. I see it as that person living a personal dream come true just by simply using a changing room.

Is it not possible to have empathy for everyone including women and not know what the awnser is? Because that's where I am. I have a six year old son and I'm sorry you feel that way about men.

QuebecBagnet · 10/11/2022 21:21

DrWhitWho · 10/11/2022 20:28

But it’s not generally only perverts, he took his son in with him, there will most likely be a reason outside of perversion that led to this.

That’s why I said generally only perverts. I agree the will also be the odd stupid person who is unable to walk through the correct door. But generally the perverts outnumber the village idiots.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 21:20

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:15

I know that - I'm not saying it isn't the point as that's clearly the end result and as I've said before we do need single sexed spaces. But I do feel there is a difference in someone doing that by mistake than doing it on purpose. Intent matters and I'm saying that accusing every man who may or may not have made a mistake for whatever reason must be a predator who is grooming his children is a bit much. What if someone was creeping him out watching his son in the male showers so he was trying to remove them? That's a very different intent - not maybe the right solution as opposed to getting staff and complaining- but very different.

What if someone was creeping him out watching his son in the male showers so he was trying to remove them?

What if, what if, what if. It's all gymnastics and whataboutery. Your example makes it even worse! Because he decided it's fine to creep out women, instead. Actually, your example makes it far far worse and shows (in that example) that the entitled man thinks nothing of creeping women out and doesn't stop to think about how vulnerable women might feel, it's all about male entitlement.

It's occam's razor. If it were innocent, he would have immediately retreated.

FOJN · 10/11/2022 21:15

My point is that on MN we are super quick to jump to the conclusion that he must be a creep with malicious intent.

You're missing the point; he does not need to be a creep or have malicious intent. Unquestioning acceptance of males in spaces where females may feel vulnerable normalises their presence in those spaces, we should not be conditioning young girls to think this is normal or that it is hateful or bigoted for them to want privacy away from men when they are getting undressed. It's unintentional grooming. We need to teach young girls to confidently assert their boundaries.

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:15

lifeturnsonadime · 10/11/2022 21:08

But it doesn't matter if he's a creep or not. He's made women and girls uncomfortable in a single sex space. That's the entire point.

I know that - I'm not saying it isn't the point as that's clearly the end result and as I've said before we do need single sexed spaces. But I do feel there is a difference in someone doing that by mistake than doing it on purpose. Intent matters and I'm saying that accusing every man who may or may not have made a mistake for whatever reason must be a predator who is grooming his children is a bit much. What if someone was creeping him out watching his son in the male showers so he was trying to remove them? That's a very different intent - not maybe the right solution as opposed to getting staff and complaining- but very different.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 10/11/2022 21:14

RFPO77 · 10/11/2022 21:08

Oh behave, if it was a genuine mistake he'd have apologised and left as soon as he realised. He didn't, there was only one reason for him being there and we all know what it was. Decent men don't go into changing rooms when young girls are changing. He took his son in with him so is modelling this behaviour and disregard for females and is no doubt raising another little perv OPs daughter has to go to school with 🙄

Or raising yet another misogynist that the world really needs.

Hopefully the female role model in the child’s life will rip the man and new one and get it into his head how wrong he was.

Of course shouldn’t be our job but someone has to get it into his dense head it’s not acceptable even if the shower not working or whatever.

Naunet · 10/11/2022 21:14

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 21:07

I'm not saying that the op didn't get a bad vibe from this particular guy. My point is that on MN we are super quick to jump to the conclusion that he must be a creep with malicious intent. I get that a lot of that comes from people's personal negative experiences with men and that makes sense. But sometimes it is just something more simple and I think jumping to the assumption that he's actively teaching his child son to be a sexual predator is a bit more far fetched than someone in the male showers made him uncomfortable or he didn't have his glasses on or he was in a rush and didn't realise where he was and noone questioned him.

And you work in safeguarding?!

Did you have to have a DBS check even though the chances of you not being a criminal outweighed the chance that are?